Over the past two decades, children's voices have begun to feature more prominently on the agendas of policy-makers, practitioners and researchers across the world. Whilst progress has, undoubtedly, been made in creating opportunities for children and teenagers’ participation, young people still inhabit a problematic position as citizens-in-the-making. Where platforms for participation exist they are often formalised and adult-led. As Children, Politics and Communication: Participation at the Margins adroitly demonstrates, many young people are politically active in their everyday lives. This insightful edited collection takes an innovative approach to participation focusing in particular on children's agency and the politics of communication across a variety of spheres. Holding central the premise that children are competent social actors, the collection focuses on the experiences of ‘children at the margins’. In doing so, the book is constructed around a diverse range of themes, including participation, migration and communication. As Nigel Thomas infers in the introduction, there are many commonalities uniting this seemingly eclectic compilation. The result is a refreshing multi-disciplinary collection packed with insightful examples and reflections from across the world.
Emanating from a seminar series organised by the then Department of Childhood Studies at Swansea University, UK, the book comprises nine chapters that are nested within and bound together by a thought-provoking introduction and conclusion. The introduction concisely sets the scene for the collection providing a clear rationale. The conclusion, a feature often omitted from edited collections, effectively situates the overarching themes of ‘communication and recognition’ and ‘migration, displacement and citizenship’ within a number of theoretical frameworks before closing with some implications for research and practice.
Roger Hart's opening chapter provides a valuable review of children's participation in the UK over the past 40 years. This insightful contribution synthesises reflections on structural shifts with an autobiographical approach that is also firmly grounded in research evidence. Reflecting on changes across a variety of contexts, from play with peers to organised groups and activities, he argues for a greater focus on children's social participation in civil society. Echoing the arguments of Roger Hart, Chapters 2, 3 and 4 are united in their call for greater recognition of children's participation in informal arenas. Vicky Johnson's chapter serves as a useful reminder of the importance of informal practices. Drawing on her evaluation-based work, she explores young people's autonomous organisation in the UK, Nepal and South Africa. In doing so, she highlights the tensions between such organisation and dominant (adult) notions of legitimate participation. Similarly, in Chapter 3, Anne-Marie Smith provides a fascinating ethnographic account of the political actions of children from rural Loxicha, Mexico, who, as a result of insurgency, established a protest camp with the women of their community in the centre of Oaxaca City. Reflecting critically on the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, she argues that whilst political children are commonly regarded either as non-children or victims, for some political action forms an integral aspect of their multi-faceted lives. In Chapter 4, Jason Hart focuses on refugee children living in a displacement camp in Jordan, where politics and political action also feature in everyday life. Situating his arguments within the context of children's rights, competency and agency, he critiques the assumption that children are mobilised into political action and violence by force. Taking a spatial approach, he argues that the camp environment shapes young people's understanding of themselves and, in turn, their responses to their circumstances.
The proceeding two chapters concentrate on asylum-seeking children, each contributing to a range of important policy debates. Providing a fascinating discussion highlighting the need to take a context-sensitive approach to lived experiences of age/childhood, Heaven Crawley focuses on the alarming experiences of unaccompanied children seeking refuge in the UK as they endeavour to negotiate individuals and institutions. She emphasises the experiences of those who cannot prove their age and whose appearance, experiences and/or actions do not fit with modern ‘western’ conceptualisations of childhood. Continuing this theme, Ravi Kohli discusses the stories and silences of asylum-seeking children in their bid for survival. Having outlined the challenges many face in having to construct a story to appease the authorities, she explores the different approaches taken by social workers seeking to elicit children's narratives. She highlights the significance of silence as a coping strategy and demonstrates how, over time, a more therapeutic approach can prove fruitful. Ravi Kohli's chapter provides an excellent link to the final three chapters that focus more explicitly on communication and interaction.
Li Wei along with Zhu Hua and Chao-Jung Wu provide a detailed account of the creative use of code-switching by multi-lingual children as a mark of resistance and a means of redefining child–adult power relations. Drawing on examples from two studies with British–Chinese children, the authors highlight code-switching as a resource both for pupil's resistance at complementary schools and at home and as a means of affirming their own fluid sense of identity. In the penultimate chapter, Amelia Church uses conversation analysis to examine in detail the linguistic resources of young children in day care in Australia. Regarding verbal conflict as a learning process, she explores the different outcomes of disputes from resolution by children through to teacher intervention, thereby highlighting young children's competencies. Framed by work associated with the ‘new literary studies’, Julia Davies provides a detailed account of young people's digital connections and networks. Drawing on a study examining the use of a web-based discussion forum by young people with myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME), she not only highlights the skills many young people acquire and use to communicate in this way, but also demonstrates the significance of this virtual space as an arena of support.
In essence, this is a well-structured, informative and thought-provoking book. One of the editor's hopes at the outset was that the collection would be of value to policy-makers and practitioners. I certainly believe the volume has achieved this aim with each chapter providing new insights into, for example, adult–child relationships, the societal positioning of young people, children's everyday political actions, the connections between communication and participation and the need for inter-generational dialogue. I also concur with the editor that whilst the individual chapters contribute immensely to a number of theoretical, policy and practice debates, the value of the volume is certainly greater than the sum of its parts, as the reader is exposed to an eclectic interdisciplinary collection that successfully combines theoretical insights and empirical examples from a variety of contexts.
