No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 August 2004
The Road to Jerusalem: Glubb Pasha, Palestine and the Jews is Benny Morris's latest scholarly endeavor to shed light on the events surrounding the 1948 Palestine war. Although, as he notes in his Introduction, it was in Jordan where Glubb, a British general-on-loan to (Trans)Jordan from 1930 to 1956 and leader of the Jordanian Arab Legion, made his main contribution to history, Morris focuses on how Glubb Pasha's actions affected Zionists during the Mandate period and, subsequently, in the State of Israel. The main point of departure for Morris is the notion that Glubb may have been anti-Semitic, thus adversely affecting the Zionists' efforts to establish their state. Yet in reading this book, the reader should pay careful attention to the author's approach, his choice of sources, and his political priorities, all of which inform the book and call into question the allegation of anti-Semitism.
The Road to Jerusalem: Glubb Pasha, Palestine and the Jews is Benny Morris's latest scholarly endeavor to shed light on the events surrounding the 1948 Palestine war. Although, as he notes in his Introduction, it was in Jordan where Glubb, a British general-on-loan to (Trans)Jordan from 1930 to 1956 and leader of the Jordanian Arab Legion, made his main contribution to history, Morris focuses on how Glubb Pasha's actions affected Zionists during the Mandate period and, subsequently, in the State of Israel. The main point of departure for Morris is the notion that Glubb may have been anti-Semitic, thus adversely affecting the Zionists' efforts to establish their state. Yet in reading this book, the reader should pay careful attention to the author's approach, his choice of sources, and his political priorities, all of which inform the book and call into question the allegation of anti-Semitism.
Glubb's alleged anti-Semitism serves the larger issue with which Morris is ultimately concerned: Israeli historiography on the 1948 war period. In the Introduction, Morris states that this study is intended to mediate the controversy between “Old Historians,” who determined the official Zionist narrative of the 1948 war and the founding of the state, and “New Historians,” who challenge the Zionist foundational myths. As a pioneer of the latter group with his The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem (1988), Morris cleared the path for Israeli scholars to engage in a new kind of critical, scholarly, national self-reflection that in effect supported long-standing Palestinian claims regarding Zionist responsibility for the creation of the refugee problem. That said, one infers a change in Morris's scholarly direction based on an article he contributed to the Guardian newspaper on 21 February 2002 discussing the al-Aqsa Intifada in Israel/Palestine. The past and the present are so interwoven here that, along with a change in his thinking with regard to prospects for peace between Israelis and Palestinians, Morris seems to have reversed his scholarly trajectory by supporting the traditional Israeli/Zionist view of the conflict. Reading The Road to Jerusalem, it is evident that his revised position on today's conflict informed his scholarly interest in Glubb's alleged anti-Semitism.
Although he sets out to prove a link between Glubb's perceived anti-Semitism and events in Zionist/Israeli history, Morris actually reaches no firm conclusion about whether the British general was anti-Semitic. He sees in Glubb's writings about Jews both hostility and empathy. Linking history to today's political events, Morris often finds Glubb's comments prophetic for their support of the current official Israeli position. For example, he quotes a report in which Glubb states that “the [1936–39] Palestinian rebellion…[has] shown that regular armies are ill adapted to cope with gang warfare, which carries on its activities by the intimidation of private citizens” (pp. 50–51). As the Israeli army has not been able to put an end to Palestinian suicide bombings during the years of the al-Aqsa Intifada, Morris ties Glubb's historical comments to the present situation, which helped formulate the position he explicated in The Guardian. Though the author wavers throughout the book on the question of anti-Semitism, he ultimately stakes a clear position about Glubb's view toward Zionism in his conclusion. For Morris it is axiomatic that Glubb, “a convinced champion of the Arab cause” (p. 233) challenges Zionism and its goals because of his “anti–Zionism.” To be anti–Zionist, for Morris, is to oppose Zionist conventional wisdom for which the project of bringing Jews and settling them in Palestine was intended to bring peace and resolution to the Jewish problem in Europe.
These issues in effect speak less to the subject of Glubb's suspected anti-Semitism than to the question of whether observers of, and participants in, this century-old conflict can criticize Zionism and Israel in the same ways in which they would criticize other national movements and occupying powers, if at all. Morris's focus on Glubb's perceived anti-Semitism seems part of a larger, one-sided discussion among many Jews and supporters of Israel today in which criticism of Zionism or the State of Israel—and, in particular, its policies toward the Palestinians—is tantamount to anti-Semitism and thus is omitted from the discourse. If supporters of Israel proclaim, support, and defend Israel as a “Jewish” state, while disparaging anyone who criticizes the policies of the “Jewish” state in its national form, under what circumstances might it be possible to criticize the State of Israel for its political policies, past and current, without being accused of anti-Semitism?
Morris offers the book as two different kinds of studies in one: it is at once a new interpretation of previously examined sources and an analysis of newly declassified material. He employs previously classified Israeli and British archival material to answer old historiographical questions: the controversial repositioning of troops that led the Arab Legion to lose Lydda and Ramle, the strategy toward the battle for Jerusalem, and the question of whether Jordan's King Abdullah or the Zionists wanted “all of Palestine,” among others. That said, the book rehashes old arguments, variously dismissing or affirming existing scholarship, without explanation, rather than breaking new ground. In the few cases where British official records disagree with accounts in existing scholarship, Morris often relegates the point to an endnote, diminishing its strength rather than offering the reader a sharp new conclusion. The reader also learns from the endnotes that Morris feels more comfortable citing Israeli sources to prove points than British or Jordanian—indeed, Arab—sources. Though difficult to attain, both primary and secondary Arab sources, especially Jordanian, are widely overlooked.
It must also be said that the publisher has not served Morris well. The book is unfortunately marred by technical and editing problems—repetition, grammatical slips, stylistically cumbersome passages, and weak internal organization of some chapters. The crude, unintelligible map of the Battle for Jerusalem drawn by hand (p. 164) contrasts sharply with the other two more refined and legible maps of the U.N. Partition Plan and the Arab states invading Palestine (pp. 90, 146). The book would have benefited from thorough editing and more careful analysis of the sources, such as that Morris undertook in his earlier work on Palestinian refugees.