This new book represents a contribution of unquestionable importance for the understanding of the origins and development of the Salvadoran revolutionary movement. The author, Peter M. Sánchez, uses the biography of the priest David Rodríguez as a common thread to address some of the most significant political processes of the last five decades in the history of El Salvador. David Rodríguez was one of the principal advocates of the popular church in the department of San Vicente and, as such, from the early 1970s he encouraged the formation of Bible Study Groups, Christian Base Communities and peasant organisations – in particular, the Union of Farm Workers (UTC, from its Spanish initials). Rodríguez also joined the Fuerzas Populares de Liberación Farabundo Martí (Farabundo Martí People's Liberation Forces, FPL), and soon became one of its most charismatic middle-ranking cadres. Indeed, one of the most valuable parts of the book recreates the ‘conversion’ of Rodríguez, first, as a progressive priest aligned with the liberation theology and, later, as a clergyman–revolutionary activist (Chapters 3 and 4). The reconstruction of this stage in David Rodríguez's biography confirms many of the findings made by the scholars of contentious politics. For example – as the author himself points out – the Salvadoran liberationist priests were central pieces in the creation of an injustice framework that turned into the first step in the construction of a powerful peasant movement. Likewise, the popular church provided key structures and resources that made peasant mobilisation possible, even against terrible state repression. Lastly, but no less important, Peter Sánchez's story confirms that the repression was the main cause of the radicalisation of the peasants who had previously been mobilised by the liberationist priests, and of the passage to militancy in the political–military organisations. In this sense – and this is a most valuable contribution – Rodríguez's tale is also useful for putting back in its real context the decision made by a fraction of the Salvadoran peasantry of resorting to armed struggle. Such a context was marked by the conditions of abuse, humiliation and exploitation of the peasantry by the landowners, and by the repressive tactics used by the National Guard when the peasants tried to demand an improvement in their work and life conditions. That is to say that David Rodríguez's experience gathered in this book also provides interesting contributions for the construction of the memory of this conflict and, particularly, regarding the causes of the war.
The detailed narrative of the process of radicalisation of a religious leader in Priest under Fire leads us to a possible reorientation of studies about this revolutionary process in this Central American country. This in-depth understanding represents a key to comprehending, in turn, the broad peasant mobilisation from which the revolutionary movement nurtured itself and which enabled it to wage a more than ten-year-long war against the Salvadoran state. The fact that it concerns the biography of a middle-ranking guerrilla cadre – and not that of a member of the general command or a founder of the revolutionary organisations – gives the testimony of David Rodríguez a special interest.
Unfortunately, the book does not examine in sufficient depth some aspects of the relationship between the guerrillas and peasant mobilisation. In particular, there is a crucial element that could have been elucidated by the interviews on which this work is based: the planning and development of the linkage strategy of the FPL with the popular movement and, more precisely, with the peasantry, a remarkably successful strategy even when compared to other left-wing revolutionary organisations of the continent and regarding which we only have scattered information thus far. Rodríguez represented the Christians on the National Commission of Masses (CONAMAS), a key organism of the FPL that integrated the leaders of the popular movement in a single structure, and which, therefore, represented a fundamental space for the planning of guerrilla tactics for the popular movement. Another aspect of David Rodríguez's experience that the book could have also examined in greater depth is related to the internal functioning of the Popular Revolutionary Bloc (BPR), the most important mass-movement front of the late 1970s. Despite this, these shortcomings do not undermine the global contribution of this work.
Finally, it is worth noting another section of the book that represents a novel contribution. Chapter 6 depicts Rodríguez's path as deputy of the successor umbrella group the Frente Farabundo Martí para la Liberación Nacional (Farabundo Martí National Liberation Front, FMLN) from the 1990s. Rodríguez's insights into the achievements and shortcomings of the 1992 peace agreements are probably the most candid narration by a member of the FMLN parliamentary elite ever to be published in the postwar era. Criticisms by Rodríguez about the detachment of part of the leadership from the popular sectors, his acknowledgment of the lack of substantial socioeconomic changes in the country in the last 25 years, and his frustration about the inability of El Salvador's democracy to create a more equal wealth distribution are factors that reflect well the disenchantment of a significant part of the old militants of the revolutionary organisations in the postwar era and that, in this occasion and in a somewhat exceptional manner, are expressed by a cadre who remained in positions of institutional responsibility.
Given all the above, Priest under Fire represents an unquestionably valuable source of information about the origins and development of the Salvadoran revolutionary movement and it should be a compulsory reference work for those interested in the recent history of this Central American country.
