This is an important and fascinating book, one that everyone involved in teaching music to Muslim children, or in training and supporting such teachers, should read. It makes an invaluable contribution to our understanding of one of the most significant social and educational challenges we currently face.
Can Muslims reconcile their values and the demands of their faith with the pressures of living in the secular societies of the West? And can Western values and attitudes adjust so as to allow Muslims a fruitful role in our culture? Music is at the heart of this debate; for in Islam music is a contested area. Indeed, as this book so clearly explains, many influential voices at the present time are urging Muslims to reject music in its entirety, except perhaps for devotional songs accompanied solely by the duf (hand-drum).
It is difficult to account for the intensity with which this view is maintained, especially since Islam has in fact a glorious musical tradition. Indeed, many of the Muslims interviewed by Diana Harris seem baffled by the hostility currently shown to music. It springs in part from a fear of Western culture, in which music is seen as inescapably associated with drugs, sex and crime. Yet Muslims cannot help but notice that music also plays many good and fruitful roles in society. The various Muslim communities of the UK face a difficult struggle to resolve this conflict. Understandably, many prefer to ignore the issue, not to think about music at all.
Teachers in Muslim faith schools face the greatest challenge – to create from scratch a music curriculum that embodies Islamic spiritual and musical values while at the same time fulfilling the demands of the National Curriculum. At present they are understandably far from ready to take up this task. Meanwhile, non-faith schools across the UK are blithely teaching Muslim children music every day! They remain relatively untouched by the debate. There is very little demand at present for Muslim children to be withdrawn from music lessons. The prevailing attitude is more one of compliance: we will let our children attend, but they should pay as little attention as possible.
Diana Harris's book aims to help us listen sympathetically to the debate and understand what is going through our Muslim pupils’ and parents’ minds – and it does so extremely well. It is absolutely packed with information and ideas, and these are conveyed largely through the voices of Muslims themselves; children, parents, scholars, teachers and musicians. Although the book has a firm research base, it avoids the distancing effects of academic theory and technical language. It simply asks the questions all UK music teachers would raise who seek the best for their Muslim pupils, and addresses them with honesty, sensitivity and insight. Above all it blessedly resists any temptation to simplify – the full complexity of ideas and experiences of Muslims from many contrasting schools of thought is here presented in faithful detail.
The book has three overlapping audiences: music teachers and managers in non-faith schools; teachers and managers in Islamic schools; and Muslim parents and community leaders. For all of these audiences the tone is pitched just right: the book's conversational and anecdotal style makes it highly readable. One notable feature is the emphasis on women's voices – including those of two of the professional musicians interviewed – which gives valuable insights into the particular pressures some Muslim girls and women experience.
Perhaps the single most useful chapter for music educators is that in which Muslims from a range of backgrounds give their personal views on the value of music, and explore the reasons for the debate within Islam. This takes us to the heart of the conflicts our Muslim pupils and their parents – and our Muslim colleagues in the staffroom – are living through. The sections on music education in Muslim countries may seem less directly relevant, but provide valuable background. They take the form of a travel diary, written in an anecdotal style. The author's honest, unguarded responses to the culture shocks she experiences speak to her intended readers far more eloquently than some cautiously academic formulation. She courageously enters into some difficult situations, and is mostly extremely successful at creating fruitful relationships. The seeming simplicity of the narrative is deceptive – stroke by stroke a detailed picture emerges of the educational systems and philosophies in which many of our current UK Muslim opinion leaders were raised.
The descriptions of music provision in the two UK schools (one secondary non-faith, the other an Islamic primary school) are of great relevance and value and repay careful reading. Both schools struggle against intense community hostility to music. In response to this they settle for a very limited curriculum; yet in both schools pupils’ love and longing for music are evident just beneath the surface. The practical suggestions for ways forward are carefully considered and give much food for thought. Many could be implemented with little difficulty. Some (for instance single-sex classes and combined arts courses) are less likely to gain immediate sympathy in non-faith schools, but they are still worth our attention, and may well have greater resonance in Islamic schools.
The book is highly successful in its aim of informing UK readers about the tensions surrounding music education in Islam, and the experiences and attitudes of young people caught up in these tensions. However, there is one angle left unexplored which the UK music educator would benefit from considering. One would hardly guess from this book that there is a thriving industry around Islamic devotional music. Yusuf Islam and Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan are mentioned; but artists such as Sami Yusuf, Raihan, and 786 have a big following among young Muslims, while artists such as Abida Parveen are revered by the older generation. There may be good reasons for this seeming blank in interviewees’ responses – after all, we would not expect all UK citizens to be knowledgeable about contemporary Christian music! If readers follow up the references in the Resources section, they will gain a somewhat fuller picture of the Islamic music scene; but perhaps they could have been given a clearer steer to this important dimension of the subject in the main body of the book.
One of Diana Harris's many strengths is the way in which she keeps faith with her interviewees, reporting with meticulous objectivity and fair-mindedness. Still, we readers are entitled to raise some issues. Two in particular strike me. The first is the extraordinarily complex, ambivalent and distanced attitudes to music encountered in the education systems of Pakistan, Egypt, and to an extent even Turkey. Lip-service is paid, but the subject is in general so poorly served! Pedagogy and materials from the colonial era still cast a confusing shadow. Official attitudes are characterised by continual pretence and evasion.
In some measure this is due simply to lack of resources. The book describes Pakistani girls taking their matriculation exams in the open air, writing on their knees; in such a context it's hardly surprising that little attention is paid to music. But this is surely not the only factor. There could be no clearer illustration of what may happen if the underlying philosophical issues are left unresolved. If Muslims are not prepared to look this problem squarely in the face, they will neither do music justice nor dismiss it completely from education; instead, they will relegate it to a barren marginal area, where confusion, fear and ignorance rule.
And this danger is not confined to Pakistan and Egypt – we can see the same tendency in the case study of music provision at ‘Castle High’ in the UK. Here the Chair of Governors is both a Muslim and a professional musician. Yet he keeps his love of music completely separate from his role in the community, and insists that music has no meaning for the pupils he is appointed to serve. The status of music in the school is vivid testimony to the crippling effects such compartmentalisation has caused.
Indeed, my second issue concerns the attitudes of both the head teacher and Head of Music at Castle High. It is maybe unfair to criticise without full knowledge – both are clearly doing their best in a difficult situation. But truly, nothing is gained by running scared of the community. Experience shows that those Heads who stand up to assaults on their core educational values, and insist on providing a vibrant arts curriculum, in the end win the backing of the majority of parents and are able to provide a rich educational experience for their pupils. The thin diet of keyboard labs and perfunctory ‘creative music’ described here is not going to persuade young Muslims that music has anything of worth to offer them.
We are at the start of a long process of patient dialogue, gradually building knowledge, understanding and trust; a process that may last a generation. No music teachers with Muslims in their classes can avoid being part of this process. For them, and for those who support their work, Diana Harris has produced an invaluable starting point and guide.
