Since 1997, exciting new findings from the imperial fora in Rome have been emerging gradually in individual articles or summary overviews. This volume now launches what will become a series of comprehensive publications of the recent excavations in each forum complex. An introduction by the editors is followed by a series of individual chapters authored by those responsible for the relevant aspects of the excavations. These are organized into four chronological groupings, but deal with discrete themes such as stratigraphic sequences or urban development.
Work in the Forum of Augustus was begun partly in response to an unexpected discovery. Excavations from 1998 to 2000 in the Forum of Trajan uncovered a hitherto-unknown exedra opening onto the north-west portico of Augustus’ forum, which had been demolished in favour of a monumental hallway connecting the two. The 2004–7 campaign pressed south-eastwards from this exedra, uncovering a section of the north-west portico and adjoining piazza from the Augustan complex.
Findings pre-dating the construction of the forum are presented first by Alessandro Delfino, casting new light on Augustus’ insistence that no householders should be forcibly displaced by his project. Bauer argued in the 1980s that a pragmatic decision to retain elements of the existing street network might lie behind this political positioning, but we can now add local topography to the picture. New evidence for levelling under the north-western half of the forum confirms that its construction entailed the removal of a considerable ‘saddle’ between the Capitoline and Quirinal hills. This, along with work to raise the ground level on the south-eastern side, clarifies the effort required to impose the geometric shape of the forum onto the uneven relief in this area, as well as into the surrounding urban fabric. As Delfino argues, this may have limited Augustus’ choices, as well as explaining why the project took so long to complete.
Post-antique spoliation has left little trace of the forum's embellishments in the newly-excavated area. Chapters on the architectonic, sculptural and epigraphic finds are all compelled to admit that they have been limited, confirming what was already known rather than providing new information. Nonetheless, careful study of the extensively-robbed foundations has revealed new insights into the construction process. In particular, Fulvia Bianchi and Matthias Bruno have got a great deal out of a small area of mortar bedding in the north-west portico. Their analysis has allowed them to reconstruct the sequence in which the coloured marble paving was laid down: first the grey bardiglio matrix, and then the concentric squares of yellow Numidian and red African marble within. Patches in front of the hallway leading into Trajan's forum also signify repairs to the paving in the late third and fourth centuries, but without any attempt to match the original Augustan pattern.
Elisabetta Carnabucci concludes the section on the imperial period by re-assessing Augustus’ forum in the light of the new excavations. It has long been known that on its completion the praetors transferred their tribunals there: not least on the basis of vadimonia from Herculaneum and Puteoli recording agreements to meet before them in the Forum of Augustus. Before the new excavations, the prevailing orthodoxy had been that the large exedrae flanking the Temple of Mars served as the praetors’ audience-chambers, but Carnabucci now argues that the smaller exedrae were better suited to this function. Her grounds are that the newly-observed foundations appear to have been designed to support pilasters, rather than free-standing columns, creating niches similar to those known in the exedrae of the Basilica Ulpia, and suitable for storing legal documents. The case is not yet secure, but it could not even have been made fifteen years ago.
The recent campaigns also vividly demonstrate the uneven impact of post-antique spoliation on the imperial fora. Those parts of Augustus’ forum exposed in the 1920s were relatively unaffected, but Vincent Cousì and Fabrizio Delici's chapter shows that between the sixth and tenth centuries the marble paving in the newly-explored sector was stripped, and the foundations of the external walls and portico steps completely robbed out. This is far more comprehensive than anything observed in the adjoining complexes, yet fragments of their marbles found in the Augustan complex — and vice versa — also indicate that reclaimed material circulated widely.
From the tenth century onwards, the defining presence in the former Forum of Augustus was the monastery of S. Basilio, established in the remains of the Temple of Mars Ultor. But while the former Forum of Trajan was urbanized by the tenth century, stratigraphic sequences from the new excavations confirm that this did not happen in the Forum of Augustus until the sixteenth century. Instead, it was used for agriculture, in spite of frequent flooding. Only after drainage systems and a new road network were installed at the instigation of Cardinale Alessandrino could the area be developed for housing.
The Quartiere Alessandrina then evolved rapidly, and since it was here demolished to ground-floor level only in the 1920s its remains were found substantially intact. Indeed, though they have now been removed, its walls, doorways, floors, courtyards, cellars and staircases can be re-visited in future thanks not only to photographic records but also comprehensive laser scanning of the structures. Meanwhile, a chapter on stamped bricks from the buildings’ walls illuminates the industrial history of early nineteenth-century Rome, while another offers a biography of the buildings drawn from historical and documentary records.
The findings reported in this book are of obvious importance, but at times I found them frustratingly obscured by its structure and organization. The multiple authorship has ensured expertly-informed discussion, but created inevitable repetition and stylistic variation between chapters. Worse, key points of orientation fall between the authorial gaps. The six main phases of activity on the site should have been introduced and defined in the introduction, rather than emerging incidentally on p. 35. Some divisions are also unhelpful. The independent treatment of sculptural and architectonic finds, for example, means that new fragments of the Caryatids and heads of Zeus Ammon from the forum frieze are discussed separately from their decorative settings.
Finally, the book is lavishly illustrated with plans, photographs and cross-sections, but these could sometimes have been used more effectively to communicate information to the reader. Interpreting geological cross-sections is challenging for non-specialists, and a clearer impression of the pre-Augustan ‘saddle’ might have been conveyed via a hypothetical 3D reconstruction; which it seemed to me the data could support. But the job of clarification and synthesis perhaps falls to others now. We must thank the authors of this volume for their careful work and important findings, and anticipate further instalments in the series eagerly.
