This book by Professor Muhammed Al-Da

mi (Baghdad University) sets out to complicate our understanding of 19th-century British and American Orientalism. Al-Da

mi analyzes a body of nonfiction literature that he deems both less politically “interested” in the Arab Islamic world than the work of professional Orientalists of the period and less prone to the Arabian Nights inspired exoticism that characterized much European imaginative literature of the time. He tacitly embeds his project within the arguments of Edward Said's Orientalism (1978), insisting that “any Westerner who wrote about the Orient is an Orientalist, and his work is inseparable from Orientalism” (p. xiii). Yet, contra Said, Al-Da

mi maintains that the Orientalism of many 19th-century British and American “men of letters” bears an often “incidental” relationship to empire and is more interested in stemming the tides of industrialization and secularization in the West than it is in establishing absolute Western “superiority” over an “inferior” Arab Islamic world. Indeed, these writers mine Arab Islamic history for sociopolitical lessons both positive and negative, calling on Europe and America to look to the Arab Islamic past for models of “civilization” and power and to read that past for warning signs of cultural and political decline.
Outlining key continuities and turning points in the history of European writing on Islam and the Arabs in an informative introduction to the volume, Al-Da

mi moves on in chapter 2 to show how two major trends in Victorian thought—medievalism and Orientalism—responded to an English present that was increasingly haunted by the specters of soulless scientism and materialism, social disharmony, and violent class struggle (compare Saree Makdisi's 1998 study Romantic Imperialism). Especially fresh are Al-Da

mi's discussions of Matthew Arnold's A Persian Passion Play (1871) and Macaulay's “Minute on Education in India” (1835). Arnold, he suggests, could only vindicate Islam by Aryanizing it; Macaulay, in turn, could only discredit Persian and Sanskrit by de-Aryanizing the two and conjoining them with Semitic Arabic under the new umbrella of the “Asiatic”—this at a time when, as Thomas R. Trautmann's Aryans and British India (1997) has shown, British Orientalists were cultivating “Aryan” kinship ties with India.
Chapter 3 rightly argues that Thomas Carlyle's “The Hero as Prophet” (1840) sought, in the example of the Prophet Muhammad, an antidote to Benthamite morality and the mechanized, godless understanding of the universe gaining ground in Victorian Britain. However, Al-Da

mi's reading wrongly divests Carlyle of all imperial interestedness, ignoring a later lecture in which Carlyle insists that the empire's Shakespeare would one day supplant the prophet of Islam and render him “obsolete.” He is quicker to spot the workings of empire in Cardinal Newman's neo-Catholic discourse on Arab Islamic history, the subject of chapter 4. By bisecting Islam into a “barbarous” North and a “civilized” South—civilized, we wonder, because of its associations with papal Rome and the “Bible lands”?—Newman could at once admire the “Southern” Muslim Arabs for their essentially dead martial past and despise the “Northern” Turks whose Ottoman Islam embodied a living threat to Europe, going so far as to recommend their extermination.
Chapters 5 and 6, which trace the rise of literary Orientalism in the United States through Washington Irving's “romantic histories” of the early Islamic caliphate and of Moorish Spain (1829–66), could easily be collapsed into one. Further, Al-Da

mi too summarily dismisses the Barbary Wars of 1785–1815 as insignificant. By considering their impact on Irving's triangulation of America with Moorish Spain and North Africa, he might enrich his compelling core argument—namely, that Irving saw in Arab Islamic Spain both the origins of America's “discovery” and a settler colony whose rise was “analogous” to that of the young United States, and whose decline could be instructive to the new nation.
The book's final chapter sketches a provocative comparison to efforts by Arab and Muslim intellectuals of the 19th century and the present to tap their own history for models of social and political “awakening.” Sadly, Al-Da

mi's initially suggestive link between Anglo-American literary Orientalism and the discourse of the Arab nahda rapidly devolves into the unproductive conclusion that Western Arabists can never “know” Arabs and Muslims as well as the latter “know” themselves. The argument leaves us hungry for thicker and more scholarly analysis.
Although Al-Da

mi sometimes sacrifices in-depth analysis to excessive exposition or to vague generalization, his study ultimately succeeds in showing us just how heavily 19th-century British and American literati looked to the Arab Islamic past for ways to restore their own societies and polities to wholeness. Yet, the obvious interest all of these writers shared in Islam's catalysis of Arab empire begs questions that Al-Da

mi never fully explores: why does the 19th-century British turn to Arab Islamic history as a political “model” coincide with a period of rapidly expanding British dominion over the Arab and Muslim worlds, and what might be the implications of that coincidence? Oddly, too, Al-Da

mi fails to explain why the “disinterested” literary Orientalism he identifies surfaces only in the Anglo-American tradition. Comparisons to French or German Orientalisms would be welcome. Finally, the book as a whole suffers from poor copyediting. Its English is too often left unidiomatic and uncorrected.
Still, Arabian Mirrors is a suggestive reading of early English and American interest in Arab Islamic history, all the more impressive because war and sanctions on Iraq crippled its author's access to recent research. I recommend it to libraries and to researchers interested in an alternate view of East–West literary–political relations in the 19th century.
