The book of Proverbs is a book of wisdom. In the Hebrew Bible, Proverbs is found among the writings (the Ketuvim), and together with the books of Ecclesiastes and Job, it constitutes the wisdom literature of the Old Testament. Arthur Jan Keefer, the author of The Book of Proverbs and Virtue Ethics, accepts this settled understanding of Proverbs and identifies wisdom as the book's organizing principle. He contends, however, that Proverbs should also be known as a book of ethics. More specifically, he argues that Proverbs, a book “palpable in moral concepts” (9), is a book of virtue that offers a tradition of virtue ethics that deserves to be considered alongside the traditions of virtue ethics offered by such moral philosophers as Socrates, Aristotle, and Thomas Aquinas. Additionally, he hopes that establishing Proverbs as a tradition of virtue ethics will render untenable the view of some scholars that the ethical vision of Proverbs is limited, rigid, and uninteresting.
In this book, Keefer undertakes an ambitious, interdisciplinary study. He seeks both to provide a philosophical interpretation of Proverbs and to make a contribution to moral philosophy. He is well suited for the task: after finishing graduate theological training, he completed doctoral work in Old Testament studies at the University of Cambridge, holding the Decani Scholarship at Clare College during his studies. He is currently a schoolmaster and chaplain at Eton College in Berkshire, England, where he teaches theology, philosophy, and religion. Although he is still relatively early in his academic career, he has published several journal articles regarding the interpretation of the Hebrew Bible, especially its wisdom literature, and this is his second book on Proverbs. His first (Proverbs 1–9 as an Introduction to the Book of Proverbs [London: T&T Clark, 2020]) was published last year, and together these two books are part of a growing body of scholarship that suggests a productive career as a thoughtful biblical interpreter.
The structure of this book is readily grasped. In the introduction, Keefer articulates his thesis and explains the method he employs in this study of Proverbs. In chapter 2, “Views of Virtue in Philosophy,” he surveys the key concepts and frameworks of the three philosophers whose thought provides analytical lenses for studying the moral and theological virtues reflected in Proverbs. Chapters 3 to 6 constitute the heart of his study, and in them, Keefer uses his interpretive method to bring Aristotle and Thomas into extended conversation with Proverbs. Accordingly, in chapter 3, “Moral Virtues in Proverbs,” he examines the discussion of specific actions, emotions, and speech in Proverbs against the three criteria applied by Aristotle to identify virtues and vices, and he concludes that many of the virtues in Proverbs are virtues in the Aristotelian sense. In chapter 4, “Honor, Shame, Humility, and Pride,” and chapter 5, “Courage, Work, Speech, and Friendship,” he continues his assessment of whether specific actions and emotions in Proverbs meet Aristotle's criteria for virtues and evaluates the similarities and the differences in the virtue lists of Proverbs and Aristotle, seeking to understand what made specific virtues prominent in either Proverbs or Aristotle or in both. In chapter 6, “Theological Virtues in Proverbs,” he considers whether concepts in Proverbs correlate with the definitions and the criteria for theological virtues delineated by Thomas, and he finds that they do. In chapter 7, “Moral Agents and the Presentation of Virtue,” he highlights some of the conclusions yielded by his study of Proverbs with the help of Socratic, Aristotelian, and Thomistic virtue ethics, and he encourages readers to understand Proverbs as a part of the Hebrew moral tradition. He also offers some reflections on lingering issues raised by his study such as the notion of human nature, the human problem in Proverbs, and the relationship between moral and theological virtues.
Keefer's dual aims related to biblical interpretation and moral philosophy and his conception of this study as a project in both philosophy and Old Testament studies are evident in the method of biblical interpretation he devised for this effort. His method calls for the extraction of specific concepts from the works of three of the most influential thinkers in virtue ethics; these concepts are then used as lenses to interpret biblical texts that are themselves examined in their own literary and cultural contexts. Accordingly, his method is designed to enable a philosophical interpretation of Proverbs that both situates the biblical materials in their ancient Near Eastern context and places them in conversation with the thought of three moral philosophers. Keefer acknowledges that projects combining philosophy and Old Testament studies can suffer from the following shortcomings, which he hopes his method will help him avoid: biblical studies may carefully examine biblical texts in their literary and social contexts but engage the discipline of philosophy in only a limited or superficial way, and moral philosophy may emphasize Greek and other extra-biblical moral traditions but fail to take into serious account the moral traditions in the biblical materials themselves. He thus offers his methodological approach of “giving unabridged attention to moral philosophy and contextually sensitive biblical interpretation” as a middle way that “facilitat[es] interaction between the Bible and philosophical texts” (9). Additionally, in devising this method, Keefer relies upon a method for evaluating rival moral traditions that was proposed by moral philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre.Footnote 1
Keefer draws upon scholarship from multiple academic disciplines and examines texts from different periods and cultures, and the footnotes, the bibliography, the index of ancient sources, and the index of authors and topics demonstrate the extent of his effort. Through this study, the richness and the complexity of Proverbial ethics become evident. As he notes, Proverbial ethics reflects concern for both who a person is and what a person does, it considers both knowledge and desire as relevant to moral decision making, and it recognizes that the goodness of an action is connected to underlying circumstances such as the time, the place, the purpose, the manner, and the person toward whom an action is directed. Keefer shows that Proverbs is indeed a book of ethics that includes fifteen moral virtues, three theological virtues, other moral concepts such as the intellectual states and actions of prudence and understanding, and categorically right and wrong behaviors such as murder, adultery, and stealing that are also proscribed by regulations in biblical law.
The interdisciplinary nature of this study makes this book worthwhile for students and scholars in various fields of inquiry. First, it will reward those engaged in biblical studies, especially those who have an interest in Hebrew wisdom literature. Because interpreters of Proverbs confront a text that collects sayings and poems, organizes ethical instruction around characters and actions but lacks the sort of systemization afforded by writers such as Aristotle and Thomas, Keefer's method of reading Proverbs through the frameworks of virtue ethics developed by Socrates, Aristotle, and Thomas affords another way to organize and analyze biblical materials and allows the reader to see biblical verses and pericopes in a fresh light. In addition to gaining insight from Keefer's handling of specific Hebrew terms and his interpretation of particular verses or pericopes, biblical studies scholars may also find in his interpretive method and his project combining philosophy and Old Testament studies inspiration to devise similar methods and undertake similar approaches in their own work.
Second, this book will reward students and scholars in the fields of moral philosophy and moral theology who may already be well acquainted with virtue ethics and the thought of Socrates, Aristotle, Thomas, and MacIntyre but who may not have conceived of Proverbs as a book of virtue ethics. Keefer's primary purposes of showing the morality of Proverbs and demonstrating that Proverbs is a book of ethics that offers its own tradition of virtue ethics rest upon an assessment of existing scholarship that those in the fields of biblical studies and moral philosophy have not read or understood Proverbs adequately as a book of virtue ethics, and he makes a compelling case that it should be so understood by biblical scholars, moral philosophers, and moral theologians.
Third, this book will reward students and scholars in the interdisciplinary field of law and religion. Biblical law and natural law have been two contributing influences in the development and perpetuation of the Western legal tradition, and biblical law and natural law converge in Proverbs. Keefer observes that biblical law, including the non-virtue regulations of the Torah, factors into the complex morality of Proverbs, and he encourages others to study Proverbial ethics and biblical law in the light of each other, considering such issues as the virtue-fostering prescriptions of biblical law and the harmony between vice and lawlessness. Accordingly, understanding Proverbs as a book of ethics will give students of law in Jewish and Christian scriptures insight into the moral and legal instruction that is found throughout the biblical materials. Likewise, Keefer shows the value of reading Proverbs as a book of virtue ethics and with the help of Aristotle and Thomas Aquinas, who are two of the most important philosophers in both virtue ethics and the natural law tradition. Students of the natural law tradition will find much to commend in the ethical vision of Proverbs and Keefer's exposition of Proverbial ethics, for it may be that Proverbs is where Scripture “address[es] . . . most helpfully” the question of how people come to know the natural law, which is less a collection of rules and more a holistic moral order “direct[ing] human beings toward ways of life that promote proper goods and purposes.”Footnote 2 Accordingly, students of legal philosophy, theological jurisprudence, law in Judaism and Christianity, and the interpretation of biblical law will find Keefer's study of Proverbs through the lenses of Socrates, Aristotle, Thomas, and virtue ethics to be a fruitful resource to advance their understanding of biblical law and natural law.
