The ongoing proliferation of white supremacy in the United States is not new, although its current fevered pitch has been hurled into stark relief by the four years of the Donald J. Trump administration. An array of emergent performance analysts, prompted by racism's persistence and intensification, is studying this phenomenon with keen lenses today. Dani Snyder-Young is one such analyst. Her latest text concertizes with whiteness studies, a burgeoning area of inquiry within critical race studies that aims to mark whiteness by exposing its embedded operations. Snyder-Young's book Privileged Spectatorship: Theatrical Interventions in White Supremacy is comprehensive in its cognition of the high stakes of white supremacy as it performs within the theatre industry. She trains her critical lens on mainstream, nonprofit theatre between 2013 and 2018. Across six chapters, divided into three overarching parts, Snyder-Young unfurls a comprehensive examination of audience and professional critical response to projects confronting white supremacy through the deployment of ever-evolving interactive performance and feedback modalities. She also illustrates the ways in which the seasonal selection practices of the theatre institutions producing such performances beg closer and ongoing evaluation.
The Introduction identifies the terrain of Snyder-Young's study: “Mainstream Theater and Privileged Spectatorship.” Chapters 1 and 2, “Making Whiteness Visible” and “Critical Catharsis,” constitute Part 1, “Come Closer,” which elaborates some of the terms crucial to understanding that terrain. Snyder-Young details the myriad approaches of practitioners and theatre producers working to renovate the antiquated framework of “catharsis” from implication-free purgation toward a more reflexive mode of ongoing action. Chapters 3 and 4, “Peeling Back the Veneer of Decorum” and “Outrage and the Boundaries of Community,” constitute Part 2, “Rage against the Machine.” These chapters foreground several examples of original dramatic work that refuses to couch their critiques of anti-Blackness and racism in polite decorum. Rather, they render transparent the blunt impact that racial animus has on the lives of people of color. Further, these theatre projects labor to evolve the interactive postshow dynamic into an open space for thoughtful discussion about the performances. Part 3, “Decolonizing Gazes and Spaces,” comprises Chapters 5 and 6, “Maintaining White Racial Comfort” and “Building Diverse Community.” Here, Snyder-Young articulates a crucial tension between a white audience that may not easily relinquish its hold on the comfort zone it has always presumed the theatre space to be, and the twenty-first-century theatre makers of color who mean to crack that zone wide open through enunciations of the lives and concerns of those historically foreclosed from that space. The Conclusion brings the book to a provisional yet hopeful close by suggesting that the work of intervening in white supremacy is incomplete and formidable. Snyder-Young's methodology is rigorous in unfurling the exigencies facing today's theatre makers as they confront the sedimented implacability of whiteness and its aesthetic demands. Her citations are inclusive of many preeminent theatre and performance scholars and artists, among them Marvin Carlson, Soyica Diggs Colbert, Jill Dolan, Caridad Svitch, and Harvey Young. Moreover, she is dedicated to calling attention to her own positionality as a white interlocutor.
Animating this complex theatre landscape has been the persistence of anti-Black animus, a condition that, as Black studies scholars such as Christina Sharpe and Saidiya Hartman have elaborated in their work, is the climatic reality of slavery's afterlife. Black Lives Matter and many other grassroots responses have arisen in this century to challenge that persistence on both national and global stages. Snyder-Young highlights this challenge by situating what she identifies, in Chapter 4, as “a pair of scandals surrounding critical engagement with theatrical events at Chicago's Steppenwolf Theatre: This Is Modern Art [by Kevin Coval and Idris Goodwin] in 2015, and [Antoinette Nwandu's] Pass Over, in 2017” (65). These events function, in effect, as the book's fulcrum. The racially biased perspectives of the professional critics of these productions piqued immense outcry. Snyder-Young describes the dynamic of those encounters as the “nodal point for antagonistic conflict” (67) and paraphrases scholars Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe's definition of antagonism as “I [arts community] cannot be me if you [the biased critic] exist” (66). A growing constellation of scholars within Black studies, however, might invert and append Laclau and Mouffe's quote as “I [the non-Black world] cannot be me if you [the Black] do not exist” to further distill the necessary antagonism that Blackness poses to the (non-Black epistemic) world. Nwandu's play unflinchingly pursues this distillation of anti-Black antagonism, which exceeds mere conflict between presumed equal entities to suggest that, to the world, Blackness signifies scandal par excellence. Coval and Goodwin's play illuminates this condition, in part, by situating graffiti art makers (graffiti having emerged from the Black underground of late 1960s Philadelphia) as brashly inhabiting, through their art, their being scandalized as criminal defacers and violators of Eurocentric aesthetic ideals. In short, Snyder-Young centers the real-time scandals surrounding the community uproars in response to two critics’ racist appraisals, and in the process, exposes the presumptive structural scandal of Blackness at the root of the performative ones.
This is, to some extent, the specter haunting the book: the ways in which the consensus around “white supremacy” often privileges the notion that antiracism is automatically of a piece with a broadband desire for universality, diversity, recognition, and inclusion, rather than complete liberation from the hegemonic violence that the collective desire for these (presumed) rites of passage authorizes, even unwittingly. In other words, might Nwandu's indictment of anti-Blackness exceed such appeal and thereby disarticulate the redundant concept of “antagonistic conflict?” If so, might the particularizing of Blackness as both scandal and antagonism, and Nwandu's daring to illustrate the violence of such positioning, have been what magnetized the critics’ animus? This reflection prompts an even more expansive cross-disciplinary discourse. Snyder-Young has begun that process by citing Black studies scholars such as Hartman, Jared C. Sexton, and Frank B. Wilderson, who center slavery, rather than whiteness per se, as a paradigm instead of as a historical event or a series of actions and experiences to be redressed. In short, anti-Blackness is a structured animus, of which “white supremacy” is only a symptom and facet.
Privileged Spectatorship: Theatrical Interventions in White Supremacy is an important contribution to the fields of theatre, drama, performance, and critical race studies. It rigorously and expansively studies long known, yet too rarely avowed, challenges within the standing agreement among the theatre's practitioners and consumers that plays will be “embedded in white racial frameworks, carrying unconscious biases” (128). This work, in exposing such deeply imbricated challenges, illumines a multifariousness of theatre practitioners whose contributions are also deeply important and, perhaps most significantly, are also honored by Snyder-Young's meticulous labor.
