In literary, historical, and cultural studies of Victorian Britain, the figure of the middle-class woman is—to adopt terms appropriate to Jill Rappoport’s marvelous new book—a gift and a regift all at once. Despite being the focus of intense and remarkably generative critical scrutiny, our assumptions about the ideological contours of Victorian middle-class womanhood can sometimes come to feel a little flat. In Giving Women: Alliance and Exchange in Victorian Culture Rappoport takes up the challenge of reinvigorating our analysis. Focusing an astute literary critical eye and a strong interdisciplinary intelligence on the paradigm of feminine self-sacrifice in which the good woman must give and give and give some more, Rappoport convincingly argues that giving, broadly conceived, offered Victorian women a way to negotiate new models of social and economic agency and female community. This reconsideration produces fresh meanings from familiar literary texts and illuminates a fascinating selection of cultural archives of women’s philanthropy and political activism. Feminist criticism and the history of feminism are richer for the new focus Rappoport provides. From a slightly different theoretical and historical standpoint, Rappoport’s argument contributes to a more expansive understanding of the social implications of economic activity, one that looks beyond narrow notions of self-interest, money, and getting and spending.
A clear and compact introductory chapter elucidates the theoretical and methodological underpinnings of Rappoport’s argument. Acknowledging theories of the gift that have structured much critical engagement of the topic (including those of Claude Lévi-Strauss, Marcel Mauss, Jacques Derrida, and, from a feminist angle, Gayle Rubin and Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick), Rappoport stakes her own formulation that emphasizes the activity of giving, asking not so much what constitutes a gift as what “relational identities” (4), forms of alliance, and modes of power are enabled (and foreclosed) through actions that claim to be gifts. Although “giving” ultimately feels like the more important term for Rappoport, a more specific notion of gifts nonetheless orients the book’s first part, which focuses more directly on gifts and exchange in literary texts. The first chapter focuses on literary annuals, anthologies circulated as gifts, examining how these textual objects “helped to construct, not just represent” (20) women as giving subjects in larger social networks. Paying careful attention to the material features of these books (bindings, illustrations, inscriptions, prefaces), Rappoport reads several textual examples—tales of philanthropy and abolition—in which scenes of giving are modeled for middle-class British readers to enlist them in horizontal networks of social connection and responsibility. The effects of these exchanges in forging cross-class and cross-race alliances are far more limited. The annuals warrant the increased scholarly attention they have received in recent years, and Rappoport’s nuanced consideration of their central paradigm—the gift—across textual and practical manifestations represents a real contribution.
The book’s second and third chapters focus on the dynamic of gift exchange in more canonical Victorian texts by women. Chapter 3 presents a fascinating interpretation of Jane Eyre (1847) and Aurora Leigh (1856), which argues that gift practices are a crucial and overlooked element of women’s economic agency. Reading Jane’s and Aurora’s bestowals and rejections of gifts and inheritances alongside broader political and economic discussions of tax policies, Rappoport convincingly argues that the two texts use gifts and giving to reimagine kinship relations along more egalitarian (although still class-bound) lines. Chapter 4 centers on Elizabeth Gaskell’s Cranford (1851) and its economy of conservation, reading the recirculation of gifts through a closed community of women in light of tensions between models of capitalist growth and scientific explorations of thermodynamics. In this novel, too, Rappoport suggests, gift exchange creates the means through which to reimagine social connections, as well as the literary forms (e.g., the marriage plot) that depended on a heteronormative kinship model. The extraliterary reach in both chapters—into taxes and physical science—provides extremely illuminating historical context.
In the book’s second part, giving takes center stage, and gifts drop out of focus somewhat. The relation between the two terms—obviously crucially linked yet with differences that might be more or less important—can sometimes raise questions. (I found myself more convinced by the first chapter’s arguments about abolitionist gift rhetoric, e.g., once I had plunged further into pt. 2’s more expansive conceptualization in which actual gifts become less significant.) But the emphasis on giving proves extraordinarily productive. Through intelligent engagement of archival sources from philanthropic ventures (the Salvation Army) and women’s suffrage organizations, in which women’s sacrifice is invoked and celebrated (most notably in the spectacular form of the hunger strike), as well as analyses of literary texts such as “Goblin Market” (Christina Rossetti, 1861) and New Woman novels, Rappoport’s claim that the paradigm of sacrifice enabled diverse forms of organization and feminist justification develops in compelling fashion. Once again in her more literary chapters, the historical evidence that Rappoport marshals—on women’s philanthropic traditions and discourses of eugenics—sheds new light on long-standing critical discussions. And the analysis of archival documents, images, and artifacts of material culture (dress, postcards and posters, bazaar crafts) from philanthropic and political organizations presents an argument of its own for the fruitfulness of interdisciplinary inquiry.
There are other gifts to be had in this book: it is beautifully written and generously illustrated (with clear, smart analyses of its images), and it offers a wealth of archival materials. Although the book is clear about the limitations of the reliance on giving, especially the class boundaries that it invoked, I was curious at times to hear more about how the gift practices that are discussed might have met or addressed resistance—not so much by their supposed beneficiaries (the skepticism or resentment of, say, the poor subjects the Army addressed comes through) but more by other discourses that circumscribed kinship, economic agency, and political alliance in different terms. But Giving Women is an absorbing, rewarding contribution to Victorian studies and feminist history—a gift that, like the best of its kind, will prompt reader-recipients to carry its insights forward with revitalized understanding.
