Stewart Gordon has written a brief introduction to various examples of slavery outside the Atlantic basin. It is suitable for use as a supplementary textbook, as well as for those who might want to know something more about slavery beyond the forms of slavery more familiar to Americans. After an introduction dealing briefly with the origin and definition of slavery, Gordon goes into more detail in four chapters, each of which presents a case study of slavery that might not be familiar to modern audiences: slavery in Ancient Athens, what he calls East African slavery, slavery on the Barbary coast of North Africa, and slavery today. This is followed by several pages of ‘Reflections and Conclusions’ and an excellent bibliography that will be useful to researchers, whether scholars working on comparative studies or students writing term papers. There is a brief but far from complete index.
Each chapter follows a similar outline: first an account of the history and historiography of the particular form of the institution of slavery that is being considered, and a discussion of its nature and importance, followed by a series of primary sources, each with an introduction and thought-provoking questions for consideration, which should be useful in classes for generating discussion, as well as for interested general readers.
One can, of course, question the choice of examples. Why Athens and not Rome? Surely something about Greek slave tutors in Rome would be eye opening for most students today. The chapter on East African slavery is less about slavery in East Africa and more about the export slave trade from there, and thus winds up discussing military slavery in India and mentioning the central Asian slave trade to the Istanbul slave market. Why not write about the Ottoman slave trade in general, or slavery in the western Indian Ocean? The chapter on slavery today talks about the role of the Second World War and the United Nations in fighting slavery and involuntary servitude, but not the role of the League of Nations. But given the brief length of the book the case studies chosen are all good ones that serve as thoughtful reminders that slavery in the antebellum southern United States was neither definitive nor even typical of slavery in human history.
This book is not intended to be a conclusive, complete, or comprehensive study of slavery throughout history. It approaches the topic more through description than classic definition, and so avoids the inevitable fuzzy borders between slavery and other institutions of dominance, although the case studies inevitably must deal with those borders. The book's agreement with many other authors that slavery began in the neolithic, and was related to domestication of animals is contradicted when the author notes the presence of significant proportions of slaves in the populations of the Pacific Northwest of North America, where hunter-gatherers in lush environments even engaged in slave trading (xiii–xiv, xxv). Just as we must question the assumption that the marginal hunter-gatherer populations of today reproduce the lifestyles, social structures, and other features of hunter-gatherers in the lusher environments of the paleolithic past before agriculture, so too the origins of slavery must be rethought. Such, however, is not the purpose of this book, which should not be criticized for not seeing what it was not investigating.
Stewart Gordon set out to write a book that considers forms of slavery that contrast with those found in New World plantation slavery, which are especially familiar to Americans and students of American history. He has succeeded admirably. His book is the product of broad erudition and a thoughtful mind. It will be useful to many.
