This book is an edited collection comprising a variety of essays, some dealing directly with the subject matter of the title (i.e. the International Criminal Court (ICC)), whereas others do so only indirectly. The object of the editor seems to have been the exposition of the law and politics of the ICC, but it is not abundantly clear if he was envisaging a detailed study of the ICC – in the form of a quasi-commentary – or instead a collection of expert essays, without any particular thread. In my opinion, only the former has been achieved. Edited collections constitute a dangerous species and one immersed with significant practical difficulties. A successful collection requires a coherent theme and an organisation which every contributor must follow without deviation. If contributors are simply asked to write what is convenient for them, absent a consistent format, it is only natural that the final product will turn out to be simply a collection of random essays that are not held together by a coherent theme. This is certainly the case with the present work. Some essays are thirty pages long, whereas others range from six to fifteen pages; some are heavily footnoted, whereas others contain only a handful. Moreover, there is significant overlap (sometimes in as many as four or five chapters) in the coverage of particular issues. The absence of any perspective is evident in the existence of eight chapters on the crime of aggression, which is a significant aspect of the ICC, but is otherwise marginal in a general examination of international criminal justice or the role of an international criminal court, particularly when a single chapter – and then hardly analytical – has been devoted to war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide. The editor, Professor Bellelli, has made a tremendous effort to remedy many of the deficiencies of the book by writing multiple lengthy chapters himself, all of which are analytical and concise, in contrast to most of the other chapters, which are generally cursory and narrow in focus and subject matter.
Given the intended size of the book I would have expected that – besides the chapters dealing with genocide – all the other essays would have been comprehensive and that other areas of ICC law and policy would have been covered. Save for some references to criminal cases before the courts of the former Yugoslavia, the practice of complementarity before national courts has been left untouched. What is the point of chapters on the International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, the Sierra Leone Special Court and the Cambodia Extraordinary Chambers in a book whose title refers specifically to the ICC, and when these chapters are of a general nature anyway?
This does not mean that the book does not have its own particular strengths. Its chapters on the crime of aggression are excellent and a good source of information for the keen reader. Yet, it is surprising that the editor was willing to commission eight chapters on the crime of aggression when a few months down the road (May 2010) he was aware that the review conference would most probably change the landscape of this offence. This observation does not take away anything from the quality of these chapters, however. Equally, the book is rich in its information on cases brought before the national courts of the former Yugoslavia. This information is not generally available and hence international criminal justice scholars interested in these unreported cases will find a wealth of information.
