From Angola to Afghanistan, one hundred years' worth of US efforts to reform agriculture and “solve” the global riddles of food production and hunger continue to leave physical traces on the land and discursive traces on the way we imagine the world and America's role in it. Nick Cullather's brilliant and wide-ranging The Hungry World: America's Cold War Battle against Poverty in Asia provides a coherent framework for apprehending these phenomena, offering the most theoretically and methodologically sophisticated account yet of the tangled, contradictory US engagement with development and agricultural reform over the course of the last century.
Cullather starts by investigating the intellectual and social-scientific construction of hunger as an international-relations phenomenon in the early twentieth century. Before they could attempt to ameliorate hunger through agricultural reform, American policymakers and scientists needed to reimagine it as a social and environmental phenomenon amenable to calculation and manipulation. Calculability, in the form of the calorie, immediately became a useful tool for measuring the dietary needs of conscript armies during the First World War or for demonstrating the nutritional – and implicitly cultural – superiority of wheat over rice.
During the interwar years agricultural reformers focussed their attention on foundation-funded efforts to research and breed high-yield strains of wheat in Mexico. Although the results proved promising, Cullather argues that the larger significance of these efforts stemmed from the stories they told and the ways they visually represented development and agricultural modernization. It is thus no surprise that the central figure in this narrative is plant pathologist Norman Borlaug, who headed the Mexican wheat research program for the Rockefeller Foundation and whose scientific expertise was more than matched by his ability to spin “a capsule narrative, part fact, part fiction, designed to convey a formula for development” (45).
The next several chapters trace the emergence of hunger in Asia as a strategic, Cold War concern commanding the attention of policymakers, funders and scientists, and the myriad responses they produced to combat it, ranging from programs of land reform to community development, the construction of hydroelectric complexes in Afghanistan, and the development of “miracle” rice at the International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) in the Philippines. This is one of the strengths of The Hungry World – its emphasis on the multiple, competing visions of development that policymakers, scientists and intellectuals proffered over the course of decades, and its refusal to simply trace one strand of a complex story at the expense of a messier reality.
Each of these developmental models was shot through with contradictions and unanticipated consequences, as the saga of the Helmand Valley Authority in Afghanistan from the 1950s through the 1970s vividly illustrates. “Pastoralists produced the country's primary export and most of its foreign exchange revenue,” Cullather writes, “and yet [the Helmand Valley Authority's] plan to convert them into wheat farmers was never seriously questioned” (130). Afghanistan's fragile environment resisted American hydroelectric schemes much as its human population did, silting up dams and rivers, salinating aquifers and rendering the land perfectly suited to cultivation of the lucrative opium poppy. Developmental models, these accounts remind the reader, both clarify and obscure, much as a speeding car focusses attention on the road ahead while blurring the landscape on either side.
Although Afghanistan was a Cold War battlefield of sorts, US–Soviet conflict is not central to Cullather's story. Rather, it repeatedly comes into focus as a source of strategic anxiety, a spur to competition, or a justification for increased funding from foundations or government agencies. More important, he suggests, were the state-centered imperatives to rationalize, incorporate and intensify as a spur to the transformation of peasant attitudes and consciousness. One notable feature of IR-5, for example, the “miracle rice” that so bewitched Philippine president Marcos, was the way that it enmeshed farmers in a new matrix of seeds, credit, fertilizers, expertise and markets. This decentering of Cold War conflict is welcome, though it occasionally occludes the global dimensions of development as a political project, as does Cullather's relative inattention to the colonial precedents for many of the postwar schemes he analyzes.
The last few chapters of The Hungry World focus on India. Cullather demonstrates how the adoption by successive Indian governments of so-called Green Revolution seeds and technologies reshaped the imagined place of agriculture in national development plans and literally reconfigured India's place in the world food economy. After India's independence in 1947 US officials emphasized community development as a low-cost path to changing peasant farming practices. Such plans were eventually sidelined not because they were ineffective, however this was measured, but because they did not produce the sort of technical or psychological breakthroughs American officials thought necessary to catalyze society-wide transformation. Whereas post-independence leaders such as Nehru sought to use agriculture as a source of surplus for feeding the cities, extracting domestic capital and fueling heavy industrialization, US officials and planners encouraged officials in New Delhi to capitalize agriculture itself and grow high-yield wheat for export, ironically deepening the country's dependence on food imports for its own population.
The agricultural plans promoted for India transformed the very meaning of hunger. In 1966 President Lyndon Johnson attempted to convince Indian prime minister Indira Gandhi to define a temporary food crisis as a famine requiring immediate intervention in the form of millions of tons of US wheat and the steamrolling of political opponents in both Washington and New Delhi. One important result of the Indian “famine,” Cullather notes, was the incorporation of American grain surpluses into new global models for hunger relief, a development which cheered American agribusiness but has helped to undermine food self-sufficiency in countries where hunger stems from low food prices that make it difficult for small farmers to sustain their livelihoods. This is one of the few places where Cullather explicitly tallies the costs and benefits of the development schemes he explores, and although he seems dubious of the exercise, The Hungry World might have addressed this issue more directly. Just how effective were these myriad efforts in ameliorating hunger and boosting agricultural productivity, and at what human and social cost? More important, what alternatives did agricultural and political elites in the Philippines, India and elsewhere envision, and how effectively did they fight for them?
Cullather's research here is impressive, drawing on a wide range of collections in the United States, India and the Philippines, including rarely consulted collections at the International Rice Research Institute and the UN Food and Agriculture Organization. He is, moreover, a gifted writer, blessed with the ability to infuse potentially treacherous tales of plant breeding and dam construction with an air of high drama, and to make the reader await the results of dwarf rice trials with bated breath. Graduate students will find this book especially useful, and parts (such as the chapter on Afghanistan) are well suited for undergraduates as well. The author's skepticism towards the development models he so skillfully deconstructs leads him to shy away from prescribing alternatives. This is too bad, especially in a work that engages with the agricultural policies of the Obama administration and the revival, in more modest form, of central ideological and narrative tenets of the Green Revolution, especially in sub-Saharan Africa. The politics of global hunger and development remain with us, and The Hungry World is the best guide we have to their tangled descent.
