Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T09:23:42.940Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Evolution of wake structures behind oscillating hydrofoils with combined heaving and pitching motion

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 September 2021

Suyash Verma
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB T6G 2R3, Canada
Arman Hemmati*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB T6G 2R3, Canada
*
†Email address for correspondence: arman.hemmati@ualberta.ca

Abstract

The wake of an oscillating teardrop hydrofoil with combined heaving and pitching motion was studied numerically at Reynolds number of 8000 and Strouhal numbers of $St=0.21{-}0.94$. The lower Strouhal number exhibited high efficiency propulsion with small thrust generation. However, larger thrust generation at high $St$ required more power, which lowered the propulsive efficiency. Quantitative assessment of vortex evolution, along with qualitative investigation of the formation and interaction of primary structures, revealed the association with elliptic instability characteristics for both co-rotating and counter-rotating vortex structures in both wakes. With respect to advection of the leading-edge vortex, the pressure distribution further depicted evidence of spanwise instability with distinct temporal evolution along the suction and pressure surfaces of the oscillating foil. Three-dimensional assessment of wake structures located downstream of the trailing edge depicted the existence of dislocations associated with primary vortex ‘rollers’. At low $St$, these were limited to fine spanwise corrugations (valleys and bulges) on weaker leading edge rollers, which enlarged as the rollers advected downstream. In contrast, at high $St$, the wake exhibited conjoint hairpin-horseshoe vortex structures that led to stronger deformations on the coupled vortex rollers. The statistical characteristics of secondary structures resembled the long wavelength mode and mode A identified previously for purely pitching and heaving foils, respectively. They also mimicked mode B for stationary cylinders. Novel wake models are introduced based on a complete vivid three-dimensional depiction of coherent wake structures.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Description of teardrop foil geometry and motion employed in the current study.

Figure 1

Table 1.Parameter space for the current studies and the companion experiments.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Schematics of the computational domain (not to scale).

Figure 3

Figure 3.Depiction of three-dimensional background and overset grid.

Figure 4

Figure 4.OGA meshing and cell identification for an oscillating foil. (a) Typical overlap of an structured overset grid (black lines), and background grid (white lines) for the current computational study. (b) Representation of hole cells in white (A), interpolation cell fringe in black (B) and calculated cells in dark grey (C), identified on the background grid.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Comparison of time histories for thrust and moment coefficients for all grids employed in our study.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Grid sensitivity study using mean streamwise velocity variations along the $y$-direction at (a) $x=2c$ and (b) $x=4c$.

Figure 7

Table 2.Grid refinement details for SIM2 in table 1. Here, $N_{total}$ represents the sum of hexahedral elements in the background grid and overset grid.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Comparison of current numerical results with experiments of Van Buren et al. (2019). Variations of mean thrust are compared at (a) $f^* = 0.67$, and (b) $f^* = 1.87$, while unsteady variations of lift and moment contribution to the total power are compared at (c) $\phi =0^\circ$ and (d) $\phi =270^\circ$. Details of the parameter space are provided in the text.

Figure 9

Table 3.Quantitative evaluation of performance, showing time-averaged coefficient of thrust ($\overline {C_{T}}$), r.m.s. value of lift ($C_{L}^{rms}$), coefficient of power ($\overline {C_{P}}$) and propulsive efficiency ($\eta$) for SIM1 and SIM2.

Figure 10

Figure 8.Contours of $\omega _z^+$ superimposed by velocity vectors for SIM1. Phases ($\psi$) of the shedding cycle are (a) $\psi =0^{\circ }$ at $t = 0$, (b) $\psi = 90^{\circ }$ at $t = T/4$, (c) $\psi = 180^{\circ }$ at $t = T/2$, (d) $\psi = 270^{\circ }$ at $t = 3T/4$ and (e) $\psi = 360^{\circ }$ at $t = T$.

Figure 11

Figure 9.Variation of force (a,b) and moment (c) in one cycle for SIM1.

Figure 12

Figure 10.Instantaneous pressure ($C_{pr}$) distribution on suction side (a–c) and pressure side (d–f) of the foil at instants (a, d) 1, (b,e) 2 and (c, f) 3 of figure 9.

Figure 13

Figure 11.Contours of $\omega _z^+$ superimposed by velocity vectors for SIM2. Phases ($\psi$) of the shedding cycle are (a) $\psi =0^{\circ }$ at $t = 0$, (b) $\psi = 90^{\circ }$ at $t = T/4$, (c) $\psi = 180^{\circ }$ at $t = T/2$, (d) $\psi = 270^{\circ }$ at $t = 3T/4$ and (e) $\psi = 360^{\circ }$ at $t = T$.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Variation of force (a,b) and moment (c) in one cycle for SIM2.

Figure 15

Figure 13.Instantaneous pressure ($C_{pr}$) distribution on suction side (a–c) and pressure side (d–f) of the foil at instants (a, d) 1, (b,e) 2 and (c, f) 3 of figure 12.

Figure 16

Figure 14.Variation of (a,c) vortex radii, $a^+$, (b, d) cross-stream coordinate of vortex centre, $y^+$ and (b, d) separation distance between the paired and coupled vortices, $\zeta ^+$, with normalized time scale $t^+$, for (a,b) SIM1 and (c, d) SIM2, respectively.

Figure 17

Figure 15.Dislocations of primary structures in the wake for SIM1 using (a) iso-surface of spanwise vorticity, $|\omega _z^+|=0.5$. The iso-contours of $|\omega _z^+|$ on the $yz$-plane are shown at (b) $x^+ =4$, and (c) $x^+ = 5$. Here, $\omega _z^+ = +0.5$ is coloured in grey and $\omega _z^+ =-0.5$ in black.

Figure 18

Figure 16.Dislocations are highlighted on the iso-surface plots of normalized $Q$-criterion ($Q^{+} = Qc^{2}/U_{\infty }^{2}\approx 0.01$), overlaid with iso-surface of $\omega _z^+$ = 0.5 in grey and $\omega _z^+ = -0.5$ in black shown from spanwise (a) top view and (b) bottom view.

Figure 19

Figure 17.Dislocations observed for the primary structures in the wake for SIM2 using (a) iso-surface of $|\omega _z^+| =3$ with valleys and bulges depicted on the $yz$-plane at (b) $x^+ = 5.4$, and (c) $x^+ = 6$. Legends are the same as previous figures.

Figure 20

Figure 18.Dislocations observed for the primary structures in the wake for SIM2 are highlighted in iso-surface plots of normalized $Q$-criterion ($Q^{+} = Qc^{2}/U_{\infty }^{2}\approx 0.09$) overlaid with coloured contours corresponding to $\omega _z^+ = 3$ (grey) and $\omega _z^+ = -3$ (black): (a) top and (b) bottom view of the wake.

Figure 21

Table 4.Quantitative comparison of spanwise wavelength for secondary vortices in wake of different geometries, motion and $Re$. Diameter ($D$), height ($h$) and chord length ($c$) for respective geometries were used for normalizing $\lambda _{z}$.

Figure 22

Figure 19.(a) Iso-surface of $\omega _z^+ = +0.5$ (grey) and $\omega _z^+=-0.5$ (black) along with $yz$-plane contour of $u^\prime$ at $x^+ = 4$. (b) The depiction of ribs using iso-surface of $\omega _x^+ = +0.055$ (grey) and $\omega _x^+ =-0.055$ (black) along with the $yz$-plane contour of streamwise vorticity at $x^+ = 4$.

Figure 23

Figure 20.(a) Iso-surface of $\omega _z^+ = +0.5$ (grey) and $\omega _z^+=-0.5$ (black) along with the $yz$-plane contour of $u^\prime$ at $x^+ = 5$. (b) The depiction of ribs using iso-surface of $\omega _x^+ = +0.055$ (grey) and $\omega _x^+ =-0.055$ (black) along with the $yz$-plane contour of streamwise vorticity at $x^+ = 5$.

Figure 24

Figure 21.Variation of $C (\Delta z)$ with respect to spanwise shift ($\Delta z^+$) during (a) 2P wake at $x^+=4$ and 5, and (b) 2S wake at $x^+=6.65$ and 7.65 for SIM1.

Figure 25

Figure 22.Alignment of streamwise vortex pairs on the $yz$-plane at (a) $x^+ = 6.65$ and (b) $x^+ = 7.65$ for SIM1.

Figure 26

Figure 23.Variation of $\rho (\Delta z)$ obtained from cross-correlations of $\omega _x^+$ between (a) full and (b) half-shedding cycles for SIM1.

Figure 27

Figure 24.(a,b) Iso-surface of $\omega _z^+ = +3$ (grey) and $\omega _z^+=-3$ (black) along with the $yz$-plane contour of $u^\prime$ at $x^+ = 5.4$. (c, d) The depiction of ribs using iso-surface of $\omega _x^+ = +0.5$ (grey) and $\omega _x^+ =-0.5$ (black) along with the $yz$-plane contour of streamwise vorticity at $x^+ = 5.4$.

Figure 28

Figure 25.(a,b) Iso-surface of $\omega _z^+ = +3$ (grey) and $\omega _z^+=-3$ (black) along with the $yz$-plane contour of $u^\prime$ at $x^+ = 6$. (c, d) The depiction of ribs using iso-surface of $\omega _x^+ = +0.5$ (grey) and $\omega _x^+ =-0.5$ (black) along with the $yz$-plane contour of streamwise vorticity at $x^+ = 6$.

Figure 29

Figure 26.Variation of $C (\Delta z)$ with respect to normalized spanwise shift ($\Delta z^+$) in the (a) near wake and (b) mid-wake of SIM2.

Figure 30

Figure 27.Iso-surface of $\omega _z^+$ with the alignment of streamwise vortex pairs shown on $yz$-planes at (a) $x^+ = 7.4$ and (b) $x^+ = 8.4$.

Figure 31

Figure 28.Variation of $\rho (\Delta z)$ with respect to normalized spanwise shift ($\Delta z^+$) based on cross-correlations of $\omega _x^+$ between (a) full and (b) half-shedding cycles for SIM2.

Figure 32

Figure 29.Vortex skeleton models for (a) SIM1 and (b) SIM2. Here, $+\varGamma$ and $-\varGamma$ denote the circulation for counter-clockwise and clockwise rollers, respectively, and $+\varGamma _{RI}$ and $-\varGamma _{RI}$ denote the circulation for counter-clockwise and clockwise ribs, respectively.