These two books are worth reading for the sound narratives and alternative perspectives that they propose on contested issues centering on the role of political Islam. They provide a reasonably interesting framing of processes that are all too often described with sensationalism. The interpretations of the role played by Islam/Islamism in the politics of conflict in the Middle East outlined by these books are not in themselves highly original. Yet considering the post-9/11 obsession with security in studies of anything Islamic or Middle Eastern, such reasonable analyses have not had the visibility that they should have had. What makes these books valuable is more this sober perspective than any highly innovative framework or any set of new data that they may contain.
Nathan C. Funk and Abdul Aziz Said's Islam and Peacemaking in the Middle East is a useful work primarily because it introduces, in a sensible way, several Islamic perspectives on social and political peace that commonly remain ignored in contemporary accounts of political Islam and Middle East politics. Their starting point is that “reexamining narratives about ‘the West’ and Islam is essential for contemporary peacemaking efforts” (p. 23). The authors' case, that a specifically “Islamic” perspective is useful to peacemaking in the Middle East, is set against the background of the U.S. policy and media debates where, in the authors' view, “a single ‘story’ of intercultural confrontation” dominates (p. 24). Hence, the contribution that this book seeks to make in the debates about the role of Islamic culture is to highlight the diversity of “helpful” conceptual and practical resources for conflict resolution within this tradition. They want to show that “when powerful external actors recognize that Islam must be included rather than excluded from problem-solving efforts in the region, they increase prospects for respectful intercultural relations and for partnership in processes of social change” (pp. 49–50).
The authors are undoubtedly right to try to counterbalance the prevalence of those analyses that stress the negative impact of Islamic cultural factors in Muslim-majority polities by noting the positive influence that some strands of the Islamic tradition can have in different social and political contexts. However, this effort at correcting a highly negative culturalist interpretation of the Middle East does not frontally address the issue of the relevance of “culture” (or religion) in causal processes. After having highlighted the negative consequences of the dominance of adversarial narratives of the region, the authors only sketch out this potential by identifying some important Islamic approaches to social and political peace formation in the Muslim-majority polities of the Middle East. These five key perspectives include the issue of legitimate violence (“peace through coercion”), of social justice (“peace through equity”), of peace mediation (“peace though conciliation”), of nonviolent activism (“peace through nonviolence”), and of global religious dialogue (“peace through universalism”).
In each case, the authors introduce some theoretical considerations, identify some historical antecedents, and analyze some contemporary political situations to illustrate how the Islamic tradition can frame an approach to peacemaking in different social fields. Unfortunately, the logic that underpins their selection is not always clear in the short space devoted to each thematic approach. For example, the suggestion in the “peace through universalism” chapter that an “overview of Sufism provides a basis for exploring universalistic understandings of the Islamic spiritual mandate” (p. 206) remains a theologically and politically debatable proposition. In the same ways, in the “peace through reconciliation” chapter it remains to be seen how far the mechanisms of Hudna (truce), examined briefly in the case of the Hamas–Israel confrontation, are indicative of specifically Islamic peace mechanisms in the region.
Those readers looking for an overview of the many configurations of the debates about war and peace, law and order, rights and justice, and so on, from Islamic perspectives will find in this work a useful introduction of these themes. By contrast, readers looking for specific information about how Islamic approaches to conflict resolution are concretely utilized by Islamic movements or institutions in the region are not likely to be satisfied with this introductory work. The recommendation section and the outline of an “agenda for Islamic–Western cooperation” that concludes the book contain proposals about initiating dialogue with relevant Islamic actors and about framing foreign policy in a culturally informed way that are sensible and sound but not particularly new. The authors are right to stress that “without a comprehensive vision of how Western–Islamic coexistence might be achieved, the power of existing strategic assumptions and cultural mythologies is likely to overwhelm piecemeal cooperative efforts” (p. 252). And yet such a vision needs to be theoretically constructed and empirically supported by more than what the book currently offers if it is to avoid ending up being just another cultural myth. What can be hoped is that this book is only the opening volume of a larger empirical work that the authors will initiate in the region, and that will provide the substantive answers that are alluded to in the present work.
Krista E. Wiegand's Bombs and Ballots tackles the sensitive issue of the political positioning of Hamas and Hezbollah in their national and international settings. Wiegand chooses not to fully engage the polarized debate on “terrorism” in order to concentrate on the tactical uses of political violence. Hence, she only proposes a working definition of terrorism as “unconventional political violence conducted by non-state actors targeting non-combatants for the purpose of achieving a political objective” (p. 9). Although some security studies specialists may be disappointed by such an approach, political scientists and area studies specialists will find themselves on familiar grounds with the analytical perspectives presented in this work. What remains problematic, however, is the author's relative lack of examination of the notion of Islamism when framing the issue of “Islamic terrorism.” A simple, generic notion of “violence” is used to distinguish between a political Islam that “uses non-violent means to reach [its] objective” and a radical Islam, which uses violent means. In their turn, Islamist political parties are identified using the common notions that they “view Islam as not just a religion but a political system” and that they “seek to expand the influence of Islam in a political system, as well as socially and economically” (p. 31).
By means of examples of militant groups that chose the path of electoral participation and those that chose to retain the use of political violence, Wiegand outlines the factors that have an impact on the strategic choices of these organizations. Employing a rational choice approach, she tries in particular to account for the emergence and survival of dual status groups, which she defines as “terrorist and guerrilla groups that have chosen to continue to use violence as deemed appropriate and also have made attempts to become political parties, not merely as political wings, but legally recognized political parties fully participating in their respective political systems as ruling or opposition parties” (p. 75). She suggests that in a context where authoritarian regimes and/or external forces are devising partial processes of democratization to retain control of a polity, this dual status can constitute a normal, logical outcome.
Wiegand's analysis of the dynamics of dual-status groups boils down to saying that these organizations pragmatically chose when to use violence and when to use politics. She does not analyze in detail whether some factors are systematically prioritized (or downplayed) by these dual-status actors. In effect, in the two sections dealing specifically with Hezbollah and with Hamas, the author emphasizes context-dependent issues when she explains the key strategic choices made by these movements at different historical junctures (the dynamics of the Israeli–Palestinian peace process in the case of Hamas, the pattern of Israeli interventions in South Lebanon and the opportunities provided by the Lebanese political system in the case of Hezbollah). Overall, the book provides a sensible introduction to the politics of Hamas and Hezbollah within a sound, albeit limited, analytical framework, but it lacks original fieldwork and sufficiently detailed information.
These books offer two very different perspectives for understanding violence and political Islam in the Middle East, each one representing a distinct approach in the literature on Muslim politics. While Wiegand proposes an empirically grounded political analysis of the strategic and tactical choices of Islamist organization in their specific political environment, Funk and Said outline a conceptual roadmap of the intellectual and organizational resources of the Islamic tradition that can be used by contemporary Islamic groups. These two approaches are complementary, and it can only be wished that they were more often used jointly in contemporary analyses of political violence in the region. Yet for all their good intentions, these two particular books fall somewhat short of expectations in their realization, mainly due to a lack of detail in the case of Wiegand and to a lack of concern for practical significance in the case of Funk and Said.
