The Educated Eye: Visual Culture and Pedagogy in the Life Sciences is a scholarly anthology of contributed essays written by participants at the 2006 Dartmouth College Humanities Institute on Visual Culture and Pedagogy organized by Nancy Anderson and Michael Dietrich. The collection consists of a total of twelve essays (two of which were previously published), together with an introduction by the editors that draws attention to what they regard as the absence of studies of visual technologies used in the biological sciences for the purpose of offering scientific knowledge and data or expressing scientific authority to a lay public. All but one of the essays include relevant illustrations or photographs. The contributors are all well-known scholars who represent a diverse set of contributing disciplines in the humanities. The essays focus narrowly on the ‘role of scientific images and media as pedagogical objects or tools within professional circles (disciplines) as well as wider public spheres covering the time period from the last few decades of the nineteenth century to the present’ (p. 3), which seems reasonable in light of the technological advances made during this period. (A single essay, at the end, discusses more recent uses of imagery in connection with use of computer simulations.)
The title is misleading in that almost all of the studies discuss the use of visual imagery in a medical, developmental or anatomical context, to the exclusion of any discussion of its use in botany, ecology and evolution. The individual essays are scholarly, insightful and well written, albeit limited to studies of the United States and Western Europe. The editors are to be commended for providing an introductory essay that valiantly attempts to draw out some common themes among these independently written works. This being said, the focus of the introductory essay is primarily on introducing the essays to be shared, rather than on providing a vision for further research in the field.
My one concern with this anthology has to do with the altogether curious way in which the term ‘pedagogy’ is being used by these scholars. On p. 4 we are told that the anthology draws from scholarship in ‘history and philosophy of science; science, technology and science studies; art history; film/media studies; visual studies and visual culture; and science communication … [which has focused on] image production, processing and consumption; the diverse use of images in science and medicine; medium specificity; and specific visualizing technologies and techniques’. While accurately representing the present volume, this underscores how very insular scholarship in the humanities is when it comes to studies of pedagogy. Research on the teaching and learning of science is wholly absent from their essays, as is any attempt to discuss the implications or indeed relevance of the findings of these authors for our understanding of how students learn. Indeed, only half of the essays even mention the fact that the images being discussed were used in formal or informal education settings, and even then never at length. The focus throughout is squarely on the (intended) advantages of the visual imagery/technology for explanatory purposes, as opposed to on discussion of whether or how said use of imagery promotes learning or how instructors’ uses of these technologies have historically changed over time. On the whole, it seems more accurate to describe these essays as discussing the use of visual imagery as rhetoric, rather than as pedagogy.
