I have long considered George Bristow (1825–98) nineteenth-century United States’ most unjustly forgotten musician. Anthony Philip Heinrich and William Henry Fry (author of the Santa Claus: Christmas Symphony in 1853) were eccentrics and good for the occasional anecdote, whereas Moreau Gottschalk carved out his own permanent half-vernacular/half-classical niche, and the European-trained John Knowles Paine and George Chadwick remain at least academically respectable. However Bristow, who for many years was a violinist in the fledgeling New York Philharmonic and absorbed European culture without visiting Europe, treated American subject matter in his symphonies, piano pieces, and opera, thus combining high Continental standards with topics of local appeal. In my view, he is the best we had at the time. His posthumous reputation, though, is neither amusing, exotic, nor academic, and the international respect he earned in his lifetime is now so faded away that I rarely find a musical scholar who has even heard his name.
All the more cause for joy, then, that Katherine K. Preston has written an exhaustively researched biography, George Frederick Bristow, for the University of Illinois Press's American Composers series. Professor emerita at the College of William and Mary and a prolific writer on U.S. musical history, she was the editor of the scholarly edition of Bristow's Second, “Jullien” Symphony (1853), making her closeness to the music especially appreciated with such an obscure composer. Apparently little remains of Bristow's interior life to make his personality vivid: Around 1867 he wrote a memoir, still unpublished, whimsically referring to himself (as “Apollo”) in third person. There are also a handful of late letters, along with some funereal accolades in which he is eulogized as “modest and unassuming to a fault,” and someone who despised “the usual methods of gaining fame and popularity” (153). Lacking abundant personal cues, Preston has thus filled her book with a bird's-eye picture of musical activity in mid-nineteenth-century New York City, so much so that the book would also be of interest even to those with no specific curiosity about its main subject. Along the way she demonstrates the innumerable segments of that musical life in which Bristow was actively and often centrally involved. Conductor, choir-master, educator of adults and children, organizer of performing societies, engager in musical polemics, as well as a composer of five symphonies and several grand works for chorus and orchestra, Bristow is positioned by Preston as the central figure of musical New York from the 1850s to at least the 1870s, making his presence so ubiquitous that we find him on every traceable path. How such a titan could vanish from our collective memory is a problem that music historians—and performers—ought to ponder.
The son of a violinist, Bristow was groomed to the family trade, and unhappily so at first, until one day when a theatrical production he performed in featured the duet “Suoni la tromba” from Vincenzo Bellini's I Puritani (1835), which was “so different from anything he had heard before” that he seemed to have decided on the spot to become a composer (4). As a violinist he also joined the newly formed New York Philharmonic in its first year (1842), though for the initial season he was only allowed to play in the rehearsals, not the concerts. He rose quickly, however, and had his big break as a composer when the celebrated French conductor Louis-Antoine Jullien (1812–60) arrived in 1853, took an interest in U.S. music, and commissioned and performed Bristow's Symphony No. 2 in D Minor, Op. 24 (1853) (thereafter subtitled with the conductor's name). Jullien also commissioned Fry's aforementioned Santa Claus Symphony, and Fry, who was 13 years Bristow's senior and working as a music critic, kindled in the younger man a militant advocacy for U.S.-born composers.
The best- (however little-) known event of Bristow's life was a subsequent rebellion against the Philharmonic for its neglect of U.S. composers, and Preston gives the clearest timeline for these events that I have seen. The orchestra's ranks had been swelled by German emigrés, and though its original mission statement included the encouragement of U.S. composers, that aim had quickly fallen by the wayside. Tensions between the Germans (including the Philharmonic's new foreign conductor) and U.S. composers ran high. Following a dismissive review of his symphony, Fry entered into a public war of letters into which his more reticent young friend was irresistibly drawn. Preston recounts that, in defending Fry, Bristow wrote that “in the eleven years of the orchestra's existence it had performed [only] ‘one whole American overture and one whole rehearsal of one whole American symphony’”—both of which happened to be works by Bristow himself (35). In March of 1854 Bristow left the orchestra in high dudgeon and took what was essentially “an unpaid leave of absence” until, with his reputation still ascendant, he rejoined it in November of the following year (56). It was a bold and public blow struck on behalf of music in the United States, and never again did the Philharmonic hold central place in Bristow's preoccupations.
He made good use of his time off, completing and performing his opera Rip van Winkle (1855), hallowed in the history books, if nowhere else, as the first opera written in the United States on an indigenous subject. He played a role in the formation of several new orchestras and choral societies, but for the rest of his life found more reliable economic security in teaching, for the sake of which he sometimes passed up performance opportunities. The most scandalous and painful episode of his life was his 1863 divorce from his insatiably unfaithful first wife—the more salacious details of which Preston quietly omits.Footnote 1 Notably, Bristow's second marriage led him to a happier family life.
Preston does not draw as sharply as Douglas W. Shadle does in his 2016 book on the Catch-22 situation that nineteenth-century American composers suffered under: If they imitated European models they were dismissed as epigones and if they did not they were thought incompetent.Footnote 2 However, she provides plenty of corroborating evidence that Bristow experienced this by citing the whiplash-inducing alternations of adulatory and condescending reviews his works received. His reputation as the country's best native conductor, however, seems to have remained constant. Preston provides further insight about how the advent of Wagnerism casts a shadow of conservatism over Bristow's later years, demonstrating that by his last decade he was falling out of favor, while the New England composers—Chadwick, Paine, Amy Beach, Arthur William Foote—upstaged him.Footnote 3 The 1898 premiere, and to this day the sole performance, of his grand choral Niagara Symphony, Op. 62, his Fifth, was Bristow's last hurrah. A few months later he dropped dead in the classroom.
That the University of Illinois Press's admirable American Composer series (for which I wrote the volume on Robert Ashley) does not include musical examples is more than usually regrettable here because so little of Bristow's music is publicly available.Footnote 4 The archive of his manuscripts housed in the New York Public Library is rather a nightmare to wade through: His handwriting is sometimes baffling and the jumble of manuscripts depresses the researcher with the considerable work it would take to get a fuller picture of him as a composer. All the more gratitude, then, is due Preston for being able to at least characterize so many pieces in detail, and the book is complemented in this respect by Shadle's aforementioned book, which does include musical excerpts. With Preston providing the fuller context for Shadle's and Victor Fell Yellin's anecdotes, we probably now have as full of an understanding of Bristow as possible until the music itself enjoys a wider exposure. This book thus fills a crucial gap in our picture of the development of American music, and fills it well.Footnote 5
