Sana Haroon's Frontier of Faith is an ambitious study of the Pashtun (Pakhtun) tribal region that once separated British India from Afghanistan and now straddles the border between present-day Pakistan and Afghanistan. Haroon refers to the region as the Tribal Areas, “a hinterland of successive, contradictory jihad in support of Pashtun ethnicism, anti-colonial nationalism, Pakistani territorialism, religious revivalism, and anti-American imperialism” (p. 3).
The British secured jurisdiction over the region, which includes the Khyber Pass, in 1879 in a treaty during the second Anglo–Afghan war that was signed by Muhammad Yaʿqub Khan, ruler of Afghanistan. Even though the British succeeded in obtaining control over a strategic overland passage to India, they were never able to fully suppress intense tribal resistance to their rule. In 1893, they convinced Amir ʿAbd al-Rahman, successor to Muhammad Yaʿqub Khan, to agree to the delineation of a boundary between Afghanistan and British India. The boundary was named the Durand Line after the British negotiator, Sir Mortimer Durand. In 1901, Lord Curzon, the viceroy of India, created the North West Frontier Province, a separate administrative unit that included the four border tribal agencies of Khyber, Khurram, North Waziristan, and South Waziristan. The Durand Line ran through the Pashtun tribal territory, dividing the tribes of the same lineage between Afghanistan and British India. Haroon explains in Frontier of Faith how imposition of the British imperial frontier “circumscribed the area in a manner that deeply influenced its religious, political, and military organization over the century to come” (p. 31).
Frontier of Faith contains a short introduction, six chapters, and an epilogue. It is supplemented with maps and figures, a glossary, bibliography, and index. The study is based on British and Pakistani archival materials, periodicals, secondary works (including works in Pashtu and Urdu), and personal interviews. The central question of the book is how Islamic religious leaders have for decades maintained the essential autonomy of the Tribal Areas.
In the first chapter, Haroon provides an impressive analysis of the ethnography, topography, and early history of the Tribal Areas. She also explains the genesis of British colonial interest in the region and recounts the discourse regarding its administration. In the following two chapters, she examines the impact of the Muslim revivalist movement in the Tribal Areas and the emergence of Swat in Waziristan as an important religious and political center under the leadership of Mullah ʿAbd al-Ghafur, better known as the Akhundzada of Swat. After being granted land in Swat by the ruler of Afghanistan in the mid-19th century, ʿAbd al-Ghafur consolidated power as the most important religious leader in the Tribal Areas by affiliating with the Qadiriyya and Naqshbandiyya Sufi orders and by building personal relationships with leaders of the Deoband religious school in India. Under the leadership of the Akhundzada of Swat, the Tribal Areas emerged collectively as an autonomous Sufi stronghold, where religious zeal and anticolonialism comingled. Haroon explains the structure of religious leadership among the Pashtuns and analyzes the pīr-disciple (pīrī-murīdī) system established by the Akhudzada of Swat and his eminent pupil and deputy, Mullah Najm al-Din of Hadda. The close fraternal ties among disciples of the Akhundzada of Swat and the Mullah of Hadda united the Pashtun tribal communities on both sides of the Durand Line and reinforced their common cultural, ethnic, and religious identity.
In Chapter 4, Haroon explains the historical ties between the religious leaders of the Tribal Areas and the Afghan royal court. This chapter also deals with the role of the disciples of the Akhundzada of Swat and the Mullah of Hadda during and after World War I, when the Tribal Areas served as a staging ground for anti-British provocations, including forays by King Amanullah of Afghanistan in his fight against the British.
In the final two chapters, Haroon explains the consolidation of autonomy in the Tribal Areas, the formation in the 1930s of the Pashtun nationalist party under the leadership of Khan ʿAbd al-Ghaffar Khan, and the rise of a concurrent anti-British insurgency led by the Faqir of Ipi, another influential religious leader of Waziristan. Haroon also examines the impact of the partition of India in 1947 on the Tribal Areas and the British rejection of the Pashtun demand for an independent Pashtunistan. The frontier tribes were given only two choices in a referendum, to join India or become a part of Pakistan. The Islamic inhabitants chose to join Islamic Pakistan, so the administered and nonadministered districts and agencies of the North West Frontier Province were transferred to Pakistan.
The last part of the final chapter is devoted to the Pashtun nationalist movements launched by ʿAbd al-Ghaffar Khan and the Faqir of Ipi. Both movements were fully supported by the Afghan government. Haroon recounts the tension that arose in the 1950s between Pakistan and Afghanistan over the issue of an independent Pashtunistan and the legality of the Durand Line, which remains a contentious issue between Afghanistan and Pakistan to this day. After years of resistance to outside control, the Tribal Areas remain “the land of an independent Islam uncompromised by modernity, westernization, and urbanization” (p. 195).
The epilogue covers the years from the rise of the Marxist regime in Afghanistan and of Zia al-Haqq in Pakistan through the era of the Taliban to the present. Haroon skillfully ties the resistance of the Tribal Areas to the British and Pakistan governments in the 19th and 20th centuries to the role of the region as a refuge for the mujahidin during the Soviet–Afghan War and more recently as a refuge for anti-Western, anti-American radical Islamists.
For all its value, Frontier of Faith has certain flaws. Haroon's broader historical discussion of the first three decades of the 20th century in Chapter 4 is somewhat problematic. She has overlooked pertinent archival materials and published historical works or has failed to review them carefully. As a result, the account she provides in this chapter is sketchy. Certain important events are not cited or are not sufficiently addressed. For example, the activities of Turkish and German political activists in the Tribal Areas during World War I are left out and the anti-British agitation led by Mullah ʿAbd-al-Razzaq in Waziristan is not adequately addressed. Haroon refers to Razzaq's close connection to the Deoband religious school in India but does not mention the important role he played as a liaison between the Afghan royal court and influential religious leaders in the Tribal Area before and during the Great War.
Inaccurate identification of Afghan historical figures reveals gaps in the author's knowledge of Afghan history. For example, Haroon refers to ʿInayatullah Khan, King Amanullah's brother, as his uncle and elsewhere refers to ʿAbd al-Qayyum as Amir Habibullah's uncle. Amir Habibullah did not have an uncle by that name (Haroon may have meant Ishikaqasi ʿAbd al-Quddus Khan, Habibullah's prime minister). She also repeats the mistake made by the British in referring to Mullah ʿAbd al-Razzaq as ʿAbd al-Raziq. Persian and Pashtu sources, including the biography in Pashtu that she cites, refer to him as Razzaq.
Haroon also makes an occasional inaccurate assertion, stating, for example, “In 1973 Zahir Shah's constitutional monarchy was overthrown and a national parliament was established. The parliament was dominated by the more moderate faction of the communist PDPA party with Mohammad Daoud, the amir's cousin at its head as prime minister” (p. 197). The Afghan parliament was actually dissolved after the fall of the constitutional monarchy. In 1973, Muhammad Daoud, King Zahir Shah's cousin, established a republican government with himself as head of state, not as prime minister. Moreover, the title of amir was officially abolished in 1926. Henceforth, Afghan rulers used the designation “shah,” as had the Sadduzai kings of Afghanistan (1747–1841). The reference to Afghanistan as an “emirate” and to Afghan rulers of the modern era as “amirs,” the misstatement of historical facts, and the misidentification of historical figures reveal some research lapses. Neither has the publisher served Haroon well in overlooking inconsistencies in the spelling of names, in failing to include page numbers in certain footnotes, in failing to define some terms, and in failing to follow a consistent method of transliteration.
Despite errors such as these, Frontier of Faith is an important work. It is a well-organized, well-written, and timely study of a pivotal region that continues to play an important role in international politics.
