Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T08:30:49.306Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Comparison of smooth- and rough-wall non-equilibrium boundary layers with favourable and adverse pressure gradients

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 March 2023

Ralph J. Volino*
Affiliation:
Mechanical Engineering Department, United States Naval Academy, Annapolis, MD 21401, USA
Michael P. Schultz
Affiliation:
Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering Department, United States Naval Academy, Annapolis, MD 21402, USA
*
† Email address for correspondence: volino@usna.edu

Abstract

Measurements were made in rough-wall boundary layers subject to favourable, zero and adverse pressure gradients. Profiles of mean velocity and turbulence quantities were acquired and velocity fields were measured in multiple planes to document flow structure. Comparisons were made to equivalent smooth-wall cases with the same free stream velocity distributions. Outer layer similarity was observed between the rough- and smooth-wall cases in all quantities in the favourable and zero pressure gradient regions, but large differences were observed with adverse pressure gradients. In both the smooth- and rough-wall cases, the favourable pressure gradient reduced the turbulence in the boundary layer, and increased the size of turbulence structures relative to the boundary layer thickness in both the streamwise and spanwise directions, while lowering their inclination angle with respect to the wall. When the boundary layer was returned to a zero pressure gradient following the favourable pressure gradient region, the turbulence level and the size and inclination of the structures returned to their canonical zero pressure gradient condition. The response of the boundary layer was somewhat faster in the rough-wall case, causing it to reach equilibrium in a shorter streamwise distance after the changes in pressure gradient than in the smooth-wall case. The adverse pressure gradient increased turbulence levels relative to the wall friction velocity, reduced the size of turbulence structures relative to the boundary layer thickness and increased their inclination angle. The changes with the adverse pressure gradient were significantly larger with the rough wall than the smooth. The results suggest that similarity might be achieved with adverse pressure gradients if smooth- and rough-wall cases with the same Clauser pressure gradient parameter history are compared.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Creative Commons
This is a work of the US Government and is not subject to copyright protection within the United States.
Copyright
© United States Naval Academy, 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Cross-section of test section in streamwise-wall normal plane. Three positions of upper wall shown: blue = ramp 1; red = ramp 2; green = ramp 3. Numbers in test section indicate streamwise measurement stations.

Figure 1

Table 1.Rough surface statistics.

Figure 2

Table 2.Experimental conditions.

Figure 3

Table 3.Measurement station streamwise locations.

Figure 4

Figure 2.Data from moderate ramp cases showing Reynolds number independence: (a) mean velocity profiles at stations (St.) 1, 6, 9 and 12 at end of initial ZPG, FPG, ZPG recovery and APG regions; (b) Reynolds shear stress profiles; (c) boundary layer thicknesses. Open symbols from the U∞,o = 0.5 m s−1 case, solid symbols from the U∞,o = 2 m s−1 case. Lines show values for corresponding smooth-wall cases with colours corresponding to quantities in the legend, solid lines for the U∞,o = 0.5 m s−1 case, dashed lines for U∞,o = 2 m s−1 case.

Figure 5

Figure 3.Mean streamwise velocity profiles in defect coordinates for case 2, ramp 1: (a) St. 1–6; (b) St. 6–9; (c) St. 9–12. Symbols for rough-wall case, lines for smooth-wall case of Volino (2020). Symbol and line colour match at each station.

Figure 6

Figure 4.Mean streamwise velocity profiles in defect coordinates for case 4, ramp 2: (a) St. 1–6; (b) St. 6–9; (c) St. 9–12. Symbols for rough-wall case; solid lines for smooth-wall ramp 2 case; dashed lines for smooth-wall ramp 1 case. Symbol and line colour match at each station.

Figure 7

Figure 5.Mean streamwise velocity profiles in defect coordinates for case 7, ramp 3: (a) St. 1–6; (b) St. 6–9; (c) St. 9–12. Symbols for rough-wall case; solid lines for smooth-wall ramp 3 case; dashed lines for smooth-wall ramp 2 case. Symbol and line colour match at each station.

Figure 8

Figure 6.Difference in $A = {(({U_\infty } - U)/{U_\infty })_{ZPG}} - (({U_\infty } - U)/{U_\infty })$ between ZPG and non-ZPG mean velocity defect profiles at y/δ = 0.4. (a) FPG St. 1–6, (b) ZPG St. 6–9, (c) APG St. 9–12, (d) all stations as a function of β, (e) all stations as a function of G. Symbols for rough-wall cases as in table 2, symbols for smooth-wall cases match shapes and filling of table 2 with cyan, magenta and black for U∞,o = 0.5 m s−1, U∞,o = 1 m s−1 and U∞,o = 2 m s−1, respectively.

Figure 9

Figure 7.Friction Reynolds number as function of momentum thickness Reynolds number for rough-wall cases, (a) uncorrected results, (b) correction using Clauser pressure gradient parameter applied. Symbols as in figure 6 for non-ZPG cases, black filled stars are for ZPG cases of Volino & Schultz (2022). Solid black line is fit to ZPG results from Volino & Schultz (2022).

Figure 10

Figure 8.Skin friction coefficient as a function of momentum thickness over roughness length: (a) uncorrected results; (b) corrected using Clauser pressure gradient parameter. Symbols for non-ZPG cases as in figure 6. Black filled stars are for ZPG cases. Solid black line is ZPG correlation from Castro (2007).

Figure 11

Figure 9.Shape factor, H, as a function of momentum thickness divided by roughness length, as done by Castro (2007): (a) uncorrected results; (b) corrected using Clauser pressure gradient parameter. Symbols as in figure 8.

Figure 12

Figure 10.Clauser shape factor as a function of Clauser pressure gradient parameter, (b) and (c) expanded views of panel (a). Symbols as in figure 6. Solid line is equilibrium condition from Mellor & Gibson (1966).

Figure 13

Figure 11.Equivalent sandgrain roughness height: (a) roughness function as function of $k_s^ +$ with ks = 2.3 mm assumed; (b) locally determined ks as function of δ with both normalized on estimated ksh at high δ/ks. Solid line is (1.2), dashed lines are displaced from solid line to correspond to ks = 3.5 mm (upper) and 1.2 mm (lower). Symbols as in figure 8.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Reynolds stress profiles for case 2, ramp 1: (a) $\overline {{{u^{\prime}}^2}} $, St. 1–6; (b) $\overline {{{u^{\prime}}^2}} $, St. 6–9; (c) $\overline {{{u^{\prime}}^2}} $, St. 9–12; (d) $- \overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} $, St. 1–6; (e) $- \overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} $, St. 6–9; (f) $- \overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} $, St. 9–12. Symbols as in figure 3.

Figure 15

Figure 13.Reynolds stress profiles for case 4, ramp 2: (a) $\overline {{{u^{\prime}}^2}} $, St. 1–6; (b) $\overline {{{u^{\prime}}^2}} $, St. 6–9; (c) $\overline {{{u^{\prime}}^2}} $, St. 9–12; (d) $- \overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} $, St. 1–6; (e) $- \overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} $, St. 6–9; (f) $- \overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} $, St. 9–12. Symbols as in figure 4.

Figure 16

Figure 14.Difference in $A = \; - \overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} /u_\tau ^2$ between ZPG and non-ZPG Reynolds shear stress profiles at y/δ = 0.4: (a) FPG St. 1–6; (b) ZPG St. 6–9; (c) APG St. 9–12; (d) all stations as function of β; (e) all stations as function of G. Symbols as in figure 6.

Figure 17

Figure 15.Profiles of the ratio of contributions to $\overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} $ from Q2 and Q4: (a) case 2, St. 1–6; (b) case 2, St. 6–9; (c) case 2, St. 9–12; (d) case 4, St. 1–6; (e) case 4, St. 6–9; (f) case 4, St. 9–12. Symbols from table 2. Solid lines for corresponding smooth-wall cases with line colour matching symbol colour at each station. Dashed line for rough-wall ZPG comparison case.

Figure 18

Figure 16.Profiles of $\overline {{{u^{\prime}}^2}v^{\prime}} $: (a) case 2, St. 1–6; (b) case 2, St. 6–9; (c) case 2, St. 9–12; (d) case 4, St. 1–6; (e) case 4, St. 6–9; (f) case 4, St. 9–12. Symbols and lines for panels (a–c) as in figure 3 and for panels (d–f) as in figure 4.

Figure 19

Figure 17.Profiles of $- 2\overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} \partial U/\partial y$ (production term for $\overline {{{u^{\prime}}^2}} $): (a) case 2, St. 1–6; (b) case 2, St. 6–9; (c) case 2, St. 9–12; (d) case 4, St. 1–6; (e) case 4, St. 6–9; (f) case 4, St. 9–12. Symbols and lines for panels (a–c) as in figure 3 and for panels (d–f) as in figure 4.

Figure 20

Figure 18.Contours of Ruu centred at y/δ = 0.4 for 12 stations of case 2, outermost contour Ruu = 0.1, contour spacing 0.1.

Figure 21

Figure 19.Streamwise slices through self-correlation point of Ruu of case 2 centred at (a–c) yref/δ = 0.15 and (d–f) yref/δ = 0.4: (a,d) St. 1–6; (b,e) St. 6–9; (c,f) St. 9–12. Symbols from table 2, lines for smooth-wall case with line colour matching symbol colour at each station.

Figure 22

Figure 20.Average inclination angle of Ruu contours as a function of dimensionless streamwise location: (a) St. 1–6; (b) St. 6–9; (c) St. 9–12. Symbols as in figure 6.

Figure 23

Figure 21.Average inclination angle of Ruu contours: (a) as a function of β; (b) as a function of Clauser shape factor, G. Symbols as in figure 6.

Figure 24

Figure 22.Average streamwise extent of Ruu = 0.5 contour as a function of dimensionless streamwise location: (a) St. 1–6; (b) St. 6–9; (c) St. 9–12. Symbols as in figure 8.

Figure 25

Figure 23.Contours of correlations for case 2: (a) Rvv, innermost contour Rvv = 0.8, contour spacing 0.2; (b) Ruv, innermost contour Rvv = −0.45, contour spacing 0.1; (c) Rλu, outermost contours Rλu = ±0.015, contour spacing 0.04; (d) Rλv, outermost contours Rλv = ±0.01, contour spacing 0.04.

Figure 26

Figure 24.Average inclination angle of Ruv contours as a function of Clauser shape factor, G. Symbols as in figure 6.

Figure 27

Figure 25.LSE conditioned on clockwise swirl events at y/δ = 0.4 for St. 9 of case 2.

Figure 28

Figure 26.Spacing between vortices identified using LSE in x–z plane (as in figure 25) as a function of G: (a) at y/δ = 0.15; (b) at y/δ = 0.4. Symbols as in figure 8.

Figure 29

Figure 27.Contours of correlations for case 2 at y/δ = 0.4: (a) Ruu, innermost contour Ruu = 0.9, contour spacing 0.1; (b) Rww, same contour levels as for Ruu; (c) Rλu, contour level 0 at centre of correlation, contour spacing 0.04, red positive, blue negative; (d) Rλw, same contours as for Ruw.

Figure 30

Figure 28.Spanwise slices through self-correlation point of Ruu of case 2: (a) centred at y/δ = 0.15, St. 1–6; (b) y/δ = 0.15, St. 6–9; (c) y/δ = 0.15, St. 9–12; (d) y/δ = 0.4, St. 1–6; (e) y/δ = 0.4, St. 6–9; (f) y/δ = 0.4, St. 9–12. Symbols and lines as in figure 19.

Figure 31

Figure 29.Contours of Ruw correlation for case 2: (a) y/δ = 0.15; (b) y/δ = 0.4. Contour level is 0 at the centre of correlation, contour spacing 0.04, red positive, blue negative.