Thousands of choral octavos are published in the United States every year, almost all of which are gebrauchsmusik. There is choral music for children; for “swing choirs”; for churches—especially for the Evangelical mega-churches springing up like kudzu—for synagogues; and yet even more arrangements of Judy Garland's greatest hits for gay men's choruses. Although a surprising amount of this choral music is serviceable and competently crafted, most of these octavos are doomed to a quicker obsolescence than laptop computers. Pity the poor choral conductors who try to make sense of this profusion of new material and attempt to find repertory that is suitable for their ensembles.
From the vast amount of choral flotsam and jetsam published annually, certain scores by a handful of fortunate composers rise to the surface and, miraculously, stay afloat, buoyed forward on a sea of consensus among conductors. Many of the commercially successful American scores are written by composers unknown outside of the insular world of the American Choral Directors Association. To those musicians and listeners not involved with choral music, the names of Clausen, Harris, Walker, and Spencer ring no bells of recognition. And, indeed, within the US musical academy, to be typecast as a “choral composer” is rarely considered a ringing endorsement, suggesting, as it does, a narrowness of focus as well as technique. (Those who deprecate composers who specialize in choral music might well recall that before the seventeenth century practically all composers—including, say, Dufay, Victoria, Tallis, and Palestrina—were of necessity “choral composers.”) Such denigrating imputations arise in part from modernist attitudes—still current within many university music departments—that exalt the abstract instrumental work over scores that use literature as a point of departure. And it is true that composers who concentrate on choral music tend, oddly, to compose few instrumental pieces.
Some important composers who have created a substantial body of choral music have transcended such prejudices, however. One would hardly classify Conrad Susa, one of America's most distinguished opera composers, as a “choral composer.” David Conte, a student of Nadia Boulanger, has written in a variety of genres, such as chamber music, instrumental music, and opera; choral music is only one important facet of the variegated catalogue of this prolific composer. Libby Larsen is another composer who works in a variety of genres, including symphonic music and opera. Morten Lauridsen—surely the most successful American composer of choral music since Randall Thompson—began to compose music for choruses only after serving a protracted apprenticeship writing lapidary songs and instrumental music.
Eric Whitacre has sought to join the ranks of these distinguished creators, and has established, through untiring industry, a thriving career at a relatively young age. Just as Susa, Conte, Larsen, and Lauridsen have evinced catholicity in their selection of genres, so Whitacre has written for concert band, as well as experimented with computer-generated sonorities. For all of his hard work thus far, however, Whitacre has not yet fully integrated his predilections into an identifiable musical voice.
This lack of a fully developed stylistic profile is evident in a compact disc devoted to Whitacre's choral music, released on the estimable Hyperion label. The performances, by Stephen Layton conducting his superb ensemble, Polyphony, evince enormous vocal control and sonic beauty. If anything, both the excellence of these interpretations and the translucence of the recorded sound bring a laser-like clarity to bear upon some of the persistent idiosyncracies of Whitacre's music, such as a predilection for slow tempos allied to a pervasive luxuriance of texture.
Whitacre's choral works are often beautiful, with a beauty that is gratifying for massed singers in the same way that pieces such as Cyril Scott's Lotus Land or Christian Sinding's Frühlingsrauschen (known to past generations in Anglophone countries as “The Rustle of Spring”) are gratifying for pianists: presenting moderately challenging music that makes the performer sound “advanced” and engages the audience. Whitacre's music is often colorful, discreetly using lively touches of choral timbre, as, for example, Water Night, a justly popular setting of a poem by Octavio Paz. His music employs a wide and imaginative range of texts, often setting poetry, such as that of e. e. cummings, that allows for the expression of earnest sentiment.
Based on a great deal of the music featured on the Hyperion disc, it seems that Whitacre has not yet assimilated fully a somewhat narrow range of influences. Chief among these influences is the music of Morten Lauridsen, aspects of whose style, including harmonic and melodic formulae, Whitacre has expropriated with evident enthusiasm. There is a crucial divergence of intent between the two composers, however. As with Renaissance polyphony, Lauridsen's harmonic idiom is produced by the sophisticated interplay of contrapuntal lines. Whitacre eschews counterpoint—surely the basis of most choral music—and instead demonstrates an insistent preference for the prismatic timbres of an enriched choral homophony. He prefers sumptuous, occasionally thick harmonic aggregates: triads encrusted with added notes that move in and out of clusters. Although his sonorous vocabulary clearly derives from that of Lauridsen, Whitacre at times uses these (literally) “borrowed” chords in a less than fully effective manner because his music lacks the technical assurance, born of a hard-won contrapuntal mastery, that lies at the heart of Lauridsen's rapt compositions.
Happily, Whitacre is still in the early stage in his career and clearly possesses the determination to achieve the best and highest. When he is truly seized by a text, his music is illuminated by flashes of inspiration, as in the finest piece on this compact disc, When David Heard, a harrowing setting of the famous and oft-set passage of the elderly King David mourning the death of his rebellious son, Absalom (2 Samuel: 18:33). An early rise to success hardly impeded Benjamin Britten, a composer who was invariably seized utterly by a text, from developing a distinctive voice. His entire career was based on a stunning technique acquired through unremitting hard work and an incessant, self-critical quest for perfection. One can only hope that Whitacre will take Britten's example to heart by constantly expanding and honing his musical vocabulary. Only the clarity provided by a constantly refined and expanded technique can reveal profundity.
