Recent years have seen a considerable change of approach in scholarship on Diodorus’ Bibliotheke (I. Sulimani, Diodorus’ Mythistory and the Pagan Mission (2011); M. Rathmann, Diodor und seine »Bibliotheke« (2016); L. I. Hau, A. Meeus and B. Sheridan (eds), Diodoros of Sicily (2018)). While previous scholars considered Diodorus a mechanical copyist or careless compiler of earlier historical works, recent studies, including Charles Muntz's new monograph, emphasise Diodorus’ own background, purposes, methods and novel contributions.
M. focuses on Bibliotheke Books 1–3, concerned with ‘barbarian’ cultures: Egyptians (Book 1); Assyrians, Babylonians, Indians, Ethiopians, Libyans and others (Books 2 and 3). As M. convincingly argues, Books 1–3 are not only a thematic unit, but also a structural entity within the Bibliotheke, in which a ‘barbarian’ worldview is closely intertwined with the intellectual mind-set of the late Roman Republic.
Ch. 1 provides insights into Quellenforschung and discusses carefully the sources of Books 1–3 (Muntz, CQ 61 (2011), 574–94; CP 107 (2012), 21–37). Diodorus need not necessarily follow one main source, but may be combining and rephrasing several different sources at once. Moreover, selecting and summarising source material is a creative occupation that mirrors Diodorus’ own interests and worldview. It is especially in the arrangement of material and highlighting of specific content that M. seeks to demonstrate Diodorus’ originality.
Ch. 2 analyses arrangement tools and schemes that Diodorus uses in Books 1–3 to combine heterogeneous subject matter. First, the books are furnished with framing and linking devices, e.g. summaries (2.1.1–2, 3.1.1–2, 4.1.5) and cross-references. Since Books 2 and 3 do not contain thematic proems, M. argues that Diodorus organised Books 1–6 not as one hexadic unit (C. Rubincam, CQ 48 (1998), 229–33), but as two triads. Second, although there were several established geographical and political models that Diodorus could have used to organise the first triad, he does not make use of them. The arrangement chosen by Diodorus, with Egypt at its centre, is unique.
Ch. 3 discusses Diodorus’ concept of the origins of civilisation (1.8) which explains human development as being driven by forces such as expediency, fear, speech, experience and, particularly, necessity (chreia) (see W. Spoerri, Späthellenistische Berichte über Welt, Kultur und Götter (1959)). Rather than exploring the origin of this line of thought, M. examines its function within the ‘barbarian’ Books 1–3 and beyond in the Bibliotheke (similarly K. Sacks, Diodorus Siculus and the First Century (1990), 55–60). Even if Diodorus shares this concept with many other authors, it reflects his own understanding of human progress and serves as an explanatory paradigm for the development of different cultures and empires, including Rome.
In ch. 4, M. highlights two main factors that could support Diodorus’ unique decision to include mythology as a separate section of his work. Spatium mythologicum is as good as spatium historicum for making moral points, the main aim of Diodorus’ Bibliotheke. Moreover, mythology delivers several examples of divine benefactors and heroic ‘culture bringers’ (a term coined by M.). By taking a euhemeristic approach, Diodorus builds a bridge between mythological and historical protagonists.
Culture bringers and their immortality are a key concept in Books 1–3 and beyond. As M. shows in detail in ch. 5, the actions of culture bringers are closely connected with the origins of civilisation: benefactors such as Osiris or Dionysus address human needs and push forward cultural development. However, as M. points out, although there are dozens of culture bringers who receive immortality for their merits, only some achieve divine honours. Why? As M. demonstrates, the path to deification in Diodorus is strenuous: travelling to the boundaries of the world, spreading civilisation and performing benefactions for the whole of mankind, undertaking vast building projects and, less importantly, military conquests. Noticeably, only one historical protagonist in the Bibliotheke (partly) fulfils these requirements, and is called by Diodorus explicitly a god: Julius Caesar. As M. points out, through the concept of the culture bringers Diodorus joins contemporary discussions on deification, including that of Caesar.
However, as M. demonstrates in ch. 6, ‘barbarian’ narratives can be used in other ways to address contemporary disputes. Pre-Ptolemaic Egypt is, for Diodorus, an exemplary constitutional monarchy: ruled by good kings, stable, long-lasting and able to resist the temptation of luxury by the implementation of good laws and customs. By contrast, the Assyrian kingdom is a conquering power, torn by inner conflicts due to extravagance, wealth and lavish kings, and meets a disastrous end. M. plausibly suggests that Diodorus implicitly engages through these two opposite monarchic models with contemporary discussions about kingship in Rome. However, less convincing is the parallel M. draws between ancient Egypt and Rome before the fall of Carthage, and between Assyria and the late Roman Republic. Ptolemaic Egypt as an antithesis of Ancient Egypt presents perhaps a better parallel as a decadent power corrupted by luxury (33.6 and 6a, 12, 22; 34/35.14). More likely is M.’s claim that Diodorus was a supporter of monarchic government. Diodorus’ picture of ancient Egypt is favourable and, as M. underlines, all culture bringers display royal features.
In ch. 7, M. attempts to reconstruct the writing and publishing of the Bibliotheke. M. suggests that Books 1–3 were completed between 46 and 42 b.c.; the Bibliotheke as a whole, though, was never completed and fully revised. This was, as M. suggests, due to the turbulent times of civil war and to several inconvenient topics of the Bibliotheke, especially in the first triad. To depict Egypt as an ideal monarchy and Dionysus as an esteemed culture bringer could be dangerous in the context of Octavian's war against Mark Antony, who displayed himself as a new Dionysus and was supported by Egyptian power. Similarly, for political reasons Diodorus may have decided to exclude the whole career of Julius Caesar, and shifted the end of his work from 46 to 60 b.c. This change, M. argues, caused several incongruities in Diodorus’ work in terms of chronology and arrangement of material. The arguments presented here are generally sound. However, I am not completely convinced that Diodorus’ allusion to the Egyptian calendar (1.50.2) must be connected with Caesar's calendar reform in 47–46 b.c. and dated accordingly (9–10).
M. provides a fresh and stimulating approach to Diodorus Books 1–3. He demonstrates in a cautious and well-founded manner that Diodorus is not only a ‘window’ into lost works of earlier historians, but has his own creative methods and agenda.
