Annette Idler's Borderland Battles mounts a compelling challenge to the traditional assumptions regarding the relationship between the state, unconventional violent non-state actors and local Andean borderland communities that underpins peace and security policy in Latin America. By examining the micro-dynamics of conflict and co-operation between violent non-state actor groups operating across the margins of three states – Colombia, Venezuela and Ecuador – through a ‘borderland lens’, Idler demonstrates the conditions under which transnational violent non-state orders establish violent, unstable or legitimate local security regimes in the absence of the state. The placement of non-state borderland governance, rather than the state, at the centre of the analysis demonstrates the pervasiveness of insecurity in borderland regions. It also highlights the inadequacy of state-centric peace and security frameworks in the face of everyday non-state violence that does not necessarily entail a direct military challenge to state sovereignty. This review highlights three major contributions of the book: the ‘borderland lens’, a typology of relationships between violent non-state actor groups and their impact on citizen security, and implications for peace and security policy and scholarship.
The ‘borderland lens’: Idler positions her work in opposition to the dominant narratives of peace and conflict in Latin America, which recognises states of citizen insecurity in the borderlands only if they pose a large-scale threat to state sovereignty. The Colombian peace agreement between the state and the FARC (Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia) guerrilla group is highlighted as an example of the analytical myopia of state-centric frames of analysis. The ‘territorial peace’ pursued under the agreement assumed that the demobilisation and transformation of the FARC into a democratic political party would allow the Colombian state to reassert its sovereignty across the FARC-held Andean borderlands through participatory security and development programmes. Idler's work paints a far more complex, ordered and violent picture of ‘post-conflict’ local governance in the borderlands, which is obscured by the bilateral structure of state-level peace negotiations, artificial war–peace binaries, and urban myths about a passive, ungoverned periphery.
In the wake of the Colombian peace agreement, the cocaine business and related forms of organised crime thrive in the Andean borderlands, where they elude the gaze of the three nation states. Conflict and criminal actors continue to operate in these regions, including the left-wing Colombian ELN (National Liberation Army), FARC dissidents, new successor groups of the demobilised FARC, post-demobilised right-wing groups, and criminal groups ranging from youth gangs to the powerful Mexican Sinaloa cartel and the Zetas. Idler argues that a ‘borderland lens’ – which centres the experiences and perspectives of local borderland communities as active security-seeking agents – is required to inform policy that responds to the complex security environment of the Andean borderlands. Idler's borderland perspective shows that, under certain conditions, violent non-state actor groups co-operate to provide legitimate local governance in the absence of the state, allowing them to impose alternative rules of behaviour on locals in return for security, healthcare, infrastructure and employment. At the same time, the myriad violent non-state actors in the borderlands may engage in competition for territory or resources, forcing civilians to live in constant states of insecurity. Local communities actively negotiate their place within governance regimes, attempting to prosper and ensure their survival. Sovereign states are located at the periphery of what Idler calls the non-state order, which connects the transnational ‘global’ informal political economy of organised crime with ‘local’ citizen security at the intersection of the three nation states. It follows that a state-centric lens of analysis will fail to see the different kinds of governance arrangements already in place in the borderlands and how they affect the lives of civilians.
Violent non-state actors and their impact on citizen security: Idler demonstrates the utility of the borderland lens by drawing on the voices and experiences of local villagers to develop a typology of violent non-state interactions that emphasises the impact of each non-state governance arrangement on citizen security. The typology places violent non-state actor group interactions into three main clusters. In the enmity cluster, violent non-state actor groups have no arrangements with each other, resulting in violent clashes between them and civilian deaths and displacements. The rules of the game are clear in situations of enmity and citizens can increase their chances of survival by following them. The rivalry cluster encompasses unstable short-term arrangements such as criminal spot sales, barter agreements, tactical alliances and sub-contractual relationships. Unstable arrangements are associated with unpredictable outbreaks of selective rather than general violence, fuelling mistrust and uncertainty in communities and eroding the social fabric. The friendship cluster of relatively stable, non-violent, long-term inter-group relations is underpinned by supply chain relationships, strategic alliances and pacific co-existence. It is the friendship cluster arrangements that give rise to forms of ‘shadow citizenship’ that delegitimise state authority. Friendly violent non-state actor groups are restrained in their use of violence, fulfil a governance function for the community and maintain a flourishing criminal economy. Interest-based motivations for co-operation at the micro-level promote less stable arrangements, whilst co-operation driven by values or a quest for power at a macro-level results in long-term arrangements amongst ‘friends’.
Policy implications: the book is rich in recommendations for policy-makers, tying empirical evidence to broader debates in peace and security circles about the need for ongoing, non-linear interventions at the level of the local community, in place of a focus on state institutions, political parties, formal territorial control and a fixed roadmap from ‘war’ to ‘peace’. Idler's work will be of interest to peace-makers and security sector reform professionals seeking to apply resilience thinking to manage the complex and overlapping array of violent non-state actors that are an everyday feature of both ‘conflict’ and ‘peaceful’ nation states in the Global South. It is also novel in highlighting that in the borderlands it is the relationship between violent non-state actor groups, not their relationship with the state, that matters for citizen security. Borderland Battles is a landmark publication that will no doubt prompt a rethink of the role of the state in peace-making, governance, justice and security.
