Despite the recent revival of interest in the Victorian epic, poems from the colonial periphery have played only a small role in the revised narrative of the epic's persistence across the nineteenth century.Footnote 1 Part of the explanation for this may lie in the centralized imperial geography of the archives that inspired both nineteenth-century scholars and epoists. As Adelene Buckland and Anna Vaninskaya remark, “Britain was certainly the place to be for a nineteenth-century aficionado of epic poetry” (163). While scholars flocked to Oxford, Cambridge, the British Museum, and the Bodleian Library to pour over the texts of Gilgamesh or old Icelandic sagas, a number of nineteenth-century poets began to see the epic itself as a tool for excavating a more geographically and archeologically localized national story. As Simon Dentith notes, “the nationalism of the nineteenth century seized upon epics – especially the old vernacular primary epics . . . and made them an expression of the national spirit (Epic 67).Footnote 2 William Morris's Sigurd the Volsung, for example, revives the mythology of the Old North to make a “Great Story” for the race of northern Europeans what the “Tale of Troy was to the Greeks” (Dentith, “Morris” 239).Footnote 3
However, while such efforts sought to re-found the epic's sense of national continuity on a more proximate geography, the genre's “very sense of modernity or contemporary civility was constructed out of the contrast” with the barbarism of the epic past (Dentith, Epic 10). This general belief in the essential antiquity and alterity of epic, what Dentith calls “epic primitivism,” also allowed the epoist to bestow heroic qualities on the subject peoples of empire, while simultaneously portraying them as noble savages that had not yet progressed from barbarism to civilization (12–13). It should come as no surprise, then, if challenges to the triumphal progressivism of nineteenth-century Britain's “heroic muse” were to emerge not among artifacts of the British Museum, but among writers from the colonies. This essay explores one such challenge, Horatio Nelson Huggins's epic Hiroona, a “Historical Romance in Poetic Form” composed in the 1880s and 1890s in Trinidad, which recounts the Anglo-Carib wars of the 1790s on the Caribbean island of St. Vincent. Huggins's epic, I argue, produces a critique of Britain's imperial self-definition in epic terms by reversing the historical progressivism assumed within the genre, producing not a notion of epic primitivism, but of epic decadentism, a belief that the origins of epic lie not in a nation's barbaric past, but in the late stages of its decline.Footnote 4
The title Hiroona derives from the Carib word “hiroon,” meaning “the blessed,” which the Caribs reportedly used to refer to St. Vincent. As an epic in the romance vein, Hiroona is a story of winners and losers. This 348-page work in twelve cantos gives a blow-by-blow account of the British conquest of St. Vincent, which ended in 1797 when the British defeated the “Black Caribs” (or Garifuna people, a mixed-race Afro-Carib tribe that adopted indigenous cultural practices), rounded up the survivors, and expelled them to a desolate island off the coast of Honduras, claiming their lands for sugar cultivation. Huggins himself was a white creole born on St. Vincent in 1830 and educated at Codrington College in Barbados. He and his family eventually moved to Trinidad, where he became Rector of St. Paul's Church in San Fernando. Huggins composed Hiroona sometime in the decade before his death in 1895, and the text remains very much a document of its fin-de-siècle moment. Huggins's children eventually deciphered and transcribed his manuscripts and had them published in 1930 by Franklin's Electric Printery in Trinidad.Footnote 5
The preface by the author's son claims that Huggins reconstructed the story from songs and legends he heard as a child on St. Vincent. Indeed, Huggins's occasionally autobiographical narrator sets himself up according to the philological theories of his day, which saw the epics of Homer as later assemblages of earlier, pre-literate bardic songs or “lays.”Footnote 6 The epic singer of Hiroona claims to take up native tales of “unmeasured grief” and “unnumbered tear” and shape them into the rhymed couplets typical of nineteenth-century epics in English (Huggins 15). Each canto, including the verse introduction, is divided into individually numbered passages of varying lengths. Though each of the numbered passages is metrically consistent within itself, the sections alternate somewhat arbitrarily between iambic tetrameter and iambic pentameter. Though Huggins did not have an opportunity to fully revise and polish the work before he died, and errors of transcription may have entered the published version, the rhythmic quality is sufficiently varied to be readable without being overly clever. Aside from some wrinkles that might have been ironed out with another pass, it marks a respectable and sustained effort, though one that requires some patience from the reader. Huggins may never win a wide audience for his work based on the aesthetic quality of the verse. Two hundred and fifty pages of rhymed couplets would strain the capabilities of even a master craftsman, and Huggins is adept, but no master. Still, there is genuine passion here. One finds moving moments that shine through the sometimes tedious rehearsal of events. There is even the occasional display of fireworks, as in the passages I discuss below. Such moments deserve to be excerpted more widely in anthologies of Caribbean verse. A new edition of the whole work, badly needed given the handful of available copies of the original, would surely find an audience among students, scholars, and readers of Caribbean literature.
Though the bulk of the poem focuses on the events surrounding the Anglo-Carib wars of 1795 to 1797, the work is bookended by two remarkable passages. The first is an introductory canto that describes Columbus's first contact with the natives. Columbus himself is described less as an intrepid explorer and more as a sort of refugee, commanding a fleet set “[a]drift from old exhausted world” (11). Even as Columbus sets out, “Mysterious fingers trace, as on the wall, / Spain's misused day of grace and Spain's downfall” (15). Columbus's transatlantic voyage is cast not as a mark of Europe's triumphal progress, but as the beginning of a process of “mysterious decay” that works its way from the Old World to the New (18). Indeed, the passage frames Columbus's journey to the New World, and the colonial system that followed on its heels, as symptoms of Europe's flagging cultural integrity. The conquest of the New World becomes a desperate attempt to find renewal abroad.
The other bookend to this story comes three hundred years and about as many pages later. After the battle for St. Vincent is won and lost, the final canto erupts into an eight-page curse on the heads of the British delivered by the defeated warrior Warramou as his people stand on the brink of exile. In his curse, Warramou prophesizes the turmoil of emancipation, the collapse of the sugar trade, the failure of global capitalism, a volcanic eruption, and the revolutionary overthrow of the ruling white population by their former slaves, before collapsing in exhaustion. The whole narrative thus spans more than four hundred years of colonial history, from the time just before Columbus's arrival in the New World to a point beyond the time of the poem's composition, projecting an image of historical continuity between the epic past, the poem's contemporary moment, and an apocalyptic future. However, while the bulk of the poem focuses on a particular slice of the history of colonial conquest in the West Indies, Huggins makes a broader argument about the origins of the epic impulse, locating the inception of the genre not within an unfolding tale of national and racial triumph, but in the transference of “mysterious decay” from one culture to another. For Huggins's beloved Hiroon, that process culminates in a vision of regional black revolution heralding the end of the white planter aristocracy from which Huggins himself descended, a class who saw themselves as the guardians of British culture overseas, but whose continuing rule the poet saw as a historical injustice.
In casting the Black Caribs as the subject of epic, Hiroona appears to share the “presupposition that epic poetry springs from the social conditions of pre-modern, ‘heroic’, society,” a central presupposition of what Dentith calls “epic primitivism” (“Morris” 239). Though Huggins does portray the Black Caribs as heroic savages, in the end, Hiroona makes the opposite case about the origins of epic, locating its generative moment at the tail end of a story of cultural decadence and degeneration. For Huggins, the driving story behind the genre is not one of the heritability of national character, but of its dissolution, a dissolution dramatized by the cross-cultural identifications made possible between planter and Carib in the shared experience of decline.
Huggins is one of a number of late-nineteenth-century commentators, such as conservative British historian James Anthony Froude and American writer Lafcadio Hearn, who imagined the West Indies as the most visible site of the British Empire's cracking integrity. In his 1888 travelogue assessing the state of The English in the West Indies, Froude maintains that any decline in the colonies would inevitably spread to the imperial center: “The West Indies are a small limb in the great body corporate of the British Empire, but there is no great and no small in the life of nations. The avoidable decay of the smallest member is an injury to the whole” (364).Footnote 7 Hearn captures the general worry over white flight in his 1890 travelogue Two Years in the French West Indies, suggesting that during “the present era of colonial decadence . . . all persons of means and energy” have followed the ebbing tide of colonial commerce and departed from the scene (329). As the American cultural theorist Brooks Adams argued in an 1899 article in the Forum titled “England's Decadence in the West Indies,” if the world had entered a “new stage of development” that put the dominance of English civilization at risk, then “the spot where the old system has broken down lies in the West Indies” (55).
While most accounts of the time depict imperialism as a process of geographic expansion from the center outward, and decadence as a kind of cultural rot that begins at empire's extremities and works its way toward the capital, Huggins depicts the process of expansion itself as the vehicle for cultural decline. Thus Huggins's epic, which appears at first as marginal both to the geography of empire and to the literary history of Victorian epic, in fact makes a direct run at the center, resorting to tales of aboriginal defeat and impending black revolution to challenge the cultural premise of epic itself. (At the same time, he bucks the assumptions of contemporaneous commentators from outside the region, such as Froude, Hearn, and Brooks, whose views were not always welcomed by the locals.)Footnote 8 For Huggins, epics of conquest are, whether they know it or not, less tales of the tribe than ideological masks thrown over the tribe's death throes. Huggins's epic attempts to refute the progressivism of Europe's cultural story by embedding Britain's particular colonial difficulties in a larger tale of cultural and historical decadence. It is that story, Huggins suggests, to which the heroes of Europe's epics of conquest have remained willfully blind. Despite its obscurity, then, the poem offers an opportunity to provincialize and complicate the genre's sense of Britain's imperial destiny.Footnote 9 At the same time, the poem offers an opportunity to expand the geographic and generic range of critical accounts of “decadent poetics” beyond the usual set of fin-de-siècle lyrics to include the colonial epic. Huggins's poem ultimately requires a remapping of the Victorian epic's self-understanding as emerging not from the pockets of native barbarism left in the modern world, or from the imperial archive, but from late European modernity itself. By the same token, the poem suggests that the fin-de-siècle poetics of decadence must be understood to share this larger, transatlantic, colonial context.
Though Hiroona has received scant critical attention, it has been praised for its sympathetic treatment of Amerindian people and for its condemnation of British colonialism. As Selwyn Cudjoe notes, Hiroona is one of several texts written in Trinidad in the 1880s that “attempt to reevaluate the position of the Amerindian within the national psyche” (294). Paula Burnett praises the unrelenting verve of Huggins's “lonely anti-colonial vision,” which she notes was a rarity for white creoles at the time (400). Nan Peacocke has argued that the poem's anti-colonial subject matter contradicts the “ideological costume” of its “Eurocentric epic form,” which she suggests is “associated through colonial schooling, the legal system, and the official church with discourses of European cultural superiority” (28). According to Peacocke, the poem's subject matter “resists the ideological and social modes the epic genre represents” (28). Dismissing the poem's epic structure as a burden to its anti-colonial content, Peacocke repositions the work as a precursor to the postcolonial novel. Indeed, the poem deserves to be considered alongside novels such as Jean Rhys's Wide Sargasso Sea (1966) as a startling attempt to account for the decadence of the white creole planter class after emancipation.
However, though Peacocke's historical work uncovering the context of the poem's composition and publication is invaluable, her interpretation poses a false division between form and content. Here, I argue that it is precisely through its manipulation of epic convention, specifically through the topos of the curse and the device of prophecy, that Hiroona makes a narrative of anti-colonial resistance possible. Hiroona owes the scaffolding upon which its lonely anti-colonial vision is hung to the history of curses and prophecies in both Old and New World epics, including Homer's Iliad and Odyssey, Virgil's Aeneid, Alonso de Ercilla's 1569 epic Araucana, and Gaspar Perez de Villagrá's 1610 Historia de la Nueva Mexico. At the same time, Hiroona responds to and rejects the more reverential accounts of Columbus's initial exploration of the New World found in prior Anglophone epics such as Joel Barlow's Vision of Columbus (Reference Barlow1787) and Columbiad (Reference Barlow1809), or Samuel Rogers's Voyage of Columbus (1810). The poem's nearest precursor in spirit is James Montgomery's long abolitionist poem, The West Indies (1809), echoes of which can be heard in the more denunciatory stretches of Hiroona’s anti-colonial, but decidedly Christian, appeal for racial egalitarianism.Footnote 10 And though it takes a more sympathetic attitude toward native peoples than Robert Southey's Madoc (1805) or the more contemporaneous The Earthly Paradise of William Morris (1868), Hiroona shares with these last two epics an initiatory gesture whereby the narrative commences by decamping from a European world plagued by civil unrest, pestilence, and cultural malaise. But even as Hiroona draws upon the generic plots and topoi of its epic predecessors, it reshapes the genre from the point of view of historical decline, employing the notion of “mysterious decay” to break through the conventional distance between epic antiquity and colonial modernity.
As a “Historical Romance” in epic form, Hiroona draws on a long tradition that, since Virgil's Aeneid, “ascribes to political power the capacity to fashion human history into narrative” (Quint 9). By “drawing on the two narrative models offered by the Iliad and the Odyssey,” Quint argues, “Virgil's poem attached political meaning to narrative form itself,” establishing distinct narrative norms for history's winners and losers (9). Though both of Homer's epics tell the story of history's victors, Virgil and those who followed after him took Odysseus's aimless, digressive wanderings as a template for the narrative condition of the defeated. It is the condition in which one finds Aeneas after his initial escape from Troy and before his later triumphs. Over time, these narrative strains diverged. Thus, “to the victors belongs epic, with its linear teleology; to the losers belongs romance, with its random or circular wandering. Put another way, the victors experience history as a coherent, end-directed story told by their own power; the losers experience a contingency that they are powerless to shape to their own ends” (9). The “wandering ship of Odysseus tossed by the winds of fortune” becomes a figure that appears again and again in succeeding epics to describe the condition of history's losers (9). In narrative structure, Hiroona more strongly resembles the post-Virgilian epic's concentration on acts of conquest and scenes of battle than the romance's focus on the wanderings of the conquered. Because its sympathies lie with the defeated, however, Hiroona shares the broader ideological commitments of the romance. Indeed, it is no accident that the story begins with Columbus set “[a]drift from old exhausted world” and ends with the captured native warrior Warramou and his people standing on a boat, exiled from their home island and set adrift from history (11). The scenes of epic conquest that make up the bulk of the story are entirely framed within, and are the product of, the larger pattern of aimless wandering more typical of the romance.
As Quint suggests, the epic tradition, with all its triumphal progressivism, contains the romance of the defeated within itself as a kind of narrative other, a counter tradition that, in the hands of Lucan and others, could offer a form of resistance to the narrative teleology imposed by empire (9).Footnote 11 The most prominent site of this counter-tradition is the curse of the defeated upon the victors, which “constitutes a rival narrative of resistance coexisting alongside the triumphalist history that the epic proclaims for the winners” (11).Footnote 12 But Quint observes that these counter narratives of native resistance are often overwhelmed by the overarching narrative control that epic grants to history's victors:
[E]ven as these poems acknowledge opposing voices, dissenting perspectives, other histories, they simultaneously depict the condition of defeat as one of self-defeat, the losers are born losers – monstrous, demonic, subhuman – condemned to a futile aimless repetition. . . . [T]he stories projected by and for the defeated have no place to go; they lack the teleology of the victors’ epic narrative, and they fall into cyclical romance patterns that are finally nonnarratable. (11)
In this sense, while Hiroona may anticipate the ideologies of native and black resistance that give shape to the postcolonial novel, its voicing of these dissenting perspectives is wholly inscribed within epic tradition. Hiroona's reinscription of these voices within the fin-de-siècle discourse of decadence, however, produces unusual results in the temporalities of these narratives, calling into question the victor's ability to narrate his own history, and offering instead an overarching story of decline that ensnares history's winners and losers alike. As I demonstrate below, the idea of decadence loops the narrative voice, and the culture to which it owes the privilege to narrate, into the nonnarratable romance patterns of the defeated.
While Hiroona draws upon a generic tradition that stretches back to antiquity, it also stands with one foot squarely within the tradition of Victorian epic. As Herbert Tucker observes, the nineteenth-century epic plays a double narrative game involving an “inside story” constituted by “the sheer telling of a plot, . . . sticky with the consensual cohesiveness that defines the genre,” and an “outside story,” that is, “the story of this telling, which [subsumes] the present narrative within a chain of transmission” (23). The inside story establishes the “normative virtues” that render the epic protagonists heroes in the eyes of the culture in which they are inscribed. The outside story, the story of the telling, claims by various conventions a place for itself in “the tradition of epic writing” (23). In this way, the Victorian epic typically represented the inside story “as one episode, whole and closed, within a story much larger: the enveloping history of a continuous culture whose defining condition . . . was developmental and open” (24).
On the surface, the inside story of Hiroona is fairly straightforward. The Caribs, though ultimately vanquished, demonstrate by their bearing in battle various qualities their culture finds virtuous: bravery in adversity, nobility in defeat, honesty, and so on. Their story appears to end with their exile. However, from the very first pages of the poem, the narrator hints that the Caribs’ fall results not from losses suffered in battle, but from the process of “mysterious decay” initially sparked by contact with European culture (18).
Here, the Europeans’ martial superiority proves necessary but not sufficient to explain the Caribs’ defeat: “even where they’ve neither fought nor bled,” a quasi-Darwinian process governs their disappearance: the “soft yet scathing, withering touch” of the “higher culture” shrinks the “feebler life” of the weaker Caribs (18). However, despite the Europeans’ “robust” appearance, it is not their cultural superiority, but their cultural exhaustion that proves fatally communicable:
Upon contact, this “mysterious decay” penetrates even where war and brutality do not, hollowing out non-European cultures from the inside.
A precedent for the infectious quality of such decay can be found in Montgomery's The West Indies:
However, though Montgomery clearly places the blame for such pestilential withering squarely on the Europeans, Huggins raises the notion of cultural decay out of the realm of mere disease to the level of historical theory. The spread of mysterious decay comes as a consequence of Columbus's attempt to escape the exhaustion of the Old World, demonstrating that decadence works its way through both conqueror and conquered, becoming a driving force behind colonialism while dissolving the integrity of both New World “tribes” and European “nations” alike.
Huggins suggests that by the time the Black Caribs lost to the British in 1797, their decline had been well underway in ways both visible and invisible for three centuries. The poem distinguishes between the original native population whom Columbus would have encountered and the later mixed-race tribe of “Black Caribs” who are the heroes of the later war, though the general references to “Caribs” within the poem sometimes elide the difference.Footnote 13 The poem might well be read to attribute the Caribs’ loss of cultural integrity to miscegenation between the indigenous people and escaped African slaves, though Huggins avoids reducing the mystery of decay to any single biological or social process. At first glance, the Black Caribs of the 1790s appear to play to type as the epic's typical “born losers,” rendered degenerate by cross-cultural contact, and thus partly responsible for their own demise. However, Hiroona deviates from the standard rendition of such dehumanized losers in one crucial aspect: the vision of cultural decline governing the inside story repeats at the level of the outside story. The story of the “continuous culture” to which the epic singer or narrator is party becomes, likewise, a story of decadence and degeneration.
From the beginning, the narrator partakes in the decline and fall of the white creole planter class that is only made explicit at narration's end when prophesied by the native hero. Huggins was not alone in recounting the decline of the West Indian plantocracy. In the decades following the emancipation of the slaves in the British colonies in 1834 and the French colonies in 1848, white creoles all across the region, including the American south, began to panic. When the sugarcane market collapsed, white creole planters began to leave the colonies in droves. A landscape once depicted by nineteenth-century naturalists as a new, tropical Eden became littered with the ruins of abandoned plantation houses, sugar mills, and colonial forts.Footnote 14 Despite new waves of immigrant workers, in the space of half a century, from roughly 1830 to 1880, the West Indies were diminished in the popular imagination to the remnants of a once-great civilization. What once looked to travelers like a tropical paradise began to look more like the Roman Forum, littered with what anthropologist Ann Laura Stoler refers to as “imperial debris” (195). As Froude dramatically described it in 1888: “The palaces of the English planters and merchants fall to decay; their wines and their furniture, their books and their pictures, are sold or dispersed. Their existence is a struggle to keep afloat, and one by one they go under in the waves” (347).
Many accounts attributed the declining fortunes of the West Indian plantocracy to the regional economic collapse that followed the loss of coerced labor. But such accounts also betray widespread fears of a more ominous threat, the specter of regional revolt on the part of the formerly enslaved black population. As Brooks Adams puts it:
If it be true that the English who, as well as the Spanish, inhabit the Western tropics, are ceasing to be able to hold their own in the struggle for life with other races, the effects cannot fail to be manifold. At the outset, for example, one of the two results must apparently follow: either this whole region must be absorbed in some more elastic economic system, or it must sink to the level of Haiti. (55)
If England's decadence began in the West Indies, its most feared consequence would be a continuation of the movement for black self-rule that first erupted with the Haitian revolution. Indeed, cause and effect here became difficult to disentangle, as the rising prospect of black revolt seemed to hasten white decline, and vice versa. The supposed atavism of a black revolution found its conceptual complement in the degeneration and decadence of white creole society.
It is no coincidence that the Carib uprising described in Hiroona, and its suppression, takes place at the same historical moment as the revolution in Haiti. The Haitian example tied together concerns over the fate of white slave-holding and formerly slave-holding populations throughout what Matthew Guterl has dubbed the “American Mediterranean,” a region that encompasses the entire rim of the Caribbean from the southern coastal states of North America to the northeastern coast of South America (6). Like Faulkner's Thomas Sutpen of Absalom! Absalom!, former slave owners across the region “saw versions of Haiti all around them, having ‘effectively loosen[ed] the first black republic from its moorings in place and in a certain kind of historical specificity’ and allowing it to ‘drift,’ to become an elusive, mobile threat” (Guterl 6, quoting Kutzinski 66).
According to Guterl, the story of the slave-holding master class became one “marked by increasing loss and privation and by the threat of a looming apocalypse” (7). By “mid-century, the abolition of slavery in the British West Indies appeared to have been a disaster (though the truth of it was far more complicated). . . . The deepest, most frightening nightmare for the Southern planter class was the prospect of another ‘St. Domingo,’ or Haitian revolution, another cathartic upheaval pitting the angry black masses against their former white overlords” (33). Before and after emancipation, fears of racial, social, and economic collapse came to determine many narratives describing the present state of history, whenever that present was described, as a moment at the end of an era. Haiti became a free-floating term for describing the historical condition of standing, above all, at the end of white colonial history.Footnote 15
In Hiroona, the narrator's occasional autobiographical disclosures hint at Huggins's personal sense of living at the end of an era of white dominance, revealed chiefly through the contemplation of native artifacts. The narrator recalls, for example, how in his “boyish years” he found fragments of “Old Carib tools and weapons rough of stone, / And even time-worn bits of human bone” lying about on St. Vincent (42). The narrator's initial childhood explorations become explorations of his own belatedness, conveying a sense of having arrived on the scene long after the death of a prior civilization. These trace ruins of a prior civilization offer themselves as displaced figures for the ruins that would become increasingly visible to Huggins between the 1830s and the 1880s: the ruins of sugar plantations, mills, and great houses left by the period of white flight after emancipation. Like the Carib curiosities often collected by members of the planter aristocracy, these memento mori-style bits of weapon and bone foretell the doom of Huggins's own class. The death of one culture becomes a portent of the death of another. Dentith suggests that in Sigurd the Volsung, Morris attempts to make a “massive fragment of the old world speak to the socially-transformed modernity of the nineteenth century” (239). For Huggins, the relatively tiny fragments of pre-colonial culture speak to the perceived state of modernity's ruin and the rapid fragmentation (and archeologicalization) of the Empire at its fringes.
By the time Huggins came to write Hiroona, then, the “outside story” of Britain's imperial progress had faltered significantly in the eyes of white West Indian creoles, whose regional identity as a class living under the threat of black revolution came to overshadow their identification with the mother country. This rift between the white planters’ regional identity and their identification with the Empire opened a space for critique.Footnote 16 As their local narratives became more determined by regional conditions, a writer such as Huggins could cast that regional sense of looming apocalypse as a symptom of the disintegration of a larger imperial story. A prophecy of regional black revolution, presented in the curse of a defeated warrior of mixed, and therefore doubly ominous, Carib and African heritage, might threaten to disrupt the larger imperial narrative in which the British Victorian epic was inscribed.
As Quint argues, epic curses have the effect of troubling narrative closure. For example, in Gaspar Perez de Villagrá's 1610 epic Historia de la Nueva Mexico, which chronicles the Spanish conquest of the American Southwest, the curse that the defeated Acoma Indians pronounce upon the Spanish
calls the idea of ending into question. Acoma has been destroyed, the war is over, the last rebels die at the hangman's tree – and yet the words of their curse echo on, a threat that all is not over . . . the curse amounts to an alternative history of resistance that competes with Villagrá's narrative of conquest, the narrative of the Historia, which presents itself as a complete and finished epic action, but which, at the very moment of formal closure, suggests a bloody and unending sequel. (104)
Quint notes, however, that though the curse topos grants a voice to native resistance, the curse itself may be appropriated by the conqueror to rationalize their ongoing “severity” toward the defeated (105). If the vanquished will cede no ground, the conqueror finds justification for a continued policy of suppression. Continued resistance, then, becomes a “suicidal” gesture, for the native voice will never be able to wrest control of the narrative away from the victor (105). The voice of resistance goes nowhere, finding only a circumscribed place within the epic singer's official history. While the curse of the defeated troubles the epic's sense of closure, the curse itself is ultimately portrayed as having no power to shape the epic singer's contemporary world.
Likewise, older versions of the curse topos project a narrative course that never breaks beyond the boundaries of the inside story. Or, if it does so, it finds itself contained by the epic's confidence in the victor's final triumph. For example, Polyphemus's curse on Odysseus, that he should arrive home deprived of his companions to find a troubled household, remains bound by the span of the narration itself. As does Dido's curse on Aeneas, for the most part. However, as Quint notes, Dido's curse “extends beyond the ending of the poem and enters into history,” calling into question not just “the narrative ending of the Aeneid,” but “the closure that the Aeneid projects upon Roman history: the empire without end foretold by Jupiter” (110–11). However, “[in] the long run, Rome's rule will be shaken but not overturned, and the continuing resistance of her subject peoples breaks down into a series of periodic, suicidal measures. Theirs is a repeated history of failures, a failed history” (113). Ultimately, the empire retains the power to narrate its own story.
Tucker observes, however, that in the Victorian epic, prophecies have a way of worming out of such narrative restrictions:
The hero's consultation of the sage or sybil, or indeed of the empowered book, halts the plot in order to declare how that plot inhabits and resumes the great cultural story. Much as, for psychoanalysis, a dream-within-a-dream can expose a true wish which the framing dream has disguised, so a given epic's nested narrative implant hatches a much larger plot, which is the one it shares with its congeners. It incubates what we are calling the genre's very idea: the privileged configuration that subsists between the conduct of a narrated action and the definitive patterns of the culture that it bespeaks, that nurtured it, and with whose further survival its own is bound up. (29)
In this sense, the prophecy represents a moment that reaffirms the triumphal march of the victor's outside story. But as it reaches beyond the narration to the world of the narrator, prophecy can breach the wall between the inside and outside narrative. Such is the case with Hiroona.
A prophetic curse then offers an opportunity to complicate the temporalities of the genre as described by Mikhail Bakhtin. According to Bakhtin, epic narrates the “absolute past,” and therefore an “absolute epic distance separates the epic world from [the] contemporary reality . . . in which the singer (the author and his audience) lives” (13). To violate this separation by “[portraying] an event on the same time-and-value plane as oneself and one's contemporaries . . . is to undertake a radical revolution, and to step out of the world of epic into the world of the novel” (13–14). The genre's integrity thus depends to an extent on the failure of the prophetic curses it produces. Though one can find many exceptions to Bakhtin's overly strict model, he provides a useful template by which to measure the ways in which Hiroona violates this theoretical separation between the position of the singer who utters the epic poem, a white creole of the planter class in the 1890s, and the heroic past conferred by the singer upon the Black Caribs.
From the poem's opening, the narrator takes the eagle’s-eye view of history. Addressing his own conjured image of Columbus directly, the narrator casts Columbus's transatlantic voyage not as an act of discovery, but as a failure to see into the future:
“Dark horrors, from thy pious soul concealed,” the narrator declares, “To my prophetic eye are seen revealed” (15).Footnote 17
The worst of the narrator's prophetic vision portrays the destruction of the West Indies’ indigenous peoples:
The narrator, speaking in the first person, prophesies the coming horrors of genocide and slavery, which to him are plainly visible in the moment of first contact. Columbus, however, remains blind to the contours of this larger outside story, maintaining through the opening an epic distance between subject and narrator.Footnote 18
While the poem opens with Columbus's failure to read the portents of the strife he brings with him, the Black Caribs, too, fail to heed the signs of their own ruin. In weighing the decision to take up arms against the British, the Black Caribs send an augur, a priest known as a “boyez,” to a lake in the shadow of a nearby volcano where the dreams of the creator-demon Qualeva are said to be visible. There, the boyez looks for any omens regarding the coming war. In the deep, the priest catches “the oncome of a gloom, portentous, vast, / Some coming dread event's foreshadow cast” (61). However, he ignores the warning: “He saw, but would not see! ‘‘Tis well! ‘tis well!’ / He said, ‘Against Hiroon there works no spell’” (61). This same priest then ignores yet another portent of destruction, “the plaintive notes of dread Souffrière bird – / Mysterious Songster,” a bird that could not be seen by mortals, but whose song constitutes a “voice of warning sent them from the dead” (62). Again, the priest fails to discern the omen: “for thrice the silent forest's depths were stirred / by three long plaintive notes – but no one heard” (63). As the scouting contingent reported back to their leaders: “‘In dreamless slumber dread Qualeva sleeps; / ‘No shadows dark alarm the peaceful mere; / ‘No note of phantom-bird has reached our ear’” (63). Here, this “mysterious songster” or “phantom bird” becomes a figure for the narrator himself, the mysterious epic voice who utters prophecies that go unheard by characters within the inside story. Just as the narrator addresses Columbus directly, these prophetic figures address the Black Caribs directly and fail to make contact. In a strange way, the narrator repeatedly includes within the inside story figures for his own failure to cross the epic distance between himself and the represented world of the text.
In the misguided war that follows, several heroic figures emerge from both the Black Carib and the English camps (only the French, who egg the Black Caribs on, come off as wholly conniving and corrupt). The nobility of the heroes emerges in acts of cross-cultural sympathy. A young Black Carib heroine saves a white woman's baby from ritual sacrifice. A white planter offers a wounded Black Carib a medicinal tonic. There are hints of interracial love, naive moments of trust, and a last-minute conversion to Christianity. But while these moments romanticize and valorize positive, cross-cultural intentions, the speaker notes that this nobility is the relic of a prior age.
In the early phases of the war, a witch by the name of Nannette emerges as the chief voice of native resistance, working dark spells to foil the English: “No Carib she of late degenerate days: / She spurned these softer thoughts and milder ways . . . Her one life-aim (it yearly grew) / ‘Revive the ancient ways, oppose the new’” (64). In the “wild harangue” that follows, this Dido-like figure claims “an ancient sybil right” to incite war through orgies, blood-sacrifice and a “ceaseless shriek of words” that tell “Of Caribs’ hero-deeds in days of old” (65). In her “high-pitched tones” she outdoes the “more sluggish Saxon temperament” (65). But if Nannette speaks in the voice of the still-un-degenerate Carib, her “wrathful story fierce and long” of “agony and wrong / At White man's hands” fails as a rousing call to arms and amounts to little more than the final recitation of a history about to be lost (65). In the “late degenerate days” at the close of Huggins's own nineteenth century, her rage, along with her history, has been all but forgotten (64). Nannette's sibylline prophecy, fierce as it is, has little effect, remaining bound by the tale of her own tribe. Her epic recitation, like that of the narrator, remains a product of her people's “late degenerate” days.
The narrator's repeated failures to penetrate the inside story by means of prophecy or portent punctuate roughly two hundred pages covering various battles, machinations, and romantic subplots. In the eleventh canto, however, the warrior Warramou shows signs of picking up on the narrator's prophetic signals:
It is only in the very last canto that the vanquished warrior, upon witnessing the defeat of his people, becomes unstuck in time, collapsing the epic distance between hero and narrator. Facing his conquerors, Warramou curses them: “White men, I curse you to your face, / Curse you and all your hated race!” (340). In the roughly 240 lines that follow, Warramou critiques colonialism, rejects Christianity in Miltonic (i.e., Satanic) fashion, and proclaims various rights on behalf of his people. In doing so, he, like Nannette, claims his place among the tellers of his own people's story, even as that story is relegated to the romance of the defeated. But unlike Nannette's sibylline harangue, Warramou's curse threatens more than just a lack of narrative closure for the victor's tale, it threatens to sweep the narrator himself into his own vision of colonial decline:
In the wake of this neglect: “‘Affrighted capital shall shrink. / ‘And enterprise starved out shall die[’]” (345).
This period of economic decline and white flight, visible anywhere one looked in the 1890s, would soon be followed by a final period of black rebellion that would stretch beyond Huggins's present moment to a future marked by black self-rule, the very possibility of which haunted the planter class from the Haitian revolution onward:
According to Bakhtin, in the codes of the epic genre, “prophecy is realized wholly within the limits of the absolute past . . . it does not touch the reader and his real time” (31). For the bulk of Hiroona, various portents remain bound by the time span of events within the narrated world, referring only to the imminent collapse of the Black Carib society. Warramou's curse, however, reflects a pervasive fear, contemporary to the 1890s world of the epic singer, that the white plantocracy had fallen into a state of decline and would soon dissipate in the shadow of black revolution. As Froude commented in 1888: “Already the English population of Trinidad is dwindling away under the uncertainties of their future position. Complete the work, set up a constitution with a black prime minister and a black legislature, and they will withdraw of themselves before they are compelled to go” (88). From Columbus's departure from Spain to the white planter's departure from the West Indies, the story of white “conquest” becomes a continuous story of decline and flight, a story revealed to the narrator’s, and now Warramou’s, prophetic eyes.
In other words, the idea of decadence or “mysterious decay” not only functions in the text as a means of accounting for the way non-European cultures disintegrate upon contact with colonial modernity, the idea of decadence also marks the disintegration of temporal boundaries within the genre, collapsing the epic distance between past and present apocalypses. Colonial modernity can no longer be seen as a high point in a linear tale of progress, but now participates in an ever-widening circle of cultural decay. As Quint notes, in epics of the vanquished, defeat is often attributed to the hands of fortune, the fates, or the gods: “The epic loser ascribes the victor's success to Fortune – to chance rather than to the victor's superiority or to some kind of historical necessity – thus leaving the possibility open that Fortune may change in the future” (103). In Hiroona, decadence takes the place of Fortune, ensnaring the victor, too, in a process that levies poetic justice invisibly through mysterious decay, opening the door to violent revolution. Where the curses of the defeated in prior epics may have ascribed to Fortune, the fates, or the gods the power to determine the survival of the culture to which the epic song itself belongs, Hiroona ascribes the privilege to narrate to the mysterious forces of decadence itself, which dictates the fates of loser and victor alike.
Hiroona's narrator positions himself in the space between the ruins of one civilization and the impending ruin of his own. The violation of epic distance between Hiroona's narrated past and the narrator's present suggests that the narrator shares what Frank Kermode would call a particularly modern “sense of an ending.” As Kermode argues, because humans are born not at the beginning or end of time, but in the middle, concepts such as “empire, decadence and renovation, progress and catastrophe . . . underlie our ways of making sense of the world from where we stand, in the middest” (29). Apocalyptic thinking therefore allows us to “project ourselves . . . past the End, so as to see the structure whole, a thing we cannot do from our spot of time in the middle” (8). The failure to accurately predict the end of the world has paradoxically reinforced a notion that “the End” is present in every passing moment: “No longer imminent, the End is immanent,” or, as Wallace Stevens would suggest, “the imagination is always at the end of an era” (Kermode 31; Stevens 22). For Kermode, modernity itself is characterized by a pervasive sense of perpetual crisis, a fear that every moment is a moment of transition pregnant with apocalyptic potential.
In the instances I have cited, while Hiroona's author has the privilege of 20/20 hindsight, Hiroona's narrator behaves as though apocalyptic crisis were, to the prophetic eye, available in every passing historical moment. For the narrator, there is no point in time from first contact onward that does not portend disaster. When Warramou breaks through the narrative span of the epic past, he not only bursts the temporal boundaries of his represented world and enters into history, he breaks from a sense of apocalypse as imminent, or on the brink, to a sense of the perpetual immanence of apocalypse, a sense that defines Hiroona's narrative structure. That is, in his vision of decline, Warramou crosses the threshold from self-contained epic past to the perpetual crisis of the modern present, as perceived by the epic singer.
As Dentith notes, the function of the “prophetic moment” is to “[look] forward to the moment of composition from out of the deep mythical past” (245).
[One] characteristic trope [of the secondary epic] is the prophetic moment in which the hero is led to contemplate how, unlikely as it seems, the contemporary moment of the story's telling has emerged from the historical narrative that the poem recounts: Aeneas is led to glimpse the result of all his efforts in the glories of Imperial Rome, while Adam in Paradise Lost gets to see the future redemption of mankind by Christ which his own action has made necessary. This classic gesture of secondary epic suggests a continuity between past and present, a national or world-historical narrative which leads from then to now. (Dentith 246)
When Huggins's hero glimpses the contemporary moment of the story's telling, however, his vision hardly confirms an outside tale of national progress. But neither does it strictly reverse this arc by presenting a linear descent toward national decay. Rather, the epic comes to represent the immanent decadence of the continuous present. One is always waiting for the barbarians, for the “irruption of history” into what Coetzee calls the “static time” imposed and maintained by empire (140).
Helen Vendler has suggested that the “notion of fin de siècle” may be more proper to epic than to lyric, “since it derives from the time span of epic narration, and lyric generically prefers the moment to the narrative span.” The lyric poet faces the “formal problem of reconciling the epic subject of history,” which is “panoramic” in scope, within the “short-breathed . . . lyric moment” (123–24). Vendler turns to W. B. Yeats and Jorie Graham for examples, but even a classic lyric of the French decadent movement such as Paul Verlaine”s 1884 poem “Langueur” compresses the end of an era into the space of one lyric line through the eyes of a single lyric “I”: “Je suis l’Empire à la fin de la décadence” (192). Huggins, speaking from the fringes of the empire, and not, like Verlaine, from the metropolitan center, turns this formal problem inside out, finding a way to keep that short-breathed moment at the end of an era alive throughout the epic span. Huggins does so by employing the prophetic eye or “I” to infuse a fin-de-siècle sensibility more typical of lyric into every moment of the epic panorama.
Also, like Verlaine's “Langueur,” Hiroona offers a vision of dissolving national borders, of the battle waged “Là-bas” from which, as the metropolitan center is distanced from the battle over there. Given that after France's own revolution, many among the French aristocracy fled to the West Indies, and continued to find themselves displaced by the Haitian revolution and the economic collapse after emancipation, it is possible to see the fin-de-siècle lyric and the colonial epic as two sides of the same coin, emerging from the same transnational discourse of decadence on both sides of the post-emancipation Atlantic.Footnote 19
One might argue that Hiroona ultimately affirms Dentith's notion of “epic primitivism,” but that it attributes the epic's search for primitive, if barbaric vitality to a pervasive sense of living at history's end. Why tap into the epic past if one were not overly concerned about how the present measured up? The difference between epic primitivism and epic decadentism comes down to where one stands regarding the value of modernity. In one sense, Huggins's epic decadentism could be seen to produce a kind of proto-West Indian nationalism, an expression of dissatisfaction with living under the thumb of a decadent empire. At the same time, however, Huggins's anti-colonial vision might also be taken as a proto-post-nationalist gesture. When “tribes and nations wither,” the idea of decadence gestures toward a space beyond the national or tribal story where all races strut as equals (18). The forms of political community it points toward are indeed revolutionary and undefined, threatening not just because they are black, but because they are open-ended, multi-racial, and not subject to the control of the epic's usual monocultural narrative telos. The wish that Huggins's narrator expresses in Hiroona is ultimately much like that expressed by another figure whose sympathies lie with empire's others, the narrator of Coetzee's Waiting for the Barbarians: “I wanted to live outside history. I wanted to live outside the history that Empire imposes on its subjects, even its lost subjects. I never wished it for the barbarians that they should have the history of Empire laid upon them. How can I believe that that is cause for shame?” (151). The last is a question Huggins, in his day, can only answer by rewriting the very genre that gave the history of Empire its shape.
