In this essay, an expanded lecture, the author just about keeps his head above water in all the cross currents of linguistic and caste politics in South India. To find oneself reading about the history of an undivided Presidency generated sentimental reactions. Here is another text which sees Europeans, above all missionaries, as constructing new identities such as Dravidian and putting South Indian languages, above all Tamil, on the map. But the author emphasises that the Dravidian movement in these years was always weak, “only a minor current of the Justice Party largely restricted to the Tamil districts” (p 46), and what is striking is the still limited expression of Tamil self-consciousness. Above all the author gives weight to the role of linguistic factors, in particular Telugu, in the power struggles of the time.
The Justice Party (JP) began with the founding, on 20 November 1916, of the South India People's Association; though it later took on the name of Justice Party from the newspaper of that name which was set up in February 1917 to rival The Hindu, newspaper of the Congress Party. With Congress boycotting the election the JP swept to power in the 1920 provincial elections with 63 out of 98 seats. A Namierite analysis is in order here for this was very much a party dedicated to delivering ‘jobs for the boys’, serving the interests of Telugu zamindars and businessmen. Any pretence of social reform had been lost with the death of the Malayalam T. M. Nair in July 1919. M. C. Rajah, a leader of the untouchable community, broke away to fill that empty space in 1923 with his Madras Adi-Dravida Mahajana Sabha. By September 1934 the JP had largely succeeded in taking away jobs from the Tamil Brahmins and so allowed their admittance to the party. Into the anti-Brahmin territory that this opened up Ramaswami Naicker launched his Self-Respect movement, “an anti-Brahmin, anti-Aryan, anti-God and anti-religious Dravidian social reform and racial movement in Tamilnadu”(p. 39), creating the possibility of a mass base for the elitist JP, though this in fact was always to prove fragile. The author reminds us that Naicker was a Kannada speaker by birth rather than Tamil. He clamoured for a separate Dravidanadu, linked up in 1940 with Jinnah pressing for a like separatist state, but with his movement much weakened, set up the Dravida Kazhagan 27 August 1944.That, of course, was to have an influential story ahead of it in the various manifestations of the DMK. The JP itself was declared defunct by 1946 but was also to get its way with the break-up of the Presidency and the setting up of the Telugu state of Andhra Pradesh in 1956.
All of this is interesting enough but it is peculiarly lop-sided in failing to say more about the opponents of the JP and the Self-Respect movement, above all the outstanding representative of the Tamil Brahmins, C. Rajagopalachari. There is no mention in the notes of the various biographies by Rajmohan Gandhi eg Rajaji: A Life (New Delhi, 1997) and my own The Political Career of C Rajagopalachari 1937–54: A Moralist in Politics (Delhi, 1978). What is lacking from the essay is any sense of the excitement engendered by a clash of personalities in this power struggle. I tried to introduce a non-Namierite dimension to the story by writing of Rajagopalachari's career in terms of a clash between the politics of principle and those of communalism. And if Rajagopalachari over-reacted to the anti-Hindi campaign led by Naicker, surely Rajagopalachari's opposition to such vicious anti-Brahmin communalism was justified. I interviewed Naicker in 1971 but found this elusive and opaque man hard to place. Confronted by Telugu demands for a separate state Rajagopalachari may have been working for the greatest prize of all from the outset, retaining sole control of Madras as the state capital for any Tamil state. This of course was to happen, and was a triumph of the politics of power. Readers may like to know of a recent study by Vasanthi Srinivasan Gandhi's Conscience Keeper: C Rajagopalachari and Indian Politics (New Delhi, 2009.)
