In this book, Chung takes the reader on a journey through the ins and outs of the immigration incorporation regime in Japan, looking at not only the formal institutions and policies that determine the boundaries of citizenship, but also at the informal institutions for incorporating non-citizens into the society. While immigration is generally believed to be a recent phenomenon in Japan, Chung asserts that, in fact, nationality and citizenship have been part of the construction of Japan as a democratic nation-state since at least the Meiji Period (1868–1910) and the adoption of Japan's first citizenship law in 1899.
Early in the twentieth century as Japanese were becoming the target of discriminatory legislation abroad, Japanese colonial ambitions were focused on Asia. With the annexation of Taiwan (1895), Sakhalin (1905), and Korea (1912), large numbers of people were under Japanese rule. They were granted citizenship status and incorporated into the outer circle of the imperial ‘family’, but it was at best second-class citizenship and left them ‘controllable, exploitable, and disposable’ (p. 69). Many of these colonial subjects came to Japan, some of their own volition and, as the war spread, many due to forced recruitment as laborers, soldiers, or ‘comfort women’ (women forced to provide sexual services to the military).
At the end of World War II, there were more than two million colonial subjects living in Japan, and the newly democratizing state was confronted with the problem of what to do with them. The solution was found in claiming that rather than defining Japanese subjects as those united in the ‘family’ of the emperor, the new ‘Japanese’ were literally united by blood. In other words, after the war citizenship was adjudicated on the basis of consanguinity (jus sanguinis; citizenship by descent), allowing for the exclusion of former colonial subjects from the construction of postwar Japanese national identity. The Japanese government, with the consent of the Occupation authorities, offered repatriation to the former colonial subjects, expecting them to take advantage of the opportunity to return to their former homes, but in fact many of them stayed, marking the beginning of Japan's so-called ‘Korean Problem.’
Chung's well-referenced analysis investigates legitimacy and identity for of all of Japan's minorities, visible and invisible, but gives primary emphasis to the former colonial subjects of Korean origin, today's permanent resident Koreans. As people of Korean descent have been in Japan for four generations, most of this population of permanent residents were born and raised in Japan. Through her detailed study, Chung shows that immigration, nationality, and citizenship are political issues which involve not only the legal position of Japan's former colonial subjects but also the social context in which all people live their lives.
There are two aspects of Chung's analysis which are of particular interest. The first is the way in which she identifies the contradictions in the Japanese immigrant incorporation regime. Naturalization is often seen as a way to attain political voice, yet even after so many years, relatively few Koreans choose to naturalize. Chung argues that like Japan, many modern states are confronted by declining rates of both voter participation and naturalization and suggests that immigrants might have alternative strategies for attaining necessary rights and services. She demonstrates that while Japanese immigration law is conservative, particularly with regard to those who stay for short periods of time, permanent residents and special permanent residents have found ways to empower themselves, obtaining access to a broad range of rights and services without having to engage in the often unwieldy and unreliable process of naturalization. These services generally involve measures by local municipal governments, often established with the cooperation of local Japanese citizens, and contrast greatly with the restrictive national policy. What may appear from the perspective of the state to be contradictory and an undesirable state of affairs may in fact be satisfactory from the perspective of the migrants themselves.
The second aspect of particular interest to this reader is Chung's multi-dimensional approach which looks at immigration not as a one-way or top-down set of rules, norms, and services, but rather an interactive process involving both top-down and bottom-up activities and actors. In particular, Chung emphasizes the role of Korean and Japanese NGOs in the construction of citizenship and non-citizenship in Japan. She traces the history of resistance by the Korean community, beginning with the anti-fingerprinting campaigns of the sixties and seventies, and shows how these have influenced campaigns for rights by other immigrant groups.
Chung's analysis is compelling and given the size and position of the Korean zainichi community, the focus on Koreans is reasonable. At the same time, more attention to the subtleties of identity in post-colonial subjects would be enlightening. For example, this analysis could be enhanced by a more detailed look at how the situation of Koreans differs from that of former colonial subjects from Taiwan (Formosa), or groups such as Indians, who have been in Japan since the late 19th century. Similarly, while Chung touches briefly on the issue of visibility, she fails to examine fully the complexities of this idea. The suggestion that the ability of most Koreans to successfully ‘pass’ as Japanese has both helped them to survive in a hostile and racist environment and at the same time has obstructed political action and the construction of hyphenated Korean-Japanese identities makes one curious as to how ‘visibility’ has played out in the construction of citizenship and nationality for other minorities such as Ainu, Okinawan and queer people.
While I appreciate the importance of this study, I am concerned by the lack of attention to the intersections of race/ethnicity, gender and class in the construction of nationality and citizenship. Who were the Koreans who comprised the colonial and post-colonial immigrant communities? While it is difficult to know the precise numbers, there were about twice as many Korean men as women living in Japan after the war. Who were the women and men who chose repatriation, and who were those who remained in Japan? For example, for many former ‘comfort women’ repatriation was not an alternative, and shame made them unable to talk of their experiences. What did they tell their children? How did the experience of incorporation and/or racism by mothers and fathers who remained in Japan affect their children? What were politics of marriage, patriarchy and identity and how were they played out on the bodies of Korean men and women, and their children?
Chung asserts that collaboration between Japanese and zainichi communities was important in the shaping of the politics of citizenship and national identity, but she fails to discuss how the newly acquired political and social rights of Japanese women might have affected their attitudes toward other women. What, for example, were the politics of motherhood, citizenship and the atomic bomb as applied to Korean survivors by organizations such as the Japan Mothers’ Congress? I agree with Chung that immigrant incorporation is a negotiated process among a variety of actors, but suggest our understanding of those processes could be greatly enhanced by the inclusion of an intersectional analysis.
