As Bernth Lindfors notes in Ira Aldridge: Performing Shakespeare in Europe, 1852–1855, by the end of Aldridge's first tour of continental Europe, the “African Roscius” (as Aldridge called himself) was famous enough that plays were being created about him, burlesquing his particular style of performing Shakespeare. These plays gave European actors “an opportunity to mimic, and thereby to recall in an amusing fashion, the impact that the real Aldridge had made on Continental audiences” (179). Throughout his meticulously researched study of this important African American actor and his European tour, Lindfors demonstrates the tour's impact on continental critics and audiences and on the trajectory of Aldridge's own career.
This book is the third in a series of biographies of Aldridge by Lindfors. The first two volumes (both published in 2011, also by Rochester University Press as part of its Rochester Studies in African History and the Diaspora) chronicle far longer periods in Aldridge's life and career. The history presented in these volumes, Ira Aldridge: The Early Years, 1807–1833 and Ira Aldridge: The Vagabond Years, 1833–1852, is summarized in the author's brief introduction. Lindfors acknowledges that the third book differs significantly from the earlier two in that it focuses on a shorter span of time and because during his European tour Aldridge performed in only a handful of roles, including Othello, Mungo (from Isaac Bickerstaff's The Padlock), Shylock, Macbeth, and, very occasionally, Richard III. Although he had played in a variety of melodramas and farces on the British Isles, as Lindfors notes, “it was primarily as a Shakespearean actor that Aldridge was known and evaluated when he toured the Continent” (6). On his tour, Aldridge either performed entirely in English with his company or—usually as Shylock—joined a European company performing in their native language while he portrayed his role in English.
In the first chapter, Lindfors describes how Aldridge prepared for the tour, hiring a company of British actors. The second chapter examines Aldridge's disappointing first engagements in Brussels, which led to the dismissal of much of the company he had just hired. Aldridge received a much more positive response alongside his reduced company in Germany, as discussed in Chapters 3–6. One problem is that, excepting a few extraordinary events such as a noteworthy gift from the King of Prussia to Aldridge, the theatrical engagements and critical responses related in this part, about a third of Lindfors's book, become increasingly repetitive.
The remaining chapters are the strongest of the book. Chapter 7 considers the actor's reception in Hungary, where the critics seem to have had a more nuanced view of Aldridge's work than was the case in Germany. Chapters 8 and 9 describe, respectively, how contemporary critics compared Aldridge to other famous actors of the time and changes to the company. Chapter 10, the most fascinating of the book, examines Aldridge's relationship with the actor and manager Karl Rémay, whose activities during the 1848 revolutions unfortunately led to Aldridge being forced to curtail his tour to Austria and Hungary in 1853. The book's final three chapters assess the remainder of Aldridge's first European tour and his return home. Lindfors closes by acknowledging that another book could very well be written detailing Aldridge's final twelve years, which included further touring in Britain and Europe—especially in Russia, where Aldridge was very warmly received.
Lindfors's book has a number of useful appendices, including a detailed itinerary of Aldridge's thirty-three-month tour, giving the dates he spent in particular cities and the number of performances he gave in each; a list of the plays Aldridge performed (including dates of each performance); as well as the names of Aldridge's company members and the continental actors with whom he performed. Also fascinating are the many images Lindfors includes. Several come from playbills or promotional posters held in a variety of research libraries, but a number of the lithographs and sketches of Aldridge are from the author's own collection. Perhaps the most noteworthy image is a sketch of Aldridge in whiteface as Macbeth in Bern. As a meticulously researched study with superb supplementary materials, Lindfors's book is a very valuable historical resource.
In some ways, Lindfors's great strengths as a historian also lead to the most significant weaknesses of the book. He relies upon contemporary letters, playbills, and historical newspapers (translated from a variety of languages by a large team of translators), as well as a wide range of scholarly monographs. However, significant portions of the book are taken up by quotations from these sources, which, although usually vividly written, can become tedious due to their sheer number. Additionally, Lindfors rarely theorizes the effects of Aldridge's performances in Europe, instead, for the most part, simply presenting chronological history. In fact, the best theoretical analysis of Aldridge's performance as Mungo comes not from Lindfors but from a critic from Solothurn, whose 24 June 1854 review, which Lindfors quotes, deftly analyzes the aesthetic and cultural effects of Aldridge juxtaposing performances of the tragic hero Othello with the comic fool Mungo. Most problematically, Lindfors so admires the subject of his book that at times history verges on hagiography. Lindfors acknowledges but skims over Aldridge's faults—his womanizing and infidelity to his wife, who accompanied him on tour, his drinking before and during performances, and his repeated dismissal of his company members. Instead of more deeply interrogating the personal and professional complexities of a man who was certainly a virtuosic actor and advocate for a new cultural perception of racial difference, Lindfors insists on seeing Aldridge as “a thoughtful, considerate, and kindhearted man” (144).
Despite these problems, the book will be extremely valuable to a wide range of scholars because of Lindfors's detailed research. Those focusing on African American actors, Shakespearean performance in continental Europe, or nineteenth-century theatre in general will find this book most welcome. Lindfors's clearly presented and engaging history, filled with vivid contemporary accounts of the reception of Aldridge's work, could also make his book of significant interest to a general audience of theatre enthusiasts.
