No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2004
It is impossible to write a review of Gaining Ground without resorting to superlatives. This is the most meticulously researched and lavishly illustrated (and heaviest) book I have ever reviewed. The subtitle, A History of Landmaking in Boston, refers to the leveling of hills and filling of bays that contributed to Boston's growth. Nancy Seasholes documents this process on a year by year, wharf by wharf, block by block basis. Maps, drawings, and photographs depict the changes.
The book is the result of the author's involvement in archaeological assessments, part of the environmental review process required of urban construction projects. One of the tasks in Boston is to determine whether the land is original or made land. If the latter, it has to be determined “when it was filled, why, by whom, how, and with what” (p. ix). The book, based in part on Seasholes's dissertation, covers “the various parts of Boston Proper but also the Fenway and Bay State Road areas, Charlestown, East Boston, South Boston, and Dorchester” (p. ix).
The Shawmut peninsula on which the Puritans settled was 487 acres. Roughly 500 acres have been added, largely by filling tidal flats. Nearby communities have grown in a similar fashion. Landmaking was facilitated by the Colonial Ordinance of 1641 that defined the rights of shoreline property owners as including the flats to the low-tide mark (p. 21). The demand for wharves (later railroads and airports) was one major reason for made land, especially at those times Boston felt it was losing trade to New York City. The demand for a place to live (especially during the Irish immigration of the 1840s) was a factor, as was pollution from wastewater disposal.
The first chapter provides a general overview; the second chapter, a discussion of landmaking technology. Although the technology always involved building a perimeter structure and filling behind it until the level was above the high-tide mark, there were changes over time in “the perimeter structures, the foundations on which they were set, the methods used to excavate, transport, and deposit the fill, and even the fill itself” (p. 13). Thereafter, the book is organized geographically, with the chapters each organized (roughly) chronologically. Each chapter begins with a map showing the part of modern Boston under discussion with the 1630 shoreline superimposed.
The simplest way to provide the flavor of the book is to provide an (edited) excerpt from the middle of Chapter 9.
… in January 1833 a group of lawyers, merchants, and businessmen formed the South Cove Corporation for the express purpose of filling the flats between Sea (the Free Bridge) and Front Streets in order to provide land for the terminals of the railroads then being built to Boston from Worcester and Providence…. In April 1833 the South Cove Corporation paid the railroad a bonus of seventy-five thousand dollars and agreed to sell it land in South Cove for merchandise … and passenger depots.
In April 1833 this land did not exist, however, and had to be created by filling. The South Cove Corporation had originally planned to purchase and fill the entire seventy-seven acres of wharves and flats bounded by Front, Essex, and Sea Streets and the South Boston Bridge …, but even before the project began the corporation decided not to undertake so much and to fill only about as far south as Orange (now Herald) Street….
Filling of South Cove began in May 1833. To obtain fill the corporation had purchased eighteen acres of marsh about a mile away at the south end of South Bay … and a three-acre gravel hill in Roxbury, also on South Bay. Scows brought the mud and gravel to South Cove (p. 246).
A short review cannot cover all this book has to offer; there are gems lurking in every chapter. For example, the first railroad in the United States was part of the Mount Vernon project (1805) and was used to carry gravel from the top to the flats (p. 138). And Logan Airport was named after a South Boston judge who was never in an airplane but had a wife interested in aviation (p. 377).
The book closes with an “Afterword” that amplifies three problems identified earlier in the book. First, falling groundwater levels, at least partially due to more efficient wastewater disposal, have led to rotting foundations in some of the filled areas. Second, the fill in some places has led to flooding in others that were not originally filled above the high-tide mark. Finally, even though the last major earthquake was in 1755, it remains true that the extensive (and expensive) capital developed on filled land is at greater risk.
Gaining Ground is packaged as a coffee table book, and it should find its way to the coffee tables of all those interested in Boston history. Others, particularly those interested in urban development, will find it rewarding because the issues Seasholes addresses are common to many cities. Among these are concerns about growing concentrations of bridges and railroads and the need to develop public land to accommodate public buildings (e.g., Faneuil Hall and the Custom House) and public space (e.g., Charlesbank-the Esplanade-Storrow Drive and Frederick Law Olmsted's Back Bay Fens). Gaining Ground is an encyclopedic work that can be consulted with profit in whole or in part. We are indebted to Nancy Seasholes.