Theodore Roosevelt left an ambiguous and challenging legacy. The twenty-sixth president is widely remembered as a socially and environmentally progressive “trust-buster” and conservationist whose policies were designed to contain the excesses of early twentieth-century American industrial capitalism. On the other hand, his racialized outlook on nature and conservation, expressed with settler colonial justifications, and his often contradictory perspectives on the rights of labor and big business make it difficult to unreservedly embrace one of the most dazzling chief executives in U.S. history as an icon of progressivism. The books under review here afford a closer look at two key areas of Roosevelt’s political profile and legacy: industrial capitalism and conservation.
Susan Berfield’s The Hour of Fate explores the Roosevelt administration’s response to trusts and economic concentration in the early twentieth century. The author, an investigative reporter for Bloomberg Businessweek and Bloomberg News, focuses her analysis on the relationship between Roosevelt and J. P. Morgan, the quintessential financier of trusts in turn-of-the-century America. Berfield centers her book squarely on the government’s case against Northern Securities, a Morgan-organized trust of the Northern Pacific Railway, and the 1902 Anthracite Coal Strike. Neither Morgan’s global shipping project (International Mercantile Marine) nor Roosevelt’s responsibility for the development of the Panama Canal play a role in her study, which ends with Roosevelt’s victory in the 1904 presidential elections.
The advantage of Berfield’s concentration on Roosevelt’s first term is the great detail with which she explores both the antitrust case and the coal strike. The trust case especially often receives only cursory treatment, but the author’s talent for a good story turns a potentially turgid subject into an empirical, textured, and fast-paced narrative. The book’s sixteen chapters are organized in two parts: part one provides foundation and context and pivots with the contest between Morgan and Roosevelt in the early years of the latter’s presidency. Individual chapters explore biographical similarities between the two, such as their privileged upbringing, family dynamics, cosmopolitan outlooks, and health challenges. The reader also learns a great deal about the complexities of trust formations, the context of the 1890 Sherman Antitrust Act, the history of labor unrest, and the interrelationship between railroad developments and economic concentration.
Despite some shared experiences, Roosevelt and Morgan arrived at diametrically opposed perspectives on the social responsibility of big business and its relationship to government. While Morgan favored doing business outside of the public limelight, Roosevelt interpreted the government as the ultimate arbiter of the public interest and thus advanced an interventionist agenda during his presidency. According to Berfield, “Roosevelt was a new kind of president. He believed that American capitalism needed a guiding hand. So did Morgan. Each assumed it should be his own” (9).
Despite their opposing interests, both also shared a surprisingly consistent fear of civil unrest and a desire for order. Berfield highlights those outlooks in the book’s second part, which covers the 1902 Anthracite Coal Strike and the spread of labor of unrest that made Roosevelt and Morgan temporary allies. The author interprets the president’s personal arbitration attempt as a transformative moment in the relationship between business and government. Previously accustomed to their monetary and personal influence in politics, big business now found its special interests sidelined and overpowered by an interventionist president whose quest for a “square deal” enjoyed widespread public support. According to the author, “Roosevelt had decided to use the force of his personality to try to broker a compromise, and just like that, decades of alliance between government and industry came to an end” (171–72). But the coal mine operators met this arbitration attempt with a recalcitrant attitude, and only the administration’s engagement of Morgan’s influence cleared the way for a compromise. Publicly, however, Roosevelt reaped the credit for ending the coal strike.
For Berfield, Roosevelt’s regulatory efforts represented a milestone in the effort for economic fairness in America. Her nuanced study clearly demonstrates Roosevelt’s desire for responsible government, concern about business excesses, and focus on order in a polity faced with widespread socioeconomic tensions. But the book’s evidence also points to the uncertain utility of Roosevelt’s approach as a historical blueprint for contemporary regulatory policies in at least three ways. First, Roosevelt’s threat of military intervention after the failure of his personal mediation attempt in the coal strike was reflexively impulsive, bellicose, and authoritarian. Secondly, his paternalistic attitude toward labor and business and his desire for recognition as the ultimate arbiter hardly qualified him as an inclusive mediator of diverging interests. Finally, his distinctions between moral and immoral business practices elevated his own intuitive judgment above the provisions of antitrust regulations. In this context, Roosevelt’s unwillingness to further engage trusts organized by Morgan, such as U.S. Steel and International Harvester, casts doubt on his consistency as stretched the boundaries between political pragmatism and a grateful accommodation to Morgan for services rendered.
Such ambiguities in Roosevelt’s record are also visible in his views on nature and conservation, as a new anthology, Theodore Roosevelt: Naturalist in the Arena, edited by Char Miller and Clay Jenkinson, amply demonstrates. Miller, a professor of environmental analysis at Pomona College, and Jenkinson, founder of the Theodore Roosevelt Center at Dickinson State University, have assembled a wide range of essays on the biographical, political, ecological, literary, and commemorative dimensions of Roosevelt’s engagement with nature and make an important contribution to the robust historiography surrounding Roosevelt and the environment. The volume provides the reader not only with a kaleidoscopic overview of the centrality of nature to Roosevelt’s life, but also with a nuanced inroad into the often composite and contradictory nature of his environmental thought and action.
The volume’s eleven essays are grouped into three parts. The first explores Roosevelt’s role as a naturalist by examining his work as a scientific observer, collector, and curator. Individual contributions analyze his collecting of specimens, extensive nature writing, ornithological accomplishments, and love of Rock Creek Park in Washington, DC. The essays in this section highlight “that natural history was not a hobby for Roosevelt—it was absolutely central to the meaning of his life and activism” (xvi).
But Roosevelt’s engagement with nature was not a solitary affair, as the essays in the collection’s second part underline. Roosevelt’s environmental thought was shaped and sharpened by his close interactions and cooperation with leading American contemporary conservationists, such as George Bird Grinnell, Gifford Pinchot, John Muir, and William T. Hornaday. The essays in this section reconstruct the intellectual currents and political communities of turn-of-the-century conservation and help trace their influence on Roosevelt’s political worldview. The essay by Char Miller on Gifford Pinchot rightfully reminds the reader that, while Roosevelt is commonly lauded for the expansion of natural reserves, such expansion was made possible through the dispossession of Indigenous polities in his administration’s aggressive interpretation of the General Allotment Act of 1887. Conservation and Indigenous dispossession were deeply intertwined.
Roosevelt’s interpretations of natural history, his experience of nature, and his conservationist agenda intersected with his perspectives on social and political organization at the national and international levels. Observations of the natural world inspired much of Roosevelt’s commentary on the political world, a connection critically examined in the book’s third and final part. Such attention is key to any exploration of the ambiguous dimensions of Roosevelt’s environmental legacies. And while Roosevelt’s conservation efforts are rightfully recognized as forward-looking today, these essays’ nuanced analyses remind us of his often racialized, Darwinian understandings of civilization, immigration, and international trade. Eugenics, race, civilization, and conflict were inextricably entwined with Roosevelt’s interpretation of the natural environment and his understanding of national cohesion and global integration.
Fittingly, the collection’s final essay, by Clay Jenkinson, explores the question of public memory and commemoration. The author underlines that, despite Roosevelt’s humble dislike of commemorative statues of himself, “Roosevelt is the best memorialized president in American history. … The list of what might be called Roosevelt shrines in America is very long and very impressive” (218). Jenkinson’s observations on Roosevelt’s “monumental footprint” are relevant, although the list became just a bit shorter when New York’s Museum of Natural History decided, in the summer of 2020, to remove the Roosevelt statue ensemble at its main entrance owing to its racially hierarchical composition. That decision is part of the broader quest for a more nuanced understanding of Roosevelt, one that praises his accomplishments without ignoring his deeply contradictory perspectives on inclusion and exclusion, equity and difference. In this context, the two books under review illustrate constructive angles for the ongoing exploration of Roosevelt’s record and legacy on conservation, capitalism, and the challenges of industrial modernity.
