This book has much to offer on a timely topic. Relying on an abundance of primary and secondary sources on European history, as well as recent research and surveys, authors Brent F. Nelsen and James L. Guth forcefully argue that the two major confessional cultures are important determinants of support for integrating Europe. The authors are well aware of the secularizing trends across Europe and of the European Union’s efforts to avoid ties with any one religion. Yet, they carefully lay out the historical differences between the Protestant and Catholic confessional cultures’ support for European unity, and they offer evidence that the influence of these cultures remains remarkably resilient.
The book is divided into four main parts. The opening section introduces the overriding thesis that a Catholic confessional culture has long offered support for more European unity whereas the Protestant confessional culture has given priority to the sovereignty of individual nation-states. Much of the chapter, however, is devoted to making the case for culture as an important explanatory factor, and then stressing the importance of forming a cultural and national identity. Here they note that religion can deeply permeate a culture even when the culture has become highly secularized.
The second part of the book lays the historical foundation for the formation of two distinct cultures. For some, this section will offer more historical details than desired, for others this rich and detailed discussion will be the heart of the book. The authors argue that even when many of the formal supranational institutions and governing operations of the Catholic papacy were reduced following the Reformation, the authority of the pope within the Catholic Church was actually heightened. As a result, they argue that Catholics retained a desire for a cultural and spiritual unity that went beyond national boundaries. In contrast, the authors write that “Protestant organization never achieved an international dimension” (p. 81) and that Protestant Europe “never attained the transnational cultural unity of the Catholics” (p. 118).
Building on this historical base, the third part of the book traces the rise and dominance of the Christian Democrats from 1945 to the early 1970s in the six founding member states of the European Community. Drawing on diverse sources, they review how the small Catholic parties of the interwar era evolved into the most powerful political parties in Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Luxembourg, and the Netherlands. Although the parties quickly shed any single confessional identity, Nelsen and Guth document that these parties retained the support of the Catholic Church and that voters’ church attendance remained one of the best predictors for support of the Christian Democratic parties. But most significantly for the thesis of this book, they review how Christian Democratic parties developed transnational networks and how they became “crusaders for a united Europe” (p. 157). Throughout this section they contrast the Christian Democratic vision with that of the Protestant nations: the one stressing European unity and renouncing the sovereignty of the state, the other acknowledging a need for cooperation while stressing the power of free markets and the importance of the national identity.
The fourth and final section of the book will no doubt be the most contested. Taking us into the growing European Community of the late 1970s, the authors draw on several data sources and research studies to argue that the confessional cultures remain influential even in highly secularized Europe. At the national level, they document that it is the Protestant nations that continue to resist efforts to integrate more fully. At the group level, they note that the Catholic Church continues to be a strong supporter of increased integration and that Catholic groups and organizations are well represented in Brussels. Finally, they cite Eurobarometer data of individuals to conclude that the “[c]onfessional culture (as measured by self-identified religious tradition) has a significant effect on attitudes toward integration, even under rigorous controls for other factors” (p. 321). Yet, the authors also acknowledge that in more recent years, the dividing lines are not always so clear. An increasing number of Protestant groups are showing support for integration and an increasing number of Catholic groups and leaders are showing reservations about the new European nation. Despite some non-confirming findings, however, the authors conclude that the two confessional cultures remain strong predictors of support for a united Europe.
The authors open the book by acknowledging that few readers, if any readers, will find it surprising that the Protestant nations of northern Europe are more resistant to unifying efforts, or that the Catholic nations of southern Europe are more supportive. Likewise, they are well aware that the reasons and motivations for unity go far beyond the confessional cultures. Yet, they are unrelenting in their argument that the confessional cultures are an important determinant in the support given for integrating Europe.
The evidence they presented for their thesis is far more compelling than I expected. From the reformation to recent events, they effectively trace how the confessional cultures have shaped support for integration. Moreover, they go beyond vague notions about cultural ideas, beliefs, and attitudes to show how transnational organizations, movements, leadership, and political parties helped fuel Catholic support for integration. The arguments presented will not replace the materialist arguments explaining support for European unity, and the persistence of these confessional cultures will no doubt be challenged by future research, and should be. That being said, the authors make a convincing case that the confessional cultures are an important explanatory factor that should not be ignored. We are indebted to the authors for a well written and carefully researched book.
