Since the 1990s scholars have been challenging the myths of the modern nation-state in the Balkans. The reasons for the violence that erupted in the region at the end of the 19th century (or in the 1990s), they have claimed, are far more complex than the basic fact of “different” people living side-by-side. Unfortunately, in making these points, scholars have largely ignored the considerable archival resources available in Istanbul. With Blood Ties, Ipek Yosmaoğlu succeeds where others have failed. Over six information-rich chapters, she harnesses hitherto neglected primary resources to develop valuable corrections to the Macedonian part of the larger late 19th-century Balkans story.
Covering the period between 1878 and 1908, Yosmaoğlu reconsiders how competing interests, including those of the “Great Powers,” directly affected the experiences of people living in “strategic” regions. In doing so, she convincingly challenges scholarly conventions about the religious, sectarian, and linguistic “differences” purportedly afflicting the region. Drawing heavily on Stathis Kalyvas’ theory of how political violence forges social and political identities, Yosmaoğlu claims that these “differences” were actually “constructed and compounded” during a period of transformation inaugurated by the empire's defeat to the Russians in 1877. After this war, violence in the Balkans became the “ultimate catalyst” for intercommunal differentiation. It is here that Yosmaoğlu is especially convincing. She explains how leading up to 1908 the manipulative use of violence by certain parties resulted in the formation of what she characterizes as “patterns of fierce dissociation.”
Laying the groundwork for the emergence of this violence are three well-written chapters in which Yosmaoğlu explains her underlying theoretical points. The author usefully identifies a number of reifying epistemologies—reinforced by cartographic conventions, education (which she assumes is a means to indoctrinate members of society), and narrowing spiritual associations—that introduced, for example, new notions of territoriality with the arrival of modern methods of “mapping” the region's cultural diversity (pp. 79–130). The subsequent struggles between competing interests wishing to gain exclusive access to these regions were often the same well-documented skirmishes between “Bulgarians and Greeks” over Orthodox Church property and cultural resources. As Yosmaoğlu rightly argues, these battles over the minutia of modern diplomatic practice transformed the sociopolitical setting for “mixed” Ottoman subjects.
Such detailed tabulations lead, however, to an unclear accounting of the extent to which the subsequent violence in a particular corner of Macedonia contributed to the disaggregation of a previously mixed Ottoman society. Yosmaoğlu actually does little to link the impact of the European-imposed practices discussed at length in the first three chapters to the day-to-day experiences of violence in Ottoman Macedonia. Undoubtedly, her well-documented cases in the second-half of the book successfully illuminate the contentious phase of life experienced by Orthodox Christians living in one corner of Macedonia. But this robust and dense study is missing an explanation of how cartographic conventions and the sociological categories around them, for example, actually informed the actions of the “rebels/bandits” behind many of the violent events prior to 1908.
Perhaps part of the problem is that the book is almost exclusively focused on events in the district of Serres, straddling what is today the shared border of Bulgaria, Greece, and the Republic of Macedonia. This narrow geographic focus in the critical evidence-building phase of her work leaves Yosmaoğlu to make arguably overstated claims about the universal application of her observations. One way around this methodological problem would have been to better integrate the work of others exploring similar issues in other parts of the Balkans. George Gavrilis, Tolga Esmer, Robert Zens, Milen Petrov, Safa Saraçoğlu, Nathalie Clayer, Maurus Reinkowski, and others have done wonderful work on the contentious politics that shaped the Ottoman Balkan territories. Similarly, Ussama Makdisi, Thomas Kuehn, Keith Watenpaugh, and Michelle Campos have looked at the larger “Middle East” and the manners in which “difference” contributed to the trajectory of the empire. Finally, Ivo Banac, Theodora Dragostinova, Mary Neuberger, Sabrina Ramet, and Maria Todorova have produced revisionist scholarship on 20th-century Balkan identity politics. These authors’ studies of post–World War I ethnonational regimes highlight how certain practices Yosmaoğlu identifies in the 1878–1908 period are fully implemented as state policies in order to produce ethnically pure post-Ottoman societies.
One might also quibble with the author's decision not to explore events leading to the revolt in the neighboring Manastır province in the summer of 1908. As suggested by the popular support of this “Young Turk” revolution (and the subsequent countercoup in 1909), many inhabitants of the Balkans (and elsewhere in the empire) still envisioned a future in which “union” as much as “progress” reigned supreme. Only after the wars of 1912–13, and perhaps the implementation of the League of Nations’ policy of encouraging “population exchanges,” did the destruction of the previous social order for which Ottoman subjects were still willing to die take place. In this light, any attempt to analyze how and why the empire's social fabric rips apart requires some reflection on the actual effects of full-scale war and subsequent campaigns of ethnic cleansing conducted by the post-Ottoman states after 1908, the year in which Yosmaoğlu ends her study.
Despite these issues, Yosmaoğlu has unquestionably produced a most welcome addition to the scholarship on violence in the Balkans and its links to long-term social organization patterns. Blood Ties should be part of any reading list covering the Balkans’ often-violent modern history because of the insights its author draws from a close reading of Ottoman sources and a wealth of photos and maps. These resources have helped Yosmaoğlu chart the rise of separatist sentiments among hitherto neighborly Orthodox Christian (and, by extension, Muslim) Ottoman subjects, a process especially interesting for graduate students exploring questions of state formation, violence, and communalism.
