Politicians' pursuit of power often has gendered dimensions and implications. Latin America, where historically we have seen political strongmen and machista attitudes combined with strong and often overstepping executive branches, is a particularly apt region in which to explore the influence of gender on politicians' discourses and strategies when they seek to gain and maintain power. The two books under review, spanning the past century and covering dictatorships, democracies, and “populist” regimes (often a hybrid of the two), address these dynamics. Gwynn Thomas's book examines the centrality of family and gender in the images and discourses of the Right and Left in Chile during the tumultuous years of socialist democracy under Salvador Allende, the military coup and dictatorship of Augusto Pinochet, and the transition to democracy (1970 to 1990). Karen Kampwirth's edited volume examines the relationship between populism and gender, and chapter authors cover leaders from the 1930s until today, from a multitude of countries in Latin America.
The basis of Thomas's research is an interesting insight: While Chilean politics between 1970 and 1990 is often portrayed as highly polarized, “familial beliefs represented a set of underlying shared assumptions on which both conflict and consensus were built” (p. 10) on both left and right. In Contesting Legitimacy in Chile, Thomas constructs a conceptual framework of four interrelated analytical categories that capture, she argues, the dominant ways that familial beliefs were invoked in political conflicts: 1) the Familial State, defined by the way the fundamental responsibilities of the state were shaped by familial beliefs, 2) the Familial Nation, defined by the role of family in the metaphorical understanding of nation, 3) the Patriarchal Leader, defined by the way that the roles and responsibilities of political leaders were determined by familial beliefs, and 4) Militant Families, defined by the role of familial beliefs in shaping citizens' political identities and justifications for political action. Seeking “to understand the constructed nature of social reality” (p. 25), and drawing on newspapers and magazines, presidential speeches, press releases, some congressional debates, and TV ads, Thomas uses these categories to empirically analyze the patterns of familial discourse and imagery (“visual text”) used by political actors.
Thomas does a nice job of weaving a narrative of familial discourse on both the Right and the Left, and the text is highly readable. Both sides (and in the 1970 campaign, in the center) promoted the ideal of a traditional nuclear family in their campaigns, and promised to be the best agents to protect, promote, and provide for this family type. Both attempted to portray the other as a grave threat to the family; the Right focused more on physical threats to family security, and the Left more on material threats to family welfare. By the 1988 plebiscite, the Left was focused on the human rights abuses of the military regime and the difficult material conditions of poor families, while the Right was warning of a return to chaos and insecurity if Pinochet did not continue in power.
Pictures can convey a thousand words, and Thomas has chosen some fascinating campaign material to illustrate her argument. Particularly chilling, in hindsight, is a campaign ad by a right-wing women's group (Acción mujeres de Chile) from August 1970, with the title “Where is the father … ?”; a mother and son sorrowfully gaze at each other and the underlying text warns that in communist countries, men are imprisoned, sent to concentration camps, and “disappeared” for having disagreed with the government (p. 69). A month after the coup in 1973, when the military regime itself was busy imprisoning and making people “disappear,” the main pro-regime newspaper published a picture of a woman blissfully jumping into the air with her arms open (“Woman: Today you can dream, the fatherland has a place for your children” [p. 145]).
The book is a valuable contribution to scholarship on gender and Chilean politics. That said, it could be improved in two ways. While its take-home message—that family discourse in its various manifestations is central—is convincing, its analysis could have been condensed and used as a point of departure to systematically examine both the causes and/or the effects of this focus on the family. Why was there such a focus on the family by political actors, and what were the political consequences of this focus? Presumably, political contenders perceived that in the Chilean context, using the organizing principle of a traditional family to highlight their promises and/or accomplishments and their opponents' weaknesses was a necessary or winning strategy. Did using familial discourse in specific ways give certain political actors more leverage and tip the balance in political outcomes? What about its impact on policies? As it stands, these sorts of questions are not systematically answered.
Further, Thomas's use of extant literature could have been broader. She relies heavily on English-language secondary sources, although there is an extensive literature in Spanish on this crucial and contested period of Chilean history (Sergio Bitar's Chile 1970–1973 [1995], Tomás Moulián's Chile actual: Anatomia de un mito [1997], Augusto Varas and Felipe Agüero's El proyecto político militar [1984], and numerous books by Manuel Antonio Garretón, to name just a few). Also, while stating that it is outside her scope, the author criticizes the gender and welfare-state literature, which, she claims, focuses “on motherhood and maternalist discourses, and does not look at the family in its own right” (p. 10, n. 19). However, an extensive literature since the 1990s discusses the ways in which regimes seek to promote different family types (Nancy Fraser, Janet C. Gornick, Jane Lewis, Juliana Martínez Franzoni, Marcia K. Meyers, and Diane Sainsbury are just a few of the scholars not mentioned). I think the insights of this literature could have helped situate the Chilean case in a broader, comparative perspective. Finally, in the conclusion, Thomas moves straight from the late 1980s to an analysis of the election of Michelle Bachelet in 2006, omitting the intervening 16 years of democracy, during which the impact of “pro-family” framing on political debate and policies has been well analyzed.
Kampwirth's Gender and Populism in Latin America takes on not only political discourse and strategies but also political policies. Her well-crafted introduction lays out the key themes of the book: the relationship of populism to gender over time (from the “classic populists” of import substitution industrialization to the “neopopulists” of the 1990s and the “radical populists” of today, Venezuela's Hugo Chávez being the quintessential example); images of masculinity and femininity promoted by populist leaders; the uneasy relationship of populism with democracy; the relationship of populist leaders to feminists; and finally, women as followers of populists. The ground the book seeks to cover is broad, and most of the chapters, many by historians but also by sociologists and political scientists, speak to only one or a few of the themes.
Given that populist leaders seek to include the traditionally excluded, there is an opportunity to mobilize women and to promote “feminine” or even “feminist” interests, as Kurt Weyland notes in his excellent foreword. Indeed, as the chapters show, several of the classic populists supported women's suffrage (for example, Lázaro Cardenas in Mexico, Getúlio Vargas in Brazil, and Juan Perón and his wife, Evita, in Argentina); the neopopulists of the 1990s promoted gender quotas (for example, Carlos Menem in Argentina and Alberto Fujimori in Peru); and the so-called radical populists enshrined gender equality into their constitutions as they revamped them (for example, Chávez in Venezuela and Evo Morales in Bolivia). On the other hand, their discourse has often been traditional and reflective (rather than ahead) of the times that they live(d) in, and in all cases, unsurprisingly, relations with organized feminists have been tense.
The chapters cover interesting ground. Worthy of note are Stéphanie Rousseau's excellent comparison of gender politics under Morales's “populism from below” and Fujimori's “populism from above,” as well as Jocelyn Olcott's comparison of Cárdenas's courting of women's support (presuffrage) with Luís Echeverría in the 1970s; both chapters highlight the complexities of simultaneously promoting women's rights while trying to contain the independent mobilization of women.
Other chapters focus more on political supporters. On Nicaragua, Victoria González-Rivera's interviews of somocista women (those who supported the dictator Anastazio Somoza), on the one hand, and Kampwirth's analysis of the former revolutionary leader and current president, Daniel Ortega, on the other hand, reveal the personalistic bases of both leaders' support. Even while Ortega opportunistically morphed into a Catholic who outlawed therapeutic abortion, with deadly consequences for poor women, his ardent followers continue to see him as “the president of all the poor” (p. 173). The chapters by Gioconda Espina and Cathy A. Rakowski and by Sujatha Fernandes shed light on the strength of Chávez's hold on power in Venezuela and the depth of his following, especially among women: “[I]t was Chávez who awoke the woman. He gave us importance, value” (p. 211).
Karin Grammático's comparison of gender discourses of the first Peronism (1946 to 1955) to the radical Montoneros in the 1970s speaks to Thomas's work. Perón declared in 1973: “We have to save the family, which is in danger” (p. 133), strikingly similar to the rhetoric across the Andes at the time. Both Grammático and Thomas show how left and right, populist and nonpopulist, democratic and dictatorial used the discourse of a “crisis in the family” to justify their political projects. Since Chile's political leaders are not considered populist, this leads to a key question I have with the edited volume: How exactly do we distinguish a populist from a nonpopulist, and what is specific and unique about populists' relationship to gender?
With this in mind, it would have been helpful to have a clearer, consistent definition of populism throughout the volume (for example, Weyland's succinct definition of populism as “characterized by personalistic leadership and a noninstitutionalized, unmediated relationship to an ample mass following” [p. vii]). As it stands, some authors, more usefully, use political definitions, while others use economic ones, and some none. For example, while Michael Conniff's discussion of three women in Brazil “who campaigned for themselves or for others using populist techniques” (p. 110) provides some interesting material, a “populist technique” is nowhere specified. A clearer definition is not irrelevant; whether there is something unique to this type of leadership (whatever it exactly is) and its relationship to gender versus that of liberal democrats or other types remains unclear.
In sum, both books are welcome additions and, given the less charted terrain, they pose intriguing questions as much as they provide answers, challenging scholars of the region to use these analyses as points of departure for further research.
