For eighteenth-century naturalists, vision was the primary sense for investigating nature. Books such as Linnaeus's Philosophia Botanica from 1751 exhibited the results of a highly specialized practice of observation and representation. Illustrated books were essential accompaniments, teaching readers how to systematize their lookings at the natural world. In Linnaeus's case, text and images functioned together to direct attention to specific characteristics, the better to aid the user in categorizing different plants into specific groupings based on similarities in physical structure.
The importance of visual training was not, of course, an exclusively eighteenth-century concern, although the chapter on Linnaean natural history in the collection under review will be of particular interest to BJHS readers. There are nine chapters overall, each examining processes of visual ‘enskilment’ in different professions and academic fields, with a particular focus on how practitioners become expert observers in their domains. Sight is not the only sense considered, however; rather, each case study positions sight in a multisensory practice that is, moreover, intricately connected to local and national contexts. Additionally, many of the authors consider how technological devices mediate visual experience. Befitting the volume's aims, the contributors come from several different scholarly backgrounds, including anthropology, sociology, cultural studies and the history of science, technology and medicine. Together they build upon recent scholarship in the anthropology of the senses to develop a more refined approach to understanding vision as a culturally situated means for interpreting and explaining the world.
The book is divided into three sections. The first three chapters look at examples of skilled vision within rural and urban settings, with a particular emphasis on aesthetics. Rane Willersley discusses his ethnographic experience with the Siberian Yukaghir people and explores the culturally distinctive visual perspective of these indigenous hunters, who, when stalking prey, see themselves as becoming part of their surroundings. Here is a markedly different understanding of sight from Western cultural interpretations. Editor Cristina Grasseni examines cattle-breeding practices in northern Italy and considers how farmers and breeders emphasize specific physical characteristics in cattle by using videos, pamphlets and toys to construct prototypical images of ‘healthy’ and ‘beautiful’ cows. The third chapter in the trio – arguably the least relevant for historians of science – is by Francesco Ronzon, who discusses transvestite culture in Verona and how vision and mimicry are central aspects of drag-queen performances.
The second set of chapters examines the role of ‘gestuality’ (non-verbal forms of body communication), especially in relation to concepts of design. Arguing that medicine in Western society is dominated by an ‘ocularcentric paradigm’ (p. 91), Simon Cohn shows that paradigm at work in the training of medical practitioners, who gradually learn to diagnose patients by being taught to discern the specific visual characteristics that distinguish one illness from another. Wendy Gunn's chapter looks at skilled vision within artistic and architectural workspaces, exploring the multifaceted nature of practitioners' engagements with their environments and how gesture, speech and graphic expression work together in shaping practice. David Turnbull uses the examples of the makers of the London Underground map and the architects of Chartres Cathedral to demonstrate how skilled practitioners transform complex heterogeneous designs into comprehensible homogeneous conceptions, arguing that an individual's way of seeing is shaped by ‘dominant technologies of vision and representation’ (p. 126). According to Turnbull, thanks to the iconic Tube map, we literally see the London Underground differently than we otherwise would.
The three case studies making up the third section discuss the relevance of skilled vision for scientific and medical training and practice, taking into consideration the social and political ‘situatedness’ of sight. Barry Saunders looks at radiological training and the role of apprenticeship schemes, emphasizing the importance of medical technology in enhancing the visual experience of specialists. Daniela Bleichmar's chapter on eighteenth-century natural history and skilled vision is the gem of the book. Beyond showing how Linnaeus's works served as instruction manuals (as noted above), she considers the significance of selectivity for naturalists' descriptions – the deliberate suppression of certain qualities in their representations of specimens – and generally helps the reader understand how complex and active a process was Linnaean observation. In the final case study, Andreas Roestorff looks at neurological imaging experiments, and considers how laboratories and workspaces can improve the visual skills needed for successful neurological science of this kind.
Skilled Visions pursues a worthwhile goal, and deserves serious attention from historians interested in scientific practice and the role of observational expertise – what it is and how it is acquired. That said, the volume is let down by its presentation. It is a difficult read for scholars new to the anthropology of the senses. In many cases the contributors assume that the reader has a strong foundation in social anthropology and cultural theory. As a result, many of the articles make passing reference to other sources on skilled vision with minimal elaboration, and use inaccessible language which takes away from the flow of the text.
