Regenerative medicine became a hot topic in the last decade, attracting the attention of the public and creating huge media hype about stem cells. A stark confusion ensued, with different countries following different strategies in order to regulate research in this domain. The focus has been mainly on the controversial ethical status of human embryonic stem cells (hESC), leading to the adoption of laws that put several constraints on researchers. This book puts in a comparative perspective current regulations in Italy and Germany, framing the topic within a larger historical picture. The latter is provided by two very interesting reconstructions by Ariane Dröscher and Christina Brandt. Dröscher's chapter focuses on the very words used in defining the object of regeneration research, i.e. stem cells, from the mid-1800s to the 1950s. From an early start in botany (in the form of the word ‘meristem’), through the primordial organism envisioned by Ernst Haeckel, to use in describing ontogenesis and regeneration from the end of the nineteenth century onwards, ‘stem cell’ has had a series of meanings. According to the research context, the words identify a different object: Dröscher counts eleven different uses of ‘stem cell’, each one contributing to shape our current perception of the biological entity now at the basis of regenerative medicine and at the centre of bioethical debates. The biological object ‘stem cell’ is, in fact, multifaceted, and the second essay in this volume points in this direction, exploring the several ‘histories’ of stem cells, and dealing with the dichotomy between continuity and discontinuity. Can contemporary stem cell research be traced back in time as a unique research field developing over time? The answer is negative; multiple reconstructions can be made, stressing different aspects. For example – and this is an interesting feature of Brandt's chapter – the ‘reversibility’ concept can be used as a guide, especially in the second half of the twentieth century (though the concept may be traced back to regeneration studies in the late nineteenth century), drawing a theoretical path along which to follow the evolution of stem cell research.
The two historical essays precede two sections devoted to the analysis of the bioethical and political debate staged in Germany and Italy in the last decade, roughly from the year 2000 to 2010. Many differences between the two countries make the comparison worthwhile: Germany, for example, shows an evolution over time, while the Italian bioethical approach appears to have been frozen in the same situation since 2003, and only court trials have been challenging the constraints on hESC research and medical practices for IVF and abortion. The first chapter about the German case is in fact devoted to the debate that took place between the year 2000 and 2008 about the modification of the Stem Cell Law regulating research on human embryonic stem cells: the main worry was about a ‘breach of the dam’ (a more catastrophic version of the slippery-slope ethical argument) leading to unlimited use of human embryos. The debate, involving several public actors and stakeholders, eventually ended in a peaceful and cautious liberalization, thanks to many compromises, that made research with human embryos possible after a broad consensus was reached. The juridical aspects of the matter are analysed in the detailed chapter authored by Jochen Taupitz, explaining the rationale for the establishment of a cut-off date for the import of hESC lines, and its subsequent alteration, and how the emotional charge of this research object was part of the debate. The state of research on hESCs in Germany is further detailed in the chapter by Anna M. Wobus and Peter Löser. The two authors describe how current legislation has affected the development of this scientific domain, resulting in a ‘relatively small’ (p. 187) number of publications by German scientists on both hESCs and human induced pluripotent stem cells. Yet research bodies have continuously supported these lines of research, so that in Germany, ‘with respect to international developments, research on hESCs has further expanded’ (p. 187).
The final chapters are devoted to the Italian case. In this country, legislation has not been subject to a reform since the Law No 40 passed in 2004 that put a strong emphasis on the juridical and moral status of the embryo. Lorenzo Beltrame's chapter deals with the media debate that preceded and followed the law, showing the co-production of the bioethical discourse by the actors involved. A very important move was the shift of the discourse from the different views of society to the therapeutic promises of hESCs. Technical issues thus obscured the deeper meaning of the fight. The same endpoint is registered by Giuseppe Testa's essay, with a more specific focus on the behaviour of the researchers involved. Both these essays are explicitly based on Sheila Jasanoff's idea of ‘civic epistemology’, and this perspective provides useful insights in framing the debate. Yet some other aspects are not encompassed in the analysis – namely the peculiar Italian political scenario, the competing political and financial interests of the various actors, and broader cultural aspects (for example the deeply embedded sexism of Italian society). Luca Marini's final chapter brings to light one striking peculiarity of the Italian situation: the dogmatic approach of the bioethicists. This is clearly the result of the Catholic stance towards ‘non-negotiable values’, allowing no room for compromise or constructive dialogue among the various players involved. This dogmatic attitude further resulted in the construction of straw men to which an ethical stigma was attached, and managed to embody a moral perspective within Italian legislation, disrespectful of other bioethical approaches and seriously constraining research and even misdirecting clinical practice.
Overall, this collection of essays is a very welcome comparison of scientific and bioethical trajectories. The distinct historical flavor of the first two essays is complemented by the sociological attitude of the subsequent national-level analyses. The various chapters boast sharply defined – albeit diverse – perspectives. As such, they raise several interesting questions, at the national level as well as in constructing a more ‘global’ history of stem cell research. Furthermore, this diversity is in itself an important starting point for future research, confronting students with a multidimensional knowledge space to be explored from several possible approaches.
