The official state narrative of the emergence of modern Turkey, much like other nationalist accounts, is one of courage, perseverance, and suffering. This story typically starts at the end of the 19th century with a description of the sad state of the Ottoman Empire, which had long suffered at the hands of the European powers and duplicitous sultans. At the brink of financial collapse, the Ottomans were soon thrown into World War I. Military defeat coupled with the sultan's treacherous acts expedited the end of the Ottoman Empire and the partitioning of its lands among the Allied powers. According to the official narrative, the suffering inflicted on the Muslim populations by the Greeks and the Armenians deepened the crisis of this period. Yet, Mustafa Kemal and his nationalist followers led and mobilized the (Muslim) people of the land to fight back in unison and with nationalist zeal, and consequently the occupying powers were forced out. Anatolia came once again under the control of its true owners, the Turks. This nationalist narrative—which is still well and alive in Turkey—is powerfully challenged at a number of key points by Gingeras’ Sorrowful Shores.
Sorrowful Shores is an analysis of the South Marmara region in northwestern Anatolia during a critical historical period spanning from the Balkan Wars (1912) to the promulgation of the Turkish Republic (1923). Drawing on documents from the Ottoman and republican archives as well as memoirs and newspapers, Gingeras’ examination unfolds in a chronological fashion, and it pays particular attention to four communities in the region: Armenians, Greeks, Albanians, and Circassians. By the turn of the 20th century, the Armenian and Greek communities were active in the region's economic life especially as farmers and traders. In the aftermath of the Balkan Wars, these local Christian groups were blamed for the loss of Ottoman territories and faced mass killings, forced relocations, and dispossessions. Albanians and Circassians, on the other hand, were relatively recent immigrants to South Marmara and were “both counted among the highest-ranking officials and officers as well as the most insidious bandits and rebels” (p. 2). It is this particular background these two Muslim groups shared that, according to Gingeras, is critical to our understanding of their experiences and involvement during the years of intercommunal violence.
One of the main contributions of Sorrowful Shores is the advancement of a carefully documented narrative of the local actors’ actions and motivations. The attempts at modernization and centralization that were initiated by the late Ottoman as well as the early republican political elite have been relatively well researched. What was actually happening at the local level, however, remains relatively obscure. By shifting the lens of inquiry from the state to the provincial actors at the local level, Sorrowful Shores delivers a nuanced and complex picture of the early 20th century in the South Marmara region. In his efforts to explain the root causes of the violence in the area, Gingeras skillfully demonstrates the shifting interactions between the state and societal actors. He brings the provincial actors to life instead of assuming them to be passive recipients of state violence or manipulation.
The history of South Marmara that Gingeras narrates is essentially that of the late Ottoman and early republican states’ efforts to consolidate their power over imperial and national territories, respectively. This process, which entailed the use of violence by the Young Turk and republican political elites, impacted the lives of both the non-Muslim and Muslim populations in the region. For example, in the account of forced relocations during World War I, the book provides a detailed description of the fate of the Albanian population as well as that of the Greek and Armenian communities that were dispossessed.
In Sorrowful Shores the political elites in power are not the only culprits of the violence and the consequent suffering that prevailed in the region. In fact, the substantive chapters of the book are dedicated to demonstrating the involvement of (mostly Muslim) provincial paramilitary groups, the rivalries between them, and their changing relationship with the Young Turk cadres, leading to the heightening of this violence. From the rise and collapse of the Young Turk hegemony to the Greek occupation of the region, and from the emergence of loyalist/pro-sultanate opposition to the strengthening of the nationalist movement, Gingeras lucidly reveals how the provincial paramilitary groups shifted their alliances according to the changing political contexts. The responses of the Circassian community illustrate these shifts as well as the divergences within that community: some of its members, including local notables, would side with the Young Turk regime and later would ally with the nationalist movement against the occupying powers. Others, such as Ahmed Anzavur and his followers, who had worked for the Ottoman's secret service Teşkilat-ı Mahsusa at the outbreak of World War I, would fight with the proloyalists and against the nationalists between 1919 and 1920. In accounting for the proloyalist insurgency in the region, Gingeras emphasizes that loyalism in the region did not signify devotion to the sultan, but rather was “grounded in the rage and hardship experienced by thousands of individuals victimized by the Committee of Union and Progress rule” (p. 83). Furthermore, Gingeras contends that the nationalist narrative that emphasizes Greek and Armenian paramilitaries and bandits wreaking havoc in the region is only partially substantiated by the historical record. The documents reveal that the activities of the Muslim paramilitary groups had an equally devastating impact on the civilian population.
Another important contribution of the book follows from Gingeras’ analysis of the motivations of the political elite and local paramilitary groups. Looking at the former, he argues that the forced relocations of Greeks, Albanians, and Armenians by the Committee of Union and Progress during World War I cannot be solely explained by nationalism. Rather, limiting his conclusions to the South Marmara region, he explains that the actions of the political elite were tied to security concerns (p. 43). Regarding the infighting of local Muslim paramilitary groups, Gingeras dismisses ethnic differences as the cause. He also convincingly challenges official accounts that portray the actions of these groups against the state as backward or reactionary. Rather, the motivations of these local actors were intimately tied to their pursuit of assuming ultimate power and control over the region. Consequently, Gingeras argues, the intercommunal violence in South Marmara can also be best described as a political conflict.
Sorrowful Shores is a meticulously researched and convincingly argued book. Gingeras raises a number of significant points pertaining to the relationship between the state and local actors and the ensuing social and political consequences for local communities, which resonates beyond the confines of Ottoman–Turkish studies. He also addresses important questions of the state's differential treatment of ethnic communities, the differing interactions of ethnic communities with the state, the social origins of paramilitary groups, and the role (and limits) of ethnicity, religion, and nationalism as forces in explaining the actions of provincial actors. Even though the book does not purport to answer all of the questions it raises, it certainly provides the reader with some suggestions for the direction of future research. Sorrowful Shores is definitely a must-read for scholars who are interested in state and nation building in general and the transformation of the Ottoman Empire to the republic in particular.
