This book, not previously brought to notice in a scholarly journal as far as the present reviewer is aware, provides an annotated listing of the excavations carried out in the central Indian state of Madhya Pradesh (now divided into two states, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh). The area covered is huge – more than 400,000 sq km – and the excavated sites are very many in number. The book has four lengthy chapters titled: 1. Archaeological Background, 2. Prehistoric Sites, 3. Proto-historic Sites, and 4. Historic Sites. This is followed by a bibliography, index, some illustrations and two appendices on radio-carbon dating in central India and ostrich egg-shell sites in central India. The quality of illustrations in Indian publications is rapidly improving but those in this book are somewhat disappointing, hinting, like the whole book itself, at the wealth of information that needs more detailed study.
Although the book easily gives an impression that all excavations conducted in Madhya Pradesh have been included, those interested in the subject should also consult S. G. Bhatt, (ed.), Narmada Valley Culture and Civilisation, Special Number, The Journal of Academy of Indian Numismatics & Sigillography XXI-XXII, 2006–07, published from Indore by the Academy of Indian Numismatics and Sigillography, and R. K. Sharma, (ed.), History, Archaeology and Culture of the Narmada Valley (Delhi: Sharada Publishing House, 2007). Attention may also be directed to Pankaj Rag, Faiz Ahmad Kidwai and O. P. Mishra, Cultural Heritage Of Narmada Valley (Spl. Reference to Hoshangabad) (Commissioner of Archaeology, Archives and Museums: Bhopal, 2007). All appeared after the book under review but include a number of excavations conducted before 2003 that have not been listed by Sharma and Mishra.
This is, of course, primarily a reference book to which scholars will refer when they want to know which sites have been explored and what has been said in the published notices. The location of each site is given, so any targeted archaeological research in central India will necessarily begin with this book (coupled with the other publications just mentioned). The volume under review will be essential for any archaeological library and the authors are to be commended for the labour they have undertaken to assemble the relevant information.
On examining the hundreds of sites that have been explored over the last five decades, some of them very important, the most striking feature is that publications are limited to a few short paragraphs in journals like Indian Archaeology – A Review. In some cases more information is given, but the general and correct impression is that while archaeologists love to dig, they have no appetite for writing their reports. There are a number of exceptional cases, for example Dungawada (pp. 99–100 in the volume under review), but these are exceptions that prove the rule. One hears that pressure is mounting to print the reports, but not much has been produced to date aside from several books that have appeared thanks to Dr Mishra's efforts in the Department of Archaeology, Museums and Archives in Bhopal. The reason for this is structural. In the Archaeological Survey of India budgets are assigned each year for excavation, so excavations are done. If budgets are not used, they are lost, so archaeologists are “still digging”, to borrow from the title of a little book by Mortimer Wheeler published in 1955. The situation is exacerbated by the fact that archaeologists in India are allowed to take their write-up into retirement and receive a pension supplement to finish the work. This is bound to subvert the intended effect: instead of encouraging completion, it will guarantee delay. The report will not be done in service and no rational human being will take a pension cut. Indeed, there is no incentive to finish whatsoever and so far nobody has figured out how to a make dead archaeologist write a report. History shows that most prefer to die rather than write.
Although a case might be made to rescue the reports and publish them, there is a deeper question about the worth of the work. Wheeler, who has just been mentioned, reformed the Archaeological Survey as its Director General from 1944 to 1948. The techniques established in his time are practically unchanged within the Archaeological Survey (university-based archaeologists and those in some state departments are more progressive). The approach of most archaeologists listed in the book under review can be gauged from the summaries which show that excavated finds are classified using established chronological and typological frameworks, i.e. those first developed in the time of Wheeler and elaborated very slightly after his time. In other words, there is an existing set of periods, Chalcolithic, Pre-NBP, NBP, Sunga/Satavahana and so forth, and these are imposed, cookie-cutter style, on whatever material is found. There really is no reason to excavate (apart from spending the budgets) because the chronological framework will always be the same. The significance of the book reviewed here is thus easily missed. In listing almost all of the excavations that have been done, and quietly noting that many reports need to be written, this publication is bound to become the factual foundation on which any reform of archaeological practice in India is going to be based.
