Daniel Horowitz's contribution to the University of Pennsylvania's series on The Arts and Intellectual Life in Modern America is both a timely and a powerful one. The developed world remains as uncertain as it has ever been about the nature and the very point of fast economic growth – when, that is, their governments can secure any. This book reveals that those interstices between prosperity, consumption, image and human fulfilment have been there since popular capitalism's astonishing takeoff in the mid-twentieth century. Horowitz's book represents another welcome guide to the tangles and conflicts commentators have got themselves into over the past sixty or so years. How seriously should one treat the torrent of “ersatz” or “kitsch” artefacts poured out in cinemas and magazines? More and more colourful and interactive televisions? Faster cars? A seemingly infinite range of digital music? These uncertainties still trouble us, and a map laying out the manner in which they always have troubled us is a welcome new resource.
In Consuming Pleasures, Horowitz paints a vivid picture of just how wide-ranging and disputatious American intellectuals' reactions to these dilemmas became. From Charlie Chaplin's ironic and playful attacks on political and social hierarchies, to the pop art of the Independent Group and its ambivalence towards the modernity its members at once celebrated and detested, from the hot desert nights full of cars Tom Wolfe so enjoyed to the sociologist Herbert Gans's view of cultural identities as a form of capital in themselves: the cacophony and the vitality of intellectual life in the English-speaking Atlantic is here laid bare. That transnational sense of intellectuals' actual physical movements is also made real, rather than simply talked about and gestured towards – the fate of many books less well informed than this one. In Consuming Pleasures a really vigorous sense of the transnational movement of ideas is encapsulated in the Frankfurt school's flight from Nazi Germany, and their subsequent influence in the United States, or Stuart Hall's move from Jamaica to Britain. The production itself is a solid one. The index and the footnotes are very helpful, critical in such a wide-ranging book; the subheadings identify each author or group of authors in turn. The illustrations – for instance a picture illustrating Marshall McLuhan's attack on the objectification of women's bodies, or a Time cover from 1952 which juxtaposed young women in swimsuits with “First Pictures – Atom Blasts through Eyes of Victims” – are very well chosen indeed.
What Horowitz also offers, and here he comes into his own, is a series of intellectual pen-portraits of such luminaries as the Frankfurt school philosopher Jürgen Habermas, the architect Reyner Banham, the anarchic libertarian futurist Marshall McLuhan, the feminist Susan Sontag, and many others along the way. It is an increasingly popular schema, obvious in such disparate works as studies of mid-twentieth-century diarists for the public research group Mass Observation to the historical geographer Miles Ogborn's Global Lives, which tracked a few representative Britons through the chaos of their early global empire. In this particular part of his project, Horowitz proves his status as a master of not only the written word, but the silences; not only the thread in the web of academic interconnections, but the spaces too. Take, for instance, his treatment of Bernard Rosenberg and David Manning White's 1957 collection Mass Culture, treated here by Horowitz as a forebear of the more serious treatments of consumerisms that were to emerge in the years to come. Here were not only Theodor Adorno's more radical essays left out – those that denied even the potential of this force to mobilize ideas and feelings “from the bottom up” – but conservative British views, from Matthew Arnold to T. S. Eliot, were also effaced. Mass Culture, as Horowitz makes clear, hovered rather uncertainly between fear and grudging acceptance of the new “admass”: what the editors left out, rather than just what they said, makes his point for him.
Sometimes the constant toing and froing of intellectual debate becomes a treadmill of one book after another. The background to the text, the extraordinary economic and social transformation of the United States which was changing almost everything in ordinary citizens' lives – might have been foregrounded a little more often. One rather misses the sense of audience, of sales figures, of the presumed reader all these experts were trying to aim at, of “impact” – if one dare use the word at a time when it has been misappropriated by bureaucrats. Horowitz reports here how writers (for instance Walter Benjamin) constructed audiences' reactions to Chaplin films, rather than his tumultuous reception itself. Other histories of the literary world's engagement with the public sphere – Jonathan Rose's recent The Intellectual Life of the British Working Classes comes to mind – have paid attention to grassroots views of academic writing concerning mass culture. Here the masses are quieter, befitting, of course, an unashamedly intellectual history, but at least Horowitz's subjects' views of their intermediary readers might have been more systematically examined.
This is, even so, a very good book, a storehouse of enormous knowledge, the results of long research, full of rewarding and bracing comparisons, cognizant of thoughtful lives lived, not only in long study, but in relation to other thinkers and doers as well. The public may not often impinge upon its deliberations, but the global world of troubled grappling with the consequences of mass prosperity is evoked with a forceful clarity. The reader takes long draughts of tough, directed prose, and comes up invigorated and enlightened. One cannot say that of every academic book on the topics of consumption or pleasure – facts which make the book a deep pleasure in itself.
