Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T06:03:02.963Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Analytical model of the linear Richtmyer–Meshkov instability when a shock is reflected

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 November 2025

Juan Gustavo Wouchuk*
Affiliation:
University of Castilla La Mancha, Ciudad Real, Spain (retired)
*
Corresponding author: Juan Gustavo Wouchuk, gustavo.wouchuk@uclm.es

Abstract

The Richtmyer–Meshkov instability (RMI) develops when a planar shock front hits a rippled contact surface separating two different fluids. After the incident shock refraction, a transmitted shock is always formed and another shock or a rarefaction is reflected back. The pressure/entropy/vorticity fields generated by the rippled wavefronts are responsible of the generation of hydrodynamic perturbations in both fluids. In linear theory, the contact surface ripple reaches an asymptotic normal velocity which is dependent on the incident shock Mach number, fluid density ratio and compressibilities. In this work we only deal with the situations in which a shock is reflected. Our main goal is to show an explicit, closed form expression of the asymptotic linear velocity of the corrugation at the contact surface, valid for arbitrary Mach number, fluid compressibilities and pre-shock density ratio. An explicit analytical formula (closed form expression) is presented that works quite well in both limits: weak and strong incident shocks. The new formula is obtained by approximating the contact surface by a rigid piston. This work is a natural continuation of J. G. Wouchuk (2001 Phys. Rev. E vol. 63, p. 056303) and J. G. Wouchuk (2025 Phys. Rev. E vol. 111, p. 035102). It is shown here that a rigid piston approximation (RPA) works quite well in the general case, giving reasonable agreement with existing simulations, previous analytical models and experiments. An estimate of the relative error incurred because of the RPA is shown as a function of the incident shock Mach number $M_i$ and ratio of $\gamma $ values at the contact surface. The limits of validity of this approximation are also discussed. The calculations shown here have been done with the scientific software Mathematica. The files used to do these calculations can be retrieved as Supplemental Files to this article.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Incident shock and contact surface, before shock refraction at $t = 0$, in one-dimensional geometry. $U_1$ is the fluid velocity behind the incident shock.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Initial tangential velocities at both sides of the contact surface, after shock refraction at $t = 0+$; two-dimensional geometry.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Behaviour of $|J_{c}(q_b)|$ as a function of $q_b$ for the parameters indicated.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Contour of integration $C$ in the complex plane, used in (8.1).

Figure 4

Figure 5.(a) Comparison of the function $P_{r1}(q_b)$ defined in (8.11) with the corresponding Bessel series (5.11), for the gases and Mach number indicated. The quantity $P_{r0} = \lim _{q_b \rightarrow 0} [\lambda _{b1}(q_b)]$ (b) A similar comparison, but for the function $J_r(q_b)$, defined in (6.12) and in (7.1), $J_{r0} = \lim _{q_b \rightarrow 0} [J_r(q_b)]$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Bromwich contour used to invert the Laplace transforms $P_r, P_t$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Blue continuous line is the function $\hat {p}_r(r_b)$ obtained after inverting (8.11) in the complex plane for the parameters indicated. Besides, the red, empty circles are calculated with the Bessel series given in (50).

Figure 7

Figure 8.The black continuous curve is calculated with (10.1). Red circles are from figure 7 of Yang et al. (1994), for the gases and shock Mach number indicated. The horizontal dashed black line is the terminal velocity $u_c^{\infty }$ calculated with (9.34).

Figure 8

Table 1.Ripple terminal velocities as given by (9.31) and the numerical simulations by Yang et al. (1994). The upper number in each entry is the result of this work and the lower one is the result shown in Table 1 of Yang et al. (1994). The adiabatic exponents are: (a) $\gamma _a = \gamma _b = 1.1$, (b) $\gamma _a = \gamma _b = 3.0$, (c) $\gamma _a = 3.0, \gamma _b = 1.5.$

Figure 9

Figure 9.Terminal velocity as a function of shock strength $s$ for the gases indicated. Blue line is given by (9.31). Black dashed line is Fraley’s formula, (13.2), and red, empty circles are from figure 11 of Yang et al. (1994).

Figure 10

Figure 10.Terminal velocity as a function of shock strength $s$ for the gases indicated. Blue line is given by (9.31). Black dashed line is Fraley’s formula, (13.2), and red, empty circles are from figure 11 of Yang et al. (1994).

Figure 11

Figure 11.Blue line is $u_c^{\infty }$ given by (9.31). Green, empty circles are given by the impulsive formula, and the black, dashed line is the third order expansion of $u_{\textit{irrot}}$ which can be found inside Supplementary materials.

Figure 12

Table 2.Comparison between $u_c^{\infty }$ and $u_{\textit{FC}}$ for the air–SF$_6$ configuration.

Figure 13

Table 3.Comparison between $u_c^{\infty }$ and $u_{\textit{FC}}$ for the air–CO$_2$ configuration.

Figure 14

Table 4.Comparison between $u_{c}^{\infty }$ and $u_{\textit{FC}}$ for the Ar–Xe configuration.

Figure 15

Table 5.Comparison between $u_{c}^{\infty }$ and $u_{\textit{FC}}$ for the He–air configuration.

Figure 16

Figure 12.Contact surface ripple velocity as a function of time for the gases indicated with $M_i = 1.45$. The horizontal dashed line is the terminal velocity, $u_c^{\infty }$. The area between $u_c(\tau _b)$ and $u_c^{\infty }$ has been shaded to properly follow the discussion in the text.

Figure 17

Figure 13.Contact surface ripple amplitude as a function of time for the experiments of Vandenboomgaerde et al. (2014). Red continuous line is the solution given by the Bessel series, while the black dashed line is the asymptotic scaling (14.11).

Figure 18

Figure 14.(a) Contact surface ripple amplitude as a function of time for case 1 of Vandenboomgaerde et al. (2014) which has $\psi _0 = 0.306\, \text{cm}$. Blue empty circles are the experimental measurements. Black solid line is $\psi _c$ from (14.8). (b) Same as (a) but for case 2, for which the experimental measurements are shown as green empty circles.

Figure 19

Figure 15.Reduced amplitude $Y_c$ plotted against dimensionless time $X_c$, according to (14.10) for the experiments of Vandenboomgaerde et al. (2014).

Figure 20

Figure 16.Ripple amplitude growth for the experiments shown in figure 4 of Liu et al. (2018). Black line is our prediction (14.8).

Figure 21

Figure 17.Reduced ripple amplitude amplitude growth for the experiments shown in figure 4 of Liu et al. (2018). Dashed, red line is our prediction (14.10).

Figure 22

Figure 18.Ripple amplitude growth for the conditions of figure 9 of Latini et al. (2007).

Figure 23

Figure 19.Reduced ripple amplitude $k (\psi _c-\psi _{\infty })$ for the same conditions as in figure 18.

Figure 24

Figure 20.(a) Post-shock ripple amplitude $\psi _0^*$ as a function of $s$, for the gases indicated. (b) Offset amplitude $\psi _{\infty }$ as a function of $s$ for the gases indicated.

Figure 25

Figure 21.Absolute value of the relative error $\eta _c$ as a function of the incident shock strength $s$ for three different values of $\varGamma = \gamma _a/\gamma _b$: case 1 is for $\gamma _b = 1.1$, and case 2 is for $\gamma _b = 1.5$. Inside each case, three curves are shown for different values of the ratio $\varGamma = \gamma _a/\gamma _b$, in which black curve (a) has $\varGamma = 1$, black curve (b) has $\varGamma = 2$ and red curve (c) has $\varGamma = 10$.

Figure 26

Figure 22.Value of $|\eta _c|$ as a function of $\varGamma$, for $\gamma _b = 1.1$, and three different incident shock strengths, as indicated in each panel. In each case, (a) corresponds to $s = 1/100$, (b) to $s = 1/10$ and (c) to $s \sim 1.0$.

Figure 27

Figure 23.Longitudinal component $u(x)$ of the velocity field for the gases indicated, as function of $x$.

Figure 28

Figure 24.Tangential component $v(x)$ of the velocity field for the gases indicated, as function of $x$.

Figure 29

Figure 25.Vector plot of the asymptotic velocity field inside both fluids for the pre-shock parameters indicated.

Supplementary material: File

Wouchuk supplementary material

Wouchuk supplementary material
Download Wouchuk supplementary material(File)
File 388.5 KB