In the spring of 1944 I was asked to join an all party Parliamentary Delegation organised by the Empire Parliamentary Association to visit our opposite numbers in Australia and New Zealand. The object of the exercise was to strengthen Empire ties at the Parliamentary level. The delegation was to consist of British and Canadian Parliamentarians, who would be the guests of the Australian and New Zealand Parliaments. The British Delegation was led by a senior Conservative member of the House of Commons, Colonel Wickham,Footnote 280 and, as I was the only representative from the Lords, I was asked to act as the Deputy Leader. This arrangement also helped to keep the balance between the parties.
We were meeting our Canadian colleagues in New York. We left Glasgow on April 5th, but did not arrive until April 13th, as the zig-zagging northerly course took us seven and a half days. Our ship was a converted luxury liner, armed against submarine and air attacks.
New York and Washington
We were greeted on arrival by the Australian Trade Commissioner, who deposited us at the Gotham Hotel. We were told that our Australian meat-boat had been held up for repairs, so we were likely to stay in New York for two or three weeks. We were warned by our Secretary, Sir Howard d'Egville,Footnote 281 to keep off the Presidential election, as many Republicans felt about Roosevelt as the Duke of Northumberland felt about Lloyd George after his Limehouse speech.Footnote 282
We found that he had also informed Congress of our arrival, and that Senator Connolly [sic],Footnote 283 Chairman of the prestigious Foreign Relations Committee of the Senate, had summoned a meeting of Senators and Congressmen to greet us in Washington. Wickham, Summers,Footnote 284 Butcher,Footnote 285 SummerskillFootnote 286 (our sole lady member), and myself were packed off to represent the delegation at the capital.
The following morning we went off to the British Embassy to meet Halifax.Footnote 287 The only interesting news was that Cordell HullFootnote 288 had already drafted official proposals for a post-war peace-keeping organisation (later the U.N.). Halifax had advised that these proposals should be disclosed to the Senate before we were informed, so that the State Department could say that no foreign power had been consulted. I did not have the feeling that Halifax was the right man for Washington. He had obviously been dumped by Churchill to get him out of the Foreign Office. It was no good telling the Americans that India was none of their business, which he said was his stock answer. He was not such a good ‘mixer’ as Lothian,Footnote 289 his predecessor, and Americans like good ‘mixers’. But Sir Gerald Campbell,Footnote 290 the Minister at the Embassy, told me he was more popular than when he first arrived, because he had lost a son in the war.Footnote 291
We went on to a very satisfactory meeting with the Congressmen and Senators invited by Senator Connolly. They were all equally friendly, but I was astonished how little some of them knew about this country. Had the British Parliament got two Chambers? Was the Lords still more powerful than the Commons? However, there was probably just as much ignorance at home about their parliamentary system.
We were all invited onto the floor of the Senate on the following morning, where we walked about and chatted while a debate was actually in progress. We were chaperoned by the Republican Senator BurtonFootnote 292 of Ohio who explained the informality of the proceedings. Most of the speeches were intended for publication in the local press, but there was genuine debate about important subjects like post-war co-operation or foreign policy.
At lunch, misgivings about us were fired point-blank. What about India? What about Palestine? Luckily I had been forewarned about their pre-occupations. After lunch our Congressman host took us round the House Office Building. He showed us the two spacious offices, where his two secretaries were hard at work. I doubt whether any legislature in the world had better facilities or a larger budget. The following evening we were asked to a dinner party given by Walter NashFootnote 293 at the New Zealand Legation. An excellent party, including Mr FraserFootnote 294 (the Prime Minister of New Zealand) and his wife, en route for the Prime Ministers’ conference in London. I had a long talk with Fraser after dinner. He was rather long-winded and less clever than Nash. He favoured more frequent meetings of Dominion and U.K. Prime Ministers in different capitals, and periodic meetings between Dominion and U.K. Foreign Secretaries. Following the example of Australia, he wanted a permanent Imperial Secretariat with headquarters in London. Remarkably prophetic!Footnote 295
Taking a little time off in the National Gallery, I ran into a party from the Embassy including the Archbishop of York (Temple)Footnote 296 among the Italian Primitives. We saw him later at a lunch given by the English Speaking Union, a huge affair with several hundred guests. He spoke with moving simplicity about the spirit of the Russian people and the devastation of Europe. There was a roar of applause when he finished, and the following day the press ran riot with ‘Right Honourables’ and ‘His Graces’ – one paper even describing him as ‘Primate of all-England’. Poor old Canterbury!Footnote 297 The Americans were really touched by his humanity.
I pulled off one sensational press story whilst I was in Washington, maddening for my colleagues as it filled the columns of the morning press the very day after they had delivered important speeches.
When I went to bed my first night at the Waterman Park Hotel, I put my shoes outside my bedroom door, as I would at a London hotel, expecting that they would be picked up and cleaned in the morning. As they had not turned up at 10.00 am, I phoned the housekeeper to find out what had happened. She told me, quite rightly, that I left them in the passage at my own risk, that shoes were rationed, and that I would be lucky to recover them. But I had not brought a second pair of walking shoes, and with no coupons it would be impossible to buy a pair. Without them I would be immobilised in the hotel for the day, and faced the prospect of going back to New York by train in a pair of antique carpet slippers. In desperation I phoned d'Egville. He did not seem at all pleased to hear about my sartorial crisis. His only somewhat curt advice was to phone the Embassy. I hesitated. I was a British subject in distress, but was lack of footwear sufficiently distressing to enlist the sympathy of the Embassy? At that moment there, was a knock on the door. I opened it. There stood a young man with the missing shoes. They had been found in another passage. I suspect the housekeeper had threatened the boys on my floor with the sack unless the shoes were returned immediately. I told Tom Wickham the story. He told the Press. The next morning it appeared on the front page of the morning papers as startling evidence of the hardships of wartime Britain, where even a Lord comes over with shoes so shabby and down at heel that the hotel staff thought he had left them out intending that they should be thrown away! Anyway, this was the news-story that put the British Parliamentary Delegation on the map in Washington.
Having paid our respects to Congress in Washington, we returned to New York. I remember particularly a delightful luncheon party at Lady Gosford's pent-house in Park Avenue. Mildred GosfordFootnote 298 was a very old friend of my mother. She used to come to London quite often, having married an Irish Peer. But she and her husband had separated, and she now lived in New York, where her father, Mr Carter, a wealthy banker, had smoothed the path for a smart social life. She had immense charm, wit, and beauty, and enjoyed a life of hospitable and cultured ease. It was a small party, and the star guests were the playwright Granville-BarkerFootnote 299 and his wife. He was a great raconteur, and told a splendid story about Churchill and Clemenceau.Footnote 300 Churchill, who was proud of the fact that he had just been elected as an Elder Brother of Trinity House,Footnote 301 wanted to tell Clemenceau of his recent distinction. So he said in his bad French ‘Je suis devenu le frère ainé du Trinité’. To which Clemenceau replied ‘Quelle responsabilité’.Footnote 302
Lady Gosford immediately capped this story with another. Clemenceau met an English political figure at a party, and asked him what he meant by saying that he was about to celebrate his golden wedding. He replied: ‘You see this lady beside me – she and I have been living together for 50 years’. ‘Oh’ said Clemenceau, ‘Of course, and now you are going to marry’.
I soon realised that the word ‘politician’ was slightly derogatory, and that admiration and respect went to the well established and highly successful business community. I was therefore very pleased to be asked to lunch at Morgan's in Wall Street, where I had an introduction from Stafford CrippsFootnote 303 to one of the partners, Tom Lamont. I waited in his private office, which was covered with framed letters from Lloyd George to Pierrepont [sic] MorganFootnote 304 thanking him for lending Britain money in the first world war. It was a most interesting lunch, with Whitney, Luffingwell, and other members of the Board. There was a sudden hush in the conversation when I said I was a ‘Labour’ whip in the Lords. But it picked up again immediately, and nowhere did I learn more about America than from my charming, courteous, and highly intelligent hosts.
I had a special affinity for the Lamont family, whom I met later at their home, as their son CorliusFootnote 305 was a fellow socialist and had written a book on the subject. I heard a lot about the Stock Exchange, and I was struck by the use of Federal taxation to check speculation by varying the amount of the tax according to the length of time an investment had been held.
I met Norman Thomas,Footnote 306 the socialist candidate for the presidency, with Roger Baldwin,Footnote 307 the champion of human rights. Thomas lectured me as if at a public meeting, and was not afraid of unpopularity by advocating a negotiated peace. It was also good to see an old personal friend, the historian Barbara Tuchman.Footnote 308 I had met her first in London during the Spanish Civil War, when she came over to Europe to support the Republican cause. She was an excellent speaker, and already engaged in writing history. She won the Pulitzer Prize soon after her return with her book on the first world war: ‘The Guns of August’. She had the remarkable gift of popularizing without distorting history.
On April 28th we finally sailed for Australia on the Sydney Star, a cargo boat of 15,000 tons with passenger accommodation. Our party consisted of us, three Canadian parliamentarians (Conservative, Liberal and CCFFootnote 309), and four Dutchmen going out to do war work. We were loaded with a cargo of explosives, so we hoped to avoid trouble with submarines. We were packed like sardines, three in a cabin, an extra bunk being fitted above the others. I shared with Tom Wickham and Spencer Summers. It grew steadily hotter as we went south, but an electric fan kept the cabin cool enough to sleep at night, though the portholes were blacked out.
The Pacific lived up to its name, calm and sunny, some porpoises and flying fish to watch from the decks, and, a few days out of Panama, our first albatross. There is no more beautiful bird to watch, as it glides over the waves without even moving its wings, and skims so close to the surface that it seems almost a miracle that it does not crash into the water. They followed us all day, and came onto the deck for scraps. They seemed never to feel fatigue, and it is this apparent lack of effort that lends such supreme grace to their movements. I won the sweepstake on the time of crossing the equator, and stood the whole crew bottles of beer for lunch. The Southern Cross was disappointing, like a crucifix, with four sham diamonds. But some magnificent sunsets. ColeridgeFootnote 310 was wrong about green being peculiar to English sunsets. But, of course, a long sea journey is dull, and I read all my books, some of them twice, and was reduced to bridge and deck games. The guns were not manned, thanks to our radar, then a novelty, which detected an empty case of oranges floating half a mile away. We only ran into one gale, in the Tasman sea off the coast of New Zealand, when the spray was driving right over the decks, and we all stayed below.
The whole journey from New York took 29 days, a week to Panama and 22 days from Panama to Sydney. What a lot people miss in these days of air travel.
Australia
We berthed in Sydney Harbour on June 4th. On June 7th we dined at the Australia Hotel with Sir Thomas GordonFootnote 311 to meet some business magnates. They seemed pleased that Britain had brought the whole wool clip for the duration and one year afterwards at 15 % above the pre-war price. We went on to Canberra and visited a station of 7000 acres, which gave us a fair idea of the staple wool industry. The capital had been planned for a population of 50,000, and was only inhabited by about 12,000. There was no trade or industry, and it had the Federal Parliament but only part of the Federal Administration. Several government departments had their headquarters in Sydney or Melbourne, and some ministers had homes elsewhere. The tug-of-war between the States and the Federal Government had left the capital without the grandeur or prosperity of a capital city, though in a wonderful setting of mountain scenery in the heart of the continent.
At the state dinner in the Parliament Buildings, I had the good luck to sit next to Mr Chiffley [sic],Footnote 312 the Commonwealth Treasurer at that time and, of course, a future Prime Minister. He was a railway trade unionist of genuine working-class origin, with a first rate brain and no interests to distract him from his job. Our High Commissioner, Sir Ronald Cross,Footnote 313 told me he rarely attended social functions. He was the Minister in charge of post-war reconstruction, and seemed to think a lot could be done to improve the social services, such as housing, if only agreement was ultimately forthcoming from the State Governments.
The highlight of the evening was a fine speech without notes from the grand old man of Australian politics, ‘Billie’ [sic] Hughes,Footnote 314 then over 80. I was a little surprised that MenziesFootnote 315 and FaddonFootnote 316 were heckled by their political opponents, in spite of their long and dignified record as elder statesmen. Fifty senators and members of the House of Representatives had come to Canberra expressly for the occasion.
On June 14th we left Sydney by air for Melbourne. Crossing the Australian Alps we missed Kosciusko, the highest peak, on account of thick cloud, but had a splendid view of snow-covered mountains as we passed over them. We were taken from the airport to the Menzies Hotel, and we lunched at Parliament House with members of the Victoria Legislature. There was a ‘hung’ Parliament, with a coalition between the UAPFootnote 317 and Country Parties, and the Labour Party [sic] was in Opposition. I replied to Premier Dunston [sic]Footnote 318 with a short speech on Britain in wartime. He wanted legislation to give more powers to the Commonwealth Government, and, after the war, massive immigration and industrial expansion. There was a Lord Mayor's reception in the afternoon. The impression was one of intensive patriotism exuding ‘Britishness’ from every quarter.
In the next few days I visited several arms and aircraft factories. On June 16th I met Sir Isaac Isaacs,Footnote 319 the first Australian Governor-General of Australia, having been before that Chief Justice. He was 89 and still deeply concerned about the Jewish problem and the need for a common home for the Jews, although he was not a Zionist. He was essentially more of a scholar than a politician.
At dinner I met a number of British and Australian military leaders, including Admiral Sir Guy Royal [sic],Footnote 320 Commander-in-Chief of the Australian Naval Forces in the South West Pacific under General MacArthur.Footnote 321 I was glad to get an impression of McArthur from a close colleague, as I was expecting to meet him later at Brisbane. He told me that McArthur had two distinct personalities: theatrical and tough before press and public, while in private he was a quiet, clear headed, staff officer with an amazing grasp of strategy. As he did not get on well with Admiral Nimitz,Footnote 322 he was planning his offensive against Japan without him. McArthur's view was that the allied strategy should be more ‘island hopping’ to eliminate Japanese aerodromes and bases between New Guinea and Japan. Japanese pockets in South East Asia could then be left to starve or die of malaria. November 1942 had in fact been the turning-point of the war in the Pacific, the Japanese having given up the offensive after their defeats in the Coral Sea and Midway, but they would fight on until the invasion of Japan itself. Australians have never forgotten that, earlier in 1942, Japanese submarines got among their coastal shipping, and sank 7 ships with iron ore between Whyalla and Newcastle.
Lieutenant General Northcote, Chief of Staff to General Blamey,Footnote 323 said that the number of Australian Army and Air Force personnel in the South Pacific was slightly larger than that of the Americans – 500,000 to 450,000 – and that most of the land fighting had been done by the Australians. They all seemed to like Prime Minister Curtin,Footnote 324 and he was even liked by McArthur. On July 9th we lunched with Prime Minister Curtin at the Canberra Hotel. He had a rather disconcerting cast in his left eye, which made you uncertain about whether he was looking at you. He said he wanted unassisted migrants from Europe after the war, but did not agree with the trade unions about excluding migrant labour. He would accept any nationality other than German. He was in favour of reciprocal arrangements for admission to full benefit of social services, including pensions, though this would mean a financial loss to Australia and gain to Britain. It was clear now that Britain would no longer be able to protect Australia and New Zealand without the support of the United States.Footnote 325 But Britain should still speak for the Empire, and carry more weight on matters of foreign policy and defence with the support of the Dominions. He would like Australia associated with the shaping of imperial policy in Europe as well as in the Pacific, which would depend on the fullest possible exchange of information and consultation on important issues. He was disappointed that his ideas about an Empire Council and a permanent Imperial Secretariat had been defeated in London by the representatives of Canada and South Africa. But he had arranged for a continuation after the war of collaboration between the Defence Departments in Whitehall and those at Canberra. In discussing post-war relations he emphasised the importance of exchanges of visits at all levels. For Empire ties were based on understanding and goodwill between the people of the mother country and the Dominions. He certainly had the breadth of vision to speak for Australia as a whole, and to grasp its importance not just to the Empire but for the entire outside world.
I spent my first evening at Brisbane with Cooper,Footnote 326 the Premier, and other members of the Executive Committee of the Queensland Branch of the Australian Labor Party. They were very proud of their record of 26 years of Labor rule, the longest of any Parliament in the Commonwealth. They said their system of compulsory arbitration in disputes between employers and employees, applied by the State and Federal Courts, had prevented stoppages during the war. Queensland was also the only State with unemployment insurance.
I also had a long talk with O'Leary,Footnote 327 the Director of Native Affairs for the Queensland Government, who considered that Queensland had done more for the Aborigines than any other State.Footnote 328 The best organised Aboriginal community was in the Islands of the Torres Straits, where they had a large measure of autonomy. Since the war they provided a garrison to guard the Islands, the only aboriginal contingent in the Australian Army. These men are not pure Aborigines, as they contain a mixture of Javanese and Polynesian strains. Before the war they lived by pearl fishing. On the Queensland mainland, apart from a pocket on the Western side of the Cape York Peninsula, there were no tribal Aborigines left: the able bodied males having been recruited by the farmers for labour gangs to cut sugar cane and help them at busy times of the year. In Queensland I had my first experience of the tragedy of the Aboriginal inhabitants of Australia.
I was delighted to find some first rate contemporary art in galleries in Melbourne and Sydney. The most striking figure among contemporary painters was William Dobell,Footnote 329 whom I met in the Sydney Art Gallery. He told me he had studied at the Slade,Footnote 330 under Tonks,Footnote 331 and that the Old Masters who had most influenced him were Goya and Rembrandt.Footnote 332 But he was typically Australian in his portrayal of character, which he pushed to the point of caricature. He was not far from Will DysonFootnote 333 or Lowe.Footnote 334 Another young artist painting tavern scenes with a Dutch gusto was Russell Drysdale.Footnote 335 Perhaps the most popular school of painting, to which RobertsFootnote 336 and StreetonFootnote 337 belonged, was a school of landscape artists, depicting vast expanses of sparse pasture, dotted by the ubiquitous gum trees, where the sheep farmer grazed his thousands of sheep on a sheep station in the outback. Streeton above all, gave you a marvellous sense of great distances, the blue haze of the intense summer heat, and the brilliant tones of a land continually drenched in sunlight.
But only today has any artist tried to portray the great Australian desert, far more typical of the continent than pastoral countryside, because it covers more than half the whole area. The first Australian to reveal the real Australia to outsiders was an Aboriginal artist, Albert Namatjira.Footnote 338 I flew over thousands of miles of the Australian desert, and at Alice Springs I saw for the first time the desert at close quarters. The colouring is magnificent, tropical in its strident tones and absence of chiaroscuro. In the foreground the flaming orange-red of the sun-drenched desert, stretching away towards the horizon until suddenly interrupted by a huge mass of naked rock, violet in the distance, and silhouetted against the bluest of blue skies. This is not a white man's country, it is far too hot and barren, and it is not surprising that it has been discovered for art by one of the Aboriginals who lived and hunted there since the old stone age. For Albert Namatjira and his colleagues this is their homeland, where he and his ancestors have lived in tribal harmony since the ‘dreamtime’, before man and nature became divided.
New Zealand
During our stay in New Zealand we drove by car 2,200 miles in about a fortnight, starting from Auckland and covering both Islands before we returned to our starting point. At every town where we stayed there was a civic reception, and every evening we split up to address private gatherings of our respective Parties. Party feeling in New Zealand ran so strong it was impossible for us to meet Labour and National supporters together. In Wellington we lunched with the Empire Parliamentary Association, and met a number of Ministers and members of both Houses. None of the politicians seemed to be of the calibre of Fraser and Nash, and I did not feel that Holland,Footnote 339 the genial farmer who led the Opposition, had the mettle of a potential Prime Minister.
We dined with Fraser and his Cabinet at the Waterloo Hotel in Wellington on our return journey. The Prime Minister had just returned from a conference of Prime Ministers in London. He had been disappointed by the lack of support for the idea of improving the machinery of imperial co-operation after the war, but was pleased by the new practice of monthly meetings between the United Kingdom Prime Minister and the Dominion High Commissioners in London. He was worried about the future damage from flying bombs, which he had encountered during his time in London. He thought the war in Europe might be over in six months, but that the war in the Pacific might last for two years after that (without the atomic bomb and surrender of Japan it might have been so). He was immensely cheered by the land, sea, and air reinforcements promised by the United Kingdom for the war against Japan.
It was not until we reached Rotorua that I realised the high artistic level of the Maori civilisation. You have to see the carved pillars and woven panels of a Maori meeting house, and the grace and rhythm of poi and haka dancers, to realise what a natural aptitude the Maoris have for art. I had a foretaste of this when I listened to the delightfully witty speech of the Maori Bishop BennettFootnote 340 at a Labour meeting at Nelson. I had the good fortune to be asked by our leader, Tom Wickham, to make a speech of thanks on behalf of the delegates for the ceremonial welcome given us by the Arawa Confederation when we met them on July 27th. I was asked by the Arawa to give them a copy of my speech for their tribal records, and the New Zealand Government did me the honour of printing and publishing it with a Maori translation and an introduction by Mr Parry,Footnote 341 the Minister of Internal Affairs. As my meeting with the Maoris at Rotorua was the most memorable event in my visit to New Zealand, I would like to place on record the actual words in which I expressed the admiration and gratitude I felt and shall always feel for their gallantry and artistic genius.
Let me first say how much we appreciate the wonderful reception you have given us at Rotorua and the delightful entertainment you have provided for our benefit, a welcome that typifies the traditional spirit of Maori hospitality.
We come to you as messengers from the far-off Mother Country, from the people of Britain, and from the two Houses of the most ancient Parliament in the Empire. The message we bring you is a message of heartfelt thanks for your magnificent contribution to the war effort of the Allies, both in the fields and factories of New Zealand and on the battle fronts wherever you have engaged the enemy. Without a moment's doubt or hesitation, in spite of the momentous choice before you, you decided to send your young men to fight beside us in far distant Europe. It was only two days after our declaration of war on Germany that your four representatives in the New Zealand Parliament asked the Government to allow the Maoris to volunteer for military service. Your response to this call to the colours was so immediate that by the spring of 1940 a Maori Battalion was ready to sail, fully trained and fully equipped, from Wellington. Every man who left his home to serve overseas went out of his own free will. You accepted unanimously and without constraint, what from the days of the Greeks and Romans to the present time, has always been regarded as the highest obligation of citizenship. There were no laggards among the Maori race. No other people engaged in this worldwide conflict have been able to mobilise its men and women for an all-out military and industrial war effort without resort to compulsion in one form or another.
The minimum age for service overseas was fixed in New Zealand at 21. But young Maoris had a convenient habit of skipping inconvenient birthdays, and the Maori Battalion was the youngest Battalion in the New Zealand Brigade. We have not forgotten how, after France had fallen in the summer of 1940, at the blackest and most critical moment in the war, your Battalion was manning our defences in the south of England, waiting in readiness to protect our homes from the German invaders. Nor have we forgotten how the Maoris emerged from their baptism of fire. Their fame as fighters in this war was first to reach the ears of the general public during the campaign in Greece. It was there that they held the Pass of Petras on Mount Olympus for a whole day against a vastly superior force, allowing the main body of British and New Zealand troops to withdraw in safety towards the sea. Without any pause for rest after the fatigue of the day and night fighting in the retreat from Greece, your men were again thrown into the front line in defence of Crete. It was in Crete that one of those bayonet charges, which make the Maori so redoubtable a foe in hand to hand fighting, cleared German airborne troops from a vital aerodrome in the heart of the Island. After the loss of our last foothold on the continent of Europe, the Maoris were in the forefront of the long North African campaign. Their grim ferocity at the battle of Alamein attracted Field Marshal Rommel'sFootnote 342 attention, and he gave them the nickname of ‘the Scalp Hunters’.
After Alamein, the Maoris swept forward with the victorious Eighth Army through Libya, Cyrenaica, and Tripolitania, until at last they were halted on the borders of Tunisia by the formidable fortifications of the Mareth Line. It was in the turning movement for which the New Zealand Division is now famous, which outflanked Rommel and obliged him to withdraw from the strongest defensive position in Tunisia, that some of the outstanding exploits of Maori gallantry are recorded. By capturing and holding with his platoon an important mountain feature, in spite of the repeated counter-attacks of a crack German Grenadier Regiment, Lieutenant Moana NgarimuFootnote 343 won the most coveted distinction in the British Empire, the medal that bears on its face the simple inscription ‘For Valour’.Footnote 344 It is not forgotten how, wounded severely in the shoulder and the leg, bleeding profusely and in great pain, he told his company commander he would prefer to stay with his men, and how he died twelve hours later with his face to the enemy. Less than a month afterwards, by storming another key point in the Tunisian Highlands, Lieutenant WikiriwhiFootnote 345 and Lance Sergeant Manahi,Footnote 346 of the Arawa, won the D.S.O.Footnote 347 and the D.C.M.Footnote 348 respectively. The Maori Battalion, mourning its dead and wounded heroes, but never lacking successors to fill the gaps in its ranks, still marched forward in the vanguard of the Mediterranean campaign, and even now is battering at the gates of Florence. I hope that this wartime comradeship between Maori and PakehaFootnote 349 may lead to an even greater mutual understanding, appreciation, and esteem when the war is over. Both peoples have their own part to play, and their own contribution to make, to stability and progress in the post war world. You Maoris have a different history, a different culture, a different language and different traditional customs from the Pakeha. You will be contributing your share to this partnership, not by allowing these vital differences to be ironed out by European influences, but by jealously preserving the best that is in your own traditions and supplementing them with whatever you can gain from the methods and habits of the West. In the application of science to life, whether it be in matters of animal husbandry and the cultivation. of crops on the farm, or in saving the lives and safe guarding the health of mothers and infants, of growing children and adults, there is a great deal you can usefully pick up from the scientific discoveries and the skilled technicians we have brought with us from Europe.
But do not forget that our system of mass production in factories has killed the artistic instincts of craftsmen, and that an all-enveloping and standardised ugliness is the price we have paid for our lace curtains and plush carpets and luxury hotels. It would be a tragic loss if your wonderful artistic talents were submerged by the advancing tide of cheap industrial products.
Your language is an instrument that lends itself naturally to the music of poetry and the spoken word. The rhythmic sense and grace of movement which animate your poi and haka dances are as beautiful and as inevitable as a bird in flight, and your mastery of intricate pattern and balanced design has left an indelible imprint on woven flax, carved wood, and polished greenstone. I beg you to cherish this precious talent you have inherited from your ancestors, to preserve it from the vulgarity of European and American commercialism, and to remember, above all, that no-one can take it from you but yourselves.
It is only by this inherent power of imagination and aptitude for art that you can enrich the New Zealand of tomorrow. Pakeha society is built on a foundation of extreme individualism, which encourages each man to pursue his own advantage with little regard for others, and spreads the social qualities like thin veneer on the surface of a harsh and universal struggle. This has led to many grave evils and injustices, which are still far from being remedied. But you are accustomed by tradition to habits of friendly co-operation. You are brought up to share your possessions, you learn to live for each other and not for yourselves alone. This keen sense of social solidarity, and a courtesy, neighbourliness, and hospitable kindness to go with it, derive from the ancient traditions you have inherited from your forefathers. Thence also proceed those martial qualities which have always distinguished the young Maori. Judging from past history over many hundreds of years, there is real danger that a society which idolises comfort may in the course of time grow decadent and soft. Men may neglect to prepare themselves in days of peace for the hardships and perils of the battlefield. There can be no better antidote than the qualities you have inherited from the brave men who challenged the Pacific in their canoes six hundred years ago. The marvellous powers of endurance, the high courage, and the spirit of chivalry you have shown in the course of the war would be just as valuable to New Zealand, to the British Empire, and to the world, in the years of peace that lie ahead.
I beg you therefore to honour the traditions that have been handed down to you, to supplement them by whatever they may require to adapt your way of life to a competitive and individualistic society, and to form from this blending process a modern code of behaviour that will be as valuable to your children as your fathers’ was to you.
The 19th century was a time of rapid change, of great hardship, and profound tribulation for the Maori people. For many years your very existence trembled in the balance. But the long and bitter conflict has ended in reconciliation and friendship and mutual respect between the Maori and the Pakeha. I believe you are emerging from the valley of shadows into the sunlight of a new and brighter era in Maori history. Your spirit has revived, your numbers are increasing, and you have been shown your entire fitness, in peace and war alike, to enjoy the rights and to discharge the duties of free and equal citizens in a modern democracy. You deserve the very best the future can give, and I do wish you from the bottom of my heart, the utmost success in the difficult but not impossible task of marrying your ancient and splendid traditions to the inescapable demands of a dominating white civilisation. Kia Ora.
Return Journey
The Leader of the House of Lords, Lord CranborneFootnote 350 had informed our High Commissioner in Australia that, owing to the death of Lord Snell, the Labour Party Deputy Leader in the Lords, I had been asked by Churchill to take his place in the Coalition Government. It was therefore desirable that I should return home as soon as possible. I left Auckland on July 31st on a special naval Boeing Clipper, provided by Admiral King,Footnote 351 with few passengers and a bunk for the night which was the last thing in comfort. My title seemed to bother the Americans; in one document I was described as a ‘British Pier’.
My first stop was at Suva in the Fiji Islands. I dined at a hotel as the guest of the Chief Secretary of the Colony, who told me that the Indian half of the population was entirely indifferent to the war. He indicated that he had noticed a considerable improvement in the impetus of the Colonial Office when Lord Cranborne succeeded Lord Moyne,Footnote 352 and he was busy preparing post-war plans for the Colonial Office regarding the development of social services, such as education and housing, and the expansion of the brick and copra industries. The plane on which I was travelling refuelled the next day at the Anglo-American Condominium of Canton Island, where I enjoyed the spectacle of a great white coral reef. The next day, August 2nd, I became conscious again of wartime conditions when I arrived at Honolulu. The population was mainly Japanese, which caused problems of security, and there was a 10.00 pm curfew every night. I stayed at the Moana Hotel, in a room overlooking an unforgettably green sea changing gradually to blue as it receded into the distance. Through my travels, there had been a sudden change of climate, from winter to summer and I bathed the following morning on a deserted Waikiki beach. The war had banished the usual hordes of American tourists, and I had the beach and the ocean to myself. The sea was smooth as a millpond, and the swimming magnificent. Never could conditions have been more perfect for the ideal holiday, and it was sad to be leaving that evening by Pan-American for San Francisco.
From Honolulu, I caught a morning plane, a venerable Douglas, to Washington on August 5th, where people were sweltering in an afternoon temperature of 95 degrees F. The British Embassy was in a tizz, because Lord BeaverbrookFootnote 353 could not be moved from the bar of the Mayflower, where he was negotiating an important agreement. I do not know whether he was wanted on the telephone by the Cabinet, or they thought he should move to the Statler Hotel which was air-conditioned. Before I left I had a last glimpse of the Mellon Collection. The next day I caught the night Clipper from Baltimore to Newfoundland. I finally reached Ireland at Foynes Airport in the Shannon Estuary, and caught a passenger plane to Bristol. August 8th was a Bank Holiday, and I travelled from Bristol to London by British Rail. There were 15 in my compartment, mostly parents returning from a visit to their evacuee children. No complaints in spite of heat and fatigue. I was home at last, after a most fascinating experience.
