Too much ink has already been spilt over the history and doctrine of Wahhabism, the 18th-century religious tradition that continues to shape modern Saudi Arabia. Its name, origin, theology, political role, alliance with al-Saʿud, and recent influence over militant Jihadis raise controversial questions that have not been resolved. Wahhabism remains a contested religious tradition that inflames the imagination of both its advocates and opponents, and whose interpretation and history over the past 250 years remain controversial among historians, religious studies specialists, and social scientists. Often overlooked in the literature on Wahhabism, however, is the fragmentation of its theology and the constant challenges it faced from within its own ranks. As with any dogmatic religious tradition surviving across changing historical circumstances and pressures, understanding Wahhabism requires confronting its multiple texts and contexts, not to mention addressing the wide range of religious voices that claim to speak on its behalf.
Given this complexity, The Clerics of Islam is a welcome addition to the vast literature on Wahhabism, and is unique because of its interdisciplinary method. Combining history and sociology, Nabil Mouline traces the evolution of Wahhabi theology and history from its early days in 18th-century central Arabia to the present. He relies on Arabic primary sources, mainly Wahhabi chronicles and theological treatises, and Western secondary literature. He draws heavily on classical social science theory, especially the reflections of Emile Durkheim and Max Weber on religion. He also conducted interviews with multiple personalities within the Saudi Committee of Grand ʿUlamaʾ, and other religious institutions in Saudi Arabia often shrouded in obscurity to outsiders. The objective of this book is to explore the three O's that Mouline identifies as key to understanding this controversial interpretation of Islam, its contribution to the foundation of the Saudi state, and its cooptation and institutionalization since 1932: orthodoxy, orthopraxy, and order.
Orthodoxy comes first, and entails the exploration of the literature produced by Wahhabi clerics. Against the idealized image of Sunni Islam that had little need for an organized clergy, guardians of patrimony, and heritage, Mouline argues the grand ʿulamaʾ of Wahhabism and their “high” culture actually approximate this hierarchical class. Like other clergy, Wahhabi clerics enjoy prestige, influence, and privilege. Yet they also struggle to fix religious interpretation and formulate uncontested meaning. Dissent has often erupted from within, resulting in schisms, expulsion, and even murder. Also pertinent is the Wahhabi symbiosis with al-Saʿud, with neither able to survive without support from the other.
Orthopraxy is another prism through which Mouline explores how clerics define appropriate socioreligious behaviour and practices. From epistles to prayers, the Wahhabi clerics created a totalitarian worldview aiming to establish control over people's behavior, rituals, and legal affairs. This control was facilitated by political power granting them monopoly and control over the population through special institutions in various state sectors, such as the judiciary and education. The book leads one to conclude that the Wahhabi clerics developed into a shadow government, developing in parallel to the authority of the princes and later kings of Saudi Arabia.
Yet orthodoxy and orthopraxy also require a third O, political order—hence their political alliance with al-Saʿud from 1744 onward. The alliance survived several political crises, for example the 1818 Ottoman–Egyptian invasion, the 1927 Ikhwan rebellion, and the multiple episodes of radical Islamist uprisings since the 1979 siege of the Mecca Grand Mosque. The partnership between al-Saʿud and the Wahhabi clerics is mutually beneficial: the first are assured obedience by religious clerics that mitigates potential dissent in the kingdom (a cornerstone in Wahhabi orthodoxy), while the second enjoys unrivalled influence, prestige, and control over society.
Interesting for the reader is Mouline's focus on the new institutions al-Saʿud created to embody Wahhabi theology, reward its clerics, now turned into state functionaries, and promote their orthodoxy and orthopraxy. For instance, he traces the genealogy of Al-Shaykh, the family and decedents of the founder of Wahhabism, Muhammad ibn ʿAbd al-Wahhab, calling them the “Levites” of the movement. He demonstrates how this religious family has controlled the highest religious offices and key state institutions, from the office of Grand Mufti to the Committee for the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention. Mouline's evidence on the social character of the ʿulamaʾ is also invaluable. He explains that much of the religious establishment has historically drawn upon the Najdi crescent, in particular the sedentary population of the small oases and towns stretching between Unayzah and Buraydah in the north to al-Aflaj in the south. Scholars originating in this crescent continue to dominate the religious establishment until the present with only a small number of individuals from other regions being allowed to occupy less prominent roles.
The book also draws interesting conclusions about the symbiotic relation between a dogmatic clergy bound by regional and kin ʿasabiyya and a centralized absolute monarchy, endowed with petrodollars to enforce loyalty and encourage expansion of its state religion. According to Mouline, the reutilization and institutionalization of the Wahhabis and their dogma under al-Saʿud's patronage birthed the first Sunni clergy in the strict sense of the term, which is ironic given that Wahhabis insist that all Muslims should acquire religious ʿilm (knowledge) directly from its divine sources, abhor all mediators between the word of God and humans, and reach out to the divine without intercession.
It would have been helpful if Mouline included a section on his methodology, especially how he navigated the vast body of Wahhabi writings. Any student of Wahhabism must address the competing bias of these literary sources, as well as the constant quest of the modern Saudi state to silence dissenting voices and reframe the movement's own history. Furthermore, the reader remains puzzled by the silence over how the great Wahhabi clerics received Mouline's request to be interviewed, especially after 9/11 when the tradition and its patronage by the Saudi leadership came under strong attack by its opponents. Mouline's access to Saudi Arabia and the inner circle of the clerics must be contextualized. This would have allowed the reader to understand the most turbulent moment in the history of this religious tradition and its alliance with al-Saud, not to mention the desire of both to absolve themselves from any responsibility through opening the Wahhabi Pandora's box to outside researchers. Finally, Mouline's conclusion that the Wahhabis now constitute a clerical elite is already obvious to many scholars of the tradition. Less clear is the dissent that they have faced throughout the history of their alliance with al-Saʿud. The fragmentation of Wahhabism under the pressure of this alliance is extremely important. It deserves further research, for it paradoxically results from the very reutilization and institutionalization intended to empower this movement.
Notwithstanding these minor points, this book is dense in detail and documentation, and its analysis is sound and convincing. Taking its place in a recent wave of new and innovative work on Wahhabism, Mouline's scholarship will inform readers about the constant struggle in Saudi Arabia of the Wahhabi clerics to pursue orthodoxy and orthopraxy within the context of achieving a stable political order.
