The title of Jen Harvie and Andy Lavender's excellent collection of essays, Making Contemporary Theatre: International Rehearsal Processes, harbors an important omission: with one exception, the rehearsal processes examined in the book are all examples of devised theatre. This is readily acknowledged by the editors in their introduction, as is their exclusive focus on postdramatic theatre and all that term entails. These parameters make the book a significant contribution to the growing literature on devising, but it is curious—and potentially deceiving for an online purchaser—that the title should be so broad when the content is so specifically focused.
That said, as its subtitle indicates, Making Contemporary Theatre seeks to expose the processes by which many of today's more innovative theatre artists and companies make their work; where many prior attempts to do just that have managed only to provide schematic outlines of approach or philosophy, Making Contemporary Theatre succeeds for the most part in putting us, as it were, into the thick of things. The writers who provide the collection's essays all spent substantial time in the rehearsal room observing—or, in some cases, participating in—the creation of a single production. As all theatre artists understand, the rehearsal process is utterly dependent on time, both in the sense of duration and that of evolution, and it is the ongoing embeddedness of these writers in the process that makes their essays so consistently insightful and instructive.
Harvie and Lavender's introduction expertly paraphrases key concepts such as postdramatic and devised theatre, and provides a useful gloss on the upcoming chapters, which helps make the book both accessible to students and friendly for more advanced readers. It also takes pains to examine and explain the values that inform the book's focus and approach—values that in similar collections too often go unexamined. Most notably, it doesn't let “international” simply imply a (desirable) breadth of scope, but examines the increasingly global conditions of production that affect the creation of a performance. As Harvie and Lavender point out, there is often a tension between the work's embodiment of its makers’ local culture and the necessity that it speak to diverse audiences as it tours the international festival circuit. Not surprisingly, this leads to further questioning of the commercial pressures that inevitably collide with a creative ethos that ostensibly shuns those demands.
In the chapters that follow, the embeddedness of the writers presents both dangers and advantages; the most immediate of the former, at least in these essays, is a loss of objectivity. The writers here are at their best when they bring a critical perspective to their subjects, both in terms of process and of product. Lourdes Orozco is exemplary in this regard in her treatment of Rodrigo García and his Carnicería Teatro's One Way to Approach the Idea of Mistrust. García is concerned with using graphic actions and images to communicate the repression and violence wrought on everyday individuals by sociopolitical institutions. Orozco appreciates García's artistry, but nevertheless questions the repressive conditions he imposes on all of his collaborators.
Unfortunately, this critical objectivity is often lost when the writer is actively involved in the production or with the company generating it. Peter Eckersall, for example, provides a comprehensive treatment of the Australian company Not Yet It's Difficult (NYID) and their creation of Blowback, a futuristic imagining of Australia as an American colony; Eckersall, however, serves as the company's dramaturge, one of a core of three who run NYID, and his essay inevitably takes on the uneasy tone of an advertisement. Similarly, Catherine Alexander provides fascinating documentation of Complicité's creation of The Elephant Vanishes, but as an actor in the piece she becomes overly rhapsodic at times. Best able to balance intimate involvement with critical distance is Adam Broinowski, who participated as a dancer-performer in the Japanese troupe Gekidan Kaitaisha's Bye Bye: The New Primitive. Gekidan Kaitaisha's work is based in butoh but highly influenced by Western critical theory, resulting in a “corporeal theatre that stages cultural deconstruction” (141). As a dancer who experienced the physical demands of butoh training and performance, Broinowski is uniquely suited to introduce this company to a Western reader. Occasionally, too, a nonparticipating observer evidences infatuation at the expense of critical distance. Alex Mermikides provides an insightful perspective on the creative methods of Forced Entertainment and their work on The Travels, but what seem to be uniformly negative press reviews of the production provoke an overly defensive response from her.
The book's remaining six chapters examine a number of companies and artists that will likely be familiar to readers, such as The Builders Association, Robert Lepage and Ex Machina, and Elevator Repair Service. Probably less known to many will be the Belgian choreographer Sidi Larbi Cherkaoui (the subject of a chapter by Lou Cope), whose dance pieces often involve the creation of more theatrical characters. A surprising inclusion in Making Contemporary Theatre is Sarah Gorman's essay on Richard Maxwell and the New York City Players, whose work, for many, may not qualify as an example of devised theatre; Gorman's chapter, however, provides documentation of an otherwise underrepresented theatre artist and company. Similarly, the staging of Chekhov's Platonov by Luc Perceval at Berlin's Schaubühne—described by Zoë Svendsen in the collection's final chapter—is clearly not an example of devising, but Perceval's highly unorthodox rehearsal process makes Svendsen's one of the most intriguing essays in the book.
Although the work of these various artists may share what could be called a postdramatic ethos, they nonetheless are marked as much by their differences in approaches and aesthetics as they are by their similarities. As a way of capturing both, Harvie and Lavender close the book with a “contingent conclusion,” something they call “not quite a manifesto,” which encapsulates the guiding tenets of the processes examined in diagrammatic form (242–3). Any such synthesis of postdramatic theatre stands on shaky intellectual ground, but this canny anticonclusion is both a tease and a deft maneuver that nicely covers all their tracks.
