1. Introduction
Particle-laden flows are ubiquitous in both natural phenomena and industrial processes (Balachandar & Eaton Reference Balachandar and Eaton2010; Brandt & Coletti Reference Brandt and Coletti2022). Examples include heavy particles such as droplets in clouds or coal powder in fluidised beds, as well as light particles such as plastic debris in the ocean or gas bubbles in liquid metals. The clustering and dynamics of particles in turbulent flows constitute a fundamental and practically relevant problem, influenced by a wide range of factors. Over the past decades, extensive experimental and numerical studies have been conducted to investigate this subject. Balachandar & Eaton (Reference Balachandar and Eaton2010) systematically reviewed numerical approaches for turbulent multi-phase flow across a range of relative particle diameters (
$D_p/\eta$
, where
$\eta$
is the Kolmogorov scale) and volume fractions (
$\phi$
). With advances in experimental measurements and numerical simulations, it has become clear that even for spheres, the effects of particle size and density ratio on particle dynamics cannot be fully characterised by a single parameter. In particular, the particle Stokes number, which is commonly used to quantify particle inertia, is insufficient (Brandt & Coletti Reference Brandt and Coletti2022). For finite-size particles, their behaviour in turbulence is jointly regulated by the finite-size effects (associated with
$D_p/ \eta$
), the inertial effects (stemming from the density ratio
$\rho _r$
) and volume-fraction effects
$\phi$
(Brandt & Coletti Reference Brandt and Coletti2022).
Early research mainly focused on the particles with density ratio
$\rho _r \gg 1$
and diameter
$D_p \ll \eta$
, which could be idealised as point particles. Maxey & Riley (Reference Maxey and Riley1983) first derived the equation of motion for such particles in non-uniform flows. Subsequent point-particle direct numerical simulations (PP-DNS) revealed that inertial point particles tend to cluster in low-vorticity and high-strain regions (Maxey Reference Maxey1987; Squires & Eaton Reference Squires and Eaton1991; Bragg & Collins Reference Bragg and Collins2014a
). Experimental works, such as Yang & Shy (Reference Yang and Shy2005), further confirmed that particles with Stokes number
$St \approx 1$
exhibit the strongest clustering. For low-inertia particles (
$St \ll 1$
), preferential clustering is primarily attributed to the centrifugal effect (Maxey Reference Maxey1987). Other studies have linked particle clustering to the local fluid acceleration, proposing the so-called ‘sweep–stick’ mechanism (Goto & Vassilicos Reference Goto and Vassilicos2008), which describes that particles are swept by the flow but tend to stick into the regions of zero acceleration. For higher-inertia particles (
$St \gtrsim O(1)$
), non-local effects (also named path-history effects) become increasingly significant. In this regime, the fluid velocity gradient tensors sampled along particle trajectories play a key role in shaping their fractal clustering (Zaichik & Alipchenkov Reference Zaichik and Alipchenkov2003; Chun et al. Reference Chun, Koch, Rani, Ahluwalia and Collins2005; Bragg et al. Reference Bragg, Ireland and Collins2015b
). Pumir & Wilkinson (Reference Pumir and Wilkinson2016) then delved into how clustering influences particle collision rates. Most recently, Bec, Gustavsson & Mehlig (Reference Bec, Gustavsson and Mehlig2024) compared the statistical models for the dynamics of heavy point particles, evaluating their ability to capture preferential sampling and fractal clustering.
For particles whose size does not satisfy
$D_p \ll \eta$
, point-particle models become invalid, and the past two decades have seen a rapid growth of particle-resolved DNS (PR-DNS). By explicitly resolving particle shape and size, PR-DNS can accurately capture particle–fluid interactions and provide valuable data for modelling and validating models in PP-DNS (Tenneti & Subramaniam Reference Tenneti and Subramaniam2014). Early studies focused on finite-size spherical particles that were heavier (Ten Cate et al. Reference Ten Cate, Derksen, Portela and Van Den Akker2004; Lucci, Ferrante & Elghobashi Reference Lucci, Ferrante and Elghobashi2010; Yeo et al. Reference Yeo, Dong, Climent and Maxey2010) or neutrally buoyant (Homann & Bec Reference Homann and Bec2010; Cisse, Homann & Bec Reference Cisse, Homann and Bec2013) relative to the carrier fluid, typically with diameters ranging from several to tens of the Kolmogorov length scales. More recent work has extended these investigations to non-spherical particles, such as ellipsoids, to better capture shape-induced effects on particle dynamics and turbulence modulation (Jiang et al. Reference Jiang, Wang, Liu, Sun and Calzavarini2022). Experimental results by Fiabane et al. (Reference Fiabane, Zimmermann, Volk, Pinton and Bourgoin2012) revealed that neutrally buoyant finite-size particles exhibit almost no clustering, whereas heavier particles display moderate clustering, for particles with diameters in the range
$ 4 \lesssim D_p/ \eta \lesssim 20$
. However, experiments cannot disentangle the respective roles of turbulence and gravity in the motion and clustering of finite-size particles and DNS have been the primary tool to separately investigate these effects.
A large number of PR-DNS studies have since explored the dynamics and clustering of finite-size particles, turbulence modulation, and the influence of gravity. Regarding clustering, Uhlmann & Chouippe (Reference Uhlmann and Chouippe2017) reported a moderate clustering level for particles with
$\rho _r=1.5$
, drawing comparisons with clustering mechanisms previously identified for point particles. More recently, Chiarini & Rosti (Reference Chiarini and Rosti2024) validated and extended the analysis to a wider range of particle sizes (
$D_p/\eta = 16{-}123$
) and density ratios (
$\rho _r=1.3{-}100$
), while Chiarini, Tandurella & Rosti (Reference Chiarini, Tandurella and Rosti2025) focused on finite-size particles at the Kolmogorov scale, comparing the dynamics and clustering of particles with
$\rho _r=5 {-} 100$
to the point-particle limit. In terms of turbulence modulation, Wang et al. (Reference Wang, Ayala, Gao, Andersen and Mathews2014) demonstrated that particles with
$\rho _r=5$
enhance turbulent dissipation due to the viscous boundary layer around particle surfaces, whereas Oka & Goto (Reference Oka and Goto2022) showed that particle wakes significantly contribute to dissipation for particles with
$\rho _r=2 {-} 512$
. Likewise, Peng, Sun & Wang (Reference Peng, Sun and Wang2023) parametrically explored how finite-size heavy particles (
$\rho _r=4 {-} 16$
) affect turbulent kinetic energy and viscous dissipation rate in turbulence. The role of gravity has also received considerable attention. Uhlmann & Doychev (Reference Uhlmann and Doychev2014) examined clustering of settling particles (
$\rho _r=1.5$
,
$Ga=121, 178$
) and its implications for the particle motion. Chouippe & Uhlmann (Reference Chouippe and Uhlmann2019) studied how turbulence alters particle settling velocity and clustering for particles with
$\rho _r=1.5$
and
$Ga=180$
. Furthermore, Fornari et al. (Reference Fornari, Picano and Brandt2016a
,
Reference Fornari, Picano, Sardina and Brandtb
, Reference Fornari, Zade, Brandt and Picano2019) investigated the effects of turbulence and volume fraction on particle dynamics for nearly neutrally buoyant particles (
$\rho _r \approx 1.02$
).
Current studies on light particles (
$\rho _r \lt 1$
) predominantly rely on point-particle models, where finite-size effects of larger particles are typically included only through corrective terms. Regarding the clustering and dynamics of light particles in turbulence, Calzavarini et al. (Reference Calzavarini, Kerscher, Lohse and Toschi2008) discussed the clustering behaviour of ‘finite-size’ point particles with varying density ratios, while Calzavarini et al. (Reference Calzavarini, Volk, Bourgoin, Lévêque, Pinton and Toschi2009) introduced the Faxén correction to account for the finite-size effects of point-particle models, which is relevant for particles of radius
$r \gt \eta\, \sqrt {Re_\lambda }$
. Using Voronoï analysis, Tagawa et al. (Reference Tagawa, Mercado, Prakash, Calzavarini, Sun and Lohse2012) showed that light particles cluster more strongly than heavy ones, preferentially aligning along vortex filaments in high-vorticity regions. Building on this foundation, Zhang, Legendre & Zamansky (Reference Zhang, Legendre and Zamansky2019) modelled the dynamics of micro-bubbles in high-Reynolds-numbers flows, and in a subsequent study, Zhang, Legendre & Zamansky (Reference Zhang, Legendre and Zamansky2021) analysed the influence of fluid inertia on the motion of light bubbles. More recently, de Wit et al. (Reference de Wit, Kunnen, Clercx and Toschi2024) proposed a method of four-way coupling in PP-DNS at high particle number densities.
To the best of the authors’ knowledge, PR-DNS studies of light particles remain very limited. Numerical methods developed to analyse the stability of a single rising light particle, such as the spectral method in a moving frame employed by Jenny, Dušek & Bouchet (Reference Jenny, Dušek and Bouchet2004) or the body-fitted approach of Auguste & Magnaudet (Reference Auguste and Magnaudet2018), are generally not suited for simulating multiple particles in complex turbulent environments. Other related work has mainly been conducted in the Euler–Euler framework (e.g. Ma et al. Reference Ma, Lucas, Jakirlić and Fröhlich2020), where bubble deformation is neglected and bubbles can be approximated as light sphere particles provided that both the Bond and Weber numbers remain below order unity (Clift, Grace & Weber Reference Clift, Grace and Weber2005). With continuous advancements in computational techniques, non-body-fitted approaches have also emerged. Recent studies, for example, have begun to explore bubble–particle interactions relevant to flotation processes (Jiang & Krug Reference Jiang and Krug2025; Tiedemann & Fröhlich Reference Tiedemann and Fröhlich2025), offering closer links to industrial applications. However, these studies involve the coupled influence of turbulence, gravity and additional point particles, making it difficult to isolate the intrinsic role of particle inertia. The mechanisms governing the dynamics and clustering of light finite-size particles in turbulent flows remain poorly understood. Motivated by these gaps, we conduct PR-DNS of light finite-size particles in forced homogeneous isotropic turbulence (HIT). This allows us to systematically investigate how particle inertia and particle–particle interactions influence their dynamics and clustering behaviour.
2. Numerical method and simulation set-ups
In the present study, we employ PR-DNS to simulate the HIT laden with finite-sized particles. In particular, the fluid flow is simulated with the second-order finite-difference method, while the solid–fluid interactions are modelled by the immersed boundary (IB) method.
2.1. Government equations and numerical methods
We assume an incompressible, Newtonian fluid with density
$\rho _f$
and kinematic viscosity
$\nu$
. The fluid flow is governed by the Navier–Stokes equations as
Here,
$\boldsymbol{u}(\boldsymbol{x}, t)$
and
$p(\boldsymbol{x}, t)$
denote the fluid velocity vector and pressure, respectively. To generate and sustain the HIT, an external forcing term
$\boldsymbol{f}$
is added to the right-hand side of the momentum equation (2.1). Specifically, the forcing term
$\boldsymbol{f}$
is generated by random Ornstein–Uhlenbeck processes, and is applied only on large scales of the fluid flow (Eswaran & Pope Reference Eswaran and Pope1988); see also Chouippe & Uhlmann (Reference Chouippe and Uhlmann2015). The last term
$\boldsymbol{f}_{\textit{IB}}$
on the right-hand side of (2.1) denotes the immersed boundary force, which is applied to enforce the no-slip boundary condition on the particle surfaces.
Regarding the particle phase, the translational and rotational dynamics of rigid spherical particles are governed by the Newton–Euler equations:
Here,
$\boldsymbol{U}_{\!p}$
and
$\boldsymbol{\omega }_p$
are the particle translational and angular velocities, respectively. The particle density is denoted by
$\rho _p$
, and the corresponding density ratio is
$\rho _r=\rho _p/\rho _f$
. For a spherical particle of diameter
$D_p$
, the volume and moment-of-inertia of the spherical particle are
${\mathscr{V}}_p = \pi D_p^3/6$
and
${\mathscr{I}}_p=\rho _p {\mathscr{V}}_p D_p^2/10$
. The fluid stress tensors
$\boldsymbol{\tau }=-p\boldsymbol{I}+\mu (\boldsymbol{\nabla }\boldsymbol{u}+\boldsymbol{\nabla }\boldsymbol{u}^{\rm T})$
are integrated over the particle surface to compute the hydrodynamic force and torque acting on each particle, as given by the first terms on the right-hand sides of (2.3)–(2.4), in which
$\boldsymbol{n}$
denotes the outward unit normal vector, and
$\boldsymbol{r}$
is the vector from the particle centroid to a point on the particle surface. Note, additionally, that gravity is not applied to particle dynamics throughout this work. This allows us to exclude the effect of particle sedimentation (or floating), and focus on the effect of particle inertia and particle–particle interactions on their dynamics in HIT.
The modelling of the contact force
$\boldsymbol{F}_{\!C}$
(and the associated torque
$\boldsymbol{T}_{\!C}$
) presented in (2.3) (and (2.4)) is introduced as follows. First, when the surface–surface distance between two particles is smaller than one grid spacing (but remains positive), a lubrication force
$\boldsymbol{F}_{\!C}=\boldsymbol{F}_{\textit{lub}}$
is applied to incorporate the sub-grid lubrication effect that cannot be well captured. The formulation of
$\boldsymbol{F}_{\textit{lub}}$
follows Jeffrey (Reference Jeffrey1982). Then if the two particles have physical contact with a small but non-zero overlap, the lubrication force is switched off and a force accounting for the collision physics is considered instead. Specifically, for heavy particles with
$\rho _r \geqslant 1$
, a soft-sphere collision force based on the spring–dashpot–slide model proposed by Costa et al. (Reference Costa, Boersma, Westerweel and Breugem2015) is adopted. However, this soft-sphere collision model may cause numerical instability for solving the dynamics of particles lighter than fluid. Therefore, as a substitute, a collision model originally designed to model the collision between bubbles (Heitkam et al. Reference Heitkam, Sommer, Drenckhan and Fröhlich2017) is adopted for particles with
$\rho _r\lt 1$
. In the present work, only the repulsive component of the model is retained, which reads
\begin{equation} \boldsymbol{F}_{\!C} = R_p \sigma \left [ 18.5 \left ( \frac {\varDelta }{R_p}\right )^2 + 2 \frac {\varDelta }{R_p}\right ] \boldsymbol{n}_C,\quad \boldsymbol{T}_{\!C} = 0, \end{equation}
where
$R_p = D_p/2$
is the particle radius,
$\varDelta$
denotes the overlap distance,
$\sigma$
is the surface tension coefficient, and
$\boldsymbol{n}_C$
is the unit normal vector pointing from the centre of the collision partner towards the current particle. This collision model accounts for the repulsive interaction among bubbles due to the surface tension, so the surface tension coefficient
$\sigma$
matters in this model. To compute this collision force, we set the Weber number as
$\textit{We} = \rho_{\!f} D_p^3 / \sigma\kern-1pt \tau _p^2 = 0.1$
, representative of light particles or bubbles that remain nearly spherical in the surface tension dominant regime. The particle relaxation time is given by
$\tau _p = D_p^2/12\beta \nu$
, where
$\beta = 3 /(1 + 2\rho _r)$
is a density-related parameter. The full model of Heitkam et al. (Reference Heitkam, Sommer, Drenckhan and Fröhlich2017) also includes viscous contributions, but these are neglected here because we consider clean light particles or bubbles (Yang, Mühlhausen & Fröhlich Reference Yang, Mühlhausen and Fröhlich2021).
To numerically solve the incompressible Navier–Stokes equations (2.1)–(2.2), a fully implicit fractional method based on a second-order finite-difference spatial discretisation is employed (Kim, Baek & Sung Reference Kim, Baek and Sung2002). A direct-forcing immersed boundary method, which was originally proposed by Uhlmann (Reference Uhlmann2005) and improved by Breugem (Reference Breugem2012), is incorporated to compute the immersed boundary forces and model the fluid–particle interactions. Additionally, a semi-implicit fluid–solid coupling method for particles with arbitrary density ratios proposed by Tschisgale, Kempe & Fröhlich (Reference Tschisgale, Kempe and Fröhlich2017) is employed. Our PR-DNS framework has been extensively validated, with detailed methodology and verification cases documented in Jiang, Xu & Zhao (Reference Jiang, Xu and Zhao2024) and Li et al. (Reference Li, Jiang, Xu and Zhao2025).
2.2. Simulation set-ups
The simulation set-ups are introduced as follows. To simulate the HIT, a cubic computational domain with side length
${{\mathcal{L}}_{x}} = {{\mathcal{L}}_{y}} = {{\mathcal{L}}_{z}} = {\mathcal{L}} = 32 D_{p}$
is employed. The fluid flow and the particle motion are triply periodic in the computational domain. A uniform Cartesian grid with a total number
$N_x \times N_y \times N_z =512^3$
of grid cells is employed for the spatial discretisation, yielding spatial resolution
$D_p/ \Delta x = 16$
(where
$\Delta x$
denotes the grid spacing). The coordinate origin is positioned at the centre of the cubic computational domain. We have also examined the grid independence by running an additional case using a refined grid (with resolution
$D_p/ \Delta x = 32$
) for the run05 case, in which the particle Reynolds number is found to be highest among all the cases under study. The comparison between the lower and higher resolution simulations is given in Appendix A. Negligible difference is identified in these two cases with different grid numbers, verifying the adequate grid resolution
$D_p/ \Delta x = 16$
.
The parameters for the background turbulence generation are specified as
$T_L \nu / {\mathcal{L}}^{2}_x= 2.12 \times 10^{-4}$
,
$\varepsilon ^{*} {{\mathcal{L}}^{4}_x} / \nu ^3 = 3.72 \times 10^{7}$
and
$\kappa _f/ \kappa _{x0} = 2.5$
. Here,
$T_L$
,
$\varepsilon ^*$
and
$\kappa _f$
control the time scale, intensity and the cut-off wavenumber of the generated HIT, respectively. Further details regarding the definitions of these parameters can be found in Chouippe & Uhlmann (Reference Chouippe and Uhlmann2015). With these parameters, we obtain a single-phase HIT (the subscript ‘0’ hereinafter denotes the single-phase flow) with Taylor-scale Reynolds number
$\textit{Re}_{\lambda 0 } =73.60$
. The ratio between the Kolmogorov length scale and the grid size is
$\eta _0 / \Delta x = 1.9782$
, indicating the sufficiency of the grid resolution to resolve the smallest turbulence length scale. It is worth noting that in particle-laden cases, the turbulent forcing is exclusively applied in the domain occupied by the carrier fluid. As a result, the effective energy input by external forces is slightly reduced with increasing particle volume fraction
$\phi$
, compared with the single-phase input. This difference is negligible for analysing particle motion and clustering (especially at fixed
$\phi$
), but it may become significant when examining turbulence modulation by particles (Uhlmann & Chouippe Reference Uhlmann and Chouippe2017).
The simulation set-ups in the current work are given in table 1. To investigate the effect of particle inertia on their dynamics in HIT, we set four cases in the dilute regime (
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
) with varying density ratio
$\rho _r = 0.002$
–
$ 20.0$
. In addition, we also set two additional cases with increased volume fractions
$\phi =1\,\%$
and
$5\,\%$
for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
). This is motivated by the most significant particle clustering for the lightest particles (see discussion in § 3.1), so we want to further explore how light particle clustering and dynamics change with the volume fraction.
Summary of parameters in the present simulations: density ratio
$\rho _r=\rho _p/ \rho _f$
, particle volume fraction
$\phi$
, number of particles
$N_p$
, relative particle diameter
$D_p / \eta$
, and Taylor-scale Reynolds number
$\textit{Re}_{\lambda }=\lambda u_{rms}/ \nu$
.

Table 1. Long description
The table presents a summary of parameters used in simulations to study the effect of particle inertia on their dynamics in homogeneous isotropic turbulence. It includes six cases with varying density ratios, particle volume fractions, number of particles, relative particle diameters, and Taylor-scale Reynolds numbers. The cases are labeled as run0, run02, run1, run20, run01, and run05. Each row lists the specific values for each parameter in the respective cases. For instance, run0 has a density ratio of 0.002, a particle volume fraction of 0.005, 313 particles, a relative particle diameter of 8.00, and a Taylor-scale Reynolds number of 72.82. The table helps in understanding how different parameters influence particle behavior in turbulent flows.
Particles are initially free released into a quiescent fluid, which evolves into HIT under external turbulent forcing. We plotted the temporal evolution of the mean and variance of particle velocity components in the three directions for the light particles in the run0 case
$(\rho _r = 0.002,\ \phi = 0.5\,\%)$
. It can be seen that the particles, initially at rest, start to move freely driven by turbulence. Figure 1 confirms that the system has reached a statistically steady state and maintained good isotropy. All subsequent statistical analyses are performed in this statistically stationary state with sufficient samples. Taking the most dilute case (run0) as an example, the flow was first evolved for a duration
$T_{{start}}/T_l \approx 5.60$
as the initial transient. After that, statistics are collected over a time window
$T_{{obs}}/T_l \approx 39.23$
. To quantitatively verify statistical convergence, we compute the standard deviations of key quantities (e.g. the normalised Voronoï volumes
$V^{i}/ \langle V^{i} \rangle$
and the particle Reynolds number
$\textit{Re}_p$
) over three time windows. Specific physical discussions regarding these statistics will be provided in the next section. The long time span window A (
$t/T_l \approx 5.60$
to
$t/T_l \approx 44.83$
) is divided into two distinct, partially overlapping subsets of equal duration
$T_{{sub}}/T_l \approx 22.41$
:
-
(i) window B1 (early/mid stage),
$t/T_l \approx 5.60$
to
$t/T_l \approx 28.01$
, -
(ii) window B2 (mid/late stage),
$t/T_l \approx 22.41$
to
$t/T_l \approx 44.83$
.
As presented in table 2, the relative errors of
$\sigma (V^{i}/ \langle V^{i} \rangle )$
between sub-intervals are within 3 %, and those of
$\sigma ({Re}_p)$
are within 1 %. These minimal variations confirm that the statistical results have converged.
3. Results and discussion
3.1. Particle distribution and clustering
To provide a more intuitive view of particle motion and clustering, we present instantaneous snapshots of particle distributions and the surrounding vortex structures for different cases in figure 2. We identified and quantified vortex structures using the
$Q$
-criterion, where
$Q$
is the second invariant of the velocity-gradient tensor
$Q=u^2_{i,i}/2-u_{i,j}u_{j,i}/2$
. Figures 2(a–d) show the particle distributions for different density ratios at volume fraction
$\phi = 0.5\,\%$
. Because of the low
$\phi$
, the instantaneous clustering patterns do not exhibit significant differences among the cases. Nevertheless, closer inspection reveals that light particles tend to reside near or even within the vortical structures (figures 2
a,b), whereas heavy particles are rarely found in such regions. In addition, small-scale vortical motions are more frequently observed in the vicinity of individual heavy particles, which can be attributed to their larger inertia and slip velocity. Figures 2(e,f) illustrate the clustering of the lightest particles
$(\rho _r = 0.002)$
at higher volume fractions (
$\phi = 1\,\%, 5\,\%$
). As the particle volume fraction increases, the clustering becomes more pronounced. In particular, at
$\phi = 5\,\%$
(figure 2
f), substantial particle clusters emerge in the regions of intense vorticity, forming large coherent clusters along the vortex structures.
Standard deviations and relative errors of the Voronoï cell volumes
$V^i/\bar {V}^i$
and particle Reynolds number
$\textit{Re}_p$
over different time windows.

Table 2. Long description
The table presents data on standard deviations and relative errors of Vorono cell volumes and particle Reynolds number across three time windows labeled A, B1, and B2. It consists of four columns: Window, Relative error of sigma(V^I/|V^I|), Relative error of sigma(R_e_p), and sigma(R_e_p). The first column lists the time windows A, B1, and B2. The second column shows the standard deviations for the Vorono cell volumes with values 0.475, 0.482, and 0.463 respectively. The third column indicates the relative errors of these standard deviations, with B1 showing a 1.41 percentage increase and B2 showing a 2.58 percentage decrease compared to A. The fourth column lists the standard deviations for the particle Reynolds number with values 0.378, 0.375, and 0.375 respectively. The fifth column shows the relative errors of these standard deviations, with B1 and B2 both showing a 0.8 percentage decrease compared to A.
Time evolution of the means and variances of the velocities of particles. Time is non-dimensionalised by the large-eddy time scale
$T_l$
.

Figure 1. Long description
The line graph displays the time evolution of the means and variances of the velocities of particles. The x-axis represents time non-dimensionalised by the large-eddy time scale, ranging from 0 to 30. The y-axis represents the means and variances of the velocities of particles. The graph includes six data lines: three solid lines representing the means of the velocities in the x, y, and z directions, and three dashed lines representing the variances of the velocities in the x, y, and z directions. The solid lines for the means of the velocities are colored red, orange, and blue, while the dashed lines for the variances are colored red, orange, and blue with a dashed pattern. The means of the velocities fluctuate around a value of 1, while the variances fluctuate around a value of 0. All values are approximated.
Instantaneous snapshots of particle distributions and vortical structures of different cases. A sub-volume covering one-sixth of the computational domain, i.e.
$-16 D_p\lt x\lt -10D_p$
, is visualised. Black spheres represent particles, and the blue contours denote the vorticity magnitude
$|\omega _{f}|$
on the
$x=-12$
plane. The semi-transparent golden structures indicate vortical regions identified by the
$Q=2$
iso-surfaces. (a–d) Cases with volume fraction
$\phi _v=0.5\,\%$
and density ratios (a)
$\rho _r=0.002$
, (b)
$\rho _r=0.2$
, (c)
$\rho _r=1.0$
, (d)
$\rho _r=20.0$
. (e,f) Light particles
$(\rho _r=0.002)$
at higher volume fractions: (e)
$\phi =1.0\,\%$
and (f)
$\phi =5.0\,\%$
.

Figure 2. Long description
The image displays a sub-volume covering one-sixth of the computational domain, showcasing particle distributions and vortical structures. Black spheres represent particles, while blue contours indicate the vorticity magnitude on the plane. Semi-transparent golden structures highlight vortical regions identified by iso-surfaces. The image compares cases with varying volume fractions and density ratios, including light particles at higher volume fractions.
The p.d.f.s of the Voronoï cell volumes. (a) Particles with different density ratios at a fixed volume fraction (
$\phi = 0.5\,\%$
). Reference data are case D5 from Uhlmann & Chouippe (Reference Uhlmann and Chouippe2017) (
$D_p/\eta =5.5$
,
$\rho _r=1.5$
). (b) The lightest particles (
$\rho _r = 0.002$
) at higher volume fractions (
$\phi = 1 \,\%$
and
$5\,\%$
). In both panels, ‘Random’ represents a random Poisson distribution at the corresponding volume fraction, and ‘Gamma’ indicates the standard gamma distribution. In (b), the solid, dashed and dash-dotted lines correspond to volume fractions
$\phi = 0.5\,\%$
,
$1.0\,\%$
and
$5.0\,\%$
, respectively.

Figure 3. Long description
The image contains two line graphs labeled (a) and (b). Graph (a) shows the probability density functions of Voronoi cell volumes for particles with different density ratios at a fixed volume fraction. The density ratios are color-coded: red for 0.002, purple for 0.2, cyan for 1.0, blue for 1.5, and orange for 20.0. The black line represents a random Poisson distribution, and the gray line indicates the standard gamma distribution. Graph (b) displays the probability density functions for the lightest particles at higher volume fractions. The solid, dashed, and dash-dotted lines correspond to volume fractions of 0.5 percent, 1.0 percent, and 5.0 percent, respectively. The black line represents a random Poisson distribution, and the gray line indicates the standard gamma distribution. Both graphs use a logarithmic scale for the y-axis, labeled as P.d.f., and the x-axis, labeled as V_i over <V_i =.
We first assess the degree of particle clustering using a Voronoï analysis. Figure 3(a) shows the probability density functions (p.d.f.s) of the normalised Voronoï cell volumes for finite-size particles of various density ratios
$\rho _r$
at a fixed volume fraction (
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
). Results for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) at two additional higher volume fractions (
$\phi =1\,\%$
and
$5\,\%$
) are also included in figure 3(b), plotted in red with different line styles. For reference, the random distributions obtained from a spatially random Poisson process at the respective volume fractions are included, along with data from the reference case D5 of Uhlmann & Chouippe (Reference Uhlmann and Chouippe2017) (
$\rho _r=1.5$
,
$D_p/\eta =5.5$
,
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
). It is evident that light particles (
$\rho _r=0.002,0.2$
) exhibit stronger clustering, and heavy particles (
$\rho _r=1.5,20$
) display weaker clustering, whereas neutrally buoyant particles (
$\rho _r=1.0$
) remain close to the random distribution. These observations align with earlier findings (Fiabane et al. Reference Fiabane, Zimmermann, Volk, Pinton and Bourgoin2012; Tagawa et al. Reference Tagawa, Mercado, Prakash, Calzavarini, Sun and Lohse2012; Uhlmann & Chouippe Reference Uhlmann and Chouippe2017). Moreover, as the volume fraction increases, the normalised Voronoï distribution for the random case narrows and converges towards mean value unity. In stark contrast, the distribution for light particles broadens, with a pronounced increase in probability at small volumes. This behaviour signifies that the clustering of the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) intensifies markedly with increasing volume fraction
$\phi$
.
To quantify the degree of clustering, we compute the clustering indicator
$C$
following the work of Tagawa et al. (Reference Tagawa, Mercado, Prakash, Calzavarini, Sun and Lohse2012, Reference Tagawa, Roghair, Prakash, van Sint Annaland, Kuipers, Sun and Lohse2013):
where
$\sigma (\bar {V}) = \sigma (V^{i}/ \langle V^{i} \rangle )$
is the standard deviation of the normalised Voronoï volumes, and
$\sigma (\bar {V}_{\textit{rnd}})$
is the corresponding value for a random distribution at the same
$\phi$
. The variation of the clustering indicator
$C$
reflects the same trend in figure 4. As the particle density ratio decreases (from 20 to 0.002), the degree of clustering first weakens and then increases, with neutrally buoyant particles (
$\rho _r = 1$
) exhibiting the lowest level of clustering (figure 4
a). It is clear that the lightest particles exhibit the largest
$C$
, indicating the strongest clustering degree (Tagawa et al. Reference Tagawa, Mercado, Prakash, Calzavarini, Sun and Lohse2012). Slightly heavier or lighter finite-size particles (
$\rho _r=20.0, 0.2$
) also exhibit non-uniform clustering. By contrast, neutrally buoyant particles (
$\rho _r=1.0$
) yield
$C \approx 1$
, indicating a random spatial distribution. Furthermore, the clustering indicator
$C$
increases significantly with
$\phi$
(figure 4
b), confirming that the clustering of light particles intensifies at higher particle concentrations. This trend qualitatively agrees with the light point particles (
$\beta =3/(1+2\rho _r)=3$
) reported in Tagawa et al. (Reference Tagawa, Mercado, Prakash, Calzavarini, Sun and Lohse2012), which is attributed to the formation of complex clustering structures of particles.
Clustering indicator
$C$
for particles of (a) different density ratios at a fixed volume fraction (
$\phi = 0.5\,\%$
), together with (b) results for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r = 0.002$
) at higher volume fractions (
$\phi = 0.5\,\%, 1.0\,\%, 5.0\,\%$
).

Figure 4. Long description
The image contains two line graphs. The first graph (a) shows the clustering indicator for particles with different density ratios at a fixed volume fraction. The x-axis represents the density ratio on a logarithmic scale, while the y-axis represents the clustering indicator. The graph features three data points connected by dashed lines, with distinct markers indicating different density ratios. The second graph (b) illustrates the clustering indicator for the lightest particles at higher volume fractions. The x-axis represents the volume fraction in percentage, and the y-axis represents the clustering indicator. The graph shows a single line with data points marked by squares, indicating an increasing trend in the clustering indicator as the volume fraction increases. All values are approximated.
3.2. Preferential particle locations
Having noticed the presence of pronounced clustering of finite-size light particles, we next turn to the question: where do these particles preferentially cluster? For point particles, previous studies have reached a clear consensus: heavy particles preferentially cluster in high-strain and low-vorticity regions, whereas light particles exhibit the opposite tendency. Several mechanisms have been proposed to explain these behaviours for heavy particles, e.g. Maxey (Reference Maxey1987), Goto & Vassilicos (Reference Goto and Vassilicos2008) and Bragg & Collins (Reference Bragg and Collins2014a ), and for light particles, e.g. Calzavarini et al. (Reference Calzavarini, Kerscher, Lohse and Toschi2008) and Tagawa et al. (Reference Tagawa, Mercado, Prakash, Calzavarini, Sun and Lohse2012). More recently, attention has shifted to finite-size effects on inertial particle clustering. Other studies, such as Uhlmann & Chouippe (Reference Uhlmann and Chouippe2017) and Chiarini & Rosti (Reference Chiarini and Rosti2024), examined the clustering mechanisms and spatial characteristics of finite-size heavy particles by analysing the distributions of vorticity and flow acceleration in their vicinity, and comparing their behaviour with point particles. However, for finite-size light particles, no DNS studies have yet explored this question.
Unlike PP-DNS, it is not suitable here to directly interpolate the local fluid variables at the particle centroid (the particle position
$\boldsymbol{x}_p$
). The approaches of previous studies evaluate the near-particle fluid variables (denoted by the subscript
$f{\kern-1pt}@{\kern-1pt}p$
) on a spherical shell of diameter
$D_{sh}=3D_p$
centred at
$\boldsymbol{x}_p$
, and then average over the shell (Uhlmann & Chouippe Reference Uhlmann and Chouippe2017; Chiarini & Rosti Reference Chiarini and Rosti2024). The choice of
$D_{sh}$
should avoid the trivial result that the interpolated near-particle fluid velocity equals the particle velocity under the no-slip boundary condition, while still capturing the local fluid information sampled by the particle. To assess the sensitivity of flow statistics to the shell averaging strategy, we first analyse the mean value of both fluid
$Q$
-criterion and vorticity magnitude
$|\omega _f|$
as a function of the distance
$r$
from the particle surface.
Normalised mean (a,b)
$Q$
-criterion
$\langle Q\rangle /\sigma (Q_0)$
and (c,d) vorticity magnitude
$|\omega _f| / |\omega _{f0}|$
, as functions of the distance from the particle surface
$r/D_p$
. (a,c) Cases for particles with different particle density ratios at fixed volume fraction
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
. (b,d) Cases for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) with varied volume fraction.

Figure 5. Long description
The image contains four line graphs. The first two graphs (a and b) display the normalized mean criterion, while the last two graphs (c and d) show the vorticity magnitude, both as functions of the distance from the particle surface. Graphs (a) and (c) compare cases for particles with different particle density ratios at a fixed volume fraction. Graphs (b) and (d) compare cases for the lightest particles with varied volume fractions. Each graph has distinct lines representing different conditions, with the x-axis labeled as the distance from the particle surface and the y-axis labeled as the normalized mean criterion or vorticity magnitude. The trends and peaks in the graphs illustrate how these parameters change with distance under different conditions.
Figures 5(a,b) present the distribution profiles of the normalised mean
$Q$
-criterion,
$\langle Q\rangle /\sigma (Q_0)$
, where
$\sigma (Q_0)$
is the standard deviation of
$Q$
in the single-phase flow. Correspondingly, figures 5(c,d) show the normalised vorticity magnitude
$|\omega _f| / |\omega _{f0}|$
, where
$|\omega _{f0}|=\omega _{\eta 0} = 1/ \tau _{\eta 0}$
denotes the mean vorticity magnitude of the single-phase flow. In the immediate vicinity of the particle surface (
$r/D_p\rightarrow 0$
), all cases exhibit positive values of
$\langle Q\rangle$
and a peak of vorticity magnitude
$|\omega _f| / |\omega _{f0}|$
. The no-slip boundary condition is expected to enhance flow shear near the particle surfaces so as to magnify the velocity gradients; our statistical results further indicate the dominant vorticial deformations (positive
$Q$
) in the near-wall region (
$r/D_p \lesssim 0.2$
). The magnitude of this positive peak varies with particle inertia. Neutrally buoyant particles
$(\rho _r=1.0)$
follow the carrier flow most closely, producing the weakest positive
$\langle Q\rangle$
near the surface; light particles deviate moderately, whereas heavy particles respond least to local fluid motion due to their large inertia, resulting in the strongest near-surface peak.
As we move slightly away from the particle surface,
$r/D_p\approx 0.5$
, a clear separation appears between light and heavy particles. Light particles
$(\rho _r \lt 1.0)$
maintain
$\langle Q\rangle \gt 0$
, indicating a tendency to preferentially sample the vortex-dominated regions. Conversely, heavier particles
$(\rho _r \geqslant 1.0)$
exhibit
$\langle Q\rangle \lt 0$
, consistent with their tendency to avoid vortical regions and cluster in high-strain zones. Neutrally buoyant particles approach zero more rapidly and remain close to zero at this location, as expected from their improved ability to follow the fluid motion with minimal inertial lag. For
$r/D_p\gtrsim 1$
, all
$\langle Q\rangle /\sigma (Q_0)$
curves converge towards zero, showing that the influence of finite-size particles on the surrounding fluid diminishes, and that the selected shell radius is large enough to capture undisturbed local flow properties.
We then examine the influence of particle volume fraction by focusing on the lightest particles
$(\rho _r = 0.002)$
, as presented in figures 5(b,d). At
$\phi =1\,\%$
, the
$\langle Q(r)\rangle$
and
$|\omega _f|$
profiles show minimal differences with
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
, indicating that clustering behaviour remains dilute and does not significantly alter the flow. However, for
$\phi =5\,\%$
, the
$\langle Q(r)\rangle$
profile shifts downwards (particularly slightly away from the particles), while the vorticity profile
$|\omega _f| / |\omega _{f0}|$
slightly increases (particularly near the particles), reflecting simultaneous enhancement of both shear and vorticity. This shift could be associated with the formation of large particle clusters, which might modulate the turbulence by enhancing both small-scale rotational regions and large-scale strain-dominated regions. The observed change therefore represents turbulence modulations induced by particle clustering, rather than a bias introduced by the selection of the shell-averaging radius. Interestingly, for light particles,
$\langle Q\rangle$
becomes slightly negative at sufficiently large distances
$(r/D_p\approx 1.5)$
for all volume fractions, further indicating their tendency to avoid low-vorticity regions, which leads to negative
$\langle Q\rangle$
values in the far field.
The p.d.f.s of the vorticity magnitude normalised by the single-phase reference value
$\omega _{f0}$
: (a,b) results at
$r/D_p=0.5$
and
$r/D_p=1$
for varying density ratios
$\rho _r$
at
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
; (c,d) results at
$r/D_p=0.5$
and
$r/D_p=1$
for the lightest particles
$(\rho _r=0.002)$
at different volume fractions
$\phi$
. The solid black curves indicate the single-phase reference p.d.f.

Figure 6. Long description
The image contains four graphs labeled (a), (b), (c), and (d), each comparing probability density functions (p.d.f.s) of vorticity magnitude normalized by single-phase reference values. Graphs (a) and (b) show results at different density ratios, while graphs (c) and (d) display results for the lightest particles at varying volume fractions. Each graph includes a solid black curve indicating the single-phase reference p.d.f. The x-axis represents the normalized vorticity magnitude, and the y-axis represents the probability density function. Insets in each graph provide a zoomed-in view of specific data ranges. The graphs illustrate how different parameters affect the distribution of vorticity magnitude in the presence of particles.
Motivated by the observations of the mean
$\langle Q\rangle /\sigma (Q_0)$
and
$|\omega _f| / |\omega _{f0}|$
profiles as functions of
$r$
, we further calculated the p.d.f.s of the vorticity magnitude in two spherical shells centred at the particle locations: one at
$r/D_p=0.5$
(corresponding to
$D_{sh}=2D_p$
), and the other at
$r/D_p=1$
(corresponding to
$D_{sh}=3D_p$
). Figures 6(a,b) show the resulting distributions for varying density ratios, and figures 6(c,d) for volume fractions. All vorticity values are normalised by the characteristic single-phase vorticity
$\omega _{f0}$
, and the corresponding single-phase p.d.f. is included for comparison. There are two distinct mechanisms that contribute to the vorticity near particle surfaces: (i) self-induced shear, arising from the strong velocity gradients enforced by the no-slip boundary condition around finite-size particles; and (ii) preferential sampling of the background turbulence. The statistics of the flow vorticity magnitude are also presented in figure 7 as references. Compared with the single-phase flow, the presence of particles leads to a pronounced rise of the tails of p.d.f.s. at
$|\omega _f| \gtrsim 5\,|\omega _{f0}|$
. In particular, the particles with
$\rho _r=20$
exhibit the heaviest tail, while the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) at
$\phi =5\,\%$
enhance vorticity over a wider range (
$|\omega _f| \gtrsim |\omega _{f0}|$
).
The p.d.f.s of the fluid vorticity magnitude normalised by the single-phase reference value
$\omega _{f0}$
: (a) on a log–log scale; (b) on a semi-log scale.

Figure 7. Long description
The image contains two graphs labeled (a) and (b). Graph (a) uses a log-log scale, while graph (b) uses a semi-log scale. Both graphs plot the probability density functions (p.d.f.s) of the fluid vorticity magnitude normalized by a single-phase reference value. The x-axis in both graphs represents the normalized vorticity magnitude, while the y-axis represents the probability density function. Multiple colored lines represent different conditions with varying density ratios and volume fractions. The black line with circles represents the single-phase reference. The graphs show how the p.d.f.s change under different conditions, with notable differences in the distribution shapes and trends. The data points are approximated.
Considering first the influence of density ratio, figures 6(a,b) demonstrate that light particles exhibit clear preferential sampling of high-vorticity regions at
$r/D_p=0.5$
. However, this effect becomes much less evident at
$r/D_p=1$
. This attenuation may be attributed to the rapid decay of particle-induced flow disturbances with increasing distance from the surface. As the sampling shell moves outwards, the conditional flow statistics asymptotically approach the background turbulence (figure 7
b). As the influence of the particle on the local flow structure weakens, the contrast in sampling behaviours between different particles diminishes. Simultaneously, the vorticity distribution gradually approaches that of the global flow field. The preference of heavy particles for low-vorticity regions is clearly visible at
$r/D_p=1$
, where particle-induced shear is weak, and background sampling dominates. At
$r/D_p=0.5$
, however, this tendency appears less distinct. A comparison with the global vorticity statistics (figure 7
b) reveals that despite their preference for strain-dominated regions, heavy particles exhibit a higher probability of sampling high vorticity at this near-surface location than in the bulk flow. This discrepancy suggests that strong local velocity gradients (e.g. particle-induced shear layers) in the immediate vicinity of the surface cause high flow vorticity. These intense local contributions may broaden the high-vorticity tail of the distribution, thereby possibly masking the underlying signature of preferential clustering in strain-dominated regions. Additionally, the curves in the small-window insets indicate that the distribution of extreme vorticity (
$|\omega _f| \gtrsim 5\,|\omega _{f0}|$
) induced by the no-slip boundary condition on the particles does not differ significantly.
When varying the particle volume fraction for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) in figures 6(c,d), the transition from
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
to
$\phi=1\,\%$
results in a slight reduction of the probability for moderate vorticity levels (
$|\omega _{f0}| \lesssim |\omega _f| \lesssim 3\,|\omega _{f0}|$
), but a slight enhancement for extreme vorticity (
$|\omega _f| \gtrsim 5\,|\omega _{f0}|$
). As shown in figure 7(a), the global vorticity statistics of the carrier flow are nearly identical for these two low volume fractions. The observed changes likely arise because an increase in particle volume fraction reduces the efficiency with which light particles sample the limited high-vorticity regions of the background turbulence. The probability of obtaining extreme vorticity values, which is driven by the strong shear generated at the particle surfaces, remains higher at
$\phi =1\,\%$
. Nevertheless, the probability of encountering high vorticity (
$|\omega _f| \gtrsim |\omega _{f0}|$
) remains above that of the single-phase reference, especially at
$r/D_p=0.5$
, where the signature of preferential sampling is still clearly visible. As before, the departures from the single-phase reference are less prominent at
$r/D_p=1$
than at
$r/D_p=0.5$
, reflecting the diminishing influence of particle–flow interactions with increasing distance from the particle surface
$r$
. This pattern suggests that the preferential sampling of high-vorticity regions by light particles is most effective in the immediate vicinity of the particles. At
$\phi =5\,\%$
, however, a pronounced enhancement of vorticity is observed at both
$r/D_p=0.5$
and
$r/D_p=1.0$
compared with the lower
$\phi$
, consistent with turbulence modulation induced by the emergence of large particle clusters. To further investigate the modulation of the flow field, we provide a brief discussion on flow statistics and energy spectra in Appendix B.
To clarify the physical mechanism underlying the strong clustering enhancement of finite-size light particles at high
$\phi$
, as quantified in figure 4, we compare our results with previous findings. In dilute conditions (
$\phi \lesssim 1\,\%$
), the preferential concentration of light particles (
$\rho _r =0.002$
) is governed primarily by the added-mass and pressure-gradient forces, which is more pronounced compared with heavy particles (Aliseda & Lasheras Reference Aliseda and Lasheras2011). As observed by Calzavarini et al. (Reference Calzavarini, Kerscher, Lohse and Toschi2008) and Tagawa et al. (Reference Tagawa, Mercado, Prakash, Calzavarini, Sun and Lohse2012), light particles tend to cluster within the high-vorticity tubes (or filaments) of the turbulence. Calzavarini et al. (Reference Calzavarini, Kerscher, Lohse and Toschi2008) notably characterised these structures as quasi-one-dimensional, with particles forming slender chains that closely trace the skeleton of vortex tubes. Our observations of
$\langle Q\rangle \gt 0$
in figure 5(a) confirm that finite-size light particles initially follow the same vortex-trapping mechanism. However, as
$\phi$
increases, a critical saturation effect emerges. The limited volume of vortex filaments is not capable of containing the large number of particles tending to accumulate in the vortex cores (de Wit et al. Reference de Wit, Kunnen, Clercx and Toschi2024). Consequently, the excluded-volume effect of finite-size particles forces the particles to form impact clustering structures surrounding the vortex cores. This induces a morphological transition from the slender filaments described by Calzavarini et al. (Reference Calzavarini, Kerscher, Lohse and Toschi2008) to thicker, more compact clusters, leading to an increase in both the clustering indicator
$C$
and the fractal dimension. Furthermore, the formation of compact particle clusters increases the possibility for many-body inter-particle interactions. The wake attraction between closely spaced particles (Tagawa et al. Reference Tagawa, Roghair, Prakash, van Sint Annaland, Kuipers, Sun and Lohse2013) may further strengthen the clusters. In turn, the formation of large-scale clusters would further modulate the carrier turbulence. In particular, the increased flow vorticity magnitude observed in figure 7 could be ascribed to the particle-induced local flow shear, which is presumably enhanced by the intensified momentum exchange within and surrounding the particle clusters. This intensification of vorticity could reinforce the preferential concentration of light particles, attracting additional light particles, and sustaining the growth of large-scale clusters.
3.3. Particle dynamics
To gain further insight into the dynamics of particles with different inertia, we recall the governing equation of a single spherical point particle (Gatignol Reference Gatignol1983; Maxey & Riley Reference Maxey and Riley1983). The particle acceleration
$\boldsymbol{a}_p = {\rm d} \boldsymbol{U}_{\!p} / {\rm d}t$
can be expressed as
The finite Reynolds number correction
$f(Re_p)$
will become increasingly relevant as
$\textit{Re}_p = \langle |\boldsymbol{u}_{\!f{\kern-1pt}@{\kern-1pt}p} - \boldsymbol{U}_{\!p}|\rangle D_p/\nu$
increases. The fluid velocity at particle position
$\boldsymbol{u}_{\!f{\kern-1pt}@{\kern-1pt}p} = \boldsymbol{u}(\boldsymbol{x}_p(t),t)$
is calculated using the value sampled at the spherical shell with
$D_{sh}=3D_p$
. The two terms on the right-hand side correspond to the Stokes drag and the combined pressure-gradient force and added-mass contributions, respectively. For heavy particles (
$\beta \rightarrow 0$
), the drag term dominates, whereas for light particles, the other term becomes increasingly significant. As a result, under the influence of combined pressure-gradient and added-mass forces, light particles tend to be entrained into the vicinity of the vortex cores and preferentially cluster along vortex filaments (Calzavarini et al. Reference Calzavarini, Kerscher, Lohse and Toschi2008). In order to examine whether the aforementioned mechanism remains important for finite-size particles, we investigate the relative angle between the particle acceleration
$\boldsymbol{a}_p$
and the slip velocity
$\boldsymbol{u}_s = \boldsymbol{u}_{\!f{\kern-1pt}@{\kern-1pt}p}-\boldsymbol{U}_{\!p}$
by computing the cosine value of the angle
$\theta _{as}$
of these two vectors:
The p.d.f.s of the angle between particle acceleration
$\boldsymbol{a}_p$
and slip velocity
$\boldsymbol{u}_s$
for (a) particles with various density ratios at a fixed volume fraction (
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
), and (b) light particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) with different
$\phi$
. The
$\sin \theta$
curve corresponding to a random distribution is included as a reference.

Figure 8. Long description
The image contains two line graphs labeled (a) and (b). Graph (a) shows the probability density functions of the angle between particle acceleration and slip velocity for particles with various density ratios at a fixed volume fraction. The density ratios are represented by different colored lines: red for 0.002, yellow for 0.2, green for 1.0, and purple for 20.0. The x-axis represents the angle in degrees, ranging from 0 to 180, and the y-axis represents the probability density function. Graph (b) shows the probability density functions for light particles with different volume fractions, represented by red for 0.5 percent, orange for 1.0 percent, and light blue for 5.0 percent. A dashed black line in both graphs represents a random distribution as a reference. The curves in both graphs illustrate how the angle between particle acceleration and slip velocity varies with different density ratios and volume fractions.
Figure 8 presents the p.d.f.s of the angle
$\theta _{as}$
under different conditions. In figure 8(a), at
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
, heavy particles (
$\rho _r=20$
) exhibit distributions strongly peaked near
$\theta _{as} = 0$
, indicating a strong alignment between the particle acceleration and the slip velocity. This reflects the dominance of the drag contribution in governing the dynamics of particles. In contrast, neutrally buoyant (
$\rho _r=1$
) and light (
$\rho _r=0.2, 0.002$
) particles display much flatter distributions, suggesting that the direction of particle acceleration is only weakly correlated with the slip velocity. Relative to the random reference, represented by the
$\sin\theta$
distribution, neutrally buoyant particles show a mild tendency towards acute angles, whereas light particles preferentially populate obtuse angles, likely due to the enhanced contribution of the pressure-gradient and added-mass terms. Figure 8(b) shows the angle distributions for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) at different volume fractions. It is interesting to note that the distributions are remarkably similar at low volume fraction (
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
and
$1.0\,\%$
), whereas at a higher volume fraction (
$\phi =5\,\%$
), the p.d.f. approaches a random distribution as
$\text{p.d.f.}(\theta _{as}) = \sin \theta _{as}$
(the dashed line in figure 8). This enhanced randomness is attributed to stronger clustering and more frequent particle–particle collisions at higher
$\phi$
, which could disrupt the local force balance and weaken the directional coherence between acceleration and slip velocity.
The p.d.f.s of (a) the particle velocity magnitude
$\boldsymbol{U}_{\!p}$
normalised by the Kolmogorov velocity
$u_{\eta }$
, and (b) the Reynolds number of particles
$\textit{Re}_{p}$
for particles with various density ratios
$\rho _r$
and volume fractions
$\phi$
. The dashed black line in (b) shows a gamma distribution (shape parameter
$A=3$
, and scale parameter
$B= 1/ \sqrt 3$
) used as reference.

Figure 9. Long description
The image contains two line graphs. The first graph (a) plots the probability density function of the particle velocity magnitude normalized by the Kolmogorov velocity. The x-axis represents the normalized particle velocity magnitude, and the y-axis represents the probability density function. Different colored lines represent various density ratios and volume fractions. The second graph (b) plots the probability density function of the Reynolds number of particles. The x-axis represents the Reynolds number, and the y-axis represents the probability density function. Different colored lines represent various density ratios and volume fractions. A dashed black line in graph (b) shows a gamma distribution used as a reference. The graphs illustrate how particle velocity and Reynolds number distributions vary with different density ratios and volume fractions.
Having examined the force balance, we now analyse the particle velocity and slip-velocity statistics. Figure 9(a) presents the p.d.f.s of the particle velocity magnitude
$|\boldsymbol{U}_{\!p}|$
normalised by the Kolmogorov velocity
$u_{\eta }$
. Except for the heaviest particle (
$\rho _r=20$
), the velocity distributions collapse closely onto that of neutrally buoyant particles at
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
, confirming that particle inertia only weakly affects their translational speed in the dilute regime. Heavy particles display noticeably reduced velocities because of their sluggish response. Light particles exhibit slightly enhanced probabilities at both low and high velocities, consistent with their stronger response to local turbulent fluctuations. At a higher volume fraction (
$\phi =5\,\%$
), however, the velocity distribution for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) changes dramatically: the entire distribution shifts towards significantly higher velocities, and a distinct secondary peak emerges. This behaviour is indicative of large-scale clustered structures, where collective motion enhances the particle velocity.
The particle Reynolds number
$\textit{Re}_p = \langle |\boldsymbol{u}_{s}|\rangle D_p/\nu$
provides further insight into the particle response. In figure 9(b), the
$\textit{Re}_p$
distribution for neutrally buoyant particles and moderately light particles (
$\rho _r=0.2$
) closely follows a gamma distribution, consistent with the observation reported in Uhlmann & Chouippe (Reference Uhlmann and Chouippe2017). Heavy particles (
$\rho _r=20$
) exhibit higher probabilities at large
$\textit{Re}_p$
, reflecting intensified slip induced by their inertia, in line with the findings of Chiarini & Rosti (Reference Chiarini and Rosti2024). For the very light particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
), the probability of finding small
$\textit{Re}_p$
is strongly enhanced, confirming their excellent flow-tracking ability. Nevertheless, a pronounced secondary peak emerges at large
$\textit{Re}_p$
, which becomes more pronounced with increasing volume fraction
$\phi$
.
The emergence of these pronounced dual peaks in the velocity distributions for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) at
$\phi =5.0\,\%$
warrants a mechanistic interpretation. We hypothesise that this behaviour stems from the interplay between intense clustering and multi-body collisional dynamics. At this high volume fraction, very light particles are continuously entrained into vortex cores, forming dense clusters. Although directly resolving all the contact details remains challenging, our particle-pair statistics indicate that approximately
$10\,\%$
of particles are experiencing simultaneous interactions with three or more neighbours, with occasionally extreme events involving up to eight particles observed. It is plausible that these multi-body encounters induce substantial impulsive accelerations, temporarily causing extreme particle velocities much greater than the characteristic particle velocity variance. This mechanism would naturally give rise to the secondary high-
$\textit{Re}_p$
peak observed in figure 9. Furthermore, these clusters are dynamically fragile. Turbulent fluctuations may intermittently destabilise them, ejecting high-speed particles outwards. While these very light particles are rapidly decelerated by the fluid due to their low inertia, frequent re-entrainment into nearby vortex structures sustains the cycle, resulting in the observed bimodal statistics. The primary peak reflects tracer-like behaviour, while the secondary peak captures these intermittent, collision-driven high-speed events within dense clusters.
Additionally, we should acknowledge that the validity of local fluid sampling may be violated in these extreme conditions. Within dense clusters, the local fluid volume fraction drops significantly, potentially deteriorating the calculation of the local flow velocity by averaging over the sphere-shell sample points; these points become sparse and heterogeneous in the interstitial fluid regions. Moreover, we speculate that the squeezing of fluid between closely spaced particles could further induce extreme local fluid flow, contributing to the widening of the slip-velocity distribution.
To further quantify the momentum exchange characteristics implied by the complex slip-velocity dynamics discussed above, we compare our DNS results with the analytical model proposed by Berk & Coletti (Reference Berk and Coletti2024) for the mean particle slip velocity. This model is rooted in the inertial filtering framework (Csanady Reference Csanady1963; Berk & Coletti Reference Berk and Coletti2021), and derives closed-form expressions for mean slip velocity under simplifying assumptions: a Gaussian distribution of slip velocity, negligible history and lift forces, the equilibrium Eulerian approximations for small light particles (Ferry & Balachandar Reference Ferry and Balachandar2001), and one-way coupling approach (neglecting particles’ feedback to fluid flows and the particle–particle interactions). While the model offers predictions for extreme density ratios (
$\rho _r \ll 1$
or
$\rho _r \gg 1$
), its accuracy relies heavily on these conditions. The particle response time
$\tau _p$
is defined as
$\tau _p = D_p^2/[12 \nu \beta\, \phi (Re_p)]$
for spherical particles. The function
$\phi (Re_p)$
accounts for finite Reynolds number effects on the drag coefficient, defined via
$C_D = (24/Re_p)\,\phi (Re_p)$
; Berk & Coletti (Reference Berk and Coletti2024) employ the Schiller and Naumann correlation (Clift et al. Reference Clift, Grace and Weber2005)
$\phi (Re_p) = 1 + 0.15\, Re_p^{0.687}$
. The Stokes number is then defined as
$St = \tau _p / \tau _{\eta }$
.
The quantitative comparison in table 3 reveals that only the dilute, extreme-density case (run0) agrees well with the theory. Deviations in other cases arise from specific violations of the model’s assumptions.
-
(i) Density ratio limits: cases run02 (
$\rho _r=0.2$
), run1 and run20 fall outside the asymptotic limits (
$\rho _r \ll 1$
or
$\gg 1$
). Notably, run20 retains reasonable agreement due to its pronounced inertia, which partially satisfies the heavy-particle approximation. -
(ii) Coupling and volume fraction effects: the larger discrepancies occur in cases run01 and run05, where high volume fractions violate the one-way coupling assumption.
Unlike the model, our DNS resolve strong two-way coupling and multi-particle interactions, both of which intensify significantly with increasing volume fraction. In dense clusters, neighbouring particles drastically alter local flow structures, rendering the ‘local’ slip velocity unrepresentative of the momentum exchange between the particle and the surrounding fluid. Consequently, the particle Reynolds number (
$\textit{Re}_p$
) also loses fidelity as a metric for inertial-to-viscous force balance in these complex interaction zones. In summary, the analytical model holds only for dilute suspensions with extreme density ratios. Substantial deviations arise in dense regimes. The collective effects, specifically turbulence modulations by particles and frequent inter-particle collisions, violate the one-way coupling assumption, and alter the slip-velocity statistics from model predictions.
Comparison between the theoretical prediction of Berk & Coletti (Reference Berk and Coletti2024) and the present numerical results of the mean particle slip velocity. Here,
$\langle |\boldsymbol{u}_s|\rangle ^{the}$
and
$\langle |\boldsymbol{u}_s|\rangle ^{cal}$
are the theoretical estimations and DNS results, respectively.

Table 3. Long description
The table presents a comparison between theoretical predictions and numerical results of the mean particle slip velocity for various cases. It includes columns for case identifiers, beta values, St values, theoretical estimations, and DNS results. The table has six rows and five columns. Row 1: run0, beta 2.988, St 0.907, theoretical 1.843, DNS 1.886. Row 2: run02, beta 2.143, St 1.194, theoretical 1.277, DNS 2.110. Row 3: run1, beta 1.000, St 2.571, theoretical 1.781, DNS 2.067. Row 4: run20, beta 0.073, St 27.386, theoretical 4.304, DNS 3.972. Row 5: run01, beta 2.988, St 0.848, theoretical 1.722, DNS 2.119. Row 6: run05, beta 2.988, St 0.657, theoretical 1.594, DNS 6.063.
3.4. Particle–particle collisions
Due to strong particle–particle interactions associated with clustering, the relative motion and collision among particles are worth special investigation. To this end, we study the particle-pair statistics and inter-particle collision rate in this subsection.
First, we examine the radial distribution function (RDF) and the radial relative velocity (RRV) of particles as functions of the centre-to-centre separation of particle pairs,
$r_c$
. The RDF, denoted by
$g(r_c)$
, is defined as (Zaidi, Tsuji & Tanaka Reference Zaidi, Tsuji and Tanaka2014)
where
$n_p = N_p / V_{{tot}}$
represents the particle number density, and
$\textrm{d}N(r_c)$
denotes the histogram of particle pairs whose centre-to-centre distance falls inside the interval
$[r_c,r_c+\textrm{d}r_c]$
. According to the definition (3.4), the RDF measures the relative probability of finding another particle at a distance
$r_c$
from a reference one. For a nominally random distribution of point particles (or finite-size particles allowing for overlapping),
$g(r_c) \equiv 1$
; a value greater than unity, i.e.
$g(r_c) \gt 1$
, indicates the local accumulation for particles at the distance
$r_c$
. In figure 10, we present the RDFs of particles for each case under study.
The RDFs
$g(r_c)$
for finite-size particles with (a,c) different density ratios
$\rho _r$
at
$\phi = 0.5\,\%$
, and (b,d) different volume fractions
$\phi$
for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r = 0.002$
), using (a,b) semi-logarithmic coordinates with the abscissa normalised by
$D_p$
, and (c,d) log–log coordinates with the abscissa normalised by the Kolmogorov length scale
$\eta$
. The black line is the
$-1/3$
power-law scaling.

Figure 10. Long description
The image contains four graphs analyzing the radial distribution functions (RDFs) for finite-size particles. Graphs (a) and (c) display data for different density ratios, while graphs (b) and (d) show data for different volume fractions of the lightest particles. Graphs (a) and (b) use semi-logarithmic coordinates with the abscissa normalized by the particle diameter. Graphs (c) and (d) use log-log coordinates with the abscissa normalized by the Kolmogorov length scale. Each graph includes a black line representing the power-law scaling. The RDF measures the relative probability of finding another particle at a specific distance from a reference particle. Values greater than unity indicate local particle accumulation at that distance.
All particles exhibit regions where
$g(r_c) \gt 1$
at a fixed volume fraction
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
, indicating the presence of clustering (figures 10
a,c). However, the magnitude and structure of the RDF depend strongly on the density ratio
$\rho _r$
. For the particles lighter than the fluid (
$\rho _r\lt 1$
), the RDF exhibits a pronounced peak value, especially for the case with the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
). In contrast, neutrally buoyant particles (
$\rho _r=1.0$
) display a moderate peak that decays rapidly for
$r_c \gt D_p$
, consistent with the weak clustering identified in our Voronoï analysis in § 3.1. Heavy particles (
$\rho _r=20$
), driven by their large inertia, exhibit a suppressed peak and mild clustering over a broader range of separations.
In figure 10(c), we provide a close-up view of the RDF with the log–log scale. It reveals that the sharp peaks emerge in the immediate vicinity of the particle surface (
$r_c \to D_p^+$
), specifically at
$r_c - D_p \approx 0.2 \eta$
. Moreover, the magnitude of this near-contact peak varies with the particle density, and is consistent with the degree of particle clustering quantified by the Voronoï analysis in § 3.1. This behaviour can be attributed to the repulsive lubrication and collision forces between finite-size particles, which prevent particle overlap. Regarding the scaling laws, particles with
$\rho _r \leqslant 1.0$
exhibit a power-law scaling
$g(r_c) \sim [(r_c-D_p)/\eta ]^{-\zeta }$
, with exponent
$\zeta \lesssim 1/3$
in the range
$\eta \lesssim r_c-D_p \lesssim 10 \eta$
. In contrast, heavy particles (
$\rho _r=20.0$
) display a negligible exponent within a wider range. These exponents are lower than those reported in previous studies about finite-size heavy particles in turbulence (Uhlmann & Chouippe Reference Uhlmann and Chouippe2017; Chiarini & Rosti Reference Chiarini and Rosti2024). This discrepancy is likely attributable to the relatively low particle density ratios and flow Reynolds number considered in this study. However, as the density ratio increases (corresponding to a higher Stokes number), the exponent exhibits a decreasing trend, consistent with the behaviour observed for inertial point particles (Bragg et al. Reference Bragg, Ireland and Collins2015a
; Ireland, Bragg & Collins Reference Ireland, Bragg and Collins2016).
When examining the influence of volume fraction for the lightest particles
$(\rho _r=0.002)$
in figures 10(b,d), distinct physical behaviours emerge. While the RDF profiles for
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
and
$\phi =1\,\%$
are qualitatively similar, a marked deviation occurs when the volume fraction increases to
$\phi =5\,\%$
. In this dense regime, the peak value of the RDF at
$r_c \to D_p^+$
is further increased, indicative of enhanced particle clustering. This enhancement arises because very light particles are continuously preferentially concentrated by turbulent structures into regions of high vorticity. This mechanism fosters the formation of tightly packed clusters, thereby intensifying particle–particle interactions, and leading to temporary attachments within these clustering regions. Moreover, a secondary peak emerges at
$r_c \approx 2 D_p$
at
$\phi =5\,\%$
. This feature suggests a transition from simple pair correlation to multi-particle aggregation, resembling a stacking structure where particles accumulate in concentric shells. This structural reorganisation leads to a slight dip in the RDF between
$r_c \approx D_p$
and
$r_c\approx 2D_p$
. Furthermore, for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) across different volume fractions (figure 10
d), the RDFs follow the
$\zeta \approx 1/3$
scaling in the intermediate range (
$0.5\eta \lesssim r_c-D_p \lesssim 10\eta$
). Following the definition by Bec et al. (Reference Bec, Biferale, Cencini, Lanotte, Musacchio and Toschi2007), the exponent corresponds to a correlation dimension
$D_2 = d - \zeta \approx 8/3$
(in three dimensions). This value suggests that finite-size light particles organise into a ‘fat’ structure, intermediate between sheet-like distributions (
$D_2=2$
) and clumpy clusters (
$D_2=3$
) (Calzavarini et al. Reference Calzavarini, Kerscher, Lohse and Toschi2008). Moreover, the scaling exponent is insensitive to the volume fraction, indicating that the observed fractal clustering is primarily governed by single-particle dynamics and fluid–particle interactions, rather than inter-particle collisions or multi-body effects.
Then we further investigate the relative motion among particles by computing the absolute RRV
$\langle |\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}|\rangle$
, defined as the averaged relative velocity between particle pairs with a given separation distance
$r_c$
:
$\langle |\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}|\rangle = \langle |(\boldsymbol{U}_{p2} - \boldsymbol{U}_{p1})\boldsymbol{\cdot }\boldsymbol{r}_c| \rangle _{|\boldsymbol{r}_c| = r_c}$
. In figure 11, we present the variation of
$\langle |\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}|\rangle$
, normalised by the single-phase Kolmogorov velocity scale
$u_{\eta 0}$
, with increasing
$r_c$
for each case under study. As we can see,
$\langle |\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}|\rangle$
increases with the separation distance
$r_c$
and gradually saturates to an asymptotic value
$\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^{*}$
, except for the peak value of
$\langle |\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}|\rangle$
at
$r_c \to D_p^+$
related to the near-contact physics, similar to the behaviour of the RDF.
The physics behind the saturation value
$\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^{*}$
is that it provides the mean speed of the relative radial motion among particles that are moving independently with a Gaussian velocity fluctuation. Thus the formulation of
$\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^{*}$
is given by (Zhou, Wexler & Wang Reference Zhou, Wexler and Wang1998)
where
$\left | \boldsymbol{U}_{p,{rms}} \right | = \sqrt {U_{p,x,{rms}}^2 + U_{p,y,{rms}}^2 + U_{p,z,{rms}}^2}$
is the magnitude of the particle random motions. In other words, if there is no interaction among particles, then the RRV should be directly related to their velocity fluctuations by (3.5). Therefore, as we can see from figure 11, the decreased value of
$\langle |\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}|\rangle$
for particle pairs with small distance (small
$r_c$
) is related to the interactions (including hydrodynamic interactions or collisions) among particles, which cause the correlation of motions for nearby particles. As the particle–particle distance increases beyond the working distance of these interactions, the decorrelation of particle motions leads to the recovery of
$\langle |\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}|\rangle$
to the saturation value given by (3.5). Additionally, as we can see from figure 11(a), in contrast to light or neutrally buoyant particles, the rate at which the RRV recovers to
$\langle |\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}|\rangle$
is slower for heavy particles due to their high inertia.
The absolute RRV
$\langle |\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}|\rangle$
(normalised by
$u_{\eta 0}$
) as a function of the particle centre-to-centre separation
$r_c$
, for (a,c) different density ratios at
$\phi = 0.5\,\%$
, and (b,d) the lightest particles (
$\rho _r = 0.002$
) at different
$\phi$
. The colourful dashed lines indicate the theoretical limit for independently moving particles with uncorrelated Gaussian velocity fluctuations
$\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^{\textrm{*}}$
. Here, (a,b) use semi-logarithmic coordinates with the abscissa normalised by
$D_p$
, and (c,d) use log–log coordinates with the abscissa normalised by
$\eta$
. The black lines refer to power-law scalings.

Figure 11. Long description
The image contains four graphs showing the absolute RRV normalized by u_eta as a function of particle center-to-center separation. Graphs (a) and (b) use semi-logarithmic coordinates with the abscissa normalized by D_p, while graphs (c) and (d) use log-log coordinates with the abscissa normalized by η. Graphs (a) and (c) display different density ratios at phi equals 1 percent, and graphs (b) and (d) show the lightest particles at different phi values. Colorful dashed lines indicate the theoretical limit for independently moving particles with uncorrelated Gaussian velocity fluctuations. Black lines refer to power-law scalings. The graphs illustrate how the RRV varies with different density ratios and phi values, highlighting the influence of particle density and clustering behavior on the RRV.
Furthermore, the comparison among cases with different volume fractions but fixed particle density
$\rho _r=0.002$
is given in figure 11(b). We can see from this plot that
$\langle |\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}|\rangle$
exhibits small step-like peaks around
$r_c \approx 2 D_p$
and
$r_c\approx 3 D_p$
at
$\phi =5\,\%$
, which should also be ascribed to the particle structures in dense suspensions, similar to the secondary peak of the RDF observed in figure 10(b). Meanwhile, the absolute RRV for the densest case is nearly an order of magnitude higher than at lower volume fractions, and the relative velocity recovers towards the limit value
$ \boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^{*}$
more rapidly at
$\phi =5\,\%$
. These features are the signatures of strong particle–particle interactions in the dense suspension and clusters.
The plots with log–log scales further clarify the multi-scale dynamics of particle relative motions (figures 11
c,d). At separations
$r_c - D_p \gtrsim \eta$
, light and neutrally buoyant particles exhibit a power-law scaling
$\langle |\boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}|\rangle \sim (r_c - D_p)^{\xi _1 = 1/3}$
, consistent with the inertial-subrange scaling of turbulent velocity increments predicted by Kolmogorov (Reference Kolmogorov1941). In other words, the dynamics of these less inertial particles effectively follows the turbulent cascade, the so-called ‘turbulent transport’ (Wang, Wexler & Zhou Reference Wang, Wexler and Zhou2000). The power-law exponents
$\xi _1 = 1/3$
observed in our finite-size particle simulations are consistent with those reported in previous simulations of point particles (Bec et al. Reference Bec, Biferale, Cencini, Lanotte and Toschi2010; Gustavsson & Mehlig Reference Gustavsson and Mehlig2011; Ireland et al. Reference Ireland, Bragg and Collins2016), demonstrating the universality of turbulent scaling laws across particle sizes. In contrast, the RRV of heavy particles (
$\rho _r = 20.0$
) exhibits a much weaker separation dependence and stronger relative motion at small separation distance (
$\eta \lesssim r_c - D_p\lesssim 4 \eta$
), as the greater particle inertia prohibits the effective responses to small-scale turbulent fluctuations. In the dissipation range (
$r_c - D_p \lesssim \eta$
), the RRV deviates significantly from the inertial-subrange behaviour. The RRVs of particles with
$\rho _r = 0.2$
and
$1.0$
reach a nearly constant value within
$r_c - D_p \lesssim 0.2\eta$
, indicating strong modulation of particle-pair dynamics by near-contact interactions. For the lightest particles (
$\rho _r = 0.002$
), the RRV exhibits a pronounced peak at contact. This behaviour is regarded as being driven by lubrication and collisions that induce rapid accelerating and bouncing events, giving rise to high relative velocities beyond the turbulent effect. At
$\phi = 5.0\,\%$
(figure 11
d), the dependence of particle relative velocity on separation distance becomes diminished. This change could be attributed to the formation of particle clusters and the onset of frequent inter-particle collisions.
Building on the RRV analysis, we further computed the second-order longitudinal velocity structure function of particles, defined as
$S_{2,p}(r_c) = \langle \boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^2\rangle = \langle [(\boldsymbol{U}_{p2} - \boldsymbol{U}_{p1})\boldsymbol{\cdot }\boldsymbol{r}_c] ^2 \rangle _{|\boldsymbol{r}_c| = r_c}$
, normalised by
$u_{\eta 0}^2$
. The results are presented in figure 12, where the colourful dashed lines denote the theoretical limit for uncorrelated particle velocities,
$\langle \boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^2 \rangle \to 2 \boldsymbol{U}_{p,{rms}}^2$
. For finite-size particles with
$\rho _r \leqslant 1.0$
(corresponding to
$St \lesssim 3$
in our study), the structure function retains the Kolmogorov scaling
$\langle \boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^2\rangle \sim (r_c - D_p)^{\xi _2}$
with
$\xi _2 = 2/3$
in the inertial subrange (
$r_c - D_p \gtrsim 10 \eta$
). This confirms that finite-size particles (with diameter
$D_p \lesssim 10 \eta$
) are dominated by the self-similar cascade of the carrier flow. Since the particle diameter is small compared to the energy-containing eddies, finite-size effects do not disrupt the scaling laws for point particles with
$St \lesssim O(1)$
(Bec et al. Reference Bec, Biferale, Cencini, Lanotte and Toschi2010; Bragg & Collins Reference Bragg and Collins2014b
; Ireland et al. Reference Ireland, Bragg and Collins2016). Notably, using the surface-to-surface distance (
$r_c - D_p$
) to scale the velocity structure functions appears to bridge the gap between the pair statistics of point particles and those of finite-size particles.
Second-order longitudinal velocity structure function for particles with (a) varying density ratio at
$\phi = 0.5\,\%$
, and (b) different volume fractions for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r = 0.002$
). The colourful dashed lines indicate the theoretical limit for uncorrelated particle velocity,
$2 \boldsymbol{U}_{p,{rms}}^2$
. The black lines refer to power-law scalings.

Figure 12. Long description
The image contains two line graphs labeled (a) and (b). Graph (a) shows the second-order longitudinal velocity structure function for particles with varying density ratios at a specific volume fraction. The x-axis represents the normalized distance from the particle diameter over viscosity, and the y-axis represents the normalized velocity structure function. Different colored lines represent different density ratios, with a black dashed line indicating a power-law scaling. Graph (b) shows the same function for different volume fractions of the lightest particles. The x-axis and y-axis are the same as in graph (a), with different colored lines representing different volume fractions. The black dashed line again indicates a power-law scaling. The colorful dashed lines in both graphs indicate the theoretical limit for uncorrelated particle velocity.
However, significant deviations emerge in the dissipation range. Classical theories for point particles predict a transition from a strain-dominated regime (
$\langle \boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^2\rangle \sim (r_c - D_p)^{\xi _2 = 2}$
) at very low
$St$
to an inertia-dominated regime characterised by caustics (
$\langle \boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^2\rangle \sim (r_c - D_p)^{\xi _2 =0}$
, i.e. a plateau) at higher
$St$
(Gustavsson & Mehlig Reference Gustavsson and Mehlig2011, Reference Gustavsson and Mehlig2014; Bragg & Collins Reference Bragg and Collins2014b
). In contrast, the scaling law in the dissipation range for finite-size particles is less applicable; instead, our results reveal three distinct behaviours. First, for particles with moderate density ratios (
$\rho _r=0.2, 1.0$
), the structure function slightly increases as the density ratio (or equivalently, the Stokes number) increases. This trend qualitatively aligns with the point particles (Bec et al. Reference Bec, Biferale, Cencini, Lanotte and Toschi2010; Gustavsson & Mehlig Reference Gustavsson and Mehlig2014), where increasing inertia drives the caustics formation. As particles approach contact, the hydrodynamic lubrication and collision forces become dominant. These forces strongly lead to another saturation of relative velocities distinct from point-particle models. Second, for heavy particles (
$\rho _r=20$
),
$\langle \boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^2\rangle$
shows weak dependence on the separation distance
$r_c$
across most scales. This suggests that the particle-pair dynamics is dominated by decorrelated inertial trajectories rather than local fluid structures. This behaviour partly aligns with the high-
$St$
limit of point particles. Third, and most notably, the structure function
$\langle \boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^2\rangle$
for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r = 0.002$
) exhibits a pronounced peak at near-contact separations, with magnitudes exceeding the theoretical limit. This behaviour cannot be explained solely by the fluid-induced caustic mechanism that relies solely on the flow statistics (Gustavsson & Mehlig Reference Gustavsson and Mehlig2011). Instead, the peak of the velocity structure function indicates a shift to a collision-dominated regime. Frequent particle–particle collisions and rebounds within dense clusters induce extreme relative velocities, overwhelming the effect of background turbulence. At
$\phi =5\,\%$
, this collision-driven effect is further amplified. The structure function
$\langle \boldsymbol{U}_{p,r}^2\rangle$
remains close to the theoretical limit across a broad range of scales, with local peaks when the centre-to-centre distance is equal to integer multiples of the particle diameter. This observation also manifests the transition from a turbulence-dominated regime to a collision-dominated regime, where cluster dynamics govern the relative velocity statistics.
The particle flux
$\varGamma (r_c)$
of finite-size particles. The dashed curve indicates the reference scaling
$\varGamma \propto r_c^2$
. The dynamic collision kernel
$\varGamma ^D$
is shown at the location
$(r_c - D_p)/D_p = 0$
for each case. (a) Effects of density ratio at a fixed volume fraction
$\phi = 0.5\,\%$
. (b) Effects of volume fraction for the lightest particles
$\rho _r = 0.002$
.

Figure 13. Long description
The image contains two line graphs labeled (a) and (b). Graph (a) shows the effects of density ratio on particle flux at a fixed volume fraction, with different colored lines representing various density ratios. Graph (b) illustrates the effects of volume fraction for the lightest particles, with different colored lines representing various volume fractions. Both graphs have a dashed curve indicating a reference scaling. The x-axis in both graphs is labeled (r_c - D_p) / D_p, and the y-axis is labeled Γ(r_c). The dynamic collision kernel is shown at the location for each case. The graphs depict how particle flux varies with these parameters, providing insights into particle-laden flows in turbulent environments.
We finally turn to the particle collision rate, which can be quantified by the collision kernel. In general, there are two different ways to define the collision kernel (Wang et al. Reference Wang, Wexler and Zhou2000). On the one hand, the collision kernel can be defined by
$\varGamma ^{D}=2 \dot {N_C}/n_p^2$
, which is called the dynamic collision kernel, with
$\dot {N_C}$
denoting the number of collision events occurring per unit time and per unit volume. On the other hand, the collision kernel can be defined in a kinetic manner. To this end, we should also introduce another quantity,
$\varGamma (r_c)$
, which measures the net flux of particle motions across the spherical surface centred at the reference particle with radius
$r_c$
. The definition of
$\varGamma (r_c)$
is given by the two aforementioned pair statistical quantities as
Then the kinetic collision kernel is exactly defined as the particle flux at
$r_c=D_p$
, i.e.
$\varGamma ^k=\varGamma (r_c=D_p)$
. In principle, the kinematic and dynamic collision kernels should be equivalent for spherical particles (Wang et al. Reference Wang, Wexler and Zhou2000).
As shown in figure 13(a), neutrally buoyant particles exhibit the smallest particle flux in the near-field region
$(r_c \leqslant 2 D_p)$
, which also leads to the lowest
$\varGamma ^D$
for this type of particle. In contrast, the lightest particles
$(\rho _r = 0.002)$
have the greatest particle flux at
$r_c \lesssim 2 D_p$
, which can be ascribed to the significant particle clustering and high relative velocities. This analysis suggests the important role of particle clustering in enhancing the collision rate for light particles in turbulence. Additionally, a reference curve indicating the
$r_c^2$
scaling, which the particle flux for independently moving particles should follow, is also included for comparison. For large particle–particle distance
$(r_c \gt 4D_p)$
, the particle flux grows approximately at rate
$\sim r_c^2$
for all cases, which is ascribed to the decorrelation of particle motions for particles with large separations. Figure 13(b) illustrates the particle flux and collision kernels for the particle with
$\rho _r=0.002$
at different volume fractions. The densest case (
$\phi = 5\,\%$
) shows a significantly higher particle flux owing to the stronger relative motions among particles in this case (see figure 11
b). However, the dynamic collision kernel is slightly reduced for both
$\phi =1\,\%$
and
$\phi=5\,\%$
. This decrease can be presumably explained by the suppression of collision events caused by the finite-size effect and by the vortex-aligned, chain-like clustering of the light particles.
4. Conclusions
We conducted a numerical investigation on the clustering behaviour and dynamics of finite-size spherical particles in HIT, with a particular focus on light particles (
$\rho _r \lt 1$
). Using PR-DNS, we examined the roles of density ratio (
$\rho _r$
) and volume fraction (
$\phi$
) in the clustering and dynamics of finite-size particles.
Finite-size light particles are found to cluster significantly more strongly than heavier ones, as quantified by Voronoï analysis and the RDF. In agreement with earlier point-particle studies, neutrally buoyant particles remain nearly randomly distributed, while heavy particles display only weak clustering due to the centrifugal effect (or the sweep–stick mechanism) that expels them from vortical regions. In contrast, light particles preferentially clustering in regions of high fluid vorticity arising from the pressure-gradient and added-mass forces dominate their force balance. What is even more interesting is that the clustering degree of the light particles increases dramatically as the volume fraction increases. At
$\phi = 5\,\%$
, particles form large and complex clusters, and chain-like structures aligned with vortex structure.
A novel and unexpected result is the emergence of a sub-population of high-speed particles within dense clusters at high
$\phi$
. Frequent and violent multi-particle collisions within clusters can temporarily accelerate particles to velocities far exceeding their velocity variance. This phenomenon leads to a distinct bimodal distribution of the particle velocity magnitudes and Reynolds numbers (
$\textit{Re}_p$
), which deviates from the predictions of theoretical models that neglect four-way coupling and turbulence modulation. This highlights the critical importance of PR-DNS in capturing the complex interplay between particle inertia, finite-size effects and inter-particle collisions in dense suspensions.
Particle-pair statistics further reinforce these findings and quantitatively demonstrate particle collision dynamics. Light particles exhibit the largest collision kernels in the near field because of their intense clustering and large RRV. Lubrication-induced attraction produces pronounced near-contact spikes for particles with
$\rho _r \leqslant 1$
, while heavy particles show much weaker short-range enhancement due to their large inertia. Increasing the volume fraction strongly amplifies collision-driven interactions: although the RRV increases, the dynamic collision kernel decreases slightly at high
$\phi$
, indicating that strong multi-particle interactions within dense clusters suppress binary collision events.
This study clarifies the fundamental mechanisms driving the clustering and dynamics of light finite-size particles in turbulence. The results have implications for understanding a wide range of natural and industrial processes, such as the transport of microplastics in oceans, and the behaviour of light particles in chemical reactors or liquid metals. Future work should consider the effects of gravity and particle shape to develop a more comprehensive understanding of the dynamics and clustering of finite-size light particles.
Funding
This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (grant nos12532011, 12472224 and 12388101). LZ acknowledges the support by State Key Laboratory of Advanced Space Propulsion (2025ASP0101).
Declaration of interests
The authors report no conflict of interest.
Appendix A. Grid independence test
To verify the reliability of our simulation results, we refined the grid resolution by a factor of 2, corresponding to
$D_p / \Delta x = 32$
. Due to the substantial computational cost, we performed this higher-resolution simulation only for the densest case, namely the one with density ratio
$\rho _r = 0.002$
and volume fraction
$\phi = 5.0\,\%$
. The statistical results of particle clustering and motion are compared in figure 14. Figure 14(a) shows the p.d.f.s of the Voronoï cell volumes of the cases with different resolutions (
$D_p / \Delta x = 16, 32$
), along with a random Poisson distribution at the same volume fraction as a reference. No significant difference can be observed between the two resolutions. Figure 14(b) presents the distributions of the particle Reynolds number
$\textit{Re}_{p}$
for both resolutions, which also show no qualitative discrepancies.
The p.d.f.s of (a) the Voronoï cell volumes and (b) the Reynolds number of particles
$\textit{Re}_{p}$
for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r = 0.002$
) at
$\phi = 5.0\,\%$
. A random Poisson distribution for particles at the same
$\phi$
is shown in (a) for reference.

Figure 14. Long description
The image contains two line graphs. The first graph (a) compares the probability density functions of Voronoi cell volumes for the lightest particles with a random Poisson distribution. The x-axis represents the normalized Voronoi cell volumes, and the y-axis represents the probability density function. Two data series are shown: one for a particle-to-grid size ratio of 16 and another for a ratio of 32. The second graph (b) displays the probability density functions of the Reynolds numbers of the lightest particles. The x-axis represents the Reynolds number, and the y-axis represents the probability density function. Two data series are shown: one for a particle-to-grid size ratio of 16 and another for a ratio of 32. The graphs illustrate the distribution differences between the simulated particles and a random Poisson distribution.
Appendix B. Turbulence modulation
To elucidate the modulation of the carrier-phase turbulence by the presence of particles, the turbulence statistics for all cases are summarised in table 4. A comparison with the single-phase flow reveals two distinct modulation regimes for the particle phase with different inertia and volume fractions. In particular, at a low volume fraction (
$\phi = 0.5\,\%$
), particles generally attenuate the turbulent kinetic energy (
$\tilde {k}\lt 1$
) and dissipation rate (
$\tilde {\epsilon } \lt 1$
) compared with the single-phase flow. The attenuation is most pronounced for heavy particles (
$\rho _r=20.0$
, case run20), which reduce the kinetic energy by approximately
$12\,\%$
. Additionally, the integral length scale
$L_{int}$
is also reduced by approximately
$9\,\%$
, indicating a reduction of large-scale turbulent structures. Lighter particles (
$\rho _r\leqslant 1.0$
) exhibit a moderate reduction in both
$k$
and
$\epsilon$
. Notably, the Kolmogorov scale
$\eta$
increases slightly (
$\tilde {\eta }\gt 1$
) for all dilute cases, suggesting the increase of the smallest scales of the carrier flow. In stark contrast, for the lightest particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) at a high volume fraction (
$\phi = 5\,\%$
), the turbulence is significantly intensified. Both
$k$
and
$\epsilon$
increase substantially by approximately 19 % and 42 %, respectively. Consequently, all the turbulent scales (including
$L_{int}$
,
$\lambda$
and
$\eta$
) decrease. While the Taylor-scale Reynolds number
$\textit{Re}_{\lambda }$
decreases only moderately, the significant enhancement in
$\epsilon$
suggests that light particles at high volume fraction not only intensify small-scale dissipation, but also alter the energy scale-by-scale budget, sustaining a more dissipative flow with finer small-scale structures.
Summary of key turbulence statistics. Here,
$\textit{Re}_\lambda$
,
$k$
,
$\epsilon$
,
$L_{int}$
,
$\lambda$
and
$\eta$
are the Taylor-scale Reynolds number, turbulent kinetic energy, dissipation rate, integral length scale, Taylor microscale and Kolmogorov length scale, respectively. The tilde denotes normalisation by the corresponding value of the single-phase turbulence. Single phase flow:
${k_0}=2.0943$
,
${\epsilon _0}=0.1596$
,
${L_{int,0}}=19.0342$
,
${\lambda _0}=2.0937$
,
${\eta _0}=0.1236$
.

Table 4. Long description
The table presents a summary of key turbulence statistics for various cases, focusing on the Taylor-scale Reynolds number, turbulent kinetic energy, dissipation rate, integral length scale, Taylor microscale, and Kolmogorov length scale. Each value is normalized by the corresponding value of single-phase turbulence. The table includes six cases: run0, run02, run1, run20, run01, and run05. For each case, the values of the Taylor-scale Reynolds number, turbulent kinetic energy, dissipation rate, integral length scale, Taylor microscale, and Kolmogorov length scale are provided. Notable trends include variations in turbulent kinetic energy and dissipation rate across different cases, with some cases showing attenuation and others showing intensification of turbulence.
Energy spectra for cases with (a) particles of varying density ratios at
$\phi =0.5\,\%$
, and (b) light particles (
$\rho _r=0.002$
) at different
$\phi$
values. Here,
$\kappa _L = 2 \pi / {\mathcal{L}}$
, and the black dashed line indicates the particle diameter wavenumber
$\kappa _D = 2 \pi / D_p$
.

Figure 15. Long description
The image contains two line graphs labeled (a) and (b). Graph (a) shows energy spectra for particles with varying density ratios, while graph (b) shows energy spectra for light particles at different values. Both graphs plot E(k) on the y-axis against k/kL on the x-axis. The black dashed line in both graphs indicates the particle diameter wavenumber. In graph (a), different colored lines represent different density ratios: black for single phase, red for 0.002, orange for 0.2, cyan for 1.0, and purple for 20.0. In graph (b), different colored lines represent different values: black for single phase, red for 0.5 percent, orange for 1.0 percent, and cyan for 5.0 percent. The graphs illustrate how energy spectra vary with different density ratios and values of light particles.
The energy spectra further confirm that this modulation is scale-dependent. For dilute cases with varying density ratios (figure 15
a), the spectra collapse onto the single-phase spectrum at large scales (
$\kappa \lt \kappa _D$
), implying that particles primarily influence scales comparable to or smaller than the particle diameter. Nevertheless, this spectral invariance does not preclude an active role in energy dynamics. Specifically, particles facilitate the transfer of energy from large scales to sub-particle scales (Chiarini & Rosti Reference Chiarini and Rosti2024). Among these, neutrally buoyant particles modulate the energy spectrum to the minimal extent, followed by light particles. However, heavy particles, due to their higher inertia, cause the most significant spectral elevation in the high-wavenumber range. As the volume fraction increases (figure 15
b), this effect becomes more pronounced and extends to larger scales (lower wavenumbers). This broadening of the affected range confirms that particle clustering structures at high volume fraction actively modulate the flow field at larger scales.
Furthermore, there should be a marked increase in energy injection for the case run05. Notably, the large-scale forcing scheme in our study maintains a constant magnitude of the large-scale forces (Eswaran & Pope Reference Eswaran and Pope1988; Chouippe & Uhlmann Reference Chouippe and Uhlmann2015). Therefore, despite the reduced fluid volume fraction (
$1-\phi$
), the observed increase in the energy input suggests a significant enhancement in the velocity–force correlation. We attribute this to the formation of large-scale particle clusters, which intensify the alignment between the flow velocity and the large-scale forces. Consequently, the constant external forcing does more work on these faster-moving fluid structures, sustaining the elevated energy levels and the correspondingly high dissipation rates observed in the high-
$\phi$
case.








ρr=ρp/ρf
ϕ
Np
Dp/η
Reλ=λurms/ν
Vi/V¯i
Rep
Tl
−16Dp
|ωf|
x=−12
Q=2
ϕv=0.5%
ρr=0.002
ρr=0.2
ρr=1.0
ρr=20.0
(ρr=0.002)
ϕ=1.0%
ϕ=5.0%
ϕ=0.5%
Dp/η=5.5
ρr=1.5
ρr=0.002
ϕ=1%
5%
ϕ=0.5%
1.0%
5.0%
C
ϕ=0.5%
ρr=0.002
ϕ=0.5%,1.0%,5.0%
Q
⟨Q⟩/σ(Q0)
|ωf|/|ωf0|
r/Dp
ϕ=0.5%
ρr=0.002
ωf0
r/Dp=0.5
r/Dp=1
ρr
ϕ=0.5%
r/Dp=0.5
r/Dp=1
(ρr=0.002)
ϕ
ωf0
ap
us
ϕ=0.5%
ρr=0.002
ϕ
sinθ
Up
uη
Rep
ρr
ϕ
A=3
B=1/3
⟨|us|⟩the
⟨|us|⟩cal
g(rc)
ρr
ϕ=0.5%
ϕ
ρr=0.002
Dp
η
−1/3
⟨|Up,r|⟩
uη0
rc
ϕ=0.5%
ρr=0.002
ϕ
Up,r*
Dp
η
ϕ=0.5%
ρr=0.002
2Up,rms2
Γ(rc)
Γ∝rc2
ΓD
(rc−Dp)/Dp=0
ϕ=0.5%
ρr=0.002
Rep
ρr=0.002
ϕ=5.0%
ϕ
Reλ
k
ϵ
Lint
λ
η
k0=2.0943
ϵ0=0.1596
Lint,0=19.0342
λ0=2.0937
η0=0.1236
ϕ=0.5%
ρr=0.002
ϕ
κL=2π/L
κD=2π/Dp