Sod Busting is part of the “How Things Worked” series at Johns Hopkins University Press. The series aims to supplement standard, brief textbook treatments of episodes in American history by giving students a sense of what it was like to experience those episodes. Though Sod Busting is less compelling than the beautifully descriptive novels about Plains life such as The Long Winter and My Antonia great frontier novels, it is both briefer and more comprehensive. Short chapters separately treat the acquisition of land, the making of farms, the borrowing of funds, and the creation of communities. The experiences of early settlers on the eastern Plains in the 1870s are compared and contrasted with the experiences of the later, western Plains settlers. The most effective expository technique in the book, perhaps not surprisingly, is to compare and contrast the diary entries of early and late settlers. The words of the settlers, like the words of Laura and Antonia, are likely to stick with the readers of the book far longer than the summaries of the academic literature that come between them.
The first chapter, on the acquisition of the land, does an admirable job describing the various ways a settler could acquire title. Particularly useful is the discussion of how settlers interacted with federal land offices and speculators, both early in the period of settlement and during the second wave of settlement in the western Plains. Settler-to-settler transactions and settlement by women receive more attention than is typical, which gives the reader a more balanced sense of the nature of these transactions. The diarists quoted in this chapter describe the isolation of settling on the Plains quite poignantly. Supplementing these quotes with maps of population density, native flora, railroad development and “improved” acreage would help students better understand this isolation.
There is less detail than the series title might suggest in the second chapter, which covers farm-building. Only about a page is given over to the work that inspires the title of the book; only five pages are allotted to the whole process of producing the output sod-breaking, crop and animal choice, planting, fertilizing, irrigating, and harvesting. On the other hand, significant space is devoted to the processes of building shelter and providing for heat, water, and waste disposal. Perhaps these essential domestic chores are given short shrift in textbook treatments, but a more balanced approach to the farm work and house work would give the reader a better picture of how things worked on the Plains.
The third chapter, on credit markets, introduces the reader to the different kinds of contracts and sources of funds that settlers used. It is admirable that a discussion of deflation is included here, though most students will need more information—along with a few numerical examples—in order to grasp just how devastating deflation was to a Plains farmer with a substantial mortgage. Similarly, the discussion of the market risks faced by farmers would be clearer with a few graphs of commodities prices, while the discussion of the ecological risk would be clearer if illustrated by an example of variations in revenue between farms or counties that could be easily constructed using either manuscript or published data from the agricultural census.
The fourth and fifth chapters discuss the communities of the Plains and how life in those communities changed in the early twentieth century. “Communities” is taken to include church, school, railroad, immigration campaigns, town boosterism, co-ops, grain elevators, stores, and more. Aiming to cover so much ground in so few pages is a lofty goal, and Sod Busting provides a good survey of the work on these topics. Tighter text and more pictures might have made reaching the goal simpler. For example, the discussion of the benefits of replacing long-distance wagon transport with transport by rail (pp. 96–97) would have been enhanced by a photo or drawing of the interiors of each. Similarly, setting the photo of a small town elevator in 1890 (p. 87) beside photos of an elevator complex in Omaha around the same period and today would help students put these institutions and technological developments in perspective.
The economic history of homesteading and Plains development is nicely treated. The author accurately describes Plains settlement as commercial from the start and describes settlers as active profit-seekers. Yet occasionally the reader will detect anti-market tone in the text. For example, strategies to increase holdings beyond a quarter-section are called “maneuvers” (p. 24); the language here and elsewhere makes settlers sound greedy rather than sensibly working to take advantage of the ever-increasing economies of scale. Yet, in other parts of the book—particularly the treatment of defaults during the crisis years of the late 1880s and early 1890s (pp. 66–69)—the tone more accurately reflects the tension between the need to participate in markets and the risks of that participation.
Overall, Sod Busting succeeds in communicating to readers that settlers did not simply arrive on the Plains, stake out a claim, and live happily ever after. It covers a lot of material, especially the newer literature on daily life on the Plains, in very few pages. It is an excellent resource for instructors who want to expand their lecture materials to cover Plains settlement more completely, but student-readers may still likely prefer to revisit the works of Wilder and Cather.
