As the twentieth century came to a close, consumers were purchasing more beef and pork (per capita) than they had in the 1950s (www.usda.gov/factbook/chapter2.pdf). Despite the continued importance of beef and pork in the American diet, one of the great institutions of the meat processing industry, the stockyard, was in its death throes. J'Nell Pate's Livestock Hotels seeks to trace out the history of America's stockyards, and, ultimately, to explain the death of this institution.
Divided into two sections, Dr. Pate's book begins by discussing the activities that took place in a typical stockyard. After the brief introduction to the activities of the stockyard, the book proceeds with a history of livestock trading in the United States. Chapter two examines the livestock markets that existed prior to 1850; chapters three through six briefly outline the history of the stockyard. The second section of the book contains case studies of 24 of the nation's largest stockyards. There are four chapters in this section; three of these chapters focus on the stockyards from a specific time period or region of the country, and the fourth chapter looks at “minor” stockyards in addition to providing a brief conclusion.
The title for the book—Livestock Hotels —comes from an analogy that the meat processing industry used to describe the activities of a modern stockyard. Much as one would see at a large urban hotel, the guests of a livestock hotel received lodging, food, and special attention (medical treatment or grooming). Although a stockyard provided hotel “services,” fundamentally, the modern stockyard served as a central market, where ranchers sold their animals to the highest bidder.
Pate expertly describes the activities of the stockyard. Over the course of the first section of the book, the day-to-day operations of a stockyard become very clear. What remains less clear, though, is why the stockyard was the institutional solution developed to meet the needs of ranchers and meat packers. In the introduction to the book, Pate asserts that the stockyards were critically dependent on railroads and meat packers. Indeed, her stated reason for writing the book is that the economic history literature has focused on the railroads and meat packing industry without paying attention to the stockyards. Over the course of the book's ten chapters, Pate describes the changes that took place in the stockyards and meat packing plants. She also briefly discusses the decline of the railroads and the rise of the livestock transport truck. Taken together, her descriptions paint a picture of an industry that was initially served by large, centralize markets—the stockyards—but that is eventually served by small, rural markets scattered throughout the country.
Because the book does not attempt to explain why these changes took place, the reader is left with a number of questions after finishing the book: What were the economic forces that led to the creation of the stockyards? Were these forces irrevocably altered when the railroads went into decline and the government began regulating the stockyards? Why did the stockyards disappear in the second half of the twentieth century rather than earlier? Was it the creation of the interstate highway system and the rise of video technology? Are the small, modern markets in rural areas an economically efficient way for buyers and sellers to come together? Pate's book does not directly answer any of these questions, though it does give the reader enough information to form an educated guess as to what the answers might be.
The second section of the book, the section that describes two dozen American stockyards, is well researched, but it is largely ineffective. Although the passages on the individual stockyards may be of interest to an individual in the meat processing industry or someone who is interested in a given city's economic history, they are too short to give the reader a full sense of what was going on in each of these stockyards. Thus, it is hard to understand what is special or unique about the stockyard in any one city. It seems that the reader would have been better served by an in-depth discussion of the most important stockyards. Had Pate focused on the largest, most significant stockyards she could have highlighted the economic forces that led to the creation of these stockyards and vividly illustrated the forces that worked to wipe them out.
Pate's passion and expertise are on display throughout this book, and the book does a good job of describing the changes that have taken place in livestock markets. Live-stock Hotels would have been a great success, though, if Pate had used her expertise to explain how economic forces worked to produce stockyards in the nineteenth century and why those forces were no longer present at the end of the twentieth century.
