No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2005
This book is part of the Greenwood Histories of the Modern Nations series that includes books on the histories of Japan, Mexico, and Spain. The aim of the series is to provide up-to-date and concise histories of many of the nations of the contemporary world. As the editors of the series explain in the foreward to this volume, the series aims to educate the interested U.S. public about the histories of the many nations that the United States deals with on a daily basis. “Each of [the authors of these histories], however, has devoted a significant portion of the book to events of the past thirty years, because the modern era has contributed the most to contemporary issues that have an impact on U.S. policy” (p. viii). The editors have asked the author to devote a large part of the book to the events of the past three decades. Herein lies what may be the biggest weakness of the present volume.
Elton Daniel starts his book with a general overview of the land and people of Iran before embarking on a brief study of ancient Persia. In this section, as in the following chapters, he proves himself to be deeply interested in, if not in love with, Iran and its people. Yet he is able to maintain an unbiased, balanced attitude toward historical developments in Iran. One cannot but be impressed by Daniel's ability to carry out this dual task at the same time.
The book is intended for the general reader or as an introduction to Iranian history for undergraduate students. In a work of this nature, it is futile to hope for a detailed analysis of particular historical periods that could be considered a contribution to our knowledge of the subject. Instead, what is presented is a brief overview of the most significant historical developments that, at times, leaps over centuries.
After a brief review of ancient Persia, the author discusses the medieval period, which he considers to cover the period from the fall of the Achaemenids in the 4th century B.C. to the emergence of Safavid rule in the 16th century. One may question the author's characterization of this vast period as “medieval.” It would perhaps be more accurate to consider the pre–Islamic period as ancient Persia and to treat Islamic Iran up to the reign of the Safavids as medieval. Be that as it may, the fact is that Daniel is a distinguished expert on the medieval period, and it is a pity that he has had to deal with this period so briefly. One would have liked to see this section greatly expanded. But this would have come into conflict with the aim of the series and the guidelines set by the editors, who emphasize the modern period. This explains why more than half of the book is dedicated to covering 20th-century developments.
For a historian writing about a period that is not his, Daniel's treatment of modern Iran is admirable. He manages to cover all the important developments without giving too much or too little space to any one of them. Modern Iranian history, however, is a minefield, and no historian or political scientist can hope to be able to walk through it unscathed. There are developments and individuals that are very contentious: Amir Kabir, the Constitutional Revolution, Reza Shah, Khomeini, to name only the most famous cases. What makes the study of these characters and developments particularly difficult is the fact that a myth already exists around each of them. For example, Daniel's treatment of Amir Kabir more or less follows the prevalent opinion—the myth, if you prefer—that sees the amir as a strong, modernizing nationalist politician who had the good of his people at heart and was tragically killed on the orders of the Shah. This image of the amir is so dominant in modern Iranian historiography that it has turned into a myth. In more recent years, however, the works of Abbas Amanat and others have focused attention on Amir Kabir as the politician who ruthlessly put down the Babi insurgency. Indeed, it has been suggested that the Shah and the conservatives agreed to his premiership because they knew him to be an efficient and ruthless man and perhaps the one best able to put down the Babis. After the rebellion was crushed, neither the court nor the traditional forces had any use for the amir anymore.
The Constitutional Revolution is another minefield in Iranian history. Again there is an existing myth, largely made up by Ahmad Kasravi, that wants to see in this revolution something like a Persian equivalent of the French Revolution. Those who made the Constitutional Revolution may not have had the French Revolution as their model, but many of those who later wrote about this revolution seem to have had the French Revolution in mind. Daniel is more careful to distance himself from the traditional interpretation of that revolution and presents a more balanced view of the events.
In conclusion, it must be said that Daniel has had the unenviable task of presenting a concise brief history of more than 2,500 years of Iranian history in fewer than 300 pages. The result is a very good book that can greatly help students new to the subject gain a general view of Iranian history and what has made Iran what it is today. This is no small achievement.