In the early fifteenth century, the Florentine humanist Jacopo d'Angelo applied the title Cosmographia to his translation of Ptolemy's Geography, preferring this name to a straightforward Latinization of the Greek. According to d'Angelo, ‘cosmography’ had previously been applied to non-mathematical descriptions of the world, and in particular to Pliny's Natural History. But d'Angelo considered Ptolemy's work more deserving of the name than Pliny's, for Ptolemy had truly founded his description of the Earth on knowledge of the heavens, justifying a titular reference to the universe as a whole. D'Angelo's rebaptism persisted into the incunable period, but it was not destined to last. Subsequent humanists reverted to ‘geography’ as the proper title for Ptolemy's text and the subject it dealt with. They did not, however, eliminate ‘cosmography’ as a literary category; and cosmographic works proliferated during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Typically these texts dealt with the intersection of astronomy and geography – the mathematical principles required to describe or map the Earth – but some authors presented their subject as truly the sum of the two disciplines. A few, emulating the geographical writings of Strabo in particular, elaborated cosmographies of encyclopedic scope that attempted to deal with the peoples, places, languages, customs, events, natural phenomena and resources of the world.
Sebastian Münster (1488–1552), an ordained Franciscan who left his order to take up the chair of Hebrew at the newly Reformed University of Basle, was responsible for the first of the truly encyclopedic cosmographies. In its first, German, incarnation of 1544, Münster's Cosmographia exceeded six hundred pages and contained over five hundred woodcuts; by 1550, appearing in both Latin and German editions, it ran to more than a thousand folio pages, and was even more extensively illustrated. The novelty of this enterprise is somewhat obscured by Matthew McLean's account, partly because he is more interested in establishing the full range of antecedents to Münster's extraordinary work than he is in explaining cosmography per se. Nevertheless, McLean offers a useful survey of the textual and cartographic traditions that fed in some way into this particular form of the cosmographic genre: not only Ptolemy, Strabo and Pliny, but also Pomponius Mela, Solinus, Herodotus, Polybius, various Fathers of the Church, medieval encyclopedists and fabulists, mappa mundi and portolani, are introduced and discussed.
McLean is at his best the closer he remains to his principal subject. Besides the biography of Münster which opens his book, later chapters deal not only with the contents and organization of Münster's Cosmographia and how these changed over time, but also with the collaborative nature of his authorship. We learn how Münster collected information, regional maps and bird's-eye views of particular cities through his correspondence, and how, by rewarding his informants through clear attribution of their contributions, he harnessed regional competition and civic pride to amass the material to enlarge successive editions. Such methods led to an overwhelming preponderance of material on the German-speaking lands, and a comparative neglect of other parts of Europe, and of Africa, Asia and the New World. We also learn something of the reception and influence of his work, the extent to which it attracted criticism, helped to shape other examples of descriptive cosmography, and was drawn on by pursuers of other literary, geographic and cartographic projects.
McLean's account is less successful, I think, in those areas of particular interest to historians of science. The natural-historical content of the Cosmographia is treated very briefly, and without much attention to recent work in the field. McLean is very interested in Münster's historical focus – indeed, he sees Münster's work as humanocentric. He might have benefited, however, from consideration of how closely interwined human and natural history were at this particular period. McLean spends some time discussing the transition from medieval to early modern cartography, and is at pains to point out that medieval maps should not be dismissed as products of inferior knowledge or skill but were cultural artefacts intended to convey particular meanings. Yet he might be thought to have made a symmetrical mistake: early modern maps and cartographic methods are described by him as ‘scientific’ and ‘dispassionate’. The desirability of interrogating these terms is not evident in his account, which also tends to conflate mathematics and experiment.
McLean repeats several times a claim borrowed from Frank Lestringant's study of another cosmographic author, André Thevet, that the characteristic sin of the early modern cosmographer was that of hubris – a sin deriving from the assumption of the ‘God's-eye’ view of the world. It is a clever idea, but not one that benefits from restatement here, and in the end McLean must concede that this ‘characteristic’ crime was not one that Münster committed. On the contrary, he points out, Münster's Cosmographia was piously intended to communicate God's providential design. This is clearly the case, but I cannot help feeling that more could have been said. McLean characterizes Münster as an irenicist living in an irenicist community, and perhaps for this reason does not seek to understand Münster's providential cosmography in confessional terms. Thus he does not engage with the ideas of Manfred Büttner, who categorized sixteenth-century geography as ‘Catholic’, ‘Lutheran’ and ‘Reformed’, declaring that Münster's style was characteristic of the Reformed scholars who sought to demonstrate not only God's providence active in the present but also its extension through time from the beginning of the world.
Some minor flaws niggle. The text has been copy-edited hastily, and the extent to which secondary sources are quoted, in the footnotes and the text, suggests that McLean has been overly influenced by his subject's habit of compilation with careful attribution. McLean and Münster are both worth reading; I would rather have encountered more of each of their words in a book of this length. Nevertheless, as the first monograph in English devoted to an important and influential sixteenth-century scholar, The Cosmographia of Sebastian Münster is a significant contribution to our understanding of a ‘lost’ form of knowledge, and unlikely to be superseded for some time to come.
