Before John Murra, no one had introduced significant and original explanations of the ancient economy of the Andean prehispanic civilizations into the literature of the Andes in a systematic and deeply informed manner. In doing so, Murra was influenced by the substantivist economic theory of Karl Polanyi, which he noted in his prologue to his 1975 book, Economic and Political Formations of the Andean World. This title reflects his theoretical debt to the substantivists, to which Murra added his ethnohistoric, ethnographic, and archaeological studies. He described an Andean world that departed from known patterns in other parts of the world and where civilizations arose under different mechanisms of economic integration. The first lectures in which Murra synthesized his views in a mature way, carefully edited in this book by Freda Yancy Wolf and Heather Lechtman, transport us to the moments when Murra presented the main interpretations of prehispanic economy that he continued to refine throughout his life.
This book contains four lectures delivered by Murra at the University of Rochester in 1969. Thirteen years earlier, in 1956, Murra had presented his doctoral dissertation, which became one of the most influential studies on the Inca economy. Between 1963 and 1966 he conducted fieldwork with Craig Morris at the Inca site of Huánuco Pampa. In 1964, he published his famous introductory text to the visit of Chucuito in Puno, and, by 1967, his study of the Chupaychu de Huánuco had come to light. Thus, by the spring of 1969, he already had the materials that he needed on which to build his model of the “Vertical Archipelago.” With this background, Murra appeared in Rochester to discuss his proposals in four lectures that form a continuum with his original views about the late societies of the prehispanic Andes.
Heather Lechtman provides an introductory essay in which she contextualizes Murra's contribution to the study of Andean societies, especially the Incas, reminding us of the ecological features of the Andes and the ways in which humans domesticated those features. She also describes the ethnohistorical sources used by Murra to generate his models, as well as the subsequent debates about his approaches, already foreshadowed in the 1969 lectures.
In the first talk, “The Archipelago Model of Vertical Control of the Andes,” Murra presents his general model. He reminds us of the nature of Andean space, mainly its stratified ecological zonation. In addition, he delves into the importance of combining ethnohistory with archeology. Thanks to the map of Joseph Tosi (1958), which is generously reproduced in this book, Murra manages to illustrate the complex ecology of the Andes with its large diversity of ecological niches. He points out the challenges that ecology and altitude posed for Andean communities and how they overcame them, especially through the domestication of plants and animals. In this world where the altitude generates a rugged geography, Andean peoples moved on foot at different altitudes to obtain food resources. Having delineated the Andean space and social displacements, Murra offers two cases of a vertical archipelago recorded in the sixteenth century: the small ethnic group of Chupaychu (2,500–3000 households) and a larger group, the Lupaca “kingdom” (20,000 households), of the Titicaca Basin. In the former case, he describes a nuclear area located between 3,000 and 3,200 meters above sea level (masl) where potatoes and corn could be produced. In addition to this nuclear area, other members of the same ethnic group exploited “ecological islands” located in the puna (above 3800 masl) to raise their camelids and extract salt or, in the ceja de selva (high jungle), to get wood and produce cotton, coca, and chili pepper. These islands were a maximum of 4 days away from the nuclear area, and although the members of the community settled there permanently, they did not lose their rights to the resources of their place of origin.
In the case of the Lupacas, he identifies a nuclear area in the puna and a series of islands that were located a 10- to 15-day walk in the coastal valleys and a 5-day walk in the ceja de selva. In addition to his description of these cases, Murra importantly proposes that, although both societies shared a general model of a vertical archipelago, each one developed different socioeconomic relations. The Incas then incorporated these forms of occupation and use of the Andean territory. Murra concludes that labor was the main form of “wealth” that could be appropriated by the elites during the Inca period.
In the second lecture titled “Reciprocity, the Anthropological Alternative to Exotic Explanations,” Murra continues to expound on his two ethnohistorical examples to detail how reciprocity works in the Andes. This mechanism, which underlies all the Andean forms of interaction, originally entailed the delivery of work (and not of goods) in exchange for a similar future consideration. Thus, as dependence was created, so was obligation. Murra's knowledge of Andean ethnography and ethnohistory enabled him to understand this mechanism of economic integration in prehispanic Andean communities. This alternative way of generating production and social relations led him to challenge the “exotic explanations” raised by Thomas More, Louis Baudin, Karl Wittfogel, and Emilio Choy. All of them were exotic for Murra, because they lacked a deep knowledge of Andean reality.
In the third lecture, “The Inca Attempt to Destroy the Markets,” Murra focuses on the Tawantinsuyu. The Incas clearly transformed the original forms of reciprocity and redistribution, modifying them for their own benefit. In the Inca state, one could speak, following Polanyi, of the existence of an “administered trade.” The Inca elite or its representatives were in charge of administering trade, and its specific location was the square of the main Inca sites, possibly the plaza in Cusco itself. Interestingly, what mostly appears in the ethnohistorical sources of the Chupaychu and Lupacas is their delivery of secondary products (coca, corn, wool, dried meat) to their lords. Food was thus part of the “general reciprocity” within kinship relationships. From this, Murra infers that certain highly valued products such as cloth were redistributed by the Inca state.
Finally, in the fourth lecture, “Structural Changes in Tawantinsuyu prior to the European Invasion,” Murra focuses on how these forms of economic integration—reciprocity, redistribution, and exchange—were transformed, especially toward the end of the Inca Empire. A state in permanent growth mode, like the Inca, needed to increase the amount of its resources available to feed and maintain its officials, and especially its armies. In this way, pre-Inca economic relations began to change, having the effect of alienating human groups from their lands and their communities, which constituted a structural change from earlier social relations. Murra suggests that this new way of controlling the inhabitants of the communities may have originated in coastal kingdoms such as Chimú. He describes a scenario in which the Incas, by altering the traditional forms of social and labor relations, also generated a series of tensions within a mosaic of ethnicities, each with its own traditional forms of economic articulation. Although the Incas extended these traditional forms, they also modified them by creating institutions that generated rebellions. Finally, Murra points out that there was a form of tribute in the Inca Empire: it was a tribute in people. This was an innovation of the Inca elite, although it possibly existed in other ancient states. Thus, for Murra, the particularity of Andean civilization rests in the way in which people were organized. By the time the Spaniards arrived in the Andes, these institutions had begun to consolidate.
There is no doubt that this book is fundamental to understanding the thought of John Murra at the peak of his career. It should be mandatory reading for any researcher who wants to understand the deep economic and political mechanisms that transcended the entire history of the Andean peoples.
