The Mexican Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Mexican Center of Uniform Law, under the auspices of the International Institute for the Unification of Private Law (UNIDROIT) based in Rome, organized an international seminar in Mexico City from September 6 to 8, 2006. The purpose of the seminar was to evaluate how efficiently international conventions protecting cultural objects. The seminar was attended mostly by Latin American colleagues and the secretaries of culture and general directors of cultural institutes of the Mexican Federal States.
There were four conventions under discussion: The UNESCO Conventions of 1970, 1972, and 2001, and the UNIDROIT Cultural Convention of 1995. The UNESCO conventions have already been ratified by Mexico, and the UNIDROIT Convention is still pending.
The exchange of experiences was very productive. Several arguments were discussed during the seminar. It is well known that the Meso-American and central Andean regions are very sensitive about pre-Columbian cultural objects. It was agreed that the pre-Columbian cultural sites should transcend the debate between cultural nationalism (Byronism) and cultural internationalism (Elginism), which has an essentially ideological background, and must be placed in another context: that of the preservation of human knowledge. It has rightly been said:
A perception of a common culture and common past is one way of learning that we are part of a community, that we belong to one another in a special way … that art speaks directly to the inner consciousness within which we resolve whether we do really feel a sense of belonging to a group or community.
Therefore, archeological objects also fulfill a cohesive function in society, particularly in Meso-America and the Inca region. Hence, we can recognize a specificity of archeological objects, which has had important repercussions in the law. In many cases we often hear that archeological sites are being destroyed because of negligence or natural elements. This may well be true, but it does not follow that pillage or mutilation will preserve archeological objects any better. The market cannot become a catalyst of the destruction or mutilation of archeological objects.
In the field of law, the preservation of cultural objects has been weakened by the juxtaposition of geopolitical realities in cultural units subject to different legal systems. One example that arose in the discussion was the problem of the migration of different pre-Columbian cultures, such as the Maya; it becomes very difficult, even for specialists, to identify the national origin. The jurisdiction in international cases could choose as the applicable law that of the country of origin of the cultural objects; however, serious difficulties would arise if an object from one and the same culture belonged to one or more different legal systems. A similar problem arises when ordering such an object's restitution. It was concluded that the design of legal instruments should primarily respond to the best cultural rather than nationalistic interests. The audience also conceded that the degree of enforcement of national laws, which protect cultural objects, is very inconsistent and, in some cases, frankly questionable. Interpol stated that the lack of a registry in cultural objects encouraged the black market and made it very difficult to combat illicit traffic.
To sum up, in this international seminar aficionados were outnumbered by the skeptics. However, there is no denying the increased international awareness and the will to protect cultural objects. The international community displays a concern for the preservation of knowledge of ancient cultures.
We were encouraged by the audience, and it was agreed to write a dictionary of legal cultural notions of our region. The objective of this dictionary is quite simple: to facilitate the protection of cultural objects. It goes without saying that it is very difficult to launch this project, but the challenges should not deter us from undertaking this task.
