Published in the same year in which the British pop group the Spice Girls reunited for a world tour, the relevance of a book about the gendered character of the music industry is thrown into even sharper relief: while the phrase ‘Girl Power’ has been the internationally recognised slogan of the Spice Girls, ever since their use of it in 1996, it was previously part of the feminist ‘riot grrrl’ network – one of the central case studies of Marion Leonard's book.
Gender in the Music Industry shows how the association of indie-rock with masculinity is produced and maintained by the discourses, practices, institutions, groups and individuals within the music industry, and how this is experienced by female musicians. Taking American and British female-centred indie-rock bands from the 1990s to the present day as a case study, Leonard discusses the ‘riot grrrl’ network and LadyFest festivals as responses to the masculinist discourse she, along with her informants, identifies as part of the music industry environment.
This book furthers understanding of rock and gender by situating the research in the experience of the musicians and other personnel within the music industry. Previous research has considered how gender is represented in rock performance (Walser, Reference WALSER1993; Whiteley, Reference WHITELEY1997) and the gendering of rock instrumentation (Bayton, Reference BAYTON and Whiteley1997) and technology (Thebérge, Reference THEBÉRGE1991); but analyses of the music industry have had relatively little to say about gendered experience of the music industry, or else they have focused on individual cases rather than showing how these relate to broader patterns of female experience. Like Bayton (Reference BAYTON1998) and Carson et al. (Reference CARSON, LEWIS and Shaw2004), Leonard investigates the gendering of rock though the words of women, informed by a field-study approach, but focuses attention on how this is mediated by the structures and discourses of the music industry.
The book is structured as seven chapters, framed by an introduction and conclusion, the sequence of which moves towards increasingly more situated fieldwork studies. Chapter 1 shows the way in which rock is produced and practised as a masculinist tradition, by analysing rock discourse and its treatment of female and male musicians. This detailed and scholarly account shows how a rock canon is created through the discourses and practices of the music industry. And by including interview material as well as analyses of encyclopaedias, guides and rock journalism, Leonard provides new insight into how this impacts on artists and audiences. In chapter 2, material from interviews with female indie rock band musicians illustrates the gender bias experienced within specific aspects of the music industry (for example, shops, tours, studios). Chapters 3 and 4 explore the creation of meaning around indie-rock. In chapter three, the discourse of rock journalism is analysed, revealing the way in which the theme of ‘madness’ functions to position (and denigrate) female musicians. Chapter 4 investigates how the image of a band is discursively constructed through analysis of the stage performances, promotional videos, press interviews and photo shoots. By adopting a broad conception of performance, and recognising the multi-media character of that performance, this chapter serves as a useful reminder of the performative function of videos and press interviews in relation to gender more generally.
Chapters 5, 6 and 7 focus in more detail on the particular case studies. Chapter 5 gives an account of the ‘riot grrrl’ network through interviews, observation, and zines and argues that ‘riot grrrl’ performances and promotion created different kinds of performer–audience relationships than those associated with the masculinist indie-rock scene, and created new opportunities for women and girls to engage with rock. (The term ‘riot grrrl’ allowed a reappropriation of the word ‘girl’ as a feisty, politically engaged, and potentially alarming, female.) Chapter 6 traces the development of ‘riot grrrl’ from a network of (geographically distributed) grrrls, to the appropriation of the message of ‘girl power’ by the Spice Girls into a repackaging of female empowerment for mainstream female consumption. Chapter 7 focuses on the female-organised LadyFest network of festivals, which were inspired by the ‘riot grrrl’ initiative.
As this description highlights, the emphasis in the book is on ‘riot grrrl’ and LadyFest and the female networks that constituted them, rather than on women in, or signed to, major record companies. It is also about how ‘riot grrrl’ and LadyFest came about, operated and were experienced by women. Hence, there are few, if any, voices of male informants within the book. The majority of informants are musicians rather than recording industry personnel, photographers, or journalists, and so to gain a fuller picture of the gendering of indie-rock future research would need to explore the gendering of indie-rock from the perspective of these participants. The research is weighted towards discourse due to the focus upon the written and spoken word of the interviews, zines and journalism. There is relatively little examination of behaviours (what people do rather than what they say). There are good methodological reasons why this might be the case (difficulties of access to the network, the retrospective character of some of the research focus), nonetheless it leaves open for future research an ethnographic study of gender in the music industry.
This is an impressive piece of research, which demonstrates a scholarly approach to the questions it sets itself, and draws upon a large quantity of primary material (interviews, zines). It is also a self-reflective and careful piece of analysis. For example, Leonard explicitly reflects upon her own position as a scholar in relation to the philosophy of ‘riot grrrl’, which resists reduction to an ‘essence’ to avoid assimilation by the masculinist music industry. This self-reflective and critical authorial voice helps the reader to avoid the pitfalls of over-simplification, and to hear the voices of the women whose experiences inform this book.
