The title of Peter Swirski's excellent new study, American Utopia and Social Engineering in Literature, Social Thought, and Political History might sound like a mouthful. However, it is an accurate description of the broad scope of this enlightening and thought-provoking book. Swirski approaches American politics as utopian social engineering by examining how society has been represented and reimagined in American fiction. How do our fictions relate to what society is and what it aims to become?
While Swirski has been long recognized as an important literary scholar and theorist, lately his work has become increasingly more focussed on American politics and culture. As in his earlier books, Swirski does not shirk away from taking a political stand:
American history, politics and social institutions … promised to lead us to the promised land and led us by the nose in circles instead. Perish the thought of land of milk and honey. The United States today is afflicted with political alienation, militarized violence, institutionalized poverty, and social agony. (3)
While Swirski recognizes the initial good intentions of campaigns to engineer a better America, in his view those attempts have backfired.
Swirski lays the groundwork for his analysis on five interconnected readings of novels ranging from the end of the Second World War to the early twenty-first century. He compares the utopian formulations of B. F. Skinner's influential Walden Two (1948) with the intentional communities that it inspired; analyzes the political apathy of American voters through the democratic psychiatric ward of Ken Kesey's One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest (1962); explores the adaptive foundation of altruism through Bernard Malamud's God's Grace (1982), a beast fable set in a nuclear postapocalyptic future; tallies the pros and cons of using technology to suppress the violent nature of humanity through Walker Percy's The Thanatos Syndrome (1986); and examines politics as emotional affectation through Philip Roth's The Plot Against America (2004).
For Swirski, the novels analyzed in American Utopia function as thought experiments: they imagine the potentially disastrous consequences of utopian social engineering. Malamud's and Percy's fictional utopias turn into stark dystopias; Skinner's naive behaviorist utopia never worked in real life. Roth's and Kesey's depictions of American democracy are just as prone to exploitation as in reality. Utopias seem not to work, not even in fiction, simply because people are not suited to function in a utopian society. Swirski argues that no successful attempt to build a better society can overlook the essential, natural traits of human beings. A utopian society requires that all members of society set the interests of others before their own – and human beings have not evolved to function that way. Swirski has long been writing from an evolutionary perspective and argues that all attempts at social engineering need to be grounded in the adapted nature of humankind. Swirski's ambitious approach fuses political science with literary criticism and evolutionary studies in a unique fashion that is sure to bear fruit for scholars of politics and literature alike.
The valuable insights of American Utopia are enriched by Swirski's unique voice that manages to combine a humorous, conversational tone with a serious academic approach. His work is as entertaining as it is enlightening. It is sure to be engaging and profitable for researchers of both politics and literature. While not all scholars will agree with Swirski's rigorous evolutionary psychological perspective, his contribution is an original and crucial addition to our understanding of American society and culture.
