This companion to Bruce Cole's earlier volume, The Composer's Handbook (Reference COLE1996), is designed for use by 11–18-year-olds and anyone involved in teaching composing in popular styles. The suggestions include projects for use in school music lessons including whole class projects, games and warm-ups. There are projects for more advanced students and suggested tasks are graded by the use of musical symbols (one to four quaver symbols indicate easy to most advanced in difficulty). The chapters are set out in three main parts; techniques, topics (genres) and project planning.
In the first part, the ‘technique’ chapters begin very simply with a section on rhythm exercises, suitable for use with beginner composers (year 7 in UK schools). These would provide useful ideas for ‘starter’ or warm up lesson activities moving onto more complex polyrhythmic drum kit patterns in a variety of styles. The melody chapter provides teachers with some useful ideas for basic melodic composition drawing its examples from a repertoire of well-known popular songs, all easily accessible, as are the songs used for the listening tasks throughout the book. There are some useful exercises on composing answering phrases and hooks, as well using ‘the dramatic leap’.
The ‘harmony’ chapter makes a real attempt to help the novice composer understand why pop harmony sounds different from classical harmony, and there are simple definitions of inversions and consecutive fifths together with some clear instructions on how to write countermelodies and the use of dissonance – all very necessary for those who want to experiment with sounds. However, the complexity involved in providing an understanding of harmony in one short chapter brings with it a tendency to revert to ‘theoretical’ principles rather than connecting with guitarists and orally motivated pop students. The chapter on harmonic structure, whilst providing standard structures found in popular music and a useful chart showing key relationships, tends to favour those with traditional notational knowledge rather than those pop musicians who prefer to use chord symbols or tablature.
Similar lack of space in the ‘instrumentation’ chapter means that despite useful examples of string and woodwind writing, and on writing in four-part harmony, most students would require further guidance. A final section on computer midi and the chapter on production provide background definitions, information and useful terminology. This techniques section of the book provides a valuable resource together with well-chosen musical examples. Whilst it is difficult to provide a comprehensive guide to all techniques covered, it is a very valuable resource for teachers and their students providing a wealth of examples and help in stylistic popular composing.
Part 2 of Cole's book surveys a wide range of genre and provides analyses of some ‘landmark’ popular songs. There is a lesson plan for working with riffs, related listening questions, including a UK GCSE examination style question, composition ideas with a variety of levels of difficulty and two related projects based on riffs. The section on ‘Songs’ provides a wealth of analyses of songs from the 1920s to more recent years. Throughout the book links are made with other materials and suggestions and references to techniques described in part 1 supports the composing sections of later chapters. Reggae, Salsa, Bhangra and Celtic music are featured in a chapter entitled, ‘Islands and Continents’. Here context supports the composing projects and there are plenty of useful notated ideas. The ‘Club and Urban’ chapter will help teachers who struggle to replicate these styles using Midi software. There are useful definitions and contextual information. Performing projects using currently popular Samba and Steel bands, and tala and riff performance suggestions, once again link with previous material in the book.
The third part is aimed specifically at teachers and provides ideas for listening logs and for devising worksheets. Additionally there are suggestions for designing schemes of work. One reservation I have for trainee teachers using this book is that suggestions for curriculum planning tends to be content based without any reference to the skill, knowledge and understandings which might be involved in the outcomes. The final chapter on using computers in the classroom unfortunately takes a very limited and dated view of the use of music technology in classrooms today. Doubtless there are still schools where, ‘the computer is often shut away in a side room of the music department or set up as a series of workstations for the students to use singly or in pairs’ (p. 147), but this is not my perception of what goes on in a large majority of classrooms today. However, some of the ideas given which assume the student is learning independently, away from the class, are useful and applicable in ‘whole class’ music technology suites. The assumption that schools are relying on ‘entry-based’ E-jay programmes or Music Maker, is also limiting and lacking in challenge. The reality is that schools more usually use Cubase programmes for sequencing and Sibelius for notating. Software such as ‘Garageband’ is becoming increasingly more popular in schools which are basing their work on Mac computers rather than PCs. This is the weakest and least inspiring of the chapters in the book. The useful Glossary provides helpful definitions for both teachers and pupils and the index will help users to link together sections in composing, listening, theoretical examples and in performing projects.
Cole's book takes the view that composing should be based on genres and styles and provides the information necessary for this. This approach is consistent with UK examination board requirements and current UK National Strategy and the ‘Musical Futures’ project. Tasks are ‘graded’ in difficulty allowing pupils to select composing ideas suited to their level of capability. There is a wealth of resource material here for teachers and it is a valuable resource for trainee teachers.
