What many know about Roman freedmen is that there were a lot of them, that they liked putting up memorial inscriptions about themselves, and that Trimalchio was one. As might be expected there are articles in this volume about or referring to the burial practices of freedmen: ‘The face of the social climber: Roman freedmen and elite ideology’ by Barbara Borg, which is a translation of an article previously published in 2000 with a new epilogue, ‘The freedman economy of Roman Italy’ by Koenraad Verboven, and ‘Feasting the dead together: household burials and the social strategies of slaves and freed persons in the early Principate’ by Carlos R. Galvao-Sobrinho. Petronius’ work is mentioned several times, most extensively in ‘“Reading” the freed slave in the Cena Trimalchionis’ by Teresa Ramsby, but the volume is not merely a rehashing of old material.
Pauline Ripat in ‘Locating the grapevine in the Late Republic’ applies social network theory to conclude that freedmen probably were a useful source of information for their social superiors, although she admits early on in the article that there is a ‘dearth of direct evidence’ (51). Marc Kleijwegt in ‘Deciphering freedwomen in the Roman Empire’ uses information from New World slavery to suggest new ways of looking at the ancient evidence. Unfortunately the volume was sent to press before Henrik Mouritsen's The Freedman in the Roman World (2011) was available.
But for those interested in modern historiography what is most intriguing is the introduction. The purpose behind the book is stated very clearly and directly. It is to give a voice to the voiceless: ‘This book is an attempt to recognize the accomplishments of the freed slaves of ancient Rome and their contributions to Roman life and culture’ (1). It would be difficult to be unsympathetic to such a motive and yet the approach as elaborated further in the introduction is not unproblematic. The editors judge the work of some scholars who, in their view, have laid too much stress on the subordination of the freed to their former masters as belittling ‘the capability and ingenuity of freed slaves by emphasizing the dependency of the freed slave on his or her former master’ (3). So the intent behind this book is a positive one: to show that freed slaves were agents in their own right, not merely victims, and to celebrate their achievements; achievements, that is, of integration into the society which had formerly enslaved them. Consequently, we hear of stories of affection and loyalty between masters and their former slaves, of dedication, of the adoption of Roman values. As the editors say: ‘The contributors of this volume building on recent scholarship seek to illuminate the many ways that freed slaves made their mark on Roman society: that is, through their hard work, social institutions, self-reinforced Roman values and essential humanity’ (10). And a little later (although this comment is made about Verboven's piece, it could well be applied to the whole volume): ‘this model represents a challenge to the moralistic undertones of scholarship that seeks to discredit all aspects of the Roman slave-society simply because, in our modern age, slavery is repugnant and unthinkable’ (12). There appears to be a contradiction here — at first this volume seems to have been driven by a laudable (but surely moral) concern to give voice to the voiceless, but later we find this condemnation of a ‘moralistic’ approach. A scholar may point to the agency of the freedmen and women, but not to the ways in which their new freedom was limited? However what is clear is that the resulting collection is a celebration of freed slaves and their acceptance of and accommodation into Roman society. Whether the freed people saw it like that or were simply trying to survive the best they could is moot.
The final article is not really about Roman slavery at all, but rather about the situation in the US after emancipation when freed slaves were desperate for education. The most valuable education then as now was a classical one and well-intentioned classicists endured ‘ostracism, insult and calumny’ to help provide that education (180). The article ‘“Saintly souls”: white teachers’ advocacy and instruction of Greek and Latin to African American freedmen’ by Michele Valerie Ronnick records some of this history. The heroes of this last piece are the white teachers who wanted to help those less fortunate than themselves. The story is an interesting one, and worth recording but the article sits a little oddly as a conclusion to a book which was intended to record the agency of freed people.
One might argue that the book overall in fact shows the success of Roman society at integrating its former slaves. It does tell a story of hard work, loyalty and affection but for some cynical readers this might simply be the dominant ideology remaining dominant.
